Resources
Consider the weak acid dissociation dynamic equilibrium: , where at . A student predicts that diluting a solution of acetic acid with pure distilled water by a factor of (to ) will decrease the percent ionization of the acid because dilution lowers reactant and product concentrations equally. (a) Calculate the percent ionization of acetic acid in both the and solutions to quantitatively evaluate this claim. (b) Explain through dynamic equilibrium reaction rates why dilution shifts the equilibrium toward higher percent ionization.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) For , percent ionization ; for , percent ionization . (b) Dilution decreases the concentrations of both products and reactants; because the reverse rate is bimolecular () while the forward rate depends only on , dilution reduces the reverse rate by a factor of while reducing the forward rate by only a factor of , causing a temporary net forward shift () until dynamic equilibrium is restored.
Steps
For the Solution
Part (a): Calculating Percent Ionization
The dissociation of acetic acid in water is given by: The acid-dissociation constant expression is: Let represent the equilibrium concentration of and produced from dissociation, in units of .
Using an ICE (Initial, Change, Equilibrium) table:
Substitute these into the expression:
Because is small, assume :
Check the 5% approximation: The approximation is valid.
For the Solution
Set up the equilibrium expression:
Applying the approximation gives , which is about of . To maintain high precision near the threshold, solve the quadratic equation directly:
Using the quadratic formula :
Calculate percent ionization:
The student's prediction is incorrect: diluting the solution tenfold increases the percent ionization from to .
Part (b): Dynamic Equilibrium Reaction Rates
At dynamic chemical equilibrium, the rate of the forward reaction equals the rate of the reverse reaction:
-
Immediate Effect of 10-Fold Dilution:
- Adding solvent instantly scales down all dissolved solute concentrations by a factor of .
- The forward reaction depends on a single solute concentration (), so decreases by a factor of :
- The reverse reaction depends on the collision of two dissolved ions ( and ), so decreases by a factor of :
-
Shift Toward Ionization:
- Immediately following dilution, (corresponding to ).
- Because molecules dissociate faster than ions recombine, a net forward shift occurs until a new dynamic equilibrium is established.
- This net dissociation converts an additional fraction of un-ionized acid into ions, resulting in a higher overall percent ionization at lower concentrations (Ostwald's dilution law).
Typical errors
01 The student forgets to divide the equilibrium hydronium concentration by the initial acid concentration when calculating percent ionization, concluding that ionization decreases because [H3O+] decreases.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
and
- Step 2
and
Correctand
You omitted the definition of percent ionization, simply appending a percent sign to rather than dividing by the initial acid concentration and multiplying by .
- Step 3Correct
Because your calculated percent values were distorted by omitting the denominator, your conclusion that percent ionization decreases followed logically from your numbers but contradicted the actual chemical behavior.
- Step 4
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly formulated the acid dissociation constant expressions and solved for the hydronium concentrations.
You clearly explained the kinetic basis of Le Châtelier's principle by contrasting the first-order forward rate with the second-order reverse rate.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou equated equilibrium hydronium concentration directly to percent ionization instead of taking its ratio relative to the starting acid molarity.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated absolute ion concentration with fractional/percent ionization. While dilution decreases the total equilibrium concentration , it increases the fraction of acid molecules that dissociate.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Percent Ionization Formula
Always divide the equilibrium concentration of ionized species by the initial analytical concentration of the parent acid before converting to a percentage.
- Distinguishing Absolute Concentration from Ionized Fraction
Diluting a weak acid decreases (raising pH), but increases the percent ionization .
Check that your quantitative percent ionization comparison matches your Part (b) kinetic conclusion: diluting must yield a larger percent ionization.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFor : .
For : (or ).
Compare the two values: , which means dilution increases percent ionization and the student's prediction was incorrect.
(a) : ; : . The claim is incorrect because percent ionization increases upon dilution. (b) As you wrote, dilution reduces the reverse rate by a factor of and forward rate by , producing a net forward shift.
02 The student treats both forward and reverse reactions as first order in dissolved solutes, concluding that dilution decreases both reaction rates by the same factor and causes no shift in equilibrium.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
0.100:\quad x = = 1.34 10^{-3} = 100% = 1.34%
- Step 2
0.0100:\quad y = = 4.24 10^{-4} = 100% = 4.24% 4.24% > 1.34%.
- Step 3
10. {} = k{}[3], 10
- Step 4
{} = k{}[3^-], 10
Correct_{} = k_r [_3^-][3^+]; [3^-] [3^+] 10, {} 10 10 = 100. {} > {},
The reverse reaction is a bimolecular collision between acetate ions and hydronium ions: . Because both ion concentrations drop by a factor of , the reverse rate drops by a factor of . Because the forward rate only drops by a factor of , the forward rate is temporarily times greater than the reverse rate, driving a net forward shift.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the percent ionization for both concentrations.
You correctly refuted the initial claim using your quantitative results from part (a).
You correctly identified the rate law for the forward reaction and how it scales with dilution.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou crossed out in your reverse rate expression, treating recombination as a unimolecular process.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou overlooked that the reverse reaction requires a collision between two distinct dissolved ions ( and ). In an elementary reversible step, the rate law reflects molecularity; because the reverse reaction is bimolecular, its rate depends on the product of both ion concentrations and scales quadratically with dilution.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Molecularity of Reverse Reactions
For an elementary reversible reaction , the reverse rate law is .
Always include every chemical species that must collide to form the reactants in the reverse rate law.
- Scaling Rates upon Dilution
If volume increases by a factor of , each solute concentration scales by . A rate with overall order in solutes scales by .
Count the total number of dissolved solute particles on each side of the equation to see which rate drops more sharply upon dilution.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the elementary reverse rate law including both reacting ions: .
Apply the -fold dilution factor: and .
Calculate the new instantaneous reverse rate: .
Compare rates: because the forward rate decreased by only while the reverse rate decreased by , , driving a net forward shift toward higher percent ionization.
Dilution decreases , , and by a factor of . Because the forward rate is proportional to , it decreases by a factor of . However, because the reverse rate is proportional to , it decreases by a factor of . Immediately after dilution, , shifting the dynamic equilibrium forward to produce a higher percent ionization.
Lock it in
What is the defining formula for the percent ionization of a weak monoprotic acid ?
. It represents the ratio of ionized acid to the initial total acid concentration.
Similar question
A solution of formic acid () has a hydronium ion concentration of . Calculate the percent ionization of formic acid in this solution.
Answer
. Use .
Hypochlorous acid () has . (a) Calculate the percent ionization in a solution. (b) Calculate the percent ionization in a solution.
Answer
(a) , (b) . For : ; . For : ; . Dilution increases percent ionization by a factor of 10.
A weak base has . Explain using the reaction quotient why diluting a solution by adding water causes an increase in percent ionization.
Answer
, driving a forward shift. For , the quotient is . Diluting by a factor of multiplies the numerator by and the denominator by , so . To restore equilibrium, the reaction shifts right, ionizing a higher fraction of the base.