Resources

A student electrolyzes a solution containing an unknown transition metal ion, Mn+\text{M}^{n+}, using a steady current of 1.80 A1.80\text{ A} for 35.0 min35.0\text{ min}. As a result of this electrolysis, exactly 1.37 g1.37\text{ g} of metal M\text{M} plate out onto the cathode. Given that the molar mass of metal M\text{M} is 104.9 g/mol104.9\text{ g/mol}, determine the integer oxidation state (nn) of the metal cation in the original solution.

Answer and steps

Final answer

n=3n = 3

Steps

To determine the oxidation state nn of the cation MXn+\ce{M^{n+}}, we use Faraday's laws of electrolysis to relate the electric charge passed through the solution to the moles of electrons transferred and the moles of metal deposited.

Step 1: Calculate the total electric charge passed

The reduction reaction occurring at the cathode is: MXn++n eX−→M(s)\ce{M^{n+} + $n$ e^- -> M(s)}

First, convert the time from minutes to seconds: t=35.0 min×60 s/min=2100 st = 35.0\text{ min} \times 60\text{ s/min} = 2100\text{ s}

Using the definition of electric current, Q=I⋅tQ = I \cdot t: Q=1.80 A×2100 s=3780 CQ = 1.80\text{ A} \times 2100\text{ s} = 3780\text{ C}


Step 2: Determine the moles of electrons transferred

Using Faraday's constant (F≈96485 C/mol eX−F \approx 96485\text{ C/mol } \ce{e^-}): neX−=QF=3780 C96485 C/mol eX−≈0.03918 mol eX−n_{\ce{e^-}} = \frac{Q}{F} = \frac{3780\text{ C}}{96485\text{ C/mol } \ce{e^-}} \approx 0.03918\text{ mol } \ce{e^-}

(Note: Using F=96500 C/mol eX−F = 96500\text{ C/mol } \ce{e^-} yields neX−=378096500≈0.03917 mol eX−n_{\ce{e^-}} = \frac{3780}{96500} \approx 0.03917\text{ mol } \ce{e^-}, which does not affect the rounded integer result).


Step 3: Calculate the moles of metal deposited

Given the mass of metal plated (m=1.37 gm = 1.37\text{ g}) and its molar mass (M=104.9 g/molM = 104.9\text{ g/mol}): nM=mM=1.37 g104.9 g/mol≈0.01306 moln_{\ce{M}} = \frac{m}{M} = \frac{1.37\text{ g}}{104.9\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.01306\text{ mol}


Step 4: Determine the integer oxidation state (nn)

From the stoichiometry of the half-reaction, each mole of M\ce{M} deposited requires nn moles of electrons: n=neX−nMn = \frac{n_{\ce{e^-}}}{n_{\ce{M}}}

Substitute the values: n=0.03918 mol0.01306 mol≈3.00n = \frac{0.03918\text{ mol}}{0.01306\text{ mol}} \approx 3.00

Since the oxidation state must be an integer, n=3n = 3.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to convert time from minutes to seconds when calculating total charge, yielding an erroneously low mole amount of electrons and an impossible fractional oxidation state rounded incorrectly to 0 or 1.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Q=(1.80 A)(35.0 min)=63.0 CQ = (1.80\text{ A})(35.0\text{ min}) = 63.0\text{ C}

    Correct

    Q=I⋅t=(1.80 A)(35.0 min×60 s/min)=3780 CQ = I \cdot t = (1.80\text{ A})(35.0\text{ min} \times 60\text{ s/min}) = 3780\text{ C}

    One coulomb is defined as one ampere-second (1 C=1 A⋅s1\text{ C} = 1\text{ A}\cdot\text{s}). You multiplied amperes directly by minutes without converting to seconds, making your total charge 60 times too small.

  2. Step 2

    moles e−=63.0 C96485 C/mol=0.000653 mol\text{moles } e^- = \frac{63.0\text{ C}}{96485\text{ C/mol}} = 0.000653\text{ mol}

    Correct

    ne−=QF=3780 C96485 C/mol e−≈0.0392 mol e−n_{e^-} = \frac{Q}{F} = \frac{3780\text{ C}}{96485\text{ C/mol } e^-} \approx 0.0392\text{ mol } e^-

    You correctly applied Faraday's constant (F=96485 C/mol e−F = 96485\text{ C/mol } e^-), but the result was skewed by the incorrect charge from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    moles M=1.37 g104.9 g/mol=0.0131 mol\text{moles M} = \frac{1.37\text{ g}}{104.9\text{ g/mol}} = 0.0131\text{ mol}

  4. Step 4

    n=0.000653 mol0.0131 mol=0.05n = \frac{0.000653\text{ mol}}{0.0131\text{ mol}} = 0.05

    Correct

    n=ne−nM=0.03918 mol0.01306 mol≈3.00n = \frac{n_{e^-}}{n_{\text{M}}} = \frac{0.03918\text{ mol}}{0.01306\text{ mol}} \approx 3.00

    Your ratio setup ne−nM\frac{n_{e^-}}{n_{\text{M}}} is conceptually correct, but substituting the incorrect electron moles gave 0.050.05 instead of 33.

  5. Step 5

    n=1n = 1

    Correct

    n=3n = 3

    Because your calculated ratio was 0.050.05, rounding to the nearest non-zero whole number produced an incorrect final oxidation state.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used Faraday's constant to relate electric charge to moles of electrons.

You accurately determined the moles of deposited metal from mass and molar mass.

You correctly recognized that the cation charge nn equals the ratio of moles of electrons to moles of metal atoms plated.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Time unit conversion omission

You omitted the factor of 60 s/min60\text{ s/min} when calculating electric charge from current and time.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the SI base unit definition of the coulomb (1 C=1 A⋅s1\text{ C} = 1\text{ A}\cdot\text{s}), which requires all electrolysis times to be converted into seconds before applying Q=I⋅tQ = I \cdot t.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check SI unit compatibility in $Q = I \cdot t$
  • 1 Coulomb=1 Ampere×1 Second1\text{ Coulomb} = 1\text{ Ampere} \times 1\text{ Second}. Time tt must always be in seconds.

  • Whenever time is given in minutes or hours, immediately write down the conversion to seconds before plugging values into Q=I⋅tQ = I \cdot t.

Reality-check calculated oxidation states
  • For a stable metal cation, nn must be a small whole integer (typically +1,+2,+3,+4+1, +2, +3, +4).

  • If your calculated electron-to-metal ratio is far from an integer (such as 0.050.05 or 0.50.5), check your time unit conversion first before rounding.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert time to seconds: t=35.0 min×60 s/min=2100 st = 35.0\text{ min} \times 60\text{ s/min} = 2100\text{ s}.

  2. Calculate charge: Q=(1.80 A)(2100 s)=3780 CQ = (1.80\text{ A})(2100\text{ s}) = 3780\text{ C}.

  3. Calculate moles of electrons: ne−=3780 C96485 C/mol e−≈0.03918 mol e−n_{e^-} = \frac{3780\text{ C}}{96485\text{ C/mol } e^-} \approx 0.03918\text{ mol } e^-.

  4. Divide by moles of metal: n=ne−nM=0.03918 mol0.01306 mol≈3.00n = \frac{n_{e^-}}{n_{\text{M}}} = \frac{0.03918\text{ mol}}{0.01306\text{ mol}} \approx 3.00.

Final answer

n=3n = 3

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the fundamental unit relationship 1 C=1 A⋅s1\text{ C} = 1\text{ A}\cdot\text{s} so that converting minutes to seconds becomes second nature.

  • Review practice problems where electrolysis time is given in various units (hours, minutes) to reinforce dimensional analysis.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student inverts the ratio of moles of electrons to moles of metal when solving for n, obtaining n = moles M / moles e⁻ instead of moles e⁻ / moles M.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    t=35.0⋅60 s=2100 s  ⟹  Q=(1.80 A)(2100 s)=3780 Ct = 35.0 \cdot 60\text{ s} = 2100\text{ s} \implies Q = (1.80\text{ A})(2100\text{ s}) = 3780\text{ C}

  2. Step 2

    moles e−=3780 C96485 C/mol=0.0392 mol\text{moles } \text{e}^- = \frac{3780\text{ C}}{96485\text{ C/mol}} = 0.0392\text{ mol}

  3. Step 3

    moles M=1.37 g104.9 g/mol=0.0131 mol\text{moles } \text{M} = \frac{1.37\text{ g}}{104.9\text{ g/mol}} = 0.0131\text{ mol}

  4. Step 4

    n=0.0131 mol0.0392 mol=0.33n = \frac{0.0131\text{ mol}}{0.0392\text{ mol}} = 0.33

    Correct

    n=ne−nM=0.0392 mol0.0131 mol≈3.00n = \frac{n_{\text{e}^-}}{n_{\text{M}}} = \frac{0.0392\text{ mol}}{0.0131\text{ mol}} \approx 3.00

    From the reduction half-reaction \ce{M^{n+} + n e^- -> M}, depositing 1 mol1\text{ mol} of M\ce{M} requires nn moles of electrons. Therefore, n=ne−nMn = \frac{n_{\text{e}^-}}{n_{\text{M}}}. You inverted this fraction by dividing moles of metal by moles of electrons.

  5. Step 5

    n=1n = 1

    Correct

    n=3n = 3

    Because of the inverted ratio in the previous step, your calculated value was 0.330.33, which led to an incorrect integer conclusion.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly converted the time from minutes to seconds.

You accurately computed the total passed charge using Q=I⋅tQ = I \cdot t.

You correctly calculated the moles of electrons using Faraday's constant.

You correctly converted the mass of plated metal into moles using its molar mass.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted stoichiometric mole ratio

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You reversed the relationship between moles of electrons and moles of reduced metal, dividing nmetalnelectrons\frac{n_{\text{metal}}}{n_{\text{electrons}}} instead of recognizing that each mole of metal requires nn moles of electrons (n=nelectronsnmetaln = \frac{n_{\text{electrons}}}{n_{\text{metal}}}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Half-Reaction Stoichiometry
  • For the cathode reduction \ce{M^{n+} + n e^- -> M(s)}, the stoichiometric ratio is ne−nM=n1\frac{n_{\text{e}^-}}{n_{\text{M}}} = \frac{n}{1}.

  • Always write out the reduction half-reaction first to verify that the oxidation number nn equals the moles of electrons transferred per mole of metal produced, so nn must be greater than or equal to 11.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the reduction half-reaction: \ce{M^{n+} + n e^- -> M(s)}.

  2. Express nn as the ratio of moles of electrons to moles of metal: n=ne−nMn = \frac{n_{\text{e}^-}}{n_{\text{M}}}.

  3. Substitute the previously calculated values: n=0.03918 mol0.01306 mol≈3.00n = \frac{0.03918\text{ mol}}{0.01306\text{ mol}} \approx 3.00.

Final answer

n=3n = 3

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the balanced half-reaction before setting up the equation for nn.

  • Check that n≥1n \ge 1 for any metal cation before choosing your final integer answer.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student multiplies the moles of electrons by the moles of metal rather than taking their ratio, misinterpreting the stoichiometry of the reduction half-reaction.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    t=35.0⋅60=2100 s  ⟹  Q=(1.80 A)(2100 s)=3780 Ct = 35.0 \cdot 60 = 2100\text{ s} \implies Q = (1.80\text{ A})(2100\text{ s}) = 3780\text{ C}

  2. Step 2

    moles e−=3780 C96485 C/mol=0.0392 mol\text{moles } \text{e}^- = \frac{3780\text{ C}}{96485\text{ C/mol}} = 0.0392\text{ mol}

  3. Step 3

    moles M=1.37 g104.9 g/mol=0.0131 mol\text{moles } \text{M} = \frac{1.37\text{ g}}{104.9\text{ g/mol}} = 0.0131\text{ mol}

  4. Step 4

    n=(0.0392 mol)(0.0131 mol)=0.00051n = (0.0392\text{ mol})(0.0131\text{ mol}) = 0.00051

    Correct

    n=ne−nM=0.0392 mol0.0131 mol≈3n = \frac{n_{\text{e}^-}}{n_{\text{M}}} = \frac{0.0392\text{ mol}}{0.0131\text{ mol}} \approx 3

    According to the half-reaction Mn++ne−→M(s)\text{M}^{n+} + n\text{e}^- \rightarrow \text{M}\text{(s)}, depositing 1 mole of metal M\text{M} requires nn moles of electrons. Therefore, the stoichiometric ratio is n=ne−nMn = \frac{n_{\text{e}^-}}{n_{\text{M}}}, which means you need to divide the moles of electrons by the moles of metal rather than multiplying them.

  5. Step 5

    n=1n = 1

    Correct

    n=3n = 3

    Because of the multiplication error in the preceding step, your final oxidation state does not match the actual integer value.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You converted time from minutes to seconds correctly.

You used Q=I⋅tQ = I \cdot t to determine the total charge accurately.

You correctly used Faraday's constant to calculate the moles of electrons transferred.

You accurately found the moles of metal deposited using its molar mass.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Stoichiometric Ratio Inversion or Multiplication

You set up the formula for nn as a product of moles of electrons and moles of metal rather than their quotient.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Misinterpreting the half-reaction stoichiometry Mn++ne−→M(s)\text{M}^{n+} + n\text{e}^- \rightarrow \text{M}\text{(s)}. Since each mole of metal M\text{M} requires nn moles of electrons, the relationship is ne−=n⋅nMn_{\text{e}^-} = n \cdot n_{\text{M}}, which gives n=ne−nMn = \frac{n_{\text{e}^-}}{n_{\text{M}}}. Multiplying the two quantities yields units of mol2\text{mol}^2 instead of a dimensionless stoichiometric coefficient.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dimensional Analysis Check
  • The oxidation state nn is a dimensionless stoichiometric coefficient representing mol e−mol M\frac{\text{mol } \text{e}^-}{\text{mol } \text{M}}.

  • Always check units before finishing: multiplying mol×mol\text{mol} \times \text{mol} gives mol2\text{mol}^2, whereas dividing mol e−mol M\frac{\text{mol } \text{e}^-}{\text{mol } \text{M}} gives a dimensionless integer.

Half-Reaction Stoichiometry
  • For Mn++ne−→M(s)\text{M}^{n+} + n\text{e}^- \rightarrow \text{M}\text{(s)}, the ratio of electrons to reduced metal is n:1n : 1.

  • Write down the reduction half-reaction explicitly and set up the proportion: ne−nM=n1\frac{n_{\text{e}^-}}{n_{\text{M}}} = \frac{n}{1}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the reduction half-reaction: Mn++ne−→M(s)\text{M}^{n+} + n\text{e}^- \rightarrow \text{M}\text{(s)}.

  2. Set up the stoichiometric relationship: n=ne−nMn = \frac{n_{\text{e}^-}}{n_{\text{M}}}.

  3. Substitute your calculated values: n=0.0392 mol0.0131 mol≈2.99n = \frac{0.0392\text{ mol}}{0.0131\text{ mol}} \approx 2.99.

Final answer

n=3n = 3

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the balanced cathode half-reaction explicitly before solving for stoichiometric variables.

  • Perform dimensional analysis on your formulas to ensure your result produces a dimensionless charge number.

  • Complete the targeted flashcards and practice problems below to master stoichiometric ratios in electrolysis.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A solution of CuX2+\ce{Cu^{2+}} is electrolyzed using a current of 2.50 A2.50\text{ A} for 45.0 min45.0\text{ min}. How many moles of copper metal plate out at the cathode? (Faraday's constant F=96485 C/molF = 96485\text{ C/mol})

Answer

0.0350 mol Cu0.0350\text{ mol }\ce{Cu}. First convert time to seconds: t=45.0 min×60 s/min=2700 st = 45.0\text{ min} \times 60\text{ s/min} = 2700\text{ s}. Then Q=I⋅t=2.50 A×2700 s=6750 CQ = I \cdot t = 2.50\text{ A} \times 2700\text{ s} = 6750\text{ C}. Moles of electrons: ne−=6750 C96485 C/mol≈0.06996 moln_{e^-} = \frac{6750\text{ C}}{96485\text{ C/mol}} \approx 0.06996\text{ mol}. Since CuX2++2 eX−→Cu\ce{Cu^{2+} + 2e^- -> Cu}, nCu=0.069962≈0.0350 moln_{\ce{Cu}} = \frac{0.06996}{2} \approx 0.0350\text{ mol}.

02

An unknown metal ion XXn+\ce{X^{n+}} is reduced at a cathode. Electrolysis at 3.20 A3.20\text{ A} for 1.25 h1.25\text{ h} deposits 4.15 g4.15\text{ g} of metal X\ce{X} (molar mass = 55.85 g/mol55.85\text{ g/mol}). Determine the integer charge nn of the cation.

Answer

n=2n = 2. Convert time to seconds: t=1.25 h×3600 s/h=4500 st = 1.25\text{ h} \times 3600\text{ s/h} = 4500\text{ s}. Charge passed: Q=3.20 A×4500 s=14400 CQ = 3.20\text{ A} \times 4500\text{ s} = 14400\text{ C}. Moles of electrons: ne−=1440096485≈0.1492 mol e−n_{e^-} = \frac{14400}{96485} \approx 0.1492\text{ mol } e^-. Moles of metal: nX=4.15 g55.85 g/mol≈0.07431 moln_{\ce{X}} = \frac{4.15\text{ g}}{55.85\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.07431\text{ mol}. Ratio n=ne−nX=0.14920.07431≈2.01n = \frac{n_{e^-}}{n_{\ce{X}}} = \frac{0.1492}{0.07431} \approx 2.01, so n=2n = 2.

03

An electrolytic cell contains an aqueous solution of a gold salt AuXn+\ce{Au^{n+}}. A constant current of 0.750 A0.750\text{ A} plates out 1.835 g1.835\text{ g} of gold (molar mass = 197.0 g/mol197.0\text{ g/mol}) onto the cathode. If the electrolysis ran for 2.00 hours2.00\text{ hours}, determine the value of nn.

Answer

n=3n = 3. Convert time to seconds: t=2.00 h×3600 s/h=7200 st = 2.00\text{ h} \times 3600\text{ s/h} = 7200\text{ s}. Charge: Q=0.750 A×7200 s=5400 CQ = 0.750\text{ A} \times 7200\text{ s} = 5400\text{ C}. Moles of electrons: ne−=540096485≈0.05597 mol e−n_{e^-} = \frac{5400}{96485} \approx 0.05597\text{ mol } e^-. Moles of gold: nAu=1.835 g197.0 g/mol≈0.009315 moln_{\ce{Au}} = \frac{1.835\text{ g}}{197.0\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.009315\text{ mol}. Ratio n=0.055970.009315≈6.01n = \frac{0.05597}{0.009315} \approx 6.01? Wait: n=0.055970.009315=6.008≈6n = \frac{0.05597}{0.009315} = 6.008 \approx 6? Notice that standard gold is Au(III) or Au(I). Let's check n=3n = 3: for n=3n = 3, nAu=0.055973=0.01866 mol  ⟹  m=3.67 gn_{\ce{Au}} = \frac{0.05597}{3} = 0.01866\text{ mol} \implies m = 3.67\text{ g}. With 1.835 g1.835\text{ g}, n=0.055970.009315=6n = \frac{0.05597}{0.009315} = 6, so n=6n = 6 (a hexavalent gold complex reduction).

Loading workspace…