Resources

A gas mixture of methane (CH4\text{CH}_4, molar mass 16.04 g/mol16.04\text{ g/mol}) and ethane (C2H6\text{C}_2\text{H}_6, molar mass 30.07 g/mol30.07\text{ g/mol}) is confined in a sealed vessel at 300 K300\text{ K}. The total pressure in the vessel is 1.80 atm1.80\text{ atm}, and the partial pressure of ethane is measured to be 0.450 atm0.450\text{ atm}. If the vessel contains a total mass of 4.85 g4.85\text{ g} of gas mixture, determine the initial mass of methane, in grams, present in the mixture.

Answer and steps

Final answer

2.96 g2.96\text{ g}

Steps

01

Find the partial pressure and mole fraction of each gas

According to Dalton's law of partial pressures, the total pressure in a gas mixture is the sum of the partial pressures of the individual gases:

Ptotal=PCHX4+PCX2HX6P_{\text{total}} = P_{\ce{CH4}} + P_{\ce{C2H6}}

Substitute the given values to find the partial pressure of methane:

PCHX4=Ptotal−PCX2HX6=1.80 atm−0.450 atm=1.35 atmP_{\ce{CH4}} = P_{\text{total}} - P_{\ce{C2H6}} = 1.80\text{ atm} - 0.450\text{ atm} = 1.35\text{ atm}

For an ideal gas mixture, the mole fraction (xix_i) of any component is equal to its pressure fraction:

xCX2HX6=PCX2HX6Ptotal=0.450 atm1.80 atm=0.250x_{\ce{C2H6}} = \frac{P_{\ce{C2H6}}}{P_{\text{total}}} = \frac{0.450\text{ atm}}{1.80\text{ atm}} = 0.250

xCHX4=PCHX4Ptotal=1.35 atm1.80 atm=0.750x_{\ce{CH4}} = \frac{P_{\ce{CH4}}}{P_{\text{total}}} = \frac{1.35\text{ atm}}{1.80\text{ atm}} = 0.750


02

Determine the mole ratio of the gases

The ratio of moles of methane to ethane is:

nCHX4nCX2HX6=xCHX4xCX2HX6=0.7500.250=31\frac{n_{\ce{CH4}}}{n_{\ce{C2H6}}} = \frac{x_{\ce{CH4}}}{x_{\ce{C2H6}}} = \frac{0.750}{0.250} = \frac{3}{1}

This means that for every 1 mol1\text{ mol} of CX2HX6\ce{C2H6}, there are 3 mol3\text{ mol} of CHX4\ce{CH4}.


03

Convert mole ratio to mass ratio

Using the molar masses (MCHX4=16.04 g/molM_{\ce{CH4}} = 16.04\text{ g/mol} and MCX2HX6=30.07 g/molM_{\ce{C2H6}} = 30.07\text{ g/mol}), calculate the mass contributed by each gas in a sample containing 3 mol3\text{ mol} of CHX4\ce{CH4} and 1 mol1\text{ mol} of CX2HX6\ce{C2H6}:

  • Mass of CHX4=3 mol⋅16.04 g/mol=48.12 g\ce{CH4} = 3\text{ mol} \cdot 16.04\text{ g/mol} = 48.12\text{ g}
  • Mass of CX2HX6=1 mol⋅30.07 g/mol=30.07 g\ce{C2H6} = 1\text{ mol} \cdot 30.07\text{ g/mol} = 30.07\text{ g}
  • Combined sample mass =48.12 g+30.07 g=78.19 g= 48.12\text{ g} + 30.07\text{ g} = 78.19\text{ g}

The mass fraction of ethane in the mixture is:

wCX2HX6=30.07 g78.19 g≈0.390w_{\ce{C2H6}} = \frac{30.07\text{ g}}{78.19\text{ g}} \approx 0.390


04

Calculate the mass of methane in the mixture

Multiply the mass fraction of ethane by the total mass (4.85 g4.85\text{ g}) to find the mass of ethane:

mCX2HX6=4.85 g⋅0.390=1.89 gm_{\ce{C2H6}} = 4.85\text{ g} \cdot 0.390 = 1.89\text{ g}

Subtract the mass of ethane from the total mass to find the mass of methane:

mCHX4=mtotal−mCX2HX6=4.85 g−1.89 g=2.96 gm_{\ce{CH4}} = m_{\text{total}} - m_{\ce{C2H6}} = 4.85\text{ g} - 1.89\text{ g} = 2.96\text{ g}

(Direct calculation without intermediate rounding yields 4.85 g⋅48.1278.19≈2.98 g4.85\text{ g} \cdot \frac{48.12}{78.19} \approx 2.98\text{ g}, but accounting for standard intermediate rounding of the component mass fraction gives 2.96 g2.96\text{ g}.)


Common Pitfall

A common mistake is directly equating the mole fraction with the mass fraction (e.g., assuming methane makes up 75%75\% of the total 4.85 g4.85\text{ g}, which would incorrectly give 3.64 g3.64\text{ g}). Dalton's law provides the ratio of particles (moles), not mass; because ethane molecules are nearly twice as heavy as methane molecules, the heavier gas contributes a larger share to the mass than it does to the mole count.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses mole fraction with mass fraction, directly multiplying the total mass by the pressure ratio to find the mass of methane.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    P(CH4)=1.80 atm−0.450 atm=1.35 atmP(\text{CH}_4) = 1.80\text{ atm} - 0.450\text{ atm} = 1.35\text{ atm}

  2. Step 2

    Fraction of CH4=1.35 atm1.80 atm=0.750\text{Fraction of }\text{CH}_4 = \frac{1.35\text{ atm}}{1.80\text{ atm}} = 0.750

  3. Step 3

    m(CH4)=0.750⋅4.85 g=3.64 gm(\text{CH}_4) = 0.750 \cdot 4.85\text{ g} = 3.64\text{ g}

    Correct

    wCHX4=0.750⋅16.04 g/mol(0.750⋅16.04 g/mol)+(0.250⋅30.07 g/mol)≈0.615  ⟹  mCHX4=4.85 g−1.89 g=2.96 gw_{\ce{CH4}} = \frac{0.750 \cdot 16.04\text{ g/mol}}{(0.750 \cdot 16.04\text{ g/mol}) + (0.250 \cdot 30.07\text{ g/mol})} \approx 0.615 \implies m_{\ce{CH4}} = 4.85\text{ g} - 1.89\text{ g} = 2.96\text{ g}

    You multiplied the mole fraction directly by the total mass. The mole fraction represents the fraction of particles (moles), not the fraction of mass. Because ethane has a higher molar mass than methane, you must factor in the molar masses of both gases to determine the mass fraction.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used Dalton's law of partial pressures to calculate the partial pressure of methane.

You correctly computed the mole fraction of methane as the ratio of its partial pressure to the total pressure.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing mole fraction with mass fraction

You treated the mole fraction (0.7500.750) as if it were the mass fraction of methane in the mixture.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

The partial pressure fraction PiPtotal\frac{P_i}{P_{\text{total}}} strictly gives the mole fraction xix_i, which reflects the number of particles. To find the mass of a component from total mass, the mole ratio must first be weighted by each component's molar mass (MM) to find the true mass fraction.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Pressure fraction equals mole fraction
  • For ideal gases, PiPtotal=xi=nintotal\frac{P_i}{P_{\text{total}}} = x_i = \frac{n_i}{n_{\text{total}}}, which is a ratio of particle amounts, not grams.

  • Label the calculated fraction clearly as xix_i (mole fraction) rather than a general 'fraction' to avoid confusing it with mass fraction.

Converting mole fraction to mass fraction
  • The mass fraction is wi=xiMi∑(xjMj)w_i = \frac{x_i M_i}{\sum (x_j M_j)}.

  • Multiply each component's mole fraction by its molar mass to determine its relative mass contribution before multiplying by total mass.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. The mole ratio of methane to ethane is nCHX4nCX2HX6=0.7500.250=31\frac{n_{\ce{CH4}}}{n_{\ce{C2H6}}} = \frac{0.750}{0.250} = \frac{3}{1}.

  2. Calculate the mass contributed by each in a reference sample with 3 mol CHX43\text{ mol }\ce{CH4} and 1 mol CX2HX61\text{ mol }\ce{C2H6}: Mass of CHX4=3 mol⋅16.04 g/mol=48.12 g\text{Mass of }\ce{CH4} = 3\text{ mol} \cdot 16.04\text{ g/mol} = 48.12\text{ g} and Mass of CX2HX6=1 mol⋅30.07 g/mol=30.07 g\text{Mass of }\ce{C2H6} = 1\text{ mol} \cdot 30.07\text{ g/mol} = 30.07\text{ g}.

  3. Determine the total reference mass: 48.12 g+30.07 g=78.19 g48.12\text{ g} + 30.07\text{ g} = 78.19\text{ g}.

  4. Find the mass fraction of ethane: wCX2HX6=30.07 g78.19 g≈0.390w_{\ce{C2H6}} = \frac{30.07\text{ g}}{78.19\text{ g}} \approx 0.390.

  5. Calculate the mass of ethane in the vessel: mCX2HX6=4.85 g⋅0.390=1.89 gm_{\ce{C2H6}} = 4.85\text{ g} \cdot 0.390 = 1.89\text{ g}.

  6. Subtract from total mass to find the mass of methane: mCHX4=4.85 g−1.89 g=2.96 gm_{\ce{CH4}} = 4.85\text{ g} - 1.89\text{ g} = 2.96\text{ g}.

Final answer

2.96 g2.96\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write explicit units and subscripts (e.g., xCHX4x_{\ce{CH4}} vs. wCHX4w_{\ce{CH4}}) so you do not accidentally treat mole ratios as mass ratios.

  • Practice converting between mole fractions and mass fractions for binary gas mixtures with different molar masses.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student swaps the molar masses of methane and ethane when setting up the mass balance equation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    x(CX2HX6)=0.450/1.80=0.250  ⟹  x(CHX4)=1−0.250=0.750x(\ce{C2H6}) = 0.450 / 1.80 = 0.250 \implies x(\ce{CH4}) = 1 - 0.250 = 0.750

  2. Step 2

    n(CHX4)=3∗n(CX2HX6)n(\ce{CH4}) = 3 * n(\ce{C2H6})

  3. Step 3

    m(total)=3∗n(CX2HX6)∗30.07+n(CX2HX6)∗16.04=4.85  ⟹  n(CX2HX6)∗106.25=4.85  ⟹  n(CX2HX6)=0.04565 molm(\text{total}) = 3 * n(\ce{C2H6}) * 30.07 + n(\ce{C2H6}) * 16.04 = 4.85 \implies n(\ce{C2H6}) * 106.25 = 4.85 \implies n(\ce{C2H6}) = 0.04565\text{ mol}

    Correct

    mtotal=nCHX4MCHX4+nCX2HX6MCX2HX6=3nCX2HX6(16.04)+nCX2HX6(30.07)=4.85 gm_{\text{total}} = n_{\ce{CH4}} M_{\ce{CH4}} + n_{\ce{C2H6}} M_{\ce{C2H6}} = 3n_{\ce{C2H6}}(16.04) + n_{\ce{C2H6}}(30.07) = 4.85\text{ g}

    You swapped the molar masses of methane and ethane: methane is 16.04 g/mol16.04\text{ g/mol} and ethane is 30.07 g/mol30.07\text{ g/mol}, but you multiplied the methane term by 30.0730.07 and the ethane term by 16.0416.04.

  4. Step 4

    n(CHX4)=3∗0.04565=0.1369 moln(\ce{CH4}) = 3 * 0.04565 = 0.1369\text{ mol}

    Correct

    nCHX4=3nCX2HX6=3(0.06203 mol)=0.1861 moln_{\ce{CH4}} = 3n_{\ce{C2H6}} = 3(0.06203\text{ mol}) = 0.1861\text{ mol}

    Your calculation correctly followed your 3:13:1 ratio, but the numerical value was carried over from the incorrect molar mass substitution in Step 3.

  5. Step 5

    m(CHX4)=0.1369 mol∗30.07 g/mol=4.12 gm(\ce{CH4}) = 0.1369\text{ mol} * 30.07\text{ g/mol} = 4.12\text{ g}

    Correct

    mCHX4=nCHX4MCHX4=0.1861 mol×16.04 g/mol≈2.98 gm_{\ce{CH4}} = n_{\ce{CH4}} M_{\ce{CH4}} = 0.1861\text{ mol} \times 16.04\text{ g/mol} \approx 2.98\text{ g} (or 2.96 g2.96\text{ g} via intermediate rounding)

    This step was affected by the earlier values and also repeated the use of 30.07 g/mol30.07\text{ g/mol} for methane instead of 16.04 g/mol16.04\text{ g/mol}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used Dalton's law of partial pressures to calculate the mole fractions of both gases.

You set up the relationship between the moles of methane and ethane accurately as nCHX4=3nCX2HX6n_{\ce{CH4}} = 3n_{\ce{C2H6}}.

You correctly recognized that total mass is the sum of each component's moles multiplied by its molar mass.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Swapped variables/constants

You assigned the molar mass of ethane (30.07 g/mol30.07\text{ g/mol}) to methane, and the molar mass of methane (16.04 g/mol16.04\text{ g/mol}) to ethane.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Variable misattribution when converting molar quantities to mass in a multi-component gas mixture.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Label Molar Masses Explicitly with Subscripts
  • MiM_i must match the specific chemical species ii: MCHX4=16.04 g/molM_{\ce{CH4}} = 16.04\text{ g/mol} and MCX2HX6=30.07 g/molM_{\ce{C2H6}} = 30.07\text{ g/mol}.

  • Write out mtotal=nCHX4MCHX4+nCX2HX6MCX2HX6m_{\text{total}} = n_{\ce{CH4}}M_{\ce{CH4}} + n_{\ce{C2H6}}M_{\ce{C2H6}} in symbols before plugging in numbers, and verify that the lighter gas has the smaller molar mass.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute the correct molar masses into the mass balance: mtotal=3nCX2HX6(16.04 g/mol)+nCX2HX6(30.07 g/mol)=4.85 gm_{\text{total}} = 3n_{\ce{C2H6}}(16.04\text{ g/mol}) + n_{\ce{C2H6}}(30.07\text{ g/mol}) = 4.85\text{ g}.

  2. Combine terms: nCX2HX6(48.12+30.07)=4.85 g  ⟹  nCX2HX6(78.19)=4.85 gn_{\ce{C2H6}}(48.12 + 30.07) = 4.85\text{ g} \implies n_{\ce{C2H6}}(78.19) = 4.85\text{ g}.

  3. Solve for nCX2HX6n_{\ce{C2H6}}: nCX2HX6=4.8578.19≈0.06203 moln_{\ce{C2H6}} = \frac{4.85}{78.19} \approx 0.06203\text{ mol}.

  4. Find the mass of methane: mCHX4=3nCX2HX6×16.04 g/mol=3(0.06203)(16.04)≈2.98 gm_{\ce{CH4}} = 3n_{\ce{C2H6}} \times 16.04\text{ g/mol} = 3(0.06203)(16.04) \approx 2.98\text{ g} (or 2.96 g2.96\text{ g} if using mass fractions).

Final answer

2.96 g2.96\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write down the formula with explicit chemical formula subscripts (e.g., MCHX4M_{\ce{CH4}} vs. MCX2HX6M_{\ce{C2H6}}) before inserting numerical values.

  • Do a quick sanity check: since methane has a higher mole fraction (75%75\%) and lower molar mass, its mass fraction should still be significant, but not equal to its mole fraction.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student incorrectly calculates the mass of ethane instead of methane after solving for the moles of ethane.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    x(CX2HX6)=0.4501.80=0.250  ⟹  x(CHX4)=0.750  ⟹  n(CHX4)=3⋅n(CX2HX6)x(\ce{C2H6}) = \frac{0.450}{1.80} = 0.250 \implies x(\ce{CH4}) = 0.750 \implies n(\ce{CH4}) = 3 \cdot n(\ce{C2H6})

  2. Step 2

    4.85=n(CX2HX6)⋅(3⋅16.04+30.07)=n(CX2HX6)⋅78.19  ⟹  n(CX2HX6)=4.8578.19=0.06203 mol4.85 = n(\ce{C2H6}) \cdot (3 \cdot 16.04 + 30.07) = n(\ce{C2H6}) \cdot 78.19 \implies n(\ce{C2H6}) = \frac{4.85}{78.19} = 0.06203\text{ mol}

  3. Step 3

    m=0.06203 mol⋅30.07 g/mol=1.87 gm = 0.06203\text{ mol} \cdot 30.07\text{ g/mol} = 1.87\text{ g}

    Correct

    mCHX4=mtotal−mCX2HX6=4.85 g−1.87 g=2.98 gm_{\ce{CH4}} = m_{\text{total}} - m_{\ce{C2H6}} = 4.85\text{ g} - 1.87\text{ g} = 2.98\text{ g} (or 2.96 g2.96\text{ g})

    You calculated the mass of ethane (1.87 g1.87\text{ g}) using its molar mass (30.07 g/mol30.07\text{ g/mol}), but the problem specifically asked for the mass of methane.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used Dalton's law to relate partial pressures to mole fractions.

You set up a sound system relating total mass and molar masses to solve for moles.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Target component mismatch in final step

You solved for the mass of ethane rather than completing the final step to find the mass of methane.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In multi-component gas mixtures, after using a single reference species as an algebraic variable to solve for moles, it is easy to default to calculating that reference component's mass instead of checking which component the prompt asked for.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Prompt Target Verification
  • Always underline or re-read the specific requested quantity and target species before writing down the final answer.

  • Check whether your calculated value represents methane (CHX4\ce{CH4}) or ethane (CX2HX6\ce{C2H6}).

Mass Complement Rule
  • For a binary mixture, the mass of the remaining component is mtarget=mtotal−motherm_{\text{target}} = m_{\text{total}} - m_{\text{other}}.

  • Subtract the mass of ethane from the total mass (4.85 g−1.87 g4.85\text{ g} - 1.87\text{ g}) to obtain the mass of methane.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the moles of methane: n(CHX4)=3⋅0.06203 mol=0.1861 moln(\ce{CH4}) = 3 \cdot 0.06203\text{ mol} = 0.1861\text{ mol}.

  2. Calculate the mass of methane: m(CHX4)=0.1861 mol⋅16.04 g/mol≈2.98 gm(\ce{CH4}) = 0.1861\text{ mol} \cdot 16.04\text{ g/mol} \approx 2.98\text{ g} (or subtract ethane mass: 4.85 g−1.87 g=2.98 g4.85\text{ g} - 1.87\text{ g} = 2.98\text{ g}, giving 2.96 g2.96\text{ g} when rounded using standard component mass fractions).

Final answer

2.96 g2.96\text{ g} (or 2.98 g2.98\text{ g})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that the chemical formula attached to your final calculated mass matches the requested species in the prompt.

  • Practice using the conservation of mass identity mA=mtotal−mBm_A = m_{\text{total}} - m_B as a quick closing step whenever you compute an intermediate component's mass.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A rigid container holds a mixture of helium (He\ce{He}, molar mass 4.00 g/mol4.00\text{ g/mol}) and argon (Ar\ce{Ar}, molar mass 39.95 g/mol39.95\text{ g/mol}). The partial pressure of helium is 2.00 atm2.00\text{ atm} and the partial pressure of argon is 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}. If the total mass of the gas mixture is 24.0 g24.0\text{ g}, calculate the mass of helium in the container.

Answer

The mole fractions are xHe=23x_{\ce{He}} = \frac{2}{3} and xAr=13x_{\ce{Ar}} = \frac{1}{3}. In a 3 mol3\text{ mol} sample, mass of He=2⋅4.00=8.00 g\ce{He} = 2 \cdot 4.00 = 8.00\text{ g} and mass of Ar=1⋅39.95=39.95 g\ce{Ar} = 1 \cdot 39.95 = 39.95\text{ g}, giving a total reference mass of 47.95 g47.95\text{ g}. The mass fraction of He\ce{He} is 8.00 g47.95 g≈0.1668\frac{8.00\text{ g}}{47.95\text{ g}} \approx 0.1668. Therefore, mHe=24.0 g⋅0.1668≈4.00 gm_{\ce{He}} = 24.0\text{ g} \cdot 0.1668 \approx 4.00\text{ g}.

02

An equimolar gas mixture of neon (Ne\ce{Ne}, 20.18 g/mol20.18\text{ g/mol}) and krypton (Kr\ce{Kr}, 83.80 g/mol83.80\text{ g/mol}) has a total pressure of 3.00 atm3.00\text{ atm} and a total mass of 52.0 g52.0\text{ g}. Find the partial pressure of neon and the mass of neon present in the mixture.

Answer

Because the mixture is equimolar, xNe=0.500x_{\ce{Ne}} = 0.500, so PNe=0.500⋅3.00 atm=1.50 atmP_{\ce{Ne}} = 0.500 \cdot 3.00\text{ atm} = 1.50\text{ atm}. The mass fraction of neon is wNe=20.1820.18+83.80=20.18103.98≈0.1941w_{\ce{Ne}} = \frac{20.18}{20.18 + 83.80} = \frac{20.18}{103.98} \approx 0.1941. Multiplying by total mass gives mNe=52.0 g⋅0.1941≈10.1 gm_{\ce{Ne}} = 52.0\text{ g} \cdot 0.1941 \approx 10.1\text{ g}.

03

A 10.0 g10.0\text{ g} sample containing carbon monoxide (CO\ce{CO}, 28.01 g/mol28.01\text{ g/mol}) and carbon dioxide (COX2\ce{CO2}, 44.01 g/mol44.01\text{ g/mol}) is at a total pressure of 2.50 atm2.50\text{ atm}. If the partial pressure of CO\ce{CO} is 1.75 atm1.75\text{ atm}, determine the mass of COX2\ce{CO2} in the sample.

Answer

The mole fractions are xCO=1.752.50=0.700x_{\ce{CO}} = \frac{1.75}{2.50} = 0.700 and xCOX2=0.300x_{\ce{CO2}} = 0.300. For 1 mol1\text{ mol} of mixture, mass is 0.700(28.01)+0.300(44.01)=19.607 g+13.203 g=32.81 g0.700(28.01) + 0.300(44.01) = 19.607\text{ g} + 13.203\text{ g} = 32.81\text{ g}. The mass fraction of COX2\ce{CO2} is wCOX2=13.20332.81≈0.4024w_{\ce{CO2}} = \frac{13.203}{32.81} \approx 0.4024. The mass of COX2\ce{CO2} is 10.0 g⋅0.4024≈4.02 g10.0\text{ g} \cdot 0.4024 \approx 4.02\text{ g}.

Loading workspace…