Resources

A student measures the melting points of three anhydrous divalent alkaline earth oxides MO\text{MO} and observes: Compound X melts at 2572 ∘C2572\,^\circ\text{C}, Compound Y melts at 2852 ∘C2852\,^\circ\text{C}, and Compound Z melts at 1973 ∘C1973\,^\circ\text{C}. The three compounds are known to be CaO\text{CaO}, MgO\text{MgO}, and BaO\text{BaO}. Identify each compound (X, Y, and Z) by back-calculating their relative lattice energies using cation ionic radii: r(Mg2+)=72 pmr(\text{Mg}^{2+}) = 72\,\text{pm}, r(Ca2+)=100 pmr(\text{Ca}^{2+}) = 100\,\text{pm}, and r(Ba2+)=135 pmr(\text{Ba}^{2+}) = 135\,\text{pm} with r(O2−)=140 pmr(\text{O}^{2-}) = 140\,\text{pm}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

X=CaO\text{X} = \text{CaO}, Y=MgO\text{Y} = \text{MgO}, Z=BaO\text{Z} = \text{BaO}. Because all three compounds share identical ionic charges (+2+2 and −2-2), lattice energy is inversely proportional to internuclear distance r0=rcation+ranionr_0 = r_{\text{cation}} + r_{\text{anion}}. Summing radii yields r0(MgO)=212 pm<r0(CaO)=240 pm<r0(BaO)=275 pmr_0(\text{MgO}) = 212\,\text{pm} < r_0(\text{CaO}) = 240\,\text{pm} < r_0(\text{BaO}) = 275\,\text{pm}. Thus, lattice energy and melting point follow MgO(2852 ∘C)>CaO(2572 ∘C)>BaO(1973 ∘C)\text{MgO} (2852\,^\circ\text{C}) > \text{CaO} (2572\,^\circ\text{C}) > \text{BaO} (1973\,^\circ\text{C}).

Steps

01

Relate Lattice Energy to Melting Point

The melting point of an ionic compound depends primarily on its lattice energy (ΔHlattice\Delta H_{\text{lattice}}), which measures the strength of the electrostatic forces holding the ionic crystal lattice together.

According to Coulomb's law, the magnitude of the lattice energy (UU) is approximately proportional to the product of ionic charges and inversely proportional to the sum of the ionic radii (the internuclear separation distance, r0r_0):

U∝∣z1z2∣r0U \propto \frac{|z_1 z_2|}{r_0}

where:

  • z1z_1 and z2z_2 are the charges of the cation and anion, respectively.
  • r0=rcation+ranionr_0 = r_{\text{cation}} + r_{\text{anion}} is the equilibrium internuclear distance.

A higher lattice energy requires more thermal energy to disrupt the crystal lattice, leading to a higher melting point.


02

Compare Ionic Charges and Internuclear Distances

All three oxides—MgO\ce{MgO}, CaO\ce{CaO}, and BaO\ce{BaO}—contain divalent metal cations (MX2+\ce{M^2+}) and oxide anions (OX2−\ce{O^2-}): ∣z1z2∣=∣(+2)(−2)∣=4|z_1 z_2| = |(+2)(-2)| = 4

Because the ionic charge product is identical for all three compounds, the relative lattice energies depend solely on the internuclear distance r0r_0:

  • For MgO\ce{MgO}: r0(MgO)=r(MgX2+)+r(OX2−)=72 pm+140 pm=212 pmr_0(\ce{MgO}) = r(\ce{Mg^2+}) + r(\ce{O^2-}) = 72\,\text{pm} + 140\,\text{pm} = 212\,\text{pm}
  • For CaO\ce{CaO}: r0(CaO)=r(CaX2+)+r(OX2−)=100 pm+140 pm=240 pmr_0(\ce{CaO}) = r(\ce{Ca^2+}) + r(\ce{O^2-}) = 100\,\text{pm} + 140\,\text{pm} = 240\,\text{pm}
  • For BaO\ce{BaO}: r0(BaO)=r(BaX2+)+r(OX2−)=135 pm+140 pm=275 pmr_0(\ce{BaO}) = r(\ce{Ba^2+}) + r(\ce{O^2-}) = 135\,\text{pm} + 140\,\text{pm} = 275\,\text{pm}

03

Determine the Trend in Lattice Energy and Melting Point

Comparing the internuclear distances: r0(MgO)<r0(CaO)<r0(BaO)r_0(\ce{MgO}) < r_0(\ce{CaO}) < r_0(\ce{BaO})

Because lattice energy is inversely proportional to r0r_0, the lattice energy order is: Lattice Energy(MgO)>Lattice Energy(CaO)>Lattice Energy(BaO)\text{Lattice Energy}(\ce{MgO}) > \text{Lattice Energy}(\ce{CaO}) > \text{Lattice Energy}(\ce{BaO})

Consequently, the melting points follow the exact same decreasing order: Melting Point: MgO>CaO>BaO\text{Melting Point: } \ce{MgO} > \ce{CaO} > \ce{BaO}


04

Match with the Observed Melting Points

Comparing the predicted order with the experimental melting points:

  • Highest melting point (2852 ∘C2852\,^\circ\text{C}): Y=MgO\text{Y} = \ce{MgO}
  • Intermediate melting point (2572 ∘C2572\,^\circ\text{C}): X=CaO\text{X} = \ce{CaO}
  • Lowest melting point (1973 ∘C1973\,^\circ\text{C}): Z=BaO\text{Z} = \ce{BaO}

Helpful Tip: Always check ionic charges before comparing ionic radii. When ionic charges differ (for example, comparing NaCl\ce{NaCl} with +1/−1+1/-1 charges to MgO\ce{MgO} with +2/−2+2/-2 charges), the charge product dominates the lattice energy trend. When charges are identical, internuclear distance determines the trend.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the relationship between lattice energy and ionic radius, assuming larger ions create stronger bonds and higher lattice energies.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    d(MgO)=72+140=212 pm  ⟹  d(CaO)=100+140=240 pm  ⟹  d(BaO)=135+140=275 pmd(\text{MgO}) = 72 + 140 = 212\text{ pm} \implies d(\text{CaO}) = 100 + 140 = 240\text{ pm} \implies d(\text{BaO}) = 135 + 140 = 275\text{ pm}

  2. Step 2

    Lattice energy increases with increasing ionic radius, so BaO>CaO>MgO\text{Lattice energy increases with increasing ionic radius, so } \text{BaO} > \text{CaO} > \text{MgO}

    Correct

    U∝∣z1z2∣r0  ⟹  Lattice energy: MgO>CaO>BaOU \propto \frac{|z_1 z_2|}{r_0} \implies \text{Lattice energy: } \text{MgO} > \text{CaO} > \text{BaO}

    Lattice energy is inversely proportional to internuclear distance (U∝1r0U \propto \frac{1}{r_0}), not directly proportional. Smaller ions get closer together, resulting in stronger electrostatic attraction and higher lattice energy.

  3. Step 3

    Melting points: Y (2852 ∘C)>X (2572 ∘C)>Z (1973 ∘C)\text{Melting points: } \text{Y } (2852\,^\circ\text{C}) > \text{X } (2572\,^\circ\text{C}) > \text{Z } (1973\,^\circ\text{C})

  4. Step 4

    Compound X=CaO,  Compound Y=BaO,  Compound Z=MgO\text{Compound X} = \text{CaO},\; \text{Compound Y} = \text{BaO},\; \text{Compound Z} = \text{MgO}

    Correct

    Compound X=CaO,  Compound Y=MgO,  Compound Z=BaO\text{Compound X} = \text{CaO},\; \text{Compound Y} = \text{MgO},\; \text{Compound Z} = \text{BaO}

    Because the lattice energy trend was reversed in Step 2, Compound Y and Compound Z were incorrectly swapped.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the equilibrium internuclear distance for all three oxides.

You correctly ordered the experimental melting points in descending order.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Coulomb's Law inverse distance error

Assuming that lattice energy increases with larger ionic radius instead of decreasing.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated lattice energy as directly proportional to ionic radius, overlooking Coulomb's law (U∝∣z1z2∣r0U \propto \frac{|z_1 z_2|}{r_0}), which dictates that smaller ions achieve shorter internuclear distances, producing stronger electrostatic attraction and higher lattice energy.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Coulombic Attraction & Distance
  • Lattice energy is inversely proportional to internuclear distance: U∝1r0U \propto \frac{1}{r_0}.

  • When ionic charges are equal, identify the compound with the smallest internuclear distance (r0r_0) as having the strongest electrostatic attraction and highest lattice energy.

Melting Point Correlation
  • Higher lattice energy requires more thermal energy to disrupt the ionic crystal lattice, leading to a higher melting point.

  • Directly pair the highest melting point with the highest calculated lattice energy.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply Coulomb's law for identical charges (z1=+2,z2=−2z_1 = +2, z_2 = -2): U∝1r0U \propto \frac{1}{r_0}.

  2. Rank lattice energy based on distance: since r0(MgO)=212 pm<r0(CaO)=240 pm<r0(BaO)=275 pmr_0(\text{MgO}) = 212\text{ pm} < r_0(\text{CaO}) = 240\text{ pm} < r_0(\text{BaO}) = 275\text{ pm}, lattice energy follows MgO>CaO>BaO\text{MgO} > \text{CaO} > \text{BaO}.

  3. Match the predicted lattice energies with melting points: highest (2852 ∘C2852\,^\circ\text{C}) is Y=MgO\text{Y} = \text{MgO}, intermediate (2572 ∘C2572\,^\circ\text{C}) is X=CaO\text{X} = \text{CaO}, and lowest (1973 ∘C1973\,^\circ\text{C}) is Z=BaO\text{Z} = \text{BaO}.

Final answer

X=CaO,  Y=MgO,  Z=BaO\text{X} = \text{CaO},\; \text{Y} = \text{MgO},\; \text{Z} = \text{BaO}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Coulomb's law for ionic lattices to reinforce why smaller ions form stronger ionic bonds.

  • Practice comparing lattice energies for compounds sharing the same ionic charges by comparing their cation or anion radii.

  • Complete the three targeted practice exercises below to master lattice energy trends.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student inverts the ranking of the observed melting temperatures when assigning the compounds.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    d(MgO)=212 pmd(\text{MgO}) = 212\,\text{pm}, d(CaO)=240 pmd(\text{CaO}) = 240\,\text{pm}, d(BaO)=275 pm  ⟹  Lattice energy is inversely proportional to d:MgO>CaO>BaOd(\text{BaO}) = 275\,\text{pm} \implies \text{Lattice energy is inversely proportional to } d: \text{MgO} > \text{CaO} > \text{BaO}

  2. Step 2

    Lowest melting point corresponds to highest lattice energy\text{Lowest melting point corresponds to highest lattice energy}

    Correct

    Higher lattice energy corresponds to higher melting point\text{Higher lattice energy corresponds to higher melting point}

    Lattice energy measures electrostatic attraction holding the crystal lattice together. Stronger attraction requires more thermal energy to overcome, which raises the melting point.

  3. Step 3

    Melting point order: Z(1973 ∘C)<X(2572 ∘C)<Y(2852 ∘C)\text{Melting point order: } \text{Z} (1973\,^\circ\text{C}) < \text{X} (2572\,^\circ\text{C}) < \text{Y} (2852\,^\circ\text{C})

  4. Step 4

    Compound X=CaO,  Compound Y=BaO,  Compound Z=MgO\text{Compound X} = \text{CaO},\; \text{Compound Y} = \text{BaO},\; \text{Compound Z} = \text{MgO}

    Correct

    Compound X=CaO,  Compound Y=MgO,  Compound Z=BaO\text{Compound X} = \text{CaO},\; \text{Compound Y} = \text{MgO},\; \text{Compound Z} = \text{BaO}

    Because of the inverted relationship in Step 2, you assigned the compound with the greatest lattice energy (MgO\text{MgO}) to the lowest melting point (Z\text{Z}) instead of the highest (Y\text{Y}).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated internuclear distances by adding the cation and anion radii.

You properly applied Coulomb's law to show that lattice energy increases as internuclear distance decreases.

You accurately ordered the given numerical melting points from lowest to highest.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted relationship between lattice energy and melting point

No, this represents a conceptual misunderstanding connecting lattice energy magnitude to phase-change temperature.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated lattice energy as if it were inversely related to melting point, confusing the stability of the solid lattice with ease of melting. High lattice energy indicates very strong ionic bonds, which require higher thermal energy (higher temperature) to disrupt.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Lattice Energy Definition
  • Lattice energy is the energy required to completely separate one mole of a solid ionic compound into gaseous ions: U∝∣z1z2∣r0U \propto \frac{|z_1 z_2|}{r_0}.

  • Remember that larger lattice energy means a more tightly bound crystal.

Melting Point Trend
  • Melting involves disrupting electrostatic interactions in the lattice; therefore, higher lattice energy directly leads to a higher melting point.

  • Match the highest lattice energy to the highest melting point.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the direct physical relationship: melting point increases as lattice energy increases.

  2. Compare the compounds: since Lattice Energy(MgO)>Lattice Energy(CaO)>Lattice Energy(BaO)\text{Lattice Energy}(\text{MgO}) > \text{Lattice Energy}(\text{CaO}) > \text{Lattice Energy}(\text{BaO}), the melting points must follow MgO>CaO>BaO\text{MgO} > \text{CaO} > \text{BaO}.

  3. Match with the observed temperatures: highest (2852 ∘C2852\,^\circ\text{C}) is Y=MgO\text{Y} = \text{MgO}, intermediate (2572 ∘C2572\,^\circ\text{C}) is X=CaO\text{X} = \text{CaO}, and lowest (1973 ∘C1973\,^\circ\text{C}) is Z=BaO\text{Z} = \text{BaO}.

Final answer

X=CaO,  Y=MgO,  Z=BaO\text{X} = \text{CaO},\; \text{Y} = \text{MgO},\; \text{Z} = \text{BaO}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how lattice energy reflects ionic bond strength and directly determines melting temperature.

  • Practice matching experimental melting points to ionic compounds with identical charges by ordering their internuclear distances.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Rank the following alkali fluorides in order of increasing melting point: LiF\text{LiF}, KF\text{KF}, and NaF\text{NaF}, given r(Li+)<r(Na+)<r(K+)r(\text{Li}^+) < r(\text{Na}^+) < r(\text{K}^+).

Answer

KF<NaF<LiF\text{KF} < \text{NaF} < \text{LiF}. Key steps: All three compounds have identical ionic charges (+1+1 and −1-1). Internuclear distance increases as cation radius increases (r0(LiF)<r0(NaF)<r0(KF)r_0(\text{LiF}) < r_0(\text{NaF}) < r_0(\text{KF})). Because lattice energy is inversely proportional to r0r_0, lattice energy and melting point follow the reverse order: KF<NaF<LiF\text{KF} < \text{NaF} < \text{LiF}.

02

Two divalent magnesium salts have melting points of 2852 ∘C2852\,^\circ\text{C} and 2227 ∘C2227\,^\circ\text{C}. The compounds are MgO\text{MgO} and MgS\text{MgS}. Given r(O2−)=140 pmr(\text{O}^{2-}) = 140\text{ pm} and r(S2−)=184 pmr(\text{S}^{2-}) = 184\text{ pm}, identify which compound has the higher melting point and explain using lattice energy.

Answer

MgO\text{MgO} has the higher melting point (2852 ∘C2852\,^\circ\text{C}). Key steps: Both have +2/−2+2/-2 charges. The oxide ion has a smaller radius than the sulfide ion (140 pm<184 pm140\text{ pm} < 184\text{ pm}), making r0(MgO)<r0(MgS)r_0(\text{MgO}) < r_0(\text{MgS}). Shorter internuclear distance leads to higher lattice energy, requiring more thermal energy to melt MgO\text{MgO}.

03

Consider three ionic solids: NaF\text{NaF}, MgF2\text{MgF}_2, and MgO\text{MgO}. Predict which compound has the highest lattice energy and which has the lowest, taking into account both ionic charges and ionic sizes (r(Na+)≈r(Mg2+)r(\text{Na}^+) \approx r(\text{Mg}^{2+}) and r(F−)≈r(O2−)r(\text{F}^-) \approx r(\text{O}^{2-})).

Answer

Highest: MgO\text{MgO}; Lowest: NaF\text{NaF}. Key steps: Lattice energy depends on charge product ∣z1z2∣|z_1 z_2| and internuclear distance r0r_0 (U∝∣z1z2∣r0U \propto \frac{|z_1 z_2|}{r_0}). Charge effects dominate: for MgO\text{MgO}, ∣(+2)(−2)∣=4|(+2)(-2)| = 4; for MgF2\text{MgF}_2, ∣(+2)(−1)∣=2|(+2)(-1)| = 2; for NaF\text{NaF}, ∣(+1)(−1)∣=1|(+1)(-1)| = 1. With roughly similar ionic radii, the lattice energy order strictly follows the charge product: MgO>MgF2>NaF\text{MgO} > \text{MgF}_2 > \text{NaF}.

Loading workspace…