Resources
Two isomeric open-chain hydrocarbons, Compound A and Compound B, both have the molecular formula . Both compounds decolorize brown bromine water in dichloromethane. However, when treated with ammoniacal silver nitrate solution (Tollens' reagent for terminal alkynes), Compound A forms a heavy white-grey precipitate, while Compound B shows no reaction. Furthermore, Compound C with the formula does not react with bromine water or Tollens' reagent under dark ambient conditions. (a) Classify each of Compounds A, B, and C as an alkane, alkene, or alkyne. (b) Explain why Compound A reacts with ammoniacal while Compound B does not, citing the hybridization and acidity of the relevant bond.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Compound A is a terminal alkyne (e.g., 1-pentyne); Compound B is an internal alkyne (e.g., 2-pentyne) or alkadiene; Compound C is an alkane (pentane); (b) Compound A possesses an -hybridized terminal alkyne carbon whose attached proton has high -character () and sufficient Bronsted-Lowry acidity () to be deprotonated by weak base to form a silver acetylide precipitate, whereas Compound B lacks an bond.
Steps
Part (a): Classification of Compounds A, B, and C
-
Calculate the Degree of Unsaturation (Index of Hydrogen Deficiency, IHD):
- For an open-chain hydrocarbon with general formula , the compound is fully saturated.
- Compound C (): Having zero degrees of unsaturation means Compound C contains only single and bonds. It does not react with bromine water or Tollens' reagent, which is characteristic of saturated hydrocarbons. Therefore, Compound C is an alkane (such as pentane).
- Compounds A and B (): An IHD of in an open-chain hydrocarbon corresponds to either one triple bond (an alkyne) or two double bonds (a diene/alkadiene). Both compounds decolorize bromine water via electrophilic addition, confirming the presence of multiple carbon-carbon bonds (unsaturation).
-
Differentiating Compounds A and B by Reaction with Ammoniacal Silver Nitrate:
- Compound A gives a heavy white/grey precipitate with ammoniacal (Tollens' reagent), a test specific to terminal alkynes containing an acetylenic hydrogen (). Therefore, Compound A is an alkyne, specifically a terminal alkyne (such as 1-pentyne, ).
- Compound B does not form a precipitate with Tollens' reagent despite having an IHD of . Thus, it lacks an acidic terminal acetylenic proton. Therefore, Compound B is an alkyne, specifically an internal alkyne (such as 2-pentyne, ), or potentially an alkadiene (such as 1,3-pentadiene or 1,4-pentadiene).
Part (b): Hybridization, Acidity, and Reactivity of the Bond
- Hybridization and Electronegativity: The terminal carbon of Compound A is -hybridized, meaning its bonding orbitals possess -character. In contrast, an -hybridized carbon has -character, and an -hybridized carbon has -character. Because -orbitals are held closer to the positively charged atomic nucleus than -orbitals, electrons in an -hybridized orbital experience a greater effective nuclear charge, making the terminal carbon significantly more electronegative.
- Acidity of the Terminal Bond: Due to the high -character, the conjugate base (the acetylide carbanion, ) is unusually well stabilized because its lone pair resides in an hybrid orbital. Consequently, terminal alkyne protons have a relatively low compared to alkene protons () and alkane protons ().
- Precipitate Formation: The mildly basic ammonia in ammoniacal silver nitrate solution deprotonates the acidic terminal hydrogen of Compound A, allowing the acetylide ion to coordinate with silver ions and precipitate as insoluble silver acetylide: Compound B either has internal triple bonding () or double bonds (); it completely lacks an -hybridized bond, so it cannot undergo this deprotonation-precipitation reaction under these conditions.
Typical errors
01 The student misinterprets the negative Tollens' test as evidence of a double bond rather than recognizing that internal alkynes also do not react with ammoniacal silver nitrate.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
Compound B is an internal alkyne (e.g., 2-pentyne) or an alkadiene.
A simple open-chain alkene has the general formula (which would be with ), whereas Compound B has the formula with . An internal alkyne (such as 2-pentyne, ) has two degrees of unsaturation, decolorizes bromine water, and gives a negative Tollens' test because it lacks an acetylenic hydrogen.
- Step 3
- Step 4
- Step 5Correct
Compound B is an internal alkyne (or alkadiene) and lacks an -hybridized bond entirely, so it cannot be deprotonated to form a silver acetylide precipitate.
Because of the earlier misclassification of Compound B as an alkene, your explanation refers to bonds rather than noting that internal alkynes have no -hybridized bonds at all.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly computed the index of hydrogen deficiency () for .
You correctly classified Compound A as an alkyne based on its positive Tollens' test.
You correctly classified Compound C as an alkane based on its saturated formula .
You clearly connected the reactivity of Compound A to the enhanced acidity of an -hybridized bond.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that a negative Tollens' test rules out alkynes, overlooking that Tollens' reagent only reacts with terminal alkynes (). Internal alkynes () are also alkynes with , but they do not possess an acetylenic proton to form a silver precipitate.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Match formula to degree of unsaturation
Open-chain monoalkenes have general formula (), while alkynes and alkadienes have formula ().
Always verify that your proposed functional class matches the calculated from the molecular formula.
- Differentiating terminal vs. internal alkynes
Tollens' reagent and ammoniacal test specifically for terminal alkynes with an bond, not all alkynes.
When an unsaturated hydrocarbon with gives a negative Tollens' test, classify it as an internal alkyne (or a diene), not a monoalkene.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the formula with to open-chain hydrocarbon classes: an alkene with one double bond requires formula (), which does not fit .
Recognize that an open-chain compound with that decolorizes bromine water must contain either one triple bond (alkyne) or two double bonds (alkadiene).
Since Compound A reacts with Tollens' reagent, it is a terminal alkyne with a unit (such as 1-pentyne).
Since Compound B has formula but shows no reaction with Tollens' reagent, it lacks a terminal group. Therefore, Compound B is an internal alkyne (such as 2-pentyne) or an alkadiene.
For part (b), explain that Compound B does not react because it completely lacks an -hybridized bond.
(a) Compound A is an alkyne (terminal alkyne); Compound B is an alkyne (internal alkyne) or alkadiene; Compound C is an alkane. (b) Compound A has an -hybridized bond with -character, making the hydrogen sufficiently acidic () to be deprotonated by ammoniacal silver ions to form an insoluble silver acetylide precipitate. In contrast, Compound B lacks an -hybridized bond entirely.
02 The student confuses the hybridization of carbon-carbon triple bonds with double bonds, attributing the acidity of the terminal alkyne C-H bond to sp2 hybridization.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Compound A is an alkyne. ⟹ Compound B is an alkyne. ⟹ Compound C is an alkane.
- Step 2
Compound A has a terminal C-H bond with hybridization and s-character, which makes the hydrogen acidic enough to react with .
CorrectCompound A possesses an -hybridized terminal alkyne carbon with -character, making the terminal bond acidic enough () to be deprotonated by weak base and form an insoluble silver acetylide precipitate.
A triple-bonded carbon forming two bonds and two bonds is -hybridized, not -hybridized. This gives it -character, which holds electron density closer to the nucleus and stabilizes the conjugate acetylide carbanion.
- Step 3
Compound B is an internal alkyne with only non-acidic C-H bonds on alkyl groups, so it does not react.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly classified Compounds A and B as alkynes and Compound C as an alkane.
You recognized that terminal alkynes possess acidic bonds that react with ammoniacal silver ions.
You accurately identified that internal alkynes lack this acidic proton and therefore do not form a precipitate with Tollens' reagent.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the hybridization scheme of an alkyne carbon with that of an alkene carbon, attributing hybridization ( -character) instead of hybridization ( -character) to a carbon involved in a carbon-carbon triple bond.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Relate Bond Order to Carbon Hybridization
A carbon with 4 single () bonds is ; a carbon with 1 double bond (1 , 1 ) is ; a carbon with 1 triple bond (1 , 2 ) or two double bonds is .
Count the steric number or number of bonds: an alkyne carbon is bonded to only two atoms with linear geometry, requiring two hybrid orbitals.
- Link $s$-Character to Carbanion Stability and Acidity
Greater fractional -character () holds the conjugate base's lone pair closer to the carbon nucleus, greatly stabilizing the anion and increasing Bronsted acidity.
Always associate terminal alkyne acidity () with the -character of an hybrid orbital.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the steric number of the terminal carbon in 1-pentyne: it is bonded to one hydrogen and one carbon (2 bonds, 0 lone pairs), giving linear geometry and hybridization.
Calculate the percent -character for orbitals: .
Explain that this -character places electron density much closer to the carbon nucleus than in () or () carbons, stabilizing the acetylide conjugate base () and resulting in a .
Conclude that mild basic ammonia in Tollens' reagent deprotonates the bond to form insoluble silver acetylide precipitate .
(a) Compound A is a terminal alkyne; Compound B is an internal alkyne (or alkadiene); Compound C is an alkane. (b) Compound A reacts with ammoniacal because its terminal carbon is -hybridized ( -character), which stabilizes the conjugate acetylide carbanion and makes the terminal proton acidic (); Compound B lacks an bond.
03 The student interprets the negative Tollens' test as a complete lack of unsaturation, incorrectly classifying Compound B as an alkane despite its reaction with bromine water.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Compound A decolorizes and forms a precipitate with Tollens' reagent, so it is an alkyne.
- Step 2
Compound B shows no reaction with Tollens' reagent, so it is an alkane.
CorrectCompound B is an alkyne (specifically an internal alkyne) or an alkadiene.
Compound B has the molecular formula (index of hydrogen deficiency ) and decolorizes bromine water, proving it is unsaturated. A negative Tollens' test only rules out a terminal alkyne; it does not make the compound an alkane.
- Step 3
Compound C does not react with or Tollens' reagent, so it is an alkane.
- Step 4
Compound A has an acidic bond that reacts with ammoniacal to precipitate.
- Step 5
Compound B has only bonds of an alkane which are not acidic, so it does not react.
CorrectCompound B is an internal alkyne (or diene) and lacks a terminal -hybridized bond, so it cannot be deprotonated to form a silver acetylide precipitate.
Your reasoning here was affected by misclassifying Compound B in part (a). Compound B contains an internal triple bond (or double bonds) rather than being an alkane, but it does lack the terminal acetylenic bond needed to react with Tollens' reagent.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated or deduced that Compound A contains a triple bond and is a terminal alkyne.
You correctly classified Compound C as a saturated alkane based on its lack of addition reactivity.
You correctly cited the hybridization and acidity of the terminal bond to explain the reaction of Compound A with Tollens' reagent.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated Tollens' reagent as a test for all unsaturation rather than specifically for terminal alkynes.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing a negative result on a specific functional-group test (ammoniacal silver nitrate for terminal alkynes) with a general absence of multiple bonds, while ignoring the positive bromine water addition test and the formula (IHD = 2).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check Index of Hydrogen Deficiency (IHD)
For a hydrocarbon , . An alkane has , an alkene has , and an alkyne or diene has .
Always compute the IHD before classifying hydrocarbons to verify if bonds or rings must be present.
- Distinguish General Unsaturation from Terminal Alkynes
Decolorization of tests for carbon-carbon multiple bonds in general, whereas ammoniacal specifically tests for terminal alkynes with an acidic proton.
When a compound decolorizes but fails Tollens' test, classify it as an alkene, internal alkyne, or diene—never as a saturated alkane.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the IHD of Compound B from : , showing two degrees of unsaturation.
Note that Compound B decolorizes bromine water, confirming the presence of carbon-carbon multiple bonds.
Because Compound B does not form a precipitate with Tollens' reagent, it lacks a terminal acetylenic proton.
Combine these findings to conclude that Compound B is an internal alkyne (such as 2-pentyne, ) or an alkadiene.
(a) Compound A is a terminal alkyne; Compound B is an internal alkyne (or alkadiene); Compound C is an alkane. (b) Compound A has an -hybridized terminal bond with high -character () that is sufficiently acidic to form insoluble silver acetylide, whereas Compound B is an internal alkyne lacking an -hybridized bond.
Lock it in
What specific structural feature is required for an alkyne to form a precipitate with ammoniacal silver nitrate (Tollens' reagent)?
A terminal acetylenic proton (an -hybridized bond). Internal alkynes () do not react because they lack this acidic proton.
Similar question
A hydrocarbon with molecular formula decolorizes but yields no precipitate with ammoniacal cuprous chloride or Tollens' reagent. Draw or name the two possible open-chain structural types and write the IUPAC name for the alkyne isomer.
Answer
. With no terminal alkyne hydrogen, it is either an internal alkyne or a conjugated/isolated diene (such as 1,3-butadiene or 1,2-butadiene). The alkyne isomer is 2-butyne ().
Compare the reaction of 1-hexyne and 3-hexyne with: (1) excess bromine in , and (2) ammoniacal silver nitrate solution. State the observable result for each compound.
Answer
(1) Both 1-hexyne and 3-hexyne decolorize reddish-brown bromine solution as electrophilic addition occurs across the triple bond. (2) 1-hexyne (a terminal alkyne) forms a white/grey precipitate of silver hexynide, whereas 3-hexyne (an internal alkyne) shows no observable reaction or precipitate.
Explain using hybridization and orbital overlap why the conjugate base of acetylene () is more stable than the conjugate base of ethylene (), and calculate the percentage of -character in each carbanion's lone pair orbital.
Answer
In , the lone pair resides in an hybrid orbital ( -character). In , the lone pair resides in an hybrid orbital ( -character). Since -orbitals are closer to the positively charged nucleus, the higher -character in the orbital holds the negative charge more tightly and stabilizes the carbanion, making acetylene significantly more acidic.