Resources

In standard Aufbau progression, subshells fill in order of increasing (n+l)(n + l), with ties broken by increasing nn. Consider the hypothetical elements at the threshold of the gg-subshell (l=4l = 4). (a) Calculate the (n+l)(n + l) value for the 5g5g and 8s8s subshells. (b) According to the Aufbau (n+l)(n + l) rule, which of these two subshells must fill first? (c) Determine the theoretical maximum electron capacity of the 5g5g subshell.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) For 5g5g: n+l=5+4=9n + l = 5 + 4 = 9; for 8s8s: n+l=8+0=8n + l = 8 + 0 = 8; (b) The 8s8s subshell must fill first because its (n+l)(n + l) value (88) is lower than that of 5g5g (99); (c) The 5g5g subshell has 2(4)+1=92(4) + 1 = 9 orbitals, corresponding to a maximum capacity of 1818 electrons.

Steps

(a) Calculating the (n+l)(n + l) Values

In atomic structure, each subshell is characterized by the principal quantum number nn and the azimuthal (orbital angular momentum) quantum number ll. The angular momentum quantum numbers correspond to subshell types as follows:

  • s  ⟹  l=0s \implies l = 0
  • p  ⟹  l=1p \implies l = 1
  • d  ⟹  l=2d \implies l = 2
  • f  ⟹  l=3f \implies l = 3
  • g  ⟹  l=4g \implies l = 4

Now, calculate the (n+l)(n + l) sum for each given subshell:

  • For the 5g5g subshell: n=5,l=4  ⟹  n+l=5+4=9n = 5, \quad l = 4 \implies n + l = 5 + 4 = 9
  • For the 8s8s subshell: n=8,l=0  ⟹  n+l=8+0=8n = 8, \quad l = 0 \implies n + l = 8 + 0 = 8

(b) Determining Which Subshell Fills First

According to the Aufbau principle governed by the Madelung (n+l)(n + l) rule:

  1. Subshells are filled in order of strictly increasing (n+l)(n + l) values.
  2. If two subshells have identical (n+l)(n + l) values, the subshell with the smaller principal quantum number nn fills first.

Comparing the two subshells:

  • 8s8s has n+l=8n + l = 8
  • 5g5g has n+l=9n + l = 9

Because 8<98 < 9, the 8s8s subshell has a lower energy threshold and must fill before the 5g5g subshell.

Common Pitfall: Do not assume that a subshell with a smaller principal quantum number nn (such as n=5n = 5 in 5g5g) always fills before one with a larger nn (such as n=8n = 8 in 8s8s). The total energy is primarily determined by (n+l)(n + l), which is why high-ll subshells can fill significantly later than higher-nn subshells of lower ll.


(c) Maximum Electron Capacity of the 5g5g Subshell

  1. The number of orbitals in any subshell is given by: Number of orbitals=2l+1\text{Number of orbitals} = 2l + 1 For the gg-subshell, l=4l = 4: Number of orbitals=2(4)+1=9 orbitals\text{Number of orbitals} = 2(4) + 1 = 9\text{ orbitals} These correspond to magnetic quantum numbers ml∈{−4,−3,−2,−1,0,+1,+2,+3,+4}m_l \in \{-4, -3, -2, -1, 0, +1, +2, +3, +4\}.
  2. By the Pauli exclusion principle, each spatial orbital can hold a maximum of 22 electrons of opposite spin (ms=+12,−12m_s = +\frac{1}{2}, -\frac{1}{2}): Maximum capacity=2×9=18 electrons\text{Maximum capacity} = 2 \times 9 = 18\text{ electrons}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misidentifies which subshell fills first by incorrectly applying the tie-breaker rule of smaller n even though the (n + l) values are not equal.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    5g:n=5,l=4  ⟹  n+l=95g: n = 5, l = 4 \implies n + l = 9; 8s:n=8,l=0  ⟹  n+l=88s: n = 8, l = 0 \implies n + l = 8

  2. Step 2

    5g5g fills first because n=5n = 5 is smaller than n=8n = 8

    Correct

    The 8s8s subshell fills first because its (n+l)(n + l) value (88) is lower than that of 5g5g (99).

    Under the Aufbau (n+l)(n + l) rule, subshells fill strictly in order of increasing (n+l)(n + l). You only compare nn as a tie-breaker when two subshells share the exact same (n+l)(n + l) value. Since 8<98 < 9, 8s8s fills before 5g5g.

  3. Step 3

    Capacity=2(2(4)+1)=18 electrons\text{Capacity} = 2(2(4) + 1) = 18\text{ electrons}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly assigned the azimuthal quantum numbers l=4l = 4 for the gg-subshell and l=0l = 0 for the ss-subshell.

You accurately computed the (n+l)(n + l) values for both 5g5g and 8s8s.

You correctly calculated the total electron capacity using the orbital multiplicity formula.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Premature Tie-Breaker Application

You compared the principal quantum number nn to determine subshell filling order even though the two subshells had different (n+l)(n + l) values.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the tie-breaker criterion (nn) as a primary sorting rule rather than a conditional rule that is only triggered when (n+l)(n + l) values are identical.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Evaluate (n + l) First
  • The subshell with the strictly lower (n+l)(n + l) sum always fills first.

  • Compare the two (n+l)(n + l) sums directly before looking at individual quantum numbers.

Apply n Only as a Tie-Breaker
  • Compare principal quantum number nn if and only if (n+l)1=(n+l)2(n + l)_1 = (n + l)_2.

  • Check whether the sums are equal; if they differ, ignore the comparison between individual nn values.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the calculated sums: (n+l)8s=8(n + l)_{8s} = 8 and (n+l)5g=9(n + l)_{5g} = 9.

  2. Since 8<98 < 9, the 8s8s subshell has a lower total energy according to the Madelung rule.

  3. Conclude that 8s8s fills before 5g5g without invoking the tie-breaker.

Final answer

(a) For 5g5g: n+l=9n + l = 9; for 8s8s: n+l=8n + l = 8; (b) The 8s8s subshell fills first because 8<98 < 9; (c) Maximum capacity is 1818 electrons.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the two-tiered hierarchy of the Madelung rule: primary sort by (n+l)(n + l), secondary sort by nn only on ties.

  • Practice ordering pairs of subshells where the one with the higher nn has a lower (n+l)(n + l) value, such as 4s4s vs. 3d3d or 6s6s vs. 4f4f.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates the number of orbitals (2l + 1 = 9) but forgets to multiply by 2 electrons per orbital, leading to a capacity of 9 electrons.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    5g:n+l=5+4=95g: n+l = 5+4 = 9 ⟹ 8s:n+l=8+0=88s: n+l = 8+0 = 8

  2. Step 2

    8s fills first because 8<98s\text{ fills first because } 8 < 9

  3. Step 3

    Capacity=2(4)+1=9 electrons\text{Capacity} = 2(4)+1 = 9\text{ electrons}

    Correct

    Capacity=2(2l+1)=2(2(4)+1)=18 electrons\text{Capacity} = 2(2l + 1) = 2(2(4) + 1) = 18\text{ electrons}

    The formula 2l+1=2(4)+1=92l + 1 = 2(4) + 1 = 9 gives the number of spatial orbitals (mlm_l values), but each orbital holds up to 22 electrons of opposite spin by the Pauli exclusion principle.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly assigned l=4l = 4 to the gg-subshell and l=0l = 0 to the ss-subshell.

You accurately summed n+ln + l for both subshells.

You properly applied the Aufbau (n+l)(n + l) ordering rule to conclude that 8s8s fills first.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing Orbitals with Electron Capacity

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You equated the number of degenerate orbitals in a subshell, 2l+12l + 1, directly with the maximum electron capacity, forgetting to multiply by 22 electrons per orbital (ms=±12m_s = \pm \frac{1}{2}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Number of Orbitals vs. Electron Capacity
  • A subshell with angular momentum quantum number ll contains 2l+12l + 1 degenerate orbitals. By the Pauli exclusion principle, each orbital holds at most 22 electrons, so the maximum electron capacity is 2(2l+1)2(2l + 1).

  • Whenever asked for maximum electron capacity, first compute the number of orbitals as 2l+12l + 1, then multiply by 22 for electron spins.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the number of orbitals: 2l+1=2(4)+1=9 orbitals2l + 1 = 2(4) + 1 = 9\text{ orbitals}

  2. Apply the Pauli exclusion principle: each orbital holds 22 electrons (ms=+12,−12m_s = +\frac{1}{2}, -\frac{1}{2})

  3. Multiply orbitals by 22: 9×2=18 electrons9 \times 2 = 18\text{ electrons}

Final answer

(a) 5g:n+l=95g: n + l = 9; 8s:n+l=88s: n + l = 8; (b) 8s8s fills first; (c) 1818 electrons

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinct physical meanings of the magnetic quantum number mlm_l (orbital count) and spin quantum number msm_s (electrons per orbital).

  • Practice calculating both orbital count and electron capacity for hypothetical subshells like hh (l=5l = 5) and ii (l=6l = 6).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student assigns the angular momentum quantum number l = 0 to 8s but misidentifies l for the s subshell as 1, yielding incorrect (n + l) values and reversing the filling order.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    5g: n+l=5+4=9n + l = 5 + 4 = 9   ⟹  \implies 8s: n+l=8+1=9n + l = 8 + 1 = 9

    Correct

    For 5g5g: n+l=5+4=9n + l = 5 + 4 = 9; for 8s8s: n+l=8+0=8n + l = 8 + 0 = 8

    You correctly set l=4l = 4 for the gg-subshell, but an ss-subshell has l=0l = 0, not l=1l = 1. Therefore, for 8s8s, n+l=8+0=8n + l = 8 + 0 = 8.

  2. Step 2

    Both have n+l=9n + l = 9, so 5g5g fills first due to smaller nn (5<85 < 8)

    Correct

    8s8s fills first because its (n+l)(n + l) value (88) is lower than that of 5g5g (99).

    Your tie-breaking reasoning was mathematically consistent with your previous step, but because n+l=8n + l = 8 for 8s8s and n+l=9n + l = 9 for 5g5g, there is no tie. The subshell with the strictly lower (n+l)(n + l) value fills first.

  3. Step 3

    Capacity=2(2(4)+1)=18 electrons\text{Capacity} = 2(2(4) + 1) = 18\text{ electrons}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified l=4l = 4 for the gg-subshell.

You calculated the total (n+l)(n + l) value for the 5g5g subshell accurately.

You correctly applied the capacity formula 2(2l+1)2(2l + 1) to find the maximum number of electrons for l=4l = 4.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Quantum Number Assignment Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the orbital angular momentum quantum number of the ss-subshell (l=0l = 0) with that of the pp-subshell (l=1l = 1), leading to an incorrect (n+l)(n + l) sum for 8s8s.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Subshell Azimuthal Quantum Numbers
  • The azimuthal quantum number starts at zero: s  ⟹  l=0s \implies l = 0, p  ⟹  l=1p \implies l = 1, d  ⟹  l=2d \implies l = 2, f  ⟹  l=3f \implies l = 3, g  ⟹  l=4g \implies l = 4.

  • Always verify that l=0l = 0 is assigned to an ss orbital before computing (n+l)(n + l).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the correct (n+l)(n + l) value for 8s8s: n+l=8+0=8n + l = 8 + 0 = 8.

  2. Compare the (n+l)(n + l) values: for 8s8s, n+l=8n + l = 8; for 5g5g, n+l=9n + l = 9.

  3. Apply the Madelung rule: because 8<98 < 9, the 8s8s subshell has lower energy and fills before 5g5g.

Final answer

(a) 5g5g: n+l=9n + l = 9; 8s8s: n+l=8n + l = 8; (b) 8s8s fills first; (c) 1818 electrons.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the sequence of orbital quantum numbers starting strictly from zero: s=0,p=1,d=2,f=3,g=4s=0, p=1, d=2, f=3, g=4.

  • Double-check (n+l)(n + l) sums before applying tie-breakers to ensure a tie actually exists.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Determine which subshell fills first according to the Aufbau principle: 4f4f or 6s6s. Support your answer by calculating the (n+l)(n + l) value for each.

Answer

6s6s fills first. For 6s6s, n+l=6+0=6n + l = 6 + 0 = 6. For 4f4f, n+l=4+3=7n + l = 4 + 3 = 7. Because 6<76 < 7, 6s6s fills before 4f4f.

02

Consider the 5d5d, 6p6p, and 7s7s subshells. (a) Calculate the (n+l)(n + l) value for each. (b) Arrange all three subshells in the correct order of filling.

Answer

(a) For 5d5d: 5+2=75 + 2 = 7; for 6p6p: 6+1=76 + 1 = 7; for 7s7s: 7+0=77 + 0 = 7. (b) Since all three have (n+l)=7(n + l) = 7, apply the tie-breaker of increasing nn: filling order is 5d→6p→7s5d \rightarrow 6p \rightarrow 7s.

03

A hypothetical 6h6h subshell has orbital angular momentum quantum number l=5l = 5. Compare the filling order of 6h6h and 10s10s, and calculate the total electron capacity of the 6h6h subshell.

Answer

For 6h6h, n+l=6+5=11n + l = 6 + 5 = 11. For 10s10s, n+l=10+0=10n + l = 10 + 0 = 10. Because 10<1110 < 11, 10s10s fills before 6h6h. The theoretical maximum capacity of 6h6h is 2(2(5)+1)=2(11)=222(2(5) + 1) = 2(11) = 22 electrons.

Loading workspace…