Resources
Students are asked to predict the electrical conductivity and net acid-base character of aqueous solutions of three salts: (1) sodium chloride (), (2) ammonium chloride (, of ), and (3) sodium cyanide (, of ). Many students fall into the convention trap of assuming all neutral salts produce electrically neutral () solutions, or mistaking salt solutions for nonelectrolytes. For each solution: (a) identify whether the salt behaves as a strong electrolyte, weak electrolyte, or nonelectrolyte in terms of ion delivery, (b) write the spectator ions that remain inert, and (c) calculate the exact of each solution at .
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) All three salts (, , ) are strong electrolytes that dissociate into solvated ions. (b) Spectator ions: and in ; in ; in . (c) Exact values: for , ; for , so ; for , yielding and .
Steps
Part (a): Electrolyte Classification
A soluble ionic compound (salt) dissolves in water by completely dissociating into its constituent cations and anions:
- Soluble salts are strong electrolytes regardless of whether the individual ions undergo subsequent hydrolysis (weak acid-base reactions).
- The classification "strong electrolyte" refers to the extent of dissociation into free ions (), which allows the solution to conduct electricity efficiently. Therefore, all three salts—, , and —are strong electrolytes.
Common Pitfall: A frequent mistake is classifying or as weak electrolytes because is a weak acid and is a weak base. While their secondary acid-base ionization with water is weak, their primary physical dissociation into ions upon dissolving is complete ().
Part (b): Identification of Spectator Ions
An ion acts as a spectator (inert) ion if it does not react appreciably with water to affect the :
- Cations derived from strong bases: Group 1 cations (such as ) and heavier Group 2 cations (, , ) do not act as acids.
- Anions derived from strong monoprotic acids: The conjugate bases of strong acids (such as , , , , ) are negligible bases and do not accept protons from water. Applying these rules to each solution:
- : Both (conjugate cation of the strong base ) and (conjugate base of the strong acid ) are inert. Spectator ions: and .
- : is inert, but is the conjugate acid of a weak base () and undergoes hydrolysis. Spectator ion: .
- : is inert, but is the conjugate base of a weak acid () and undergoes hydrolysis. Spectator ion: .
Part (c): Calculation of at
Because neither nor reacts with water, the self-ionization of water controls the hydronium ion concentration:
The salt dissociates completely to give . The ammonium ion undergoes acid hydrolysis:
Setting up an equilibrium expression where :
Since is very small, assume :
Checking the approximation: , so the simplification is valid.
Calculating the :
The salt dissociates completely to give . The cyanide ion undergoes base hydrolysis:
Setting up an equilibrium expression where :
Assuming :
Checking the approximation: , which is well within the acceptable limit.
Now determine and :
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the weak acid/base character of the hydrolyzing ions with the electrolyte strength of the salts, incorrectly classifying NH4Cl and NaCN as weak electrolytes.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
: strong electrolyte : weak electrolyte : weak electrolyte
CorrectAll three salts (, , and ) are strong electrolytes.
You correctly classified , but soluble ionic salts such as and dissociate essentially into solvated ions in water. Electrolyte strength measures total free-ion delivery for electrical conductivity, not whether the resulting ions act as weak acids or bases.
- Step 2
: , : :
- Step 3
:
- Step 4
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the inert spectator ions for all three salt solutions.
You set up and solved the weak acid and weak base equilibrium expressions with total mathematical accuracy.
You converted and into the exact target values.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated the secondary acid-base ionization (hydrolysis) of an ion in water with the primary dissolution/dissociation of the ionic compound itself. Because has a small and has a small , you classified the parent salts as weak electrolytes, overlooking that soluble salts dissociate into solvated cations and anions.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Dissolution vs. Hydrolysis
Electrolyte classification depends entirely on how completely a substance forms ions upon dissolving in water ( for strong electrolytes; partial for weak electrolytes; none for molecular nonelectrolytes).
Classify every soluble ionic salt as a strong electrolyte, regardless of whether its individual ions act as weak acids or weak bases in secondary reactions.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCheck the bonding and solubility of the compound: and are soluble ionic salts composed of cations and anions.
Write the initial dissociation step in water: and . Both proceed to completion ().
Conclude that because they provide a high concentration of mobile ions in solution, both salts are strong electrolytes.
All three salts (, , and ) are strong electrolytes.
02 The student calculates the hydroxide ion concentration from Kb for NaCN but forgets to convert pOH to pH, reporting pOH directly as the pH.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
- Step 4
- Step 5Correct
In base hydrolysis, the variable represents , so taking yields . Because is the salt of a weak acid and strong base, the solution is basic; you must subtract from to obtain .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly classified all three salts as strong electrolytes based on complete physical dissociation.
You correctly picked out the inert spectator ions for each solution.
You set up both weak acid and weak base hydrolysis expressions flawlessly and solved for the equilibrium ion concentrations with valid approximations.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou calculated and labeled it as , forgetting that yields .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisOverlooking the identity of the generated species ( vs. ) in the hydrolysis equilibrium, leading to omitting the final conversion.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check the Identity of $x$
For a base equilibrium producing , , which means .
Always write down the label before taking the negative logarithm so you remember you are computing .
- Sanity Check Acid-Base Character
A solution containing a weak base anion (like ) must produce a basic solution with at .
If your calculated for a basic salt is less than , immediately check whether you calculated instead of .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFrom your equilibrium step, .
Calculate the hydroxide ion potential: .
Apply the relation at : .
03 The student assumes that all salts produce completely neutral solutions, concluding that the pH of all three solutions is 7.00 and that all ions are inert spectators.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You listed every constituent ion from dissociation instead of filtering for inert spectator ions. Conjugate ions of weak species react with water: is the conjugate acid of weak base and hydrolyzes, so only is a spectator in . Likewise, is the conjugate base of weak acid and hydrolyzes, so only is a spectator in .
- Step 3Correct
Because and undergo hydrolysis, their solutions are not neutral. Acid hydrolysis of yields (), and base hydrolysis of yields ().
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly classified all three soluble ionic compounds as strong electrolytes based on their complete dissociation into ions in water.
You correctly identified the neutral character and of the solution.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo, this is a conceptual misunderstanding rather than a calculation slip.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated all salt solutions as chemically neutral and assumed all dissociated ions are spectators, overlooking that conjugate partners of weak acids and weak bases hydrolyze in water to change the solution pH.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identifying Spectator Ions
Only conjugate ions of strong acids (e.g., , , ) and strong bases (Group 1 cations, heavy Group 2 cations) are inert spectators.
Inspect each ion in the salt: if an ion comes from a weak acid or weak base, it will undergo hydrolysis and is not a spectator ion.
- Calculating pH of Hydrolyzing Salts
For a salt containing a weak conjugate acid cation, use . For a weak conjugate base anion, use .
Set up an ICE table or the weak-species approximation using the ion concentration from dissociation, then convert to pH.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDetermine which ions hydrolyze: in , is inert and acts as a weak acid; in , is inert and acts as a weak base.
Calculate for : , so .
Calculate for : , yielding and .
(a) All three salts are strong electrolytes. (b) Spectator ions: and in ; in ; in . (c) values: , , .
Lock it in
How do you classify the electrolyte strength of any soluble ionic salt, such as or ?
It is always a strong electrolyte because it dissociates into mobile ions upon dissolving, regardless of any subsequent ion hydrolysis.
Similar question
Classify potassium nitrite (, of ) as a strong electrolyte, weak electrolyte, or nonelectrolyte, and state the spectator ion(s) in an aqueous solution.
Answer
is a strong electrolyte because it is a soluble ionic salt that completely dissociates into and . The spectator ion is , as the alkali metal cation does not react with water, whereas undergoes weak base hydrolysis.
A student measures the electrical conductivity of two beakers: Beaker A contains () and Beaker B contains . Predict which beaker will light a conductivity bulb brightly and explain why using electrolyte classifications.
Answer
Beaker B will light the bulb brightly. is a soluble ionic salt (strong electrolyte) that dissociates to provide total ions. In contrast, is a molecular weak acid (weak electrolyte) that ionizes only slightly (), providing very few conducting ions.
Consider a solution of ammonium acetate, ( of , of ). Identify its electrolyte classification, identify any spectator ions, and determine its at .
Answer
Electrolyte classification: Strong electrolyte (dissociates into and ). Spectator ions: None, because both the cation and anion undergo hydrolysis. , because , meaning the production of exactly balances .