Resources
Two closed flasks at are set up to evaluate student intuition regarding the particle model. Flask 1 contains of liquid water in dynamic equilibrium with its vapor (equilibrium vapor pressure ). Flask 2 contains pure nitrogen gas at . A student predicts that doubling the volume of each container to at constant temperature () will cut the total gas pressure in half in both flasks, reasoning that 'expanding the volume always halves particle density and pressure.' (a) Calculate the final equilibrium pressure in Flask 2 in torr. (b) Calculate the mass of liquid water evaporated into the vapor phase in Flask 1 upon expansion to , and state the final equilibrium pressure in Flask 1 in torr, assuming liquid water remains present. (c) At the particle level, explain why the student's prediction fails for Flask 1.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) Mass of additional water evaporated (total vapor mass ), and ; (c) The student's intuition treats vapor as a fixed amount of gas (Boyle's law). In Flask 1, dynamic equilibrium exists between liquid and vapor. When volume doubles, vapor particle density momentarily drops, reducing condensation rate below evaporation rate; liquid molecules evaporate until the original vapor density and dynamic equilibrium pressure () are fully restored.
Steps
Part (a): Final Pressure in Flask 2
Flask 2 contains a fixed quantity of non-condensable gas () at constant temperature (). Because the number of moles and the temperature are held constant, Boyle's law applies:
Solving for the final pressure :
Part (b): Mass of Water Evaporated and Final Pressure in Flask 1
At a given temperature, the equilibrium vapor pressure of a pure substance depends exclusively on temperature, provided that both liquid and vapor phases coexist. Because liquid water remains present at , the equilibrium vapor pressure does not change:
To determine the mass of liquid water that must evaporate to maintain this pressure in the expanded volume, apply the ideal gas law ():
-
Calculate the moles of water vapor in the initial flask:
-
Calculate the moles of water vapor required to fill the final flask at the same vapor pressure:
-
Calculate the additional moles and mass of water evaporated:
-
Verify that liquid water remains:
The total mass of water in the vapor phase is:
Because the initial mass of liquid was and , excess liquid remains (), confirming that dynamic equilibrium is re-established at .
Part (c): Particle-Level Explanation of Why the Prediction Fails
- The Student's Pitfall: The student assumed that the number of gas particles remains constant in both containers (treating the vapor as an isolated gas obeying Boyle's law).
- Dynamic Equilibrium in Flask 1: Initially, the rate of liquid evaporation equals the rate of vapor condensation ().
- Disruption upon Expansion: When the volume is doubled instantaneously, the vapor molecules disperse across twice the space. The particle density of the vapor drops by half, which cuts the collision rate of gas molecules with the liquid surface in half, thereby reducing .
- Restoration of Equilibrium: The rate of evaporation depends solely on temperature and the kinetic energy distribution of the liquid molecules, so remains unchanged. Since , net evaporation occurs. Additional liquid molecules escape into the gas phase until the vapor particle density—and therefore the condensation rate—matches the evaporation rate once more, fully restoring the pressure to .
Typical errors
01 The student treats water vapor in Flask 1 as a fixed amount of gas governed strictly by Boyle's law, ignoring the dynamic liquid-vapor equilibrium.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
, ,
In Flask 1, liquid water is present in dynamic equilibrium with its vapor. As long as liquid remains at , the equilibrium vapor pressure stays constant at . When the volume increases, additional liquid water must evaporate into the expanded headspace to maintain this equilibrium pressure.
- Step 3
"The student's prediction actually holds because doubling volume doubles the space available for particles, reducing particle density and collisions with the container walls by half in both flasks."
CorrectDoubling the volume momentarily halves the vapor particle density, reducing the condensation rate below the evaporation rate (). Because evaporation depends only on temperature, net evaporation occurs until vapor density and wall collision frequency are fully restored to their original equilibrium values ().
The prediction fails for Flask 1 because the particle density does not stay halved. A temporary decrease in vapor density reduces the rate of condensation while the rate of evaporation remains constant, resulting in net evaporation until the equilibrium vapor particle density is restored.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified Boyle's law as the appropriate relationship for a closed, fixed-mole gas sample in Flask 2.
You carried out the algebraic substitution and calculation for part (a) accurately.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated water vapor in dynamic equilibrium with its liquid phase as a fixed-quantity ideal gas governed by Boyle's law (), overlooking that equilibrium vapor pressure depends exclusively on temperature as long as liquid is present.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check for Phase Equilibrium
If a closed system contains both liquid and gas phases of the same substance, vapor pressure depends only on temperature: , independent of container volume (provided liquid remains).
Do not apply Boyle's law () to a condensable vapor in equilibrium with its liquid; keep the vapor pressure fixed at .
- Dynamic Equilibrium at the Particle Level
Dynamic equilibrium means . Evaporation rate depends on temperature; condensation rate depends on vapor particle density.
When volume expands, vapor density momentarily drops, making . Net evaporation continues until the original vapor density is restored.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationState the equilibrium vapor pressure: Because liquid water remains at , .
Find additional moles evaporated: .
Convert moles to mass: .
Verify liquid remains: Total vapor mass initial liquid, so liquid remains present.
; mass of additional water evaporated
02 The student calculates the total mass of water vapor present in the expanded 2.00 L flask instead of the mass that newly evaporated upon expansion.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
You calculated the total mass of water vapor occupying the entire container (), but the question asked for the mass of liquid water that evaporated upon expansion. Since the initial container already held of vapor, the additional evaporated mass is .
- Step 4
"When volume increases, the rate of condensation decreases while evaporation rate remains constant, causing net evaporation until the vapor particle density is restored to equilibrium."
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the final pressure of nitrogen gas in Flask 2 using Boyle's law.
You recognized that equilibrium vapor pressure remains constant at because temperature is unchanged and liquid remains.
You accurately explained at the particle level how a decrease in condensation rate drives net evaporation until equilibrium is re-established.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou solved for the total final mass of vapor in the container instead of subtracting the vapor that was already present before expansion.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the absolute final state quantity () with the change during the process ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distinguish Total Vapor from Newly Evaporated Vapor
When a closed container already at vapor-liquid equilibrium expands, liquid evaporates to supply only the additional volume .
Calculate the difference , or compute .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate initial vapor moles in : .
Calculate additional moles evaporated to fill the added volume: .
Convert additional moles to mass: .
03 The student attributes the restoration of vapor pressure to an increase in molecular speed and evaporation rate rather than a decrease in condensation rate.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
When the volume doubles, the water molecules move faster and escape the liquid surface at a higher rate because of the increased volume, producing more vapor until pressure returns to .
CorrectAt constant temperature, the average molecular speed and evaporation rate remain unchanged. Doubling the volume reduces the vapor particle density by half, which cuts the rate of condensation in half. Because , net evaporation occurs until the vapor density and condensation rate are restored.
Molecular speed depends solely on temperature, which remains constant at , so liquid molecules do not move faster or escape at a higher rate. The driving force for net evaporation is that doubling the gas volume halves vapor density, decreasing the rate of condensation below the constant rate of evaporation.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used Boyle's law to determine the final pressure of nitrogen in Flask 2.
You identified that the equilibrium vapor pressure in Flask 1 is independent of container volume as long as liquid water persists.
You accurately calculated the moles and mass of additional water needed to fill the doubled volume.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou associated net phase change with an increase in molecular speed and evaporation rate rather than recognizing that temperature fixes evaporation kinetics while volume changes affect the condensation rate.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Temperature Controls Kinetic Energy
Average molecular speed and the rate of evaporation depend strictly on temperature and surface area, not container volume.
Keep the evaporation rate constant when container volume changes at constant temperature.
- Volume Perturbs Gas Density
Increasing gas volume decreases vapor particle density, which reduces the collision frequency of vapor molecules with the liquid surface and thus lowers the rate of condensation.
Explain shifts in liquid-vapor dynamic equilibrium by comparing the fixed evaporation rate to the changed condensation rate.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationState that temperature is constant (), meaning the average molecular kinetic energy and the rate of evaporation remain unchanged.
Show that doubling the volume immediately cuts the vapor particle density in half, decreasing the rate of vapor collisions with the liquid surface (condensation rate).
Conclude that because , net evaporation proceeds until the vapor particle density matches its original value, returning the pressure to .
(a) ; (b) , ; (c) Because temperature is constant, liquid evaporation rate is unchanged. Doubling volume lowers vapor density and halves the condensation rate; net evaporation occurs until vapor density and pressure are fully restored.
Lock it in
Does doubling the volume of a closed flask containing liquid water in equilibrium with its vapor cut the vapor pressure in half at constant temperature?
No. As long as excess liquid remains, the vapor pressure remains constant at because more liquid evaporates to restore equilibrium.
Similar question
A closed vessel contains of liquid ethanol and ethanol vapor in dynamic equilibrium at (). The volume is compressed isothermally to . (a) What is the final equilibrium pressure of ethanol vapor? (b) Does liquid ethanol condense or evaporate during compression?
Answer
(a) . At constant temperature, equilibrium vapor pressure does not change as long as liquid is present. (b) Condenses. Compressing the volume temporarily increases vapor particle density, so condensation rate exceeds evaporation rate until equilibrium pressure is restored.
A sealed container holds liquid water and water vapor in equilibrium at (). The container volume is expanded isothermally to . Assuming excess liquid remains, calculate the mass of additional water that evaporates into the vapor phase (, molar mass of ).
Answer
Mass evaporated .
- Additional volume to fill: .
- Additional moles: .
- Mass: .
A rigid bulb contains of liquid water at (). The bulb is expanded to at constant temperature. Determine whether any liquid water remains at equilibrium, and calculate the final pressure in the bulb. (Molar mass of ).
Answer
No liquid water remains; .
- Initial total moles: .
- Moles required to sustain in : .
- Since , all water evaporates completely (no dynamic equilibrium).
- Final pressure: .