Resources

When writing complete nuclear equations, nuclear scientists adhere to the conservation of mass number (AA) and atomic number (ZZ). During positron emission, a proton converts into a neutron, an emitted positron (+10e{}_{+1}^{0}e or β+\beta^+), and an electron neutrino. Write the balanced nuclear equation for the positron decay of sodium-22 (1122Na{}_{11}^{22}\text{Na}), and explain why counting atomic electrons causes a mass deficit calculation trap: specifically, show that the net change in atomic mass for positron emission requires subtracting the mass of 22 electron equivalents (2me=0.001097 u2m_e = 0.001097\text{ u}) from the difference of the neutral atomic masses Δm=M(1122Na)−M(1022Ne)−2me\Delta m = M({}_{11}^{22}\text{Na}) - M({}_{10}^{22}\text{Ne}) - 2m_e. Given M(1122Na)=21.994437 uM({}_{11}^{22}\text{Na}) = 21.994437\text{ u} and M(1022Ne)=21.991386 uM({}_{10}^{22}\text{Ne}) = 21.991386\text{ u}, calculate the maximum kinetic energy QQ released in MeV\text{MeV} (1 u=931.5 MeV1\text{ u} = 931.5\text{ MeV}).

Answer and steps

Final answer

Balanced equation: 1122Na→1022Ne++1+0e+νe{}_{11}^{22}\text{Na} \rightarrow {}_{10}^{22}\text{Ne} + {}_{+1}^{\phantom{+}0}e + \nu_e; Q=1.82 MeVQ = 1.82\text{ MeV}

Steps

01

Write the Balanced Nuclear Equation

In any nuclear reaction, both the total mass number (AA, total nucleons) and the total atomic number (ZZ, nuclear charge) must be conserved:

  • Mass number conservation: The parent nucleus X1122X211222Na\ce{^{22}_{11}Na} has A=22A = 22. A positron (+10e{}_{+1}^{0}e or β+\beta^+) and an electron neutrino (νe\nu_e) each have A=0A = 0. Therefore, the daughter nucleus must have: Adaughter=22−0=22A_{\text{daughter}} = 22 - 0 = 22
  • Atomic number conservation: The parent nucleus has Z=11Z = 11. The emitted positron has Z=+1Z = +1, and the neutrino has Z=0Z = 0. Therefore, the daughter nucleus must have: Zdaughter=11−1=10Z_{\text{daughter}} = 11 - 1 = 10

Element 1010 is neon (Ne\ce{Ne}). The balanced equation is: X1122X211222Na→X1022X210222Ne+X+10X2+120e+νXe\ce{^{22}_{11}Na -> ^{22}_{10}Ne + {}_{+1}^{0}e + \nu_e}


02

Explain the 2me2m_e Mass Deficit Trap

Nuclear energy release (QQ) depends strictly on the difference in bare nuclear masses: Δm=mnuc(X1122X211222Na)−[mnuc(X1022X210222Ne)+m(β+)]\Delta m = m_{\text{nuc}}(\ce{^{22}_{11}Na}) - \left[m_{\text{nuc}}(\ce{^{22}_{10}Ne}) + m(\beta^+)\right] (The rest mass of the electron neutrino νe\nu_e is negligible, and m(β+)=mem(\beta^+) = m_e.)

However, standard mass tables list the masses of neutral atoms (MM), which include orbital electrons:

  • A neutral X1122X211222Na\ce{^{22}_{11}Na} atom contains 1111 orbital electrons: mnuc(X1122X211222Na)=M(X1122X211222Na)−11mem_{\text{nuc}}(\ce{^{22}_{11}Na}) = M(\ce{^{22}_{11}Na}) - 11m_e
  • A neutral X1022X210222Ne\ce{^{22}_{10}Ne} atom contains 1010 orbital electrons: mnuc(X1022X210222Ne)=M(X1022X210222Ne)−10mem_{\text{nuc}}(\ce{^{22}_{10}Ne}) = M(\ce{^{22}_{10}Ne}) - 10m_e

Substituting these atomic expressions into the nuclear mass defect gives: Δm=[M(X1122X211222Na)−11me]−[(M(X1022X210222Ne)−10me)+me]\Delta m = \left[M(\ce{^{22}_{11}Na}) - 11m_e\right] - \left[\left(M(\ce{^{22}_{10}Ne}) - 10m_e\right) + m_e\right]

Simplifying the terms: Δm=M(X1122X211222Na)−11me−M(X1022X210222Ne)+10me−me\Delta m = M(\ce{^{22}_{11}Na}) - 11m_e - M(\ce{^{22}_{10}Ne}) + 10m_e - m_e Δm=M(X1122X211222Na)−M(X1022X210222Ne)−2me\Delta m = M(\ce{^{22}_{11}Na}) - M(\ce{^{22}_{10}Ne}) - 2m_e

Physical Intuition: When the nucleus with charge +11+11 decays to charge +10+10, the atom has one excess orbital electron that it must shed to become a neutral neon atom. In addition, the nucleus creates and ejects a positron (1me1m_e). Therefore, comparing the neutral parent atom to the neutral daughter atom fails to account for two electron masses (2me2m_e) carrying mass-energy away from the system.


03

Calculate the Mass Defect and Energy Released (QQ)

Using the given data:

  • M(X1122X211222Na)=21.994437 uM(\ce{^{22}_{11}Na}) = 21.994437\text{ u}
  • M(X1022X210222Ne)=21.991386 uM(\ce{^{22}_{10}Ne}) = 21.991386\text{ u}
  • 2me=0.001097 u2m_e = 0.001097\text{ u}
  1. Compute the mass defect Δm\Delta m: Δm=21.994437 u−21.991386 u−0.001097 u\Delta m = 21.994437\text{ u} - 21.991386\text{ u} - 0.001097\text{ u} Δm=0.003051 u−0.001097 u=0.001954 u\Delta m = 0.003051\text{ u} - 0.001097\text{ u} = 0.001954\text{ u}
  2. Convert the mass defect into energy QQ using the conversion factor 1 u=931.5 MeV1\text{ u} = 931.5\text{ MeV}: Q=0.001954 u×931.5 MeV/u≈1.8202 MeVQ = 0.001954\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} \approx 1.8202\text{ MeV}

Rounding to two decimal places gives Q=1.82 MeVQ = 1.82\text{ MeV}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student ignores the 2m_e term when calculating the mass deficit, mistakenly assuming atomic electron masses cancel out as in beta-minus decay.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    1122Na→1022Ne++10e+νe{}_{11}^{22}\text{Na} \rightarrow {}_{10}^{22}\text{Ne} + {}_{+1}^{0}e + \nu_e

  2. Step 2

    Δ\Delta m = m_N(Na\text{Na}) - m_N(Ne\text{Ne}) - m_e   ⟹  \implies m_N(Na\text{Na}) = M(Na\text{Na}) - 11m_e  and \text{ and } m_N(Ne\text{Ne}) = M(Ne\text{Ne}) - 10m_e   ⟹  \implies Δ\Delta m = M(Na\text{Na}) - M(Ne\text{Ne}) - 2m_e  because of the emitted positron and one extra orbital electron.\text{ because of the emitted positron and one extra orbital electron.}

  3. Step 3

    Δ\Delta m = 21.994437 u\text{ u} - 21.991386 u\text{ u} = 0.003051 u\text{ u}

    Correct

    Δ\Delta m = 21.994437 u\text{ u} - 21.991386 u\text{ u} - 0.001097 u\text{ u} = 0.001954 u\text{ u}

    You omitted the −2me-2m_e (0.001097 u0.001097\text{ u}) term you just derived when substituting the numerical atomic masses.

  4. Step 4

    Q = 0.003051 u\text{ u} ×\times 931.5 MeV/u\text{ MeV/u} = 2.842 MeV\text{ MeV}

    Correct

    Q = 0.001954 u\text{ u} ×\times 931.5 MeV/u\text{ MeV/u} ≈\approx 1.82 MeV\text{ MeV}

    Your conversion method is correct, but the calculated energy value is carried forward from the incomplete mass defect in Step 3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You wrote the complete and balanced positron emission equation with the correct daughter nucleus and electron neutrino.

You successfully proved why positron emission requires subtracting two electron mass equivalents when using neutral atomic masses.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of $2m_e$ in numerical evaluation

You clearly proved that Δm=M(1122Na)−M(1022Ne)−2me\Delta m = M({}_{11}^{22}\text{Na}) - M({}_{10}^{22}\text{Ne}) - 2m_e, but you accidentally left out the −2me-2m_e term when plugging in the numerical values.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the theoretical derivation and numerical substitution as separate phases, causing an accidental slip where the derived −2me-2m_e correction was omitted during data entry.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Match formula to numbers
  • Every algebraic term in the final theoretical formula must have an explicit numerical counterpart in the substitution line.

  • Before computing, count the terms in your symbolic equation and verify that each term has an assigned number on the substitution line.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute the given masses and the 2me2m_e term into your derived formula: Δm=21.994437 u−21.991386 u−0.001097 u=0.001954 u\Delta m = 21.994437\text{ u} - 21.991386\text{ u} - 0.001097\text{ u} = 0.001954\text{ u}.

  2. Convert this corrected mass defect into energy: Q=0.001954 u×931.5 MeV/u≈1.82 MeVQ = 0.001954\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} \approx 1.82\text{ MeV}.

Final answer

Balanced equation: 1122Na→1022Ne++1+0e+νe{}_{11}^{22}\text{Na} \rightarrow {}_{10}^{22}\text{Ne} + {}_{+1}^{\phantom{+}0}e + \nu_e; Q=1.82 MeVQ = 1.82\text{ MeV}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out every numerical subtraction step explicitly, crossing off each term against the algebraic formula.

  • Practice contrasting β−\beta^- decay (where atomic electron masses cancel completely) and β+\beta^+ decay (which always retains the −2me-2m_e factor).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student subtracts only one electron mass (1m_e) instead of 2m_e, accounting for the emitted positron but forgetting the shed orbital electron.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    1122Na→1022Ne++1+0e+νe^{22}_{11}\text{Na} \rightarrow {}^{22}_{10}\text{Ne} + {}_{+1}^{\phantom{+}0}e + \nu_e

  2. Step 2

    Δm=mN(Na)−mN(Ne)−me  ⟹  Using atomic masses gives mN(Na)=M(Na)−11me and mN(Ne)=M(Ne)−10me  ⟹  Δm=M(Na)−M(Ne)−2me\Delta m = m_N(\text{Na}) - m_N(\text{Ne}) - m_e \implies \text{Using atomic masses gives } m_N(\text{Na}) = M(\text{Na}) - 11m_e \text{ and } m_N(\text{Ne}) = M(\text{Ne}) - 10m_e \implies \Delta m = M(\text{Na}) - M(\text{Ne}) - 2m_e

  3. Step 3

    Δm=21.994437 u−21.991386 u−0.0005485 u=0.0025025 u\Delta m = 21.994437\text{ u} - 21.991386\text{ u} - 0.0005485\text{ u} = 0.0025025\text{ u}

    Correct

    Δm=21.994437 u−21.991386 u−0.001097 u=0.001954 u\Delta m = 21.994437\text{ u} - 21.991386\text{ u} - 0.001097\text{ u} = 0.001954\text{ u}

    Although you derived −2me-2m_e in your formula, you substituted 0.0005485 u0.0005485\text{ u} (the mass of 1me1m_e) instead of the provided two-electron mass equivalent (2me=0.001097 u2m_e = 0.001097\text{ u}).

  4. Step 4

    Q=0.0025025 u×931.5 MeV/u=2.331 MeVQ = 0.0025025\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} = 2.331\text{ MeV}

    Correct

    Q=0.001954 u×931.5 MeV/u≈1.82 MeVQ = 0.001954\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} \approx 1.82\text{ MeV}

    Your conversion method from mass defect to MeV\text{MeV} was executed properly, but the final energy reflects the numerical error in Δm\Delta m from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly balanced the nuclear equation by conserving nucleon and proton numbers.

You showed a solid theoretical understanding by deriving the Δm=ΔM−2me\Delta m = \Delta M - 2m_e relationship using atomic and nuclear masses.

You correctly applied the conversion factor 1 u=931.5 MeV1\text{ u} = 931.5\text{ MeV}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Single-electron substitution slip

You derived the −2me-2m_e term symbolically, but inadvertently looked up or plugged in the mass of a single electron (me≈0.0005485 um_e \approx 0.0005485\text{ u}) instead of the given double-electron value (0.001097 u0.001097\text{ u}).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Disconnect between symbolic variable derivation and numerical parameter substitution: writing '2me2m_e' in algebra often leads students to plug in mem_e if they forget to multiply by 22 or overlook that the question already specified the combined quantity 2me=0.001097 u2m_e = 0.001097\text{ u}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Positron Mass Deficit Bookkeeping
  • For positron emission, Δm=Mparent−Mdaughter−2me\Delta m = M_{\text{parent}} - M_{\text{daughter}} - 2m_e, because one electron is shed from the electron cloud and one positron is emitted from the nucleus.

  • Always verify that the numerical value being subtracted represents the full 2me2m_e (2×0.0005486 u≈0.001097 u2 \times 0.0005486\text{ u} \approx 0.001097\text{ u}), not just 1me1m_e.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute the given neutral atomic masses and the full 2me2m_e value: Δm=21.994437 u−21.991386 u−0.001097 u\Delta m = 21.994437\text{ u} - 21.991386\text{ u} - 0.001097\text{ u}.

  2. Compute the mass defect: Δm=0.003051 u−0.001097 u=0.001954 u\Delta m = 0.003051\text{ u} - 0.001097\text{ u} = 0.001954\text{ u}.

  3. Convert to energy: Q=0.001954 u×931.5 MeV/u≈1.8202 MeVQ = 0.001954\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} \approx 1.8202\text{ MeV}.

Final answer

Q=1.82 MeVQ = 1.82\text{ MeV}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check numerical substitutions against given constants when formulas contain multiplier coefficients like 2me2m_e.

  • Contrast positron emission (subtract 2me2m_e) with β−\beta^- emission (electron masses cancel directly between parent and daughter atoms) to keep the physical electron counts clear.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student adds 2m_e rather than subtracting it when calculating the mass deficit.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    1122Na→1022Ne++1+0e+νe{}_{11}^{22}\text{Na} \rightarrow {}_{10}^{22}\text{Ne} + {}_{+1}^{\phantom{+}0}e + \nu_e

  2. Step 2

    Δm=mN(Na)−mN(Ne)−me  ⟹  mN(Na)=M(Na)−11me, mN(Ne)=M(Ne)−10me  ⟹  Δm=M(Na)−M(Ne)−2me\Delta m = m_N(\text{Na}) - m_N(\text{Ne}) - m_e \implies m_N(\text{Na}) = M(\text{Na}) - 11m_e,\, m_N(\text{Ne}) = M(\text{Ne}) - 10m_e \implies \Delta m = M(\text{Na}) - M(\text{Ne}) - 2m_e

  3. Step 3

    Δm=21.994437 u−21.991386 u+0.001097 u=0.004148 u\Delta m = 21.994437\text{ u} - 21.991386\text{ u} + 0.001097\text{ u} = 0.004148\text{ u}

    Correct

    Δm=21.994437 u−21.991386 u−0.001097 u=0.001954 u\Delta m = 21.994437\text{ u} - 21.991386\text{ u} - 0.001097\text{ u} = 0.001954\text{ u}

    You accidentally added the value of 2me2m_e (0.001097 u0.001097\text{ u}) instead of subtracting it, which reversed your own derived formula.

  4. Step 4

    Q=0.004148 u×931.5 MeV/u=3.864 MeVQ = 0.004148\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} = 3.864\text{ MeV}

    Correct

    Q=0.001954 u×931.5 MeV/u≈1.82 MeVQ = 0.001954\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} \approx 1.82\text{ MeV}

    You used the correct conversion factor 931.5 MeV/u931.5\text{ MeV/u}, but the resulting energy is incorrect due to the sign error in the mass defect calculation.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly balanced the nuclear equation with all conservation laws satisfied.

You clearly explained and algebraically derived the 2me2m_e mass deficit correction from neutral atomic masses.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign substitution error

You derived Δm=M(Na)−M(Ne)−2me\Delta m = M(\ce{Na}) - M(\ce{Ne}) - 2m_e with a minus sign, but switched to +0.001097 u+ 0.001097\text{ u} when substituting the numbers.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Lapse in transcription consistency between the algebraic formula and the arithmetic substitution step.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Formula-to-Number Sign Check
  • Every minus sign in the derived formula must directly translate to a subtraction operation in the numerical substitution.

  • Circle all subtraction signs in the algebraic expression before writing down numerical values to ensure no sign flips during substitution.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Δm=21.994437 u−21.991386 u−0.001097 u=0.001954 u\Delta m = 21.994437\text{ u} - 21.991386\text{ u} - 0.001097\text{ u} = 0.001954\text{ u}

  2. Q=0.001954 u×931.5 MeV/u≈1.82 MeVQ = 0.001954\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} \approx 1.82\text{ MeV}

Final answer

Q=1.82 MeVQ = 1.82\text{ MeV}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Re-evaluate the numerical line by carefully carrying through the minus sign in front of 2me2m_e.

  • Perform a sanity check on positron emission: because creating a positron and losing an orbital electron consumes mass-energy, the available QQ-value must be smaller than the raw atomic mass difference M(parent)−M(daughter)M(\text{parent}) - M(\text{daughter}).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Carbon-11 (611C{}_{6}^{11}\text{C}, atomic mass 11.011434 u11.011434\text{ u}) decays by positron emission to boron-11 (511B{}_{5}^{11}\text{B}, atomic mass 11.009305 u11.009305\text{ u}). Given 2me=0.001097 u2m_e = 0.001097\text{ u} and 1 u=931.5 MeV1\text{ u} = 931.5\text{ MeV}, calculate the decay energy QQ in MeV\text{MeV}.

Answer

Q=0.961 MeVQ = 0.961\text{ MeV}. Key steps: Δm=11.011434−11.009305−0.001097=0.001032 u\Delta m = 11.011434 - 11.009305 - 0.001097 = 0.001032\text{ u}; Q=0.001032 u×931.5 MeV/u≈0.961 MeVQ = 0.001032\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} \approx 0.961\text{ MeV}.

02

Fluorine-18 (918F{}_{9}^{18}\text{F}, M=18.000938 uM = 18.000938\text{ u}) decays to oxygen-18 (818O{}_{8}^{18}\text{O}, M=17.999160 uM = 17.999160\text{ u}) via β+\beta^+ emission. What is the maximum kinetic energy of the emitted positron, assuming the neutrino carries zero kinetic energy and 2me=0.001097 u2m_e = 0.001097\text{ u}?

Answer

Q=0.634 MeVQ = 0.634\text{ MeV}. Key steps: Δm=18.000938−17.999160−0.001097=0.000681 u\Delta m = 18.000938 - 17.999160 - 0.001097 = 0.000681\text{ u}; Q=0.000681 u×931.5 MeV/u≈0.634 MeVQ = 0.000681\text{ u} \times 931.5\text{ MeV/u} \approx 0.634\text{ MeV}.

03

A student claims that an isotope can undergo positron decay whenever Mparent>MdaughterM_{\text{parent}} > M_{\text{daughter}}. Explain why this threshold condition is incorrect, and state the minimum mass difference required.

Answer

Positron emission requires Mparent−Mdaughter>2meM_{\text{parent}} - M_{\text{daughter}} > 2m_e (approximately 1.022 MeV1.022\text{ MeV}). If the neutral mass difference is between 00 and 2me2m_e, positron decay is energetically forbidden, and the nucleus can decay only via electron capture.

Loading workspace…