Resources

A remediation engineer models the migration of trichloroethylene (TCE) between an industrial wastewater stream and a natural organic sediment layer. The octanol-water partition coefficient of TCE is reported as log⁡Kow=2.42\log K_{\text{ow}} = 2.42. A student attempts to calculate the soil organic carbon-water distribution coefficient using the empirical sorption equation log⁡Koc=0.903 log⁡Kow−0.094\log K_{\text{oc}} = 0.903\,\log K_{\text{ow}} - 0.094, but incorrectly treats the logarithm values: the student takes 10−log⁡Kow10^{-\log K_{\text{ow}}} due to a mistaken sign convention regarding thermodynamic equilibrium distribution constants, resulting in log⁡Koc=−2.28\log K_{\text{oc}} = -2.28 instead of the correct evaluation. (a) Calculate the true linear adsorption distribution coefficient KocK_{\text{oc}} in L/kg\text{L/kg}. (b) If an aquifer sediment contains an organic carbon fraction foc=0.018f_{\text{oc}} = 0.018 and Kd=foc×KocK_d = f_{\text{oc}} \times K_{\text{oc}}, calculate the correct solid-water distribution ratio KdK_d (L/kg\text{L/kg}) versus the corrupted KdK_d value caused by the negative sign convention blunder.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) True Koc=123 L/kg\text{True } K_{\text{oc}} = 123\text{ L/kg}; (b) Correct Kd=2.21 L/kg\text{Correct } K_d = 2.21\text{ L/kg} vs. Corrupted Kd=9.45×10−5 L/kg\text{Corrupted } K_d = 9.45 \times 10^{-5}\text{ L/kg}

Steps

01

Correct Value of KdK_d

Part (a): Calculating the True Soil Organic Carbon-Water Distribution Coefficient (KocK_{\text{oc}})

The empirical relation between the octanol-water partition coefficient (KowK_{\text{ow}}) and the soil organic carbon-water partition coefficient (KocK_{\text{oc}}) is: log⁡Koc=0.903 log⁡Kow−0.094\log K_{\text{oc}} = 0.903\,\log K_{\text{ow}} - 0.094 Substitute the correct value log⁡Kow=2.42\log K_{\text{ow}} = 2.42: log⁡Koc=0.903(2.42)−0.094=2.1853−0.094=2.0913\log K_{\text{oc}} = 0.903(2.42) - 0.094 = 2.1853 - 0.094 = 2.0913 Convert from logarithmic form to find KocK_{\text{oc}}: Koc=102.0913≈123.38 L/kg≈123 L/kgK_{\text{oc}} = 10^{2.0913} \approx 123.38\text{ L/kg} \approx 123\text{ L/kg}

Part (b): Calculating the True vs. Corrupted Solid-Water Distribution Ratio (KdK_d)

The sediment-water distribution coefficient KdK_d represents the ratio of contaminant mass bound to the sediment per unit mass of sediment relative to its concentration in the pore water, scaled by the sediment fraction of organic carbon (focf_{\text{oc}}): Kd=foc⋅KocK_d = f_{\text{oc}} \cdot K_{\text{oc}}

Using the organic carbon fraction foc=0.018f_{\text{oc}} = 0.018 and the rounded true Koc=123 L/kgK_{\text{oc}} = 123\text{ L/kg}:

Kd=0.018⋅123 L/kg=2.214 L/kg≈2.21 L/kgK_d = 0.018 \cdot 123\text{ L/kg} = 2.214\text{ L/kg} \approx 2.21\text{ L/kg}

(Using the unrounded intermediate value 123.38 L/kg123.38\text{ L/kg} yields 2.22 L/kg2.22\text{ L/kg}.)

02

Corrupted Value of KdK_d

From the sign-error calculation, the corrupted log⁡Koc\log K_{\text{oc}} was −2.28-2.28:

Koc, corrupted=10−2.28≈5.248×10−3 L/kgK_{\text{oc, corrupted}} = 10^{-2.28} \approx 5.248 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L/kg}

Multiplying by foc=0.018f_{\text{oc}} = 0.018:

Kd,corrupted=0.018⋅(5.248×10−3 L/kg)≈9.45×10−5 L/kgK_{d, \text{corrupted}} = 0.018 \cdot (5.248 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L/kg}) \approx 9.45 \times 10^{-5}\text{ L/kg}


Environmental Significance Pitfall

Partition coefficients such as KowK_{\text{ow}} and KocK_{\text{oc}} are defined as concentration ratios at equilibrium (CsorbedCaqueous\frac{C_{\text{sorbed}}}{C_{\text{aqueous}}}) and are strictly positive values; their logarithms are also positive whenever the chemical partitions preferentially into the organic phase over water.

A sign error converting log⁡Kow\log K_{\text{ow}} from positive to negative drastically underestimates the compound's affinity for sediment by more than four orders of magnitude (≈104\approx 10^4), incorrectly predicting that trichloroethylene (TCE) will barely adsorb and will flush immediately, whereas it actually undergoes significant retardation in organic-rich sediment.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to take the antilogarithm of log Koc and mistakenly uses the logarithmic value as Koc itself.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    log⁡Koc=0.903×2.42−0.094=2.091\log K_{\text{oc}} = 0.903 \times 2.42 - 0.094 = 2.091

  2. Step 2

    Koc=2.091 L/kgK_{\text{oc}} = 2.091\text{ L/kg}

    Correct

    Koc=102.0913≈123 L/kgK_{\text{oc}} = 10^{2.0913} \approx 123\text{ L/kg}

    You equated KocK_{\text{oc}} directly to log⁡Koc\log K_{\text{oc}}. Because the correlation yields the common logarithm, you must take the antilogarithm: Koc=102.091≈123 L/kgK_{\text{oc}} = 10^{2.091} \approx 123\text{ L/kg}.

  3. Step 3

    Correct Kd=0.018×2.091=0.0376 L/kg\text{Correct } K_d = 0.018 \times 2.091 = 0.0376\text{ L/kg}

    Correct

    Correct Kd=0.018×123.38 L/kg≈2.21 L/kg\text{Correct } K_d = 0.018 \times 123.38\text{ L/kg} \approx 2.21\text{ L/kg}

    You correctly multiplied by foc=0.018f_{\text{oc}} = 0.018, but this calculation inherited the un-exponentiated KocK_{\text{oc}} value from Step 2.

  4. Step 4

    Corrupted Koc=−2.28 L/kg  ⟹  Corrupted Kd=0.018×(−2.28)=−0.0410 L/kg\text{Corrupted } K_{\text{oc}} = -2.28\text{ L/kg} \implies \text{Corrupted } K_d = 0.018 \times (-2.28) = -0.0410\text{ L/kg}

    Correct

    Corrupted Koc=10−2.28≈5.25×10−3 L/kg  ⟹  Corrupted Kd=0.018×(5.25×10−3)≈9.45×10−5 L/kg\text{Corrupted } K_{\text{oc}} = 10^{-2.28} \approx 5.25 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L/kg} \implies \text{Corrupted } K_d = 0.018 \times (5.25 \times 10^{-3}) \approx 9.45 \times 10^{-5}\text{ L/kg}

    You used the corrupted log⁡Koc=−2.28\log K_{\text{oc}} = -2.28 directly as KocK_{\text{oc}}, producing a negative distribution coefficient. An equilibrium partition ratio cannot be negative; you must first convert using 10−2.2810^{-2.28}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted log⁡Kow\log K_{\text{ow}} into the linear empirical equation and calculated log⁡Koc=2.091\log K_{\text{oc}} = 2.091.

You correctly applied the relationship Kd=foc×KocK_d = f_{\text{oc}} \times K_{\text{oc}} in Part (b).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Antilogarithm

You dropped the logarithm operator without applying its inverse, equating log⁡K\log K directly to KK.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated logarithmic values as linear equilibrium constants rather than converting via K=10log⁡KK = 10^{\log K}. A key physical check is that partition coefficients represent positive equilibrium concentration ratios and can never be negative.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Logarithmic vs. Linear Values
  • If an equation outputs log⁡10X=y\log_{10} X = y, then the physical quantity is X=10yX = 10^y.

  • Always convert log⁡K\log K to K=10log⁡KK = 10^{\log K} before substituting into linear multi-phase partitioning formulas.

Physical Reality Check
  • An equilibrium partition coefficient K=C1/C2K = C_1 / C_2 must always be strictly positive (K>0K > 0).

  • If your calculated KK or KdK_d is negative, check whether you accidentally used log⁡K\log K directly instead of 10log⁡K10^{\log K}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert log⁡Koc=2.0913\log K_{\text{oc}} = 2.0913 to linear form: Koc=102.0913≈123.38 L/kgK_{\text{oc}} = 10^{2.0913} \approx 123.38\text{ L/kg}.

  2. Calculate correct KdK_d: Kd=foc×Koc=0.018×123.38 L/kg≈2.21 L/kgK_d = f_{\text{oc}} \times K_{\text{oc}} = 0.018 \times 123.38\text{ L/kg} \approx 2.21\text{ L/kg}.

  3. Convert corrupted log⁡Koc=−2.28\log K_{\text{oc}} = -2.28 to linear form: Koc, corrupted=10−2.28≈5.248×10−3 L/kgK_{\text{oc, corrupted}} = 10^{-2.28} \approx 5.248 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L/kg}.

  4. Calculate corrupted KdK_d: Kd,corrupted=0.018×(5.248×10−3 L/kg)≈9.45×10−5 L/kgK_{d, \text{corrupted}} = 0.018 \times (5.248 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L/kg}) \approx 9.45 \times 10^{-5}\text{ L/kg}.

Final answer

(a) True Koc=123 L/kg\text{True } K_{\text{oc}} = 123\text{ L/kg}; (b) Correct Kd=2.21 L/kg\text{Correct } K_d = 2.21\text{ L/kg} vs. Corrupted Kd=9.45×10−5 L/kg\text{Corrupted } K_d = 9.45 \times 10^{-5}\text{ L/kg}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between logarithmic scale variables (such as pH\text{pH}, pKa\text{p}K_a, log⁡Kow\log K_{\text{ow}}) and their linear physical quantities.

  • Practice converting empirical LFER (linear free-energy relationship) outputs back into linear values before performing mass-balance or distribution calculations.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misinterprets foc = 0.018 as a percentage and divides by 100 when calculating Kd.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    log⁡Koc=0.903×2.42−0.094=2.091  ⟹  Koc=102.091=123.3 L/kg\log K_{\text{oc}} = 0.903 \times 2.42 - 0.094 = 2.091 \implies K_{\text{oc}} = 10^{2.091} = 123.3\text{ L/kg}

  2. Step 2

    foc=0.018100=0.00018f_{\text{oc}} = \frac{0.018}{100} = 0.00018

    Correct

    foc=0.018f_{\text{oc}} = 0.018

    You divided focf_{\text{oc}} by 100100, but foc=0.018f_{\text{oc}} = 0.018 is already given as a dimensionless mass fraction (1.8%1.8\%), not as 0.018%0.018\%.

  3. Step 3

    Correct Kd=0.00018×123.3=0.0222 L/kg\text{Correct } K_d = 0.00018 \times 123.3 = 0.0222\text{ L/kg}

    Correct

    Kd=0.018×123.38 L/kg≈2.21 L/kgK_d = 0.018 \times 123.38\text{ L/kg} \approx 2.21\text{ L/kg}

    You correctly multiplied your focf_{\text{oc}} by KocK_{\text{oc}}, but this value is off by two decimal places due to dividing focf_{\text{oc}} by 100100 in the previous step.

  4. Step 4

    Corrupted Koc=10(−2.28)=0.00525 L/kg  ⟹  Corrupted Kd=0.00018×0.00525=9.45×10−7 L/kg\text{Corrupted } K_{\text{oc}} = 10^{(-2.28)} = 0.00525\text{ L/kg} \implies \text{Corrupted } K_d = 0.00018 \times 0.00525 = 9.45 \times 10^{-7}\text{ L/kg}

    Correct

    Corrupted Koc=10−2.28≈5.25×10−3 L/kg  ⟹  Corrupted Kd=0.018×(5.248×10−3 L/kg)≈9.45×10−5 L/kg\text{Corrupted } K_{\text{oc}} = 10^{-2.28} \approx 5.25 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L/kg} \implies \text{Corrupted } K_d = 0.018 \times (5.248 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L/kg}) \approx 9.45 \times 10^{-5}\text{ L/kg}

    You correctly found the corrupted Koc=10−2.28K_{\text{oc}} = 10^{-2.28} and applied the formula for KdK_d, but the result inherits the 100×100\times dilution from the focf_{\text{oc}} error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You substituted log⁡Kow\log K_{\text{ow}} correctly to determine the true value of log⁡Koc\log K_{\text{oc}}.

You converted logarithmic partition coefficients back to linear scale using base-1010 exponentiation.

You used the correct relationship Kd=foc×KocK_d = f_{\text{oc}} \times K_{\text{oc}} for both the true and corrupted scenarios.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Fraction vs. Percentage Confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated a decimal fraction (foc=0.018f_{\text{oc}} = 0.018) as though it were already a percentage value (0.018%0.018\%) requiring conversion to decimal by dividing by 100100.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Fraction vs. Percent Notation
  • Values given as a fraction (ff, such as focf_{\text{oc}} or mass fraction ww) without a percent symbol are already in decimal form; only values explicitly written with '%\%' need to be divided by 100100.

  • Check whether the parameter symbol is ff (fraction) or explicitly labeled with %\%. If foc=0.018f_{\text{oc}} = 0.018, use 0.0180.018 directly.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Keep the fraction as given: foc=0.018f_{\text{oc}} = 0.018.

  2. Compute the correct distribution ratio: Kd=foc×Koc=0.018×123.38 L/kg≈2.21 L/kgK_d = f_{\text{oc}} \times K_{\text{oc}} = 0.018 \times 123.38\text{ L/kg} \approx 2.21\text{ L/kg}.

  3. Compute the corrupted distribution ratio: Kd,corrupted=0.018×10−2.28 L/kg=0.018×5.248×10−3 L/kg≈9.45×10−5 L/kgK_{d,\text{corrupted}} = 0.018 \times 10^{-2.28}\text{ L/kg} = 0.018 \times 5.248 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L/kg} \approx 9.45 \times 10^{-5}\text{ L/kg}.

Final answer

(a) True Koc=123 L/kg\text{True } K_{\text{oc}} = 123\text{ L/kg}; (b) Correct Kd=2.21 L/kg\text{Correct } K_d = 2.21\text{ L/kg} vs. Corrupted Kd=9.45×10−5 L/kg\text{Corrupted } K_d = 9.45 \times 10^{-5}\text{ L/kg}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review whether environmental parameters labeled as 'fraction' (focf_{\text{oc}}, fwaterf_{\text{water}}, etc.) are stated in decimal or percentage form before starting calculations.

  • Verify order of magnitude: an organic-rich aquifer sediment with foc=0.018f_{\text{oc}} = 0.018 (1.8%1.8\%) should have a KdK_d around 1 to 2%1\text{ to }2\% of KocK_{\text{oc}}, not 0.018%0.018\%.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A hydrophobic pesticide has an estimated log⁡Koc=3.50\log K_{\text{oc}} = 3.50. Calculate the linear organic carbon partition coefficient KocK_{\text{oc}} in L/kg\text{L/kg}, and find KdK_d for a soil with an organic carbon fraction foc=0.020f_{\text{oc}} = 0.020.

Answer

Koc=103.50≈3162 L/kgK_{\text{oc}} = 10^{3.50} \approx 3162\text{ L/kg}. Then, Kd=foc×Koc=0.020×3162≈63.2 L/kgK_d = f_{\text{oc}} \times K_{\text{oc}} = 0.020 \times 3162 \approx 63.2\text{ L/kg}.

02

Benzene has log⁡Kow=2.13\log K_{\text{ow}} = 2.13. An empirical relation gives log⁡Koc=0.81 log⁡Kow+0.10\log K_{\text{oc}} = 0.81\,\log K_{\text{ow}} + 0.10. Determine: (a) log⁡Koc\log K_{\text{oc}}, (b) true KocK_{\text{oc}}, and (c) the sediment distribution ratio KdK_d in an aquifer with foc=0.0050f_{\text{oc}} = 0.0050.

Answer

(a) log⁡Koc=0.81(2.13)+0.10=1.825\log K_{\text{oc}} = 0.81(2.13) + 0.10 = 1.825. (b) Koc=101.825≈66.8 L/kgK_{\text{oc}} = 10^{1.825} \approx 66.8\text{ L/kg}. (c) Kd=0.0050×66.8≈0.334 L/kgK_d = 0.0050 \times 66.8 \approx 0.334\text{ L/kg}.

03

A polar herbicide has a negative logarithmic sorption value: log⁡Koc=−0.40\log K_{\text{oc}} = -0.40. A technician incorrectly writes Koc=−0.40 L/kgK_{\text{oc}} = -0.40\text{ L/kg}. (a) Calculate the true KocK_{\text{oc}}. (b) If foc=0.015f_{\text{oc}} = 0.015, calculate the true KdK_d and explain physically why a negative KdK_d is impossible.

Answer

(a) True Koc=10−0.40≈0.398 L/kgK_{\text{oc}} = 10^{-0.40} \approx 0.398\text{ L/kg}. (b) True Kd=0.015×0.398≈5.97×10−3 L/kgK_d = 0.015 \times 0.398 \approx 5.97 \times 10^{-3}\text{ L/kg}. A distribution ratio Kd=Csolid/CwaterK_d = C_{\text{solid}} / C_{\text{water}} cannot be negative because physical chemical concentrations cannot be less than zero.

Loading workspace…