Resources
In a high-resolution laboratory spectroscopy experiment, an undergraduate chemistry student passes an electric discharge through a hydrogen sample placed in an external magnetic field of and records the emission spectrum using a Fabry-Perot interferometer. (a) In the absence of a magnetic field, the student observes the red Balmer line () at . How does the Bohr model explain this single line? (b) Under the magnetic field, the line splits into distinct sub-components (the normal Zeeman effect). Calculate the energy shift in electron-volts for a transition involving states with (where the Bohr magneton ). (c) Explain why the quantum mechanical model readily accounts for this splitting via orbital magnetic quantum numbers () while the Bohr model completely fails to predict it.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) The Bohr model attributes the line strictly to energy differences between concentric fixed-energy shells (), predicting only a single spectral frequency; (b) (corresponding to a wavelength shift ); (c) The quantum mechanical model introduces the magnetic quantum number (), where each orbital possesses a magnetic dipole moment proportional to its orbital angular momentum vector that interacts with the external field (), lifting the degeneracy of the and orbitals; the Bohr model lacks 3D spatial quantization and spatial orientation quantum numbers, rendering it incapable of predicting the Zeeman effect.
Steps
Part (a): Explanation of the Single Emission Line by the Bohr Model
In the Bohr model of the hydrogen atom, electrons occupy discrete, concentric, circular orbits around the nucleus. The energy of an electron in an orbit is uniquely determined by the principal quantum number :
When an electron undergoes a transition from a higher energy orbit () to a lower energy orbit (), it emits a single photon with an energy equal to the difference between these two fixed levels:
Because each shell is treated as a single uniform energy state without sub-levels or spatial orientation, the model predicts exactly one transition frequency, producing a single sharp line at .
Part (b): Calculation of the Zeeman Energy Shift
In an external magnetic field , the orbital magnetic dipole moment interacts with the field, causing an energy shift given by:
Given:
Substitute these values into the expression:
(Optional wavelength check: Since , this corresponds to a tiny spectral splitting of .)
Part (c): Comparison of Quantum Mechanics and the Bohr Model
-
Why the Quantum Mechanical Model Accounts for Splitting:
- The quantum mechanical model describes electrons in three dimensions using three spatial quantum numbers: (principal), (orbital angular momentum), and (magnetic quantum number, where ).
- An electron with non-zero angular momentum () possesses an orbital magnetic dipole moment .
- In the absence of an external magnetic field, states with the same and but different values of are degenerate (they have identical energies).
- When an external magnetic field is applied, it exerts a torque on the orbital dipole moment, adding an interaction potential energy . This lifts the degeneracy, shifting states with positive, zero, and negative by different amounts and splitting the single line into multiple components depending on selection rules ().
-
Why the Bohr Model Fails:
- The Bohr model confines the electron to a two-dimensional, flat circular orbit governed solely by the single quantum number .
- It lacks three-dimensional wave functions, subshells, and spatial quantization (the direction of orbital angular momentum in space).
- Consequently, it provides no physical mechanism or quantum number to describe different spatial orientations interacting differently with an external magnetic field.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the energy difference ΔEZ directly with a photon wavelength shift and attempts to apply the de Broglie or Rydberg formula with n instead of multiplying μB by B.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
The Zeeman energy shift formula depends on the orbital magnetic quantum number change , not the principal quantum number difference . Although gave the correct numerical magnitude, the shift applies symmetrically as .
- Step 3Correct
You already had the energy shift in electron-volts (). Dividing an energy value by a wavelength in meters creates an inconsistent quantity with units of , rather than an energy in .
- Step 4
Quantum mechanics has describing orientation of angular momentum, which splits into states in a magnetic field. Bohr model has no magnetic quantum number , so it cannot predict the split.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou accurately stated how the Bohr model uses to predict a single emission line for the Balmer series.
You correctly identified that quantum mechanics uses to describe orbital spatial orientation and split degenerate states in a magnetic field.
You correctly multiplied the Bohr magneton by the magnetic field to find the scale of the energy shift.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou divided your calculated energy shift by the unshifted wavelength , turning a completed energy value in into an invalid quantity.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated the principal quantum number shell difference with the magnetic quantum number change , and you were uncertain about whether directly yields energy or requires wavelength division.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distinguishing $n$ from $m_l$
Principal quantum number defines radial shell energy in an isolated atom (), whereas magnetic quantum number specifies the spatial orientation of orbital angular momentum interacting with an external field.
In , always insert the magnetic quantum number selection value (or ), never shell indices .
- Verifying Energy Units
The product has units of , which is already an energy.
Do not divide by . If a wavelength shift is requested, use the differential relation .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the given transition condition: .
Substitute into the Zeeman shift formula: .
Evaluate the product directly: .
02 The student misinterprets Δml = ±1 as defining a total shift spanned across both endpoints, doubling the shift by using Δml = 2.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Energy levels in Bohr's model depend solely on . ⟹ The transition from to has a single energy difference , giving one line.
- Step 2
Between and , ⟹
CorrectYou calculated the total energy difference across both outer components () rather than the shift of each component relative to the unperturbed transition ($ m_l = 1). The energy shift of each side component is $$\pm 8.68 10^{-5}$.$$
- Step 3
Quantum mechanics introduces to describe spatial orientations of orbital angular momentum that interact with . ⟹ Bohr orbits are planar circular orbits defined only by , without space quantization, so no splitting can occur.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly attributed the single Bohr line to energy levels depending strictly on the principal quantum number .
You accurately identified the role of the magnetic quantum number in spatial quantization and dipole-field interactions.
You recognized the structural limitation of Bohr's planar circular orbits in describing field-induced line splitting.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated the selection rule change between states during a transition () with the overall span between the extreme sub-levels ( to ), which inadvertently doubled your calculated shift.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Spectral Shift vs. Total Splitting Span
A spectral line shift represents the displacement of an emitted line from the original central frequency, given by where .
Use or to find the individual component shifts ($ _B B2_B B$ only when explicitly asked for the peak-to-peak total separation.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the magnetic quantum number shift for the transition: .
Substitute the parameters into the Zeeman shift equation: .
Evaluate numerically: .
03 The student attributes the failure of the Bohr model to the absence of electron spin rather than the absence of orbital angular momentum spatial quantization (ml).
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Bohr assumed electron orbits have quantized energy based on . Only one photon energy is emitted, so only one spectral line appears.
- Step 2
- Step 3
Quantum mechanics includes electron spin which splits the line into two sub-components in a magnetic field. ⟹ The Bohr model fails because it treats the electron as a spinless particle without spin-orbit coupling.
CorrectQuantum mechanics introduces the orbital magnetic quantum number (where ), describing the spatial orientation of orbital angular momentum. In an external field , the magnetic dipole interaction energy removes the degeneracy of the orbitals. The Bohr model fails because it confines electrons to flat, two-dimensional circular orbits with no 3D spatial quantization or orientation quantum number .
You attributed the normal Zeeman splitting to electron spin () and spin-orbit coupling. The normal Zeeman effect arises from orbital angular momentum spatial quantization () interacting with the external magnetic field. The Bohr model fails because it lacks three-dimensional spatial quantization of orbital orientation, not because of missing spin.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the Bohr model predicts a single line because energy depends solely on the principal quantum number .
You correctly calculated the magnitude of the Zeeman energy shift using .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou associated magnetic splitting with intrinsic electron spin () rather than the spatial quantization of orbital angular momentum (). The normal Zeeman effect specifically lifts the -fold orbital degeneracy due to different spatial orientations of the orbital magnetic dipole moment in an external field .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Quantum Numbers: $m_l$ vs. $m_s$
The orbital magnetic quantum number defines the spatial orientation of the orbital angular momentum vector , whereas the spin quantum number defines the intrinsic spin angular momentum .
When analyzing Zeeman splitting governed by orbital states (normal Zeeman effect), focus on orbital spatial quantization () and the resulting interaction energy .
- Dimensionality in Bohr vs. Quantum Mechanics
The Bohr model is strictly a two-dimensional planar orbit model specified by , completely missing spatial orientation in 3D space.
Attribute the failure of the Bohr model in external magnetic fields to its lack of 3D spatial quantization and subshell orientation quantum numbers ().
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the physical origin of the normal Zeeman effect: an external field interacts with the orbital magnetic dipole moment , producing potential energy .
Explain why the quantum mechanical model succeeds: it provides the magnetic quantum number , which lifts the degeneracy of states with different spatial orientations when placed in an external magnetic field.
Explain why the Bohr model fails: it models the electron as orbiting in a single fixed 2D plane with only one quantum number , so it provides no physical mechanism or quantum number for 3D spatial orientation.
(a) In the Bohr model, energy levels depend solely on , so the transition involves a single fixed energy difference , yielding only one spectral line. (b) . (c) Quantum mechanics introduces the orbital magnetic quantum number (), where different orbital spatial orientations interact with via to lift orbital degeneracy. The Bohr model fails because it assumes flat 2D orbits and lacks 3D spatial quantization.
Lock it in
What physical property does the magnetic quantum number represent, and what values can it take for a given subshell ?
It represents the spatial orientation (quantization along the -axis) of orbital angular momentum, taking integer values from to .
Similar question
A hydrogen atom in a subshell () is placed in a magnetic field of . Calculate the energy separation in between the and sublevels (using ).
Answer
. Key step: .
An electron undergoes a transition between states where the magnetic energy changes by in an external field of . Determine the change in magnetic quantum number for this transition.
Answer
. Key step: .
A spectral line at undergoes normal Zeeman splitting in a field with . Calculate the resulting wavelength shift in nanometers given that (where ).
Answer
. Key steps: First compute . Then .