Resources

A cylinder containing 1.00 mol1.00\text{ mol} of an ideal gas at T=298 KT = 298\text{ K} expands isothermally from Vi=2.00 LV_i = 2.00\text{ L} to Vf=10.0 LV_f = 10.0\text{ L}. In an extreme multi-stage limit, the expansion is carried out against a variable external pressure in NN equal incremental volume steps ΔV=Vf−ViN\Delta V = \frac{V_f - V_i}{N}. At the asymptotic limit where N→∞N \to \infty, the process becomes quasi-static and reversible (Pext=Pgas=nRTVP_{\text{ext}} = P_{\text{gas}} = \frac{nRT}{V}). Because TT is constant, ΔU=0\Delta U = 0. Calculate the asymptotic limit of the work wrevw_{\text{rev}} (in kJ\text{kJ}) and heat qrevq_{\text{rev}} (in kJ\text{kJ}) transferred during this reversible limit, and compare it to the single-stage limit (N=1N = 1) where expansion occurs against a constant Pext=Pf=nRTVfP_{\text{ext}} = P_f = \frac{nRT}{V_f}. (R=8.314 J/(mol⋅K)R = 8.314\text{ J/(mol}\cdot\text{K)})

Answer and steps

Final answer

Reversible limit (N→∞N \to \infty): wrev=−3.99 kJw_{\text{rev}} = -3.99\text{ kJ}, qrev=+3.99 kJq_{\text{rev}} = +3.99\text{ kJ}; Single-stage (N=1N = 1): w1=−1.98 kJw_1 = -1.98\text{ kJ}, q1=+1.98 kJq_1 = +1.98\text{ kJ}

Steps

01

General Principles of Isothermal Gas Expansion

For an ideal gas undergoing an isothermal process (T=constantT = \text{constant}), the internal energy change is zero:

ΔU=0\Delta U = 0

According to the First Law of Thermodynamics, ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w. Therefore, for any isothermal process:

q=−wq = -w

The pressure-volume work performed during an expansion against an external pressure PextP_{\text{ext}} is given by:

w=−∫ViVfPext dVw = -\int_{V_i}^{V_f} P_{\text{ext}}\, dV


02

Multi-Stage Reversible Limit (N→∞N \to \infty)

In the continuous, reversible limit, the expansion is carried out infinitely slowly so that the gas remains in mechanical equilibrium with the surroundings at every infinitesimal step:

Pext=Pgas=nRTVP_{\text{ext}} = P_{\text{gas}} = \frac{nRT}{V}

Integrating along the expansion path:

wrev=−∫ViVfnRTV dV=−nRTln⁡(VfVi)w_{\text{rev}} = -\int_{V_i}^{V_f} \frac{nRT}{V}\, dV = -nRT \ln\left(\frac{V_f}{V_i}\right)

Substitute the given numerical values:

  • n=1.00 moln = 1.00\text{ mol}
  • R=8.314 J/(mol⋅K)R = 8.314\text{ J/(mol}\cdot\text{K)}
  • T=298 KT = 298\text{ K}
  • Vi=2.00 LV_i = 2.00\text{ L}
  • Vf=10.0 LV_f = 10.0\text{ L}

wrev=−(1.00 mol)⋅(8.314 J/(mol⋅K))⋅(298 K)⋅ln⁡(10.0 L2.00 L)w_{\text{rev}} = -(1.00\text{ mol}) \cdot (8.314\text{ J/(mol}\cdot\text{K)}) \cdot (298\text{ K}) \cdot \ln\left(\frac{10.0\text{ L}}{2.00\text{ L}}\right)

wrev=−2477.57 J⋅ln⁡(5)=−2477.57 J⋅1.6094≈−3988 J=−3.99 kJw_{\text{rev}} = -2477.57\text{ J} \cdot \ln(5) = -2477.57\text{ J} \cdot 1.6094 \approx -3988\text{ J} = -3.99\text{ kJ}

Applying the first law:

qrev=−wrev=+3.99 kJq_{\text{rev}} = -w_{\text{rev}} = +3.99\text{ kJ}


03

Single-Stage Irreversible Expansion (N=1N = 1)

In a single-stage expansion against a constant final pressure Pext=PfP_{\text{ext}} = P_f:

Pf=nRTVfP_f = \frac{nRT}{V_f}

The work done is:

w1=−PextΔV=−Pf(Vf−Vi)=−nRTVf(Vf−Vi)=−nRT(1−ViVf)w_1 = -P_{\text{ext}} \Delta V = -P_f (V_f - V_i) = -\frac{nRT}{V_f} (V_f - V_i) = -nRT \left(1 - \frac{V_i}{V_f}\right)

Substitute the numerical values:

w1=−(1.00 mol)⋅(8.314 J/(mol⋅K))⋅(298 K)⋅(1−2.00 L10.0 L)w_1 = -(1.00\text{ mol}) \cdot (8.314\text{ J/(mol}\cdot\text{K)}) \cdot (298\text{ K}) \cdot \left(1 - \frac{2.00\text{ L}}{10.0\text{ L}}\right)

w1=−2477.57 J⋅(1−0.200)=−2477.57 J⋅0.800≈−1982 J=−1.98 kJw_1 = -2477.57\text{ J} \cdot (1 - 0.200) = -2477.57\text{ J} \cdot 0.800 \approx -1982\text{ J} = -1.98\text{ kJ}

Applying the first law:

q1=−w1=+1.98 kJq_1 = -w_1 = +1.98\text{ kJ}


04

Comparison and Physical Interpretation

  • Work: Work is a path function, not a state function. The reversible path extracts the maximum possible work from the system (∣wrev∣=3.99 kJ>∣w1∣=1.98 kJ|w_{\text{rev}}| = 3.99\text{ kJ} > |w_1| = 1.98\text{ kJ}) because the opposing external pressure is maintained at the highest possible value at every point during the expansion.
  • Heat: Because the system performs more work in the reversible process, it must absorb more heat from the surroundings (qrev=+3.99 kJ>q1=+1.98 kJq_{\text{rev}} = +3.99\text{ kJ} > q_1 = +1.98\text{ kJ}) to maintain a constant temperature (ΔU=0\Delta U = 0).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets the standard IUPAC thermodynamic sign convention w = -∫ P_ext dV and writes w = +nRT ln(V_f / V_i), causing positive work and negative heat during expansion.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    wrev=nRTln⁡(VfVi)  ⟹  wrev=(1.00)(8.314)(298)ln⁡(10.02.00)=+3.99 kJw_{\text{rev}} = nRT \ln\left(\frac{V_f}{V_i}\right) \implies w_{\text{rev}} = (1.00)(8.314)(298) \ln\left(\frac{10.0}{2.00}\right) = +3.99\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    wrev=−∫ViVfPext dV=−nRTln⁡(VfVi)=−(1.00)(8.314)(298)ln⁡(5)=−3.99 kJw_{\text{rev}} = -\int_{V_i}^{V_f} P_{\text{ext}}\,dV = -nRT \ln\left(\frac{V_f}{V_i}\right) = -(1.00)(8.314)(298)\ln(5) = -3.99\text{ kJ}

    By IUPAC convention, thermodynamic work is defined as w=−∫Pext dVw = -\int P_{\text{ext}}\,dV. During an expansion (Vf>ViV_f > V_i), the system does work on the surroundings, so energy leaves the system and ww must be negative.

  2. Step 2

    qrev=ΔU−wrev=0−3.99 kJ=−3.99 kJq_{\text{rev}} = \Delta U - w_{\text{rev}} = 0 - 3.99\text{ kJ} = -3.99\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    qrev=ΔU−wrev=0−(−3.99 kJ)=+3.99 kJq_{\text{rev}} = \Delta U - w_{\text{rev}} = 0 - (-3.99\text{ kJ}) = +3.99\text{ kJ}

    You correctly applied the First Law of Thermodynamics (ΔU=q+w  ⟹  q=ΔU−w\Delta U = q + w \implies q = \Delta U - w), but substituting your positive work value resulted in an incorrect negative sign for heat.

  3. Step 3

    wirr=Pf(Vf−Vi)=nRTVf(Vf−Vi)  ⟹  wirr=(1.00×8.314×29810.0)×(10.0−2.00)=+1.98 kJw_{\text{irr}} = P_f (V_f - V_i) = \frac{nRT}{V_f}(V_f - V_i) \implies w_{\text{irr}} = \left(\frac{1.00 \times 8.314 \times 298}{10.0}\right) \times (10.0 - 2.00) = +1.98\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    w1=−PextΔV=−nRTVf(Vf−Vi)=−1.98 kJw_1 = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V = -\frac{nRT}{V_f}(V_f - V_i) = -1.98\text{ kJ}

    Single-stage work against a constant external pressure is w=−PextΔVw = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V. Because the gas expands against the atmosphere, the work value must be negative.

  4. Step 4

    qirr=−1.98 kJq_{\text{irr}} = -1.98\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    q1=ΔU−w1=0−(−1.98 kJ)=+1.98 kJq_1 = \Delta U - w_1 = 0 - (-1.98\text{ kJ}) = +1.98\text{ kJ}

    Because internal energy is conserved in an isothermal process (ΔU=0\Delta U = 0), q=−wq = -w. Since work is negative, heat absorbed from the thermal reservoir must be +1.98 kJ+1.98\text{ kJ}.

  5. Step 5

    The reversible limit yields more work (+3.99 kJ+3.99\text{ kJ}) than the single-stage limit (+1.98 kJ+1.98\text{ kJ}).

    Correct

    The reversible limit performs more work on the surroundings (∣wrev∣=3.99 kJ>∣w1∣=1.98 kJ|w_{\text{rev}}| = 3.99\text{ kJ} > |w_1| = 1.98\text{ kJ}), so wrev=−3.99 kJw_{\text{rev}} = -3.99\text{ kJ} represents a larger magnitude of work done by the system than w1=−1.98 kJw_1 = -1.98\text{ kJ}.

    Your physical conclusion about magnitudes is correct, but stating positive values conflicts with the thermodynamic definition that work done by an expanding system is negative.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled that ΔU=0\Delta U = 0 for an isothermal process involving an ideal gas.

You set up the mathematical form of the integral ∫nRTV dV\int \frac{nRT}{V}\,dV and evaluated the natural logarithm accurately.

You correctly formulated the single-stage irreversible work expression using Pext=Pf=nRTVfP_{\text{ext}} = P_f = \frac{nRT}{V_f}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
IUPAC Sign Convention Omission

You dropped the negative sign from the thermodynamic definition w=−∫Pext dVw = -\int P_{\text{ext}}\,dV, leading to w>0w > 0 and q<0q < 0 during expansion.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the physics definition of work done by a gas (Wby=∫P dVW_{\text{by}} = \int P\,dV) with the standard IUPAC chemistry convention (w=−∫Pext dVw = -\int P_{\text{ext}}\,dV), which tracks energy flow from the system's perspective.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
IUPAC Work Definition
  • w=−∫ViVfPext dVw = -\int_{V_i}^{V_f} P_{\text{ext}}\,dV

  • Always write the explicit minus sign in the definition before integrating or substituting values.

Physical Reality Check for Expansion
  • Expansion (Vf>ViV_f > V_i) does work on the surroundings, reducing system energy; isothermal expansion requires heat input from the surroundings.

  • Check that w<0w < 0 and q>0q > 0 whenever an ideal gas expands isothermally.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Reversible limit: wrev=−nRTln⁡(VfVi)=−(1.00 mol)(8.314 J/(mol⋅K))(298 K)ln⁡(5)=−3.99 kJw_{\text{rev}} = -nRT \ln\left(\frac{V_f}{V_i}\right) = -(1.00\text{ mol})(8.314\text{ J/(mol}\cdot\text{K)})(298\text{ K})\ln(5) = -3.99\text{ kJ}.

  2. Reversible heat: qrev=ΔU−wrev=0−(−3.99 kJ)=+3.99 kJq_{\text{rev}} = \Delta U - w_{\text{rev}} = 0 - (-3.99\text{ kJ}) = +3.99\text{ kJ}.

  3. Single-stage limit: w1=−Pf(Vf−Vi)=−nRTVf(Vf−Vi)=−(2477.57 J)(0.800)=−1.98 kJw_1 = -P_f(V_f - V_i) = -\frac{nRT}{V_f}(V_f - V_i) = -(2477.57\text{ J})(0.800) = -1.98\text{ kJ}.

  4. Single-stage heat: q1=ΔU−w1=0−(−1.98 kJ)=+1.98 kJq_1 = \Delta U - w_1 = 0 - (-1.98\text{ kJ}) = +1.98\text{ kJ}.

Final answer

Reversible limit (N→∞N \to \infty): wrev=−3.99 kJw_{\text{rev}} = -3.99\text{ kJ}, qrev=+3.99 kJq_{\text{rev}} = +3.99\text{ kJ}; Single-stage (N=1N = 1): w1=−1.98 kJw_1 = -1.98\text{ kJ}, q1=+1.98 kJq_1 = +1.98\text{ kJ}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the IUPAC first law expression ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w paired with w=−∫Pext dVw = -\int P_{\text{ext}}\,dV.

  • Practice checking thermodynamic signs before calculating: ask whether energy enters (++) or leaves (−-) the system.

  • Solve problems comparing reversible and multi-stage irreversible expansions to solidify path-dependent work values.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student inverts the volume ratio inside the logarithm as V_i / V_f instead of V_f / V_i, yielding a positive value of work under the formula w = -nRT ln(ratio).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    wrev=−nRTln⁡(ViVf)  ⟹  wrev=−(1.00)(8.314)(298)ln⁡(2.0010.0)=+3.99 kJw_{\text{rev}} = -nRT \ln\left(\frac{V_i}{V_f}\right) \implies w_{\text{rev}} = -(1.00)(8.314)(298) \ln\left(\frac{2.00}{10.0}\right) = +3.99\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    wrev=−nRTln⁡(VfVi)=−(1.00 mol)(8.314 J/(mol⋅K))(298 K)ln⁡(10.0 L2.00 L)=−3.99 kJw_{\text{rev}} = -nRT \ln\left(\frac{V_f}{V_i}\right) = -(1.00\text{ mol})(8.314\text{ J/(mol}\cdot\text{K)})(298\text{ K}) \ln\left(\frac{10.0\text{ L}}{2.00\text{ L}}\right) = -3.99\text{ kJ}

    Integrating −∫ViVfnRTV dV-\int_{V_i}^{V_f} \frac{nRT}{V}\,dV yields −nRT[ln⁡V]ViVf=−nRTln⁡(VfVi)-nRT [\ln V]_{V_i}^{V_f} = -nRT \ln\left(\frac{V_f}{V_i}\right). Placing the initial volume in the numerator inverted the sign, erroneously making expansion work positive.

  2. Step 2

    qrev=−wrev=−3.99 kJq_{\text{rev}} = -w_{\text{rev}} = -3.99\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    qrev=−wrev=−(−3.99 kJ)=+3.99 kJq_{\text{rev}} = -w_{\text{rev}} = -(-3.99\text{ kJ}) = +3.99\text{ kJ}

    You correctly applied the First Law relation ΔU=q+w=0  ⟹  q=−w\Delta U = q + w = 0 \implies q = -w, but the sign error from your reversible work carried into this value.

  3. Step 3

    wirr=−Pf(Vf−Vi)=−(nRTVf)(Vf−Vi)  ⟹  wirr=−(1.00×8.314×29810.0)×(10.0−2.00)=−1.98 kJ  ⟹  qirr=+1.98 kJw_{\text{irr}} = -P_f (V_f - V_i) = -\left(\frac{nRT}{V_f}\right)(V_f - V_i) \implies w_{\text{irr}} = -\left(\frac{1.00 \times 8.314 \times 298}{10.0}\right) \times (10.0 - 2.00) = -1.98\text{ kJ} \implies q_{\text{irr}} = +1.98\text{ kJ}

  4. Step 4

    Comparing the two, wrev=+3.99 kJ while wirr=−1.98 kJ.\text{Comparing the two, } w_{\text{rev}} = +3.99\text{ kJ} \text{ while } w_{\text{irr}} = -1.98\text{ kJ}.

    Correct

    Both work values are negative because the gas expands; the reversible path does maximum work on the surroundings: ∣wrev∣=3.99 kJ>∣w1∣=1.98 kJ.\text{Both work values are negative because the gas expands; the reversible path does maximum work on the surroundings: } |w_{\text{rev}}| = 3.99\text{ kJ} > |w_1| = 1.98\text{ kJ}.

    Because of the inverted sign in step 1, your comparison contrasted a positive work value with a negative one rather than comparing the magnitudes of work done by the gas.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that ΔU=0\Delta U = 0 for an isothermal process of an ideal gas, giving q=−wq = -w.

You correctly computed the work and heat for the single-stage irreversible expansion against PfP_f.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula recall error: inverted logarithmic limits

You set the logarithmic ratio as ViVf\frac{V_i}{V_f} instead of VfVi\frac{V_f}{V_i}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing integration limits [ln⁡V]ViVf=ln⁡(Vf)−ln⁡(Vi)=ln⁡(Vf/Vi)[\ln V]_{V_i}^{V_f} = \ln(V_f) - \ln(V_i) = \ln(V_f / V_i) with Boyle's law pressure-volume inversion ratios (Pi/Pf=Vf/ViP_i/P_f = V_f/V_i), combined with not checking the physical sign convention (w<0w < 0 for expansion work done by the system).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Integration Limits for Definite Integrals
  • ∫ab1x dx=ln⁡(b)−ln⁡(a)=ln⁡(ba)=ln⁡(upperlower)\int_{a}^{b} \frac{1}{x}\,dx = \ln(b) - \ln(a) = \ln\left(\frac{b}{a}\right) = \ln\left(\frac{\text{upper}}{\text{lower}}\right).

  • Always write the upper limit in the numerator and the lower limit in the denominator: ln⁡(Vf/Vi)\ln(V_f / V_i).

Thermodynamic Sign Sanity Check
  • For an expansion (Vf>ViV_f > V_i), work is done by the system on the surroundings, so w<0w < 0.

  • Before proceeding, check that an expanding gas has w<0w < 0 and absorbs heat (q>0q > 0).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute the proper ratio into the reversible work equation: wrev=−nRTln⁡(VfVi)=−(1.00 mol)(8.314 J/(mol⋅K))(298 K)ln⁡(10.0 L2.00 L)w_{\text{rev}} = -nRT \ln\left(\frac{V_f}{V_i}\right) = -(1.00\text{ mol})(8.314\text{ J/(mol}\cdot\text{K)})(298\text{ K}) \ln\left(\frac{10.0\text{ L}}{2.00\text{ L}}\right).

  2. Compute the value: wrev=−2477.57 J×1.6094=−3988 J=−3.99 kJw_{\text{rev}} = -2477.57\text{ J} \times 1.6094 = -3988\text{ J} = -3.99\text{ kJ}.

  3. Determine the heat: qrev=−wrev=−(−3.99 kJ)=+3.99 kJq_{\text{rev}} = -w_{\text{rev}} = -(-3.99\text{ kJ}) = +3.99\text{ kJ}.

  4. Compare: Both paths do work on the surroundings (w<0w < 0), with the reversible path doing more work (∣wrev∣=3.99 kJ>∣w1∣=1.98 kJ|w_{\text{rev}}| = 3.99\text{ kJ} > |w_1| = 1.98\text{ kJ}) and therefore absorbing more heat (qrev=+3.99 kJ>q1=+1.98 kJq_{\text{rev}} = +3.99\text{ kJ} > q_1 = +1.98\text{ kJ}).

Final answer

Reversible limit (N→∞N \to \infty): wrev=−3.99 kJw_{\text{rev}} = -3.99\text{ kJ}, qrev=+3.99 kJq_{\text{rev}} = +3.99\text{ kJ}; Single-stage (N=1N = 1): w1=−1.98 kJw_1 = -1.98\text{ kJ}, q1=+1.98 kJq_1 = +1.98\text{ kJ}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice deriving w=−∫ViVfP dVw = -\int_{V_i}^{V_f} P\,dV from first principles to solidify where ln⁡(Vf/Vi)\ln(V_f / V_i) originates.

  • Perform a physical sign check after computing work: expansion always means w<0w < 0, while compression always means w>0w > 0.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misapplies the constant-pressure formula w = -P_i ΔV using initial pressure P_i instead of the final pressure P_f for single-stage expansion against the final opposing pressure.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    wrev=−nRTln⁡(VfVi)=−(1.00)(8.314)(298)ln⁡(10.02.00)=−3.99 kJ  ⟹  qrev=−wrev=+3.99 kJw_{\text{rev}} = -nRT \ln\left(\frac{V_f}{V_i}\right) = -(1.00)(8.314)(298)\ln\left(\frac{10.0}{2.00}\right) = -3.99\text{ kJ} \implies q_{\text{rev}} = -w_{\text{rev}} = +3.99\text{ kJ}

  2. Step 2

    wirr=−Pi(Vf−Vi)=−(nRTVi)(Vf−Vi)=−(1.00×8.314×2982.00)×(10.0−2.00)=−9.91 kJ  ⟹  qirr=−wirr=+9.91 kJw_{\text{irr}} = -P_i (V_f - V_i) = -\left(\frac{nRT}{V_i}\right)(V_f - V_i) = -\left(\frac{1.00 \times 8.314 \times 298}{2.00}\right) \times (10.0 - 2.00) = -9.91\text{ kJ} \implies q_{\text{irr}} = -w_{\text{irr}} = +9.91\text{ kJ}

    Correct

    w1=−Pf(Vf−Vi)=−(nRTVf)(Vf−Vi)=−1.98 kJ  ⟹  q1=+1.98 kJw_1 = -P_f (V_f - V_i) = -\left(\frac{nRT}{V_f}\right)(V_f - V_i) = -1.98\text{ kJ} \implies q_1 = +1.98\text{ kJ}

    In an irreversible single-stage expansion against the surroundings, the external opposing pressure is fixed at the final pressure Pext=Pf=nRTVfP_{\text{ext}} = P_f = \frac{nRT}{V_f}, not the initial pressure PiP_i. Setting Pext=PiP_{\text{ext}} = P_i overestimates the opposing pressure during an expansion.

  3. Step 3

    The single-stage expansion does more work (−9.91 kJ-9.91\text{ kJ}) than the reversible expansion (−3.99 kJ-3.99\text{ kJ}).

    Correct

    The reversible expansion produces the maximum magnitude of work (∣wrev∣=3.99 kJ>∣w1∣=1.98 kJ|w_{\text{rev}}| = 3.99\text{ kJ} > |w_1| = 1.98\text{ kJ}).

    Because your value for wirrw_{\text{irr}} was calculated using PiP_i, your conclusion contradicted the thermodynamic principle that a reversible expansion yields the maximum possible work done by the system.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and applied the integral formula for reversible isothermal work of an ideal gas.

You correctly related heat and work using the First Law condition ΔU=0\Delta U = 0 for an isothermal process.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
External Pressure Substitution Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You substituted the initial state pressure PiP_i for PextP_{\text{ext}} instead of the final opposing pressure PfP_f. During a single-stage spontaneous expansion, the gas pushes against the lower final pressure PfP_f (or the constant external resistance), never against its initial internal pressure.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Opposing Pressure in Expansion
  • Thermodynamic work is defined by w=−∫Pext dVw = -\int P_{\text{ext}}\, dV. For a single-stage expansion to VfV_f, the opposing external pressure is Pext=PfP_{\text{ext}} = P_f.

  • Always identify the external resistance against which the system pushes before calculating constant-pressure work.

Maximum Work Criterion
  • For an isothermal expansion between two fixed states, a reversible path delivers the maximum magnitude of expansion work: ∣wrev∣≥∣wirr∣|w_{\text{rev}}| \ge |w_{\text{irr}}|.

  • If your calculated irreversible expansion work magnitude exceeds the reversible work magnitude, stop and re-check the pressure term.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the opposing external pressure to the final equilibrium pressure: Pext=Pf=nRTVfP_{\text{ext}} = P_f = \frac{nRT}{V_f}.

  2. Compute the work: w1=−Pf(Vf−Vi)=−(1.00 mol×8.314 J/(mol⋅K)×298 K10.0 L)×(10.0 L−2.00 L)=−1982 J=−1.98 kJw_1 = -P_f (V_f - V_i) = -\left(\frac{1.00\text{ mol} \times 8.314\text{ J/(mol}\cdot\text{K)} \times 298\text{ K}}{10.0\text{ L}}\right) \times (10.0\text{ L} - 2.00\text{ L}) = -1982\text{ J} = -1.98\text{ kJ}.

  3. Compute the heat absorbed: q1=−w1=+1.98 kJq_1 = -w_1 = +1.98\text{ kJ}.

  4. Compare the magnitudes: ∣wrev∣=3.99 kJ>∣w1∣=1.98 kJ|w_{\text{rev}}| = 3.99\text{ kJ} > |w_1| = 1.98\text{ kJ}, verifying that the reversible pathway performs the maximum work.

Final answer

wrev=−3.99 kJw_{\text{rev}} = -3.99\text{ kJ}, qrev=+3.99 kJq_{\text{rev}} = +3.99\text{ kJ}; w1=−1.98 kJw_1 = -1.98\text{ kJ}, q1=+1.98 kJq_1 = +1.98\text{ kJ}; reversible expansion delivers greater work magnitude than single-stage expansion.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review why PextP_{\text{ext}} governs expansion work rather than the system's initial pressure.

  • Practice drawing P–VP\text{--}V indicator diagrams to visually verify that the area under a reversible isotherm always bounds the single-stage rectangle from above during expansion.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A sample of 0.500 mol0.500\text{ mol} of an ideal gas expands isothermally at 300 K300\text{ K} from 2.00 L2.00\text{ L} to 6.00 L6.00\text{ L} against a constant external pressure Pext=1.00 atmP_{\text{ext}} = 1.00\text{ atm}. Calculate ww and qq for this process in joules (1 L⋅atm=101.325 J1\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = 101.325\text{ J}).

Answer

w=−405 Jw = -405\text{ J}, q=+405 Jq = +405\text{ J}. Work is w=−PextΔV=−(1.00 atm)(6.00 L−2.00 L)=−4.00 L⋅atm=−405.3 Jw = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V = -(1.00\text{ atm})(6.00\text{ L} - 2.00\text{ L}) = -4.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = -405.3\text{ J}. For an isothermal expansion of an ideal gas, ΔU=0\Delta U = 0, so q=−w=+405.3 Jq = -w = +405.3\text{ J}.

02

Calculate the work wrevw_{\text{rev}} (in kJ\text{kJ}) when 2.00 mol2.00\text{ mol} of an ideal gas is compressed reversibly and isothermally at 350 K350\text{ K} from 25.0 L25.0\text{ L} to 5.00 L5.00\text{ L}. (R=8.314 J/(mol⋅K)R = 8.314\text{ J/(mol}\cdot\text{K)})

Answer

wrev=+9.37 kJw_{\text{rev}} = +9.37\text{ kJ}. For reversible isothermal compression, wrev=−nRTln⁡(Vf/Vi)=−(2.00)(8.314)(350)ln⁡(5.00/25.0)=−(5819.8)ln⁡(0.200)=−(5819.8)(−1.6094)=+9366 J=+9.37 kJw_{\text{rev}} = -nRT \ln(V_f/V_i) = -(2.00)(8.314)(350)\ln(5.00/25.0) = -(5819.8)\ln(0.200) = -(5819.8)(-1.6094) = +9366\text{ J} = +9.37\text{ kJ}.

03

An ideal gas expands from Vi=1.0 LV_i = 1.0\text{ L} to Vf=4.0 LV_f = 4.0\text{ L} at T=300 KT = 300\text{ K} (n=1.0 moln = 1.0\text{ mol}) in two equal stages: stage 1 against P1=nRT2.5 LP_1 = \frac{nRT}{2.5\text{ L}} until V=2.5 LV = 2.5\text{ L}, then stage 2 against P2=nRT4.0 LP_2 = \frac{nRT}{4.0\text{ L}} until V=4.0 LV = 4.0\text{ L}. Calculate total work w2w_2 and compare its magnitude to the reversible work ∣wrev∣|w_{\text{rev}}|.

Answer

w2=−2.42 kJw_2 = -2.42\text{ kJ} and ∣wrev∣=3.46 kJ|w_{\text{rev}}| = 3.46\text{ kJ}. In stage 1, w2a=−P1(2.5−1.0)=−nRT(1.5/2.5)=−0.60 nRTw_{2a} = -P_1(2.5 - 1.0) = -nRT(1.5/2.5) = -0.60\,nRT. In stage 2, w2b=−P2(4.0−2.5)=−nRT(1.5/4.0)=−0.375 nRTw_{2b} = -P_2(4.0 - 2.5) = -nRT(1.5/4.0) = -0.375\,nRT. Total w2=−0.975 nRT=−0.975(1.0)(8.314)(300)=−2432 J≈−2.42 kJw_2 = -0.975\,nRT = -0.975(1.0)(8.314)(300) = -2432\text{ J} \approx -2.42\text{ kJ}. Reversible work is wrev=−nRTln⁡(4)=−1.386 nRT=−3.46 kJw_{\text{rev}} = -nRT \ln(4) = -1.386\,nRT = -3.46\text{ kJ}. Notice ∣w1∣<∣w2∣<∣wrev∣|w_1| < |w_2| < |w_{\text{rev}}|, showing work extracted increases toward the reversible limit.

Loading workspace…