Resources
Both silicon carbide (, carborundum) and solid carbon dioxide (, dry ice) contain Group 14 atoms bonded to Group 16 or Group 14 elements. However, sublimes at and is an ultra-hard abrasive, whereas solid sublimes at at . (a) Classify each solid into its correct structural class (molecular solid vs. covalent network solid). (b) Explain why carbon forms discrete linear molecules with oxygen () utilizing strong multiple bonds, whereas silicon preferentially forms an extended three-dimensional network of single bonds in and .
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) is a three-dimensional covalent network solid; solid is a discrete molecular solid held together only by weak London dispersion forces. (b) Carbon, a second-period element with small atomic radius, achieves effective lateral orbital overlap between compact orbitals to form strong, thermodynamically favored double bonds with oxygen. Silicon, a third-period element with a larger atomic radius and diffuse orbitals, exhibits poor lateral overlap; consequently, forming four strong single bonds (bond enthalpy for ) in a continuous 3D tetrahedral network is significantly more exothermic than forming localized double bonds.
Steps
Part (a): Structural Classification
-
Silicon Carbide ():
- Classification: Covalent network solid (or macromolecular solid).
- Reasoning: Silicon carbide consists of an infinite three-dimensional framework where each silicon atom is covalently bonded to four carbon atoms in a tetrahedral arrangement, and vice versa. Subliming or melting requires breaking immense numbers of strong, directional covalent bonds throughout the lattice, resulting in extreme hardness and a very high sublimation temperature ().
-
Solid Carbon Dioxide (, Dry Ice):
- Classification: Molecular solid.
- Reasoning: In solid , strong intramolecular covalent double bonds () hold individual molecules together, but the crystal lattice itself is held together only by weak intermolecular forces (London dispersion forces). Little energy is required to overcome these dispersion forces, leading to a low sublimation point ().
Part (b): Orbital Overlap and Energetics ( Bonding vs. Network Bonds)
-
Atomic Radius and Orbital Overlap:
- Carbon (Period 2): Carbon has a small covalent radius and relatively compact valence orbitals. When carbon bonds to oxygen (or another carbon), the short internuclear distance permits effective sideways (lateral) overlap of unhybridized orbitals. This results in stable, strong double bonds, enabling carbon to satisfy its octet within a discrete, neutral molecule.
- Silicon (Period 3): Silicon has an additional inner electron shell, a significantly larger atomic radius, and diffuse valence orbitals. The greater internuclear distance prevents effective lateral overlap between and (or and ) orbitals, making bonds involving silicon weak and unstable.
-
Thermodynamic Preference:
- Because lateral overlap is inefficient for silicon, the enthalpy of one double bond ( or ) is much less than the combined bond enthalpy of two single bonds ( or ).
- Consequently, silicon maximizes its thermodynamic stability by forming four strong single bonds in an extended tetrahedral network ( or ) rather than localized multiple bonds.
Common Pitfall: Do not confuse intermolecular forces with intramolecular covalent bonds when explaining sublimation temperatures. Solid sublimes at a low temperature not because the bonds are weak (they are very strong), but because only weak London dispersion forces between discrete molecules must be overcome.
Typical errors
01 The student misattributes the difference in bonding preference to electronegativity differences rather than atomic radius and poor lateral 3p-pπ overlap.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
is a covalent network solid. is a molecular solid.
- Step 2
Carbon is more electronegative than silicon. ⟹ Due to high electronegativity, carbon pulls electron density to form double bonds with oxygen. Silicon has lower electronegativity, so it cannot form double bonds and must form single bonds instead.
CorrectCarbon is a Period 2 element with a small covalent radius and compact orbitals, allowing strong, effective lateral sideways overlap ( bonding) with oxygen to form stable double bonds in discrete . Silicon is a Period 3 element with a larger atomic radius and diffuse orbitals; the larger internuclear distance prevents effective lateral overlap, making bonds weak. Consequently, forming four strong single bonds in an extended network is thermodynamically favored over double bonds.
Electronegativity governs bond polarity, not the geometric ability of atomic orbitals to form sideways bonds. The inability of silicon to form stable double bonds stems from its larger atomic radius and more diffuse orbitals, which cannot overlap laterally with sufficient efficiency.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly classified both silicon carbide and solid carbon dioxide into their appropriate structural classes.
You recognized that carbon forms double bonds in carbon dioxide whereas silicon forms single bonds in extended networks.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated multiple-bond formation as a consequence of electronegativity pulling electron density, rather than an orbital geometry phenomenon determined by atomic radius, principal quantum level, and lateral orbital overlap efficiency.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Orbital Size and Lateral Overlap
Effective sideways overlap requires compact valence orbitals and short internuclear distances (Period 2 elements). Diffuse orbitals () at longer internuclear distances yield very weak overlap.
When explaining why Period 3+ elements avoid multiple bonds, always inspect valence shell principal quantum number , atomic radius, and lateral orbital overlap efficiency instead of electronegativity.
- Thermodynamics: Two $\sigma$ Bonds vs. One $\pi$ Bond
For heavier elements like silicon, the bond energy of two single bonds (e.g., ) is significantly greater than the total bond energy of one double bond ().
Use bond enthalpy comparison to explain why extended single-bond networks are energetically preferred over localized double bonds for silicon.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the valence orbitals and covalent radii of carbon (Period 2, , compact) and silicon (Period 3, , diffuse).
Explain that the short distance permits strong sideways overlap of orbitals to form stable bonds in discrete molecules.
State that silicon's larger atomic radius leads to poor lateral overlap between diffuse orbitals and oxygen's orbitals.
Conclude that forming four strong single bonds in a continuous 3D network is far more exothermic than forming weak or double bonds.
(a) is a covalent network solid; solid is a molecular solid. (b) Carbon's compact orbitals achieve strong lateral overlap with oxygen at short internuclear distances, whereas silicon's larger atomic radius and diffuse orbitals prevent effective lateral overlap, favoring an extended 3D network of single bonds.
02 The student claims that silicon cannot form multiple bonds because it lacks available valence p orbitals or must use d orbitals instead of recognizing orbital overlap limits.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
is a covalent network solid. Solid is a molecular solid.
- Step 2
Carbon has orbitals that can participate in bonding.
- Step 3
Silicon in Period 3 has orbitals available, which prevents bonding from occurring.
CorrectSilicon (Period 3) has a larger atomic radius and more diffuse valence orbitals; the longer internuclear distance prevents effective lateral (sideways) overlap, making bonds weak and unfavorable.
The presence of empty orbitals does not inhibit bonding. Instead, silicon's larger atomic radius and diffuse orbitals lead to poor sideways overlap at greater internuclear distances.
- Step 4
Silicon is forced to use hybridization to form an extended network of single bonds.
CorrectBecause one or double bond is significantly weaker than two single bonds, silicon maximizes its thermodynamic stability by forming an extended network of strong bonds.
Your conclusion followed from the misconception in Step 3. Silicon adopts an -hybridized network because forming multiple strong single bonds is thermodynamically favored over forming weak multiple bonds.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly classified both silicon carbide as a covalent network solid and dry ice as a molecular solid.
You recognized that carbon's valence orbitals participate in bond formation.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou stated that available orbitals actively prevent bonding.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the presence of accessible higher-energy empty subshells () with spatial/geometric limits on orbital overlap, overlooking how atomic size and orbital diffuseness govern lateral overlap efficiency.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Orbital Overlap vs. Atomic Radius
Sideways () overlap requires short bond lengths; larger atoms with diffuse valence orbitals have poor lateral overlap.
Explain the rarity of multiple bonds in Period 3 elements by evaluating bond distance and orbital diffuseness rather than invoking orbitals.
- Thermodynamics of Multiple vs. Single Bonds
When two single bonds have a combined bond enthalpy greater than one corresponding double bond, an extended network of single bonds is favored over discrete multiple-bonded molecules.
Compare the enthalpy of multiple single bonds versus multiple bonds to explain why silicon forms a continuous network.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSilicon is in Period 3 and possesses a larger covalent radius with diffuse valence orbitals.
Because the and bond distances are relatively long, sideways (lateral) overlap between and orbitals is very weak.
Energetically, the bond enthalpy of two single bonds () is far greater than the bond enthalpy of one double bond ().
Silicon maximizes thermodynamic stability by forming four strong single bonds in a continuous 3D network rather than forming discrete molecules with weak bonds.
Lock it in
Why can Period 2 elements (C, N, O) readily form stable double and triple bonds, while Period 3 elements (Si, P, S) rarely do?
Period 2 elements have small atomic radii and compact orbitals allowing strong lateral overlap. Period 3 elements have larger radii and diffuse orbitals, making sideways overlap too weak.
Similar question
Elemental nitrogen exists as discrete diatomic molecules () with a triple bond, whereas elemental phosphorus exists as tetrahedral molecules containing only single bonds. Explain this difference based on atomic radius and orbital overlap.
Answer
Nitrogen is in Period 2 with a small radius and compact orbitals that form one strong and two strong bonds (). Phosphorus is in Period 3 with a larger radius and diffuse orbitals; lateral overlap is poor, so three single bonds in are much more stable than one triple bond.
Explain why (quartz) is a hard, high-melting solid (melting point ), whereas sublimes at , referencing the chemical bonding and intermolecular forces involved.
Answer
consists of discrete covalent molecules held together in the solid phase only by weak London dispersion forces, requiring little thermal energy to separate. In contrast, is a continuous covalent network where each silicon atom is bonded to four oxygen atoms by strong covalent bonds; melting requires breaking these immense covalent bonds throughout the entire lattice.
Using the bond enthalpy data: , , , and estimated , justify thermodynamically why carbon favors discrete while silicon favors network .
Answer
For carbon, forming one double bond () is more exothermic than forming two single bonds (), favoring double-bonded molecules. For silicon, forming two single bonds () releases significantly more energy than forming one double bond (), making an extended 3D network with four single bonds per Si thermodynamically favored.