Resources
Two identical rigid glass bulbs, Bulb A and Bulb B, are held at a constant temperature of . Bulb A contains of helium gas (molar mass ), while Bulb B contains of sulfur hexafluoride gas (, molar mass ). A student intuitively predicts that the heavier gas must exert a significantly higher pressure than helium because its molecules are roughly times more massive. By analyzing Avogadro's law, the ideal gas equation, and kinetic molecular theory, determine the exact ratio of the pressure in Bulb A to the pressure in Bulb B (), and state whether the student's prediction is correct or incorrect.
Answer and steps
Final answer
; the student's prediction is incorrect because at identical , , and , ideal gas pressure depends strictly on particle number density and average translational kinetic energy per molecule, not molecular mass.
Steps
Apply the Ideal Gas Law and Avogadro's Principle
The ideal gas equation relates pressure (), volume (), amount of substance in moles (), and absolute temperature ():
where is the universal gas constant.
Comparing the state variables for both bulbs:
- Volume:
- Temperature:
- Moles:
Taking the ratio of the two pressures:
According to Avogadro's law, equal volumes of gases at the same temperature and pressure contain an equal number of particles. Conversely, equal numbers of moles in identical volumes at the same temperature exert identical pressures, regardless of the identity or mass of the gas particles.
Molecular Explanation via Kinetic Molecular Theory (KMT)
The student's intuition confuses the mass of an individual particle with the pressure exerted by the gas ensemble. According to the Kinetic Molecular Theory:
- Average Kinetic Energy Depends Only on Temperature: At , both atoms and molecules have the exact same average translational kinetic energy.
-
Speed vs. Momentum per Collision: The root-mean-square speed is inversely proportional to the square root of the molar mass:
- molecules are heavier ( is larger), so each individual collision transfers more momentum ().
- However, because molecules move much slower (), they strike the container walls much less frequently (collision frequency ).
- Combined Effect on Pressure:
The greater momentum per impact of the heavier molecules is precisely cancelled out by their lower collision frequency.
Conclusion and Common Pitfall
- Pressure Ratio:
- Evaluation: The student's prediction is incorrect.
- Common Pitfall: Assuming heavier gas molecules create higher pressure by mistaking gas pressure for static weight. Gas pressure arises from thermal kinetic collisions against the walls, which depends strictly on number density () and absolute temperature (), not molecular mass.
Typical errors
01 The student assumes gas pressure is directly proportional to molecular mass rather than molar amount, predicting the pressure ratio reflects the ratio of molar masses.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
(at constant and )
You set pressure proportional to molar mass. However, the ideal gas law states that pressure depends on the number of moles , volume , and temperature , not the mass or chemical identity of the particles.
- Step 2Correct
Because your proportionality relationship was based on molar mass instead of mole amount, your computed pressure ratio directly inherited this error.
- Step 3Correct
Because the true pressure ratio is , both gases exert the exact same pressure, meaning the heavier gas does not exert higher pressure.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recorded the molar masses given for helium and sulfur hexafluoride.
You set up a clear ratio comparing Bulb A to Bulb B.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNone. This error stems from a fundamental conceptual confusion between particle mass and macroscopic gas pressure.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated gas pressure as if it were determined by the static weight or individual mass of the molecules rather than thermal kinetic collisions. In kinetic molecular theory, heavier molecules do carry more momentum per impact (), but their lower thermal speed exactly offsets this with a lower collision frequency (), leaving total pressure determined solely by number density and temperature.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Dependence of Ideal Gas Pressure
Check whether , , and are identical between two gases; if they are, their ideal pressures must be equal regardless of particle mass.
- Kinetic Molecular Balancing
Remember that heavier gas particles move slower at the same temperature, precisely canceling the extra force of each heavier impact.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the state variables for both bulbs: , , and .
Apply the ideal gas equation: . Since , , , and are identical for both containers, .
Compute the ratio: .
Conclude that the prediction is incorrect because molecular mass does not influence ideal gas pressure.
; the student's prediction is incorrect.
02 The student confuses the root-mean-square molecular velocity ratio with the pressure ratio, assuming pressure is proportional to molecular speed.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You equated the pressure ratio directly to the molecular speed ratio. Pressure depends on both the collision frequency (which scales with speed, ) and the momentum transferred per collision (which scales with momentum, ). Because and frequency , the mass dependence completely cancels out.
- Step 2Correct
Your numerical computation of correctly reflects the ratio of root-mean-square speeds, but it does not represent the pressure ratio.
- Step 3
The student's prediction is incorrect because the lighter gas exerts higher pressure.
CorrectThe student's prediction is incorrect because both gases exert the exact same pressure ().
While you correctly concluded that the prediction was incorrect, your reasoning that lighter gases exert higher pressure is inaccurate. Equal moles of any ideal gas in equal volumes at the same temperature exert identical pressure.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recalled the root-mean-square speed formula .
You accurately substituted the molar masses and computed the molecular speed ratio.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeAssuming that faster-moving molecules inevitably produce higher macroscopic gas pressure.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisOverlooking the kinetic molecular theory balance where higher collision frequency of lighter molecules is exactly offset by the greater momentum transferred per impact by heavier molecules, leaving pressure governed strictly by .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check State Variables First
Always compare , , and before considering molecular mass or speed. If , , and are identical, ideal gas pressures must be equal.
- Balance Collision Frequency and Momentum Transfer
Remember that collision frequency scales with while momentum transfer per impact scales with , so their product is independent of molar mass.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the ideal gas expression for pressure: .
Identify the given parameters: , , and .
Form the pressure ratio: .
; the student's prediction is incorrect.
Lock it in
According to the ideal gas law (), how does molecular mass affect the pressure of an ideal gas at fixed , , and ?
It has no effect. Pressure depends strictly on the number of gas particles (), volume, and temperature, not on the mass or identity of the particles.
Similar question
Two rigid flasks at contain equal masses () of (molar mass ) and (molar mass ). Determine the ratio of pressure in the neon flask to that in the argon flask ().
Answer
. Key steps: Calculate moles: ; . At identical and , , so .
A mixture contains of and of in a single rigid vessel at . Compare the partial pressures and , and calculate the total pressure in atmospheres ().
Answer
; . Key steps: Since mole fractions are equal (), . .
At , how does the average translational kinetic energy per molecule of compare to that of ? If the root-mean-square speed of is , express the collision frequency per unit area of wall surface for relative to at equal number densities.
Answer
Average kinetic energy is identical: . Collision frequency ratio is . Key steps: Average translational KE depends only on temperature, so . Wall collision frequency at equal number density.