Resources
Three unlabeled solid crystalline samples (, , and ) are analyzed in the laboratory. Solid has a melting point of , does not conduct electricity in the solid state, but forms an electrically conductive solution when dissolved in water (). Solid has a melting point of , does not conduct electricity in either the solid or liquid state, and dissolves in ethanol but not water. Solid has a melting point of , exhibits high electrical conductivity of as a solid at , and is malleable under mechanical stress. (a) Classify each solid as an ionic compound, a molecular substance, or a metallic substance. (b) Identify the primary attractive force or bonding type holding the constituent particles together in the solid lattice for each sample.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Solid : ionic compound; Solid : molecular substance; Solid : metallic substance. (b) Solid : electrostatic attractions between cations and anions (ionic bonds); Solid : intermolecular forces (dispersion forces and dipole-dipole attractions); Solid : nondirectional electrostatic attraction between a lattice of metal cations and delocalized valence electrons (metallic bonds).
Steps
Analysis of Solid
To classify each crystalline solid and identify its bonding, analyze its physical properties—such as melting point, electrical conductivity under different conditions, and mechanical behavior.
- Properties observed:
- High melting point (), which indicates strong attractive forces throughout the three-dimensional lattice.
- Non-conductive in the solid phase because ions are locked rigidly into place and cannot migrate.
- Electrically conductive in aqueous solution because the crystal lattice dissociates into mobile, charge-carrying cations and anions.
- Classification (a): Ionic compound (characteristic of salts like sodium chloride, ).
- Primary bonding type (b): Ionic bonding, consisting of strong, multidirectional electrostatic attractions between positively charged cations and negatively charged anions.
Analysis of Solid
- Properties observed:
- Low melting point (), indicating that relatively little thermal energy is needed to overcome the attractions holding the discrete units together.
- Non-conductive in both solid and liquid states, indicating the absence of free mobile ions or delocalized electrons.
- Soluble in ethanol (a less polar organic solvent) and insoluble in water, typical of nonpolar or weakly polar molecules.
- Classification (a): Molecular substance (characteristic of covalent molecular solids such as iodine, ).
- Primary attractive force (b): Intermolecular forces (specifically London dispersion forces and/or dipole-dipole interactions), which act between neutral, discrete molecules.
- Common Pitfall: Do not confuse the strong intramolecular covalent bonds holding the atoms together within a molecule with the much weaker intermolecular forces holding the molecules together in the crystal lattice. Melting breaks intermolecular forces, not covalent bonds.
Analysis of Solid
- Properties observed:
- High melting point (), reflecting robust bonding across the lattice.
- Extremely high electrical conductivity in the solid state (), which requires freely moving valence electrons.
- Malleability under mechanical stress, showing that layers of atoms can slide past one another without disrupting the cohesion of the lattice.
- Classification (a): Metallic substance (characteristic of metals like copper, ).
- Primary bonding type (b): Metallic bonding, characterized by the nondirectional electrostatic attraction between an ordered lattice of fixed metal cations and a delocalized "sea" of mobile valence electrons.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the intramolecular covalent bonds holding atoms together within molecules with the intermolecular forces holding the molecules together in the solid crystal lattice.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Solid A: ionic compound ⟹ Solid B: molecular substance ⟹ Solid C: metallic substance
- Step 2
Solid A: ionic bonds ⟹ Solid C: metallic bonds
- Step 3
Solid B: covalent bonds
CorrectIntermolecular forces (dispersion forces and dipole-dipole attractions)
Covalent bonds are intramolecular forces that hold the individual atoms together inside each discrete molecule. The lattice of a molecular solid is held together by much weaker intermolecular forces, which explains its low melting point of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly classified all three crystalline solids based on their physical properties.
You identified ionic bonds as the primary attraction holding the lattice of Solid together.
You identified metallic bonds as the primary attraction holding the lattice of Solid together.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the strong intramolecular covalent bonds holding atoms together within discrete molecules with the much weaker intermolecular forces (such as dispersion or dipole-dipole forces) that hold the molecules to one another within a molecular crystal lattice.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Intramolecular vs. Intermolecular Forces
In a molecular substance, strong covalent bonds hold atoms together inside each molecule (intramolecular), but weak attractions (intermolecular forces) hold separate molecules together in the solid crystal.
When asked for the force holding a molecular solid together or the force overcome during melting/boiling, always name intermolecular forces (dispersion, dipole-dipole, or hydrogen bonding), not covalent bonds (unless it is a network covalent solid like diamond or quartz).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDetermine the constituent particles of the solid: Solid is a molecular substance, so its crystal lattice consists of discrete, neutral molecules rather than ions or isolated bonded atoms.
Identify the attractions acting between these discrete molecules: neutral molecules are attracted to one another through intermolecular forces (London dispersion forces and dipole-dipole attractions).
Verify with physical data: overcoming these relatively weak intermolecular forces requires little thermal energy, which matches the low melting point of .
(a) Solid : ionic compound; Solid : molecular substance; Solid : metallic substance. (b) Solid : ionic bonds; Solid : intermolecular forces; Solid : metallic bonds.
02 The student associates high electrical conductivity in aqueous solution with mobile delocalized electrons of metals rather than dissociated mobile ions.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Solid : metallic substance metallic bonds
CorrectSolid : ionic compound ionic bonds (electrostatic attractions between cations and anions)
Solid does not conduct electricity as a solid, but it conducts when dissolved in water. Metals conduct electricity in the solid phase through delocalized electrons, whereas ionic compounds only conduct when their rigid lattice is broken into mobile ions (in aqueous solution or molten form).
- Step 2
Solid : molecular substance intermolecular forces
- Step 3
Solid : ionic compound ionic bonds
CorrectSolid : metallic substance metallic bonds (attraction between metal cations and delocalized valence electrons)
Solid exhibits very high solid-state electrical conductivity () and malleability under stress. Ionic solids are electrical insulators in the solid state and are brittle rather than malleable because shifting ionic layers causes like-charge repulsion.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified Solid as a molecular solid based on its low melting point and lack of electrical conductivity.
You correctly paired each substance classification with its corresponding lattice bonding type (metallic with metallic bonds, molecular with intermolecular forces, and ionic with ionic bonds).
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou associated electrical conductivity in aqueous solution with metals rather than recognizing that solid-state electrical conductivity and malleability define metallic solids, whereas electrical conductivity upon dissolution in water defines soluble ionic compounds.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Solid-State vs. Solution Conductivity
Metals conduct electricity in the solid and liquid states via mobile delocalized valence electrons. Ionic compounds are non-conductive as solids and only conduct when melted or dissolved in water, which frees ions to move.
Check the phase in which conductivity occurs: solid conductivity indicates metallic bonding, while conductivity exclusively in liquid/aqueous states indicates ionic bonding.
- Mechanical Behavior under Stress
Metals are malleable because nondirectional metallic bonds allow atomic planes to slide past each other without shattering. Ionic crystals are brittle because shifting layers align like charges (cation-cation or anion-anion), causing rapid cleavage.
When a substance is described as malleable, classify it as a metal; if brittle, consider an ionic solid or network covalent crystal.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify that Solid does not conduct as a solid but conducts in aqueous solution, which means it consists of ions locked in a lattice that become mobile when dissolved. Therefore, Solid is an ionic compound held together by ionic bonds.
Identify that Solid conducts electricity strongly in the solid state and is malleable, which means it contains a delocalized 'sea of electrons' surrounding metal cations. Therefore, Solid is a metallic substance held together by metallic bonds.
(a) Solid : ionic compound; Solid : molecular substance; Solid : metallic substance. (b) Solid : ionic bonds (electrostatic attractions between cations and anions); Solid : intermolecular forces; Solid : metallic bonds (attractions between cations and delocalized electrons).
Lock it in
What type of forces hold the constituent particles together in the lattice of a molecular solid such as ice or iodine?
Intermolecular forces (e.g., London dispersion, dipole-dipole, hydrogen bonding). Covalent bonds hold atoms together inside each molecule, not between separate molecules.
Similar question
Solid sulfur () melts at and does not conduct electricity. Identify (a) the type of solid it forms and (b) the specific primary force holding the units together in the solid crystal.
Answer
(a) Molecular solid. (b) London dispersion forces (intermolecular forces). The nonpolar, discrete ring molecules are held together in the solid by London dispersion forces, not by breaking covalent bonds.
Two non-conductive solids, and , both contain covalent bonds. Solid melts at , while Solid does not melt until . Explain the difference in melting points based on the forces holding their lattices together.
Answer
Solid is a molecular solid held together by weak intermolecular forces, which require little energy to overcome. Solid is a covalent network solid (like ) held together by a continuous three-dimensional network of strong covalent bonds, requiring extreme thermal energy to break.
A crystalline substance has a melting point of , is ductile, conducts electricity in both solid and liquid states, but is insoluble in water. Contrast the nature of electrical conduction in substance with that of an ionic solid like .
Answer
Substance is a metal whose conductivity is due to freely mobile, delocalized valence electrons moving through a rigid lattice of cations. An ionic solid like cannot conduct in the solid state because ions are fixed; it only conducts when melted or dissolved in water, where mobile cations and anions act as charge carriers.