Resources

A batch condensation reaction synthesizes benzylideneacetone (C10H10O\text{C}_{10}\text{H}_{10}\text{O}, molar mass 146.19 g/mol146.19\text{ g/mol}) by reacting benzaldehyde (C7H6O\text{C}_7\text{H}_6\text{O}, molar mass 106.12 g/mol106.12\text{ g/mol}) with acetone (C3H6O\text{C}_3\text{H}_6\text{O}, molar mass 58.08 g/mol58.08\text{ g/mol}) using an aqueous sodium hydroxide catalyst: C7H6O+C3H6O→C10H10O+H2O\text{C}_7\text{H}_6\text{O} + \text{C}_3\text{H}_6\text{O} \rightarrow \text{C}_{10}\text{H}_{10}\text{O} + \text{H}_2\text{O}. A chemist mixes 53.06 g53.06\text{ g} of benzaldehyde with an excess of 58.08 g58.08\text{ g} of acetone in 150.00 g150.00\text{ g} of water containing 2.00 g2.00\text{ g} of dissolved NaOH\text{NaOH}. The reaction achieves an 82.00%82.00\% isolated yield of pure benzylideneacetone. Couple stoichiometric limiting reactant principles with green chemistry metrics to calculate: (a) the isolated mass of benzylideneacetone in grams, and (b) the overall Process Mass Intensity (PMI\text{PMI}) of the operation, including all initial reactants, excess reagents, catalyst, and water solvent.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Isolated mass=59.94 g\text{Isolated mass} = 59.94\text{ g}; (b) PMI=4.39\text{PMI} = 4.39

Steps

01

Identify the Limiting Reactant

Write the balanced chemical equation for the aldol condensation:

CX7HX6O+CX3HX6O→CX10HX10O+HX2O\ce{C7H6O + C3H6O -> C10H10O + H2O}

The reaction has a 1:11:1 stoichiometric molar ratio between benzaldehyde (CX7HX6O\ce{C7H6O}) and acetone (CX3HX6O\ce{C3H6O}).

Calculate the initial moles of each reactant:

nbenzaldehyde=53.06 g106.12 g/mol=0.5000 moln_{\text{benzaldehyde}} = \frac{53.06\text{ g}}{106.12\text{ g/mol}} = 0.5000\text{ mol}

nacetone=58.08 g58.08 g/mol=1.000 moln_{\text{acetone}} = \frac{58.08\text{ g}}{58.08\text{ g/mol}} = 1.000\text{ mol}

Since 0.5000 mol<1.000 mol0.5000\text{ mol} < 1.000\text{ mol}, benzaldehyde is the limiting reactant, and acetone is in excess.


02

Calculate the Theoretical and Isolated Mass of Product

From the 1:11:1 stoichiometry, 0.5000 mol0.5000\text{ mol} of benzaldehyde theoretically produces 0.5000 mol0.5000\text{ mol} of benzylideneacetone (CX10HX10O\ce{C10H10O}).

Compute the theoretical yield in grams:

mtheoretical=0.5000 mol×146.19 g/mol=73.095 gm_{\text{theoretical}} = 0.5000\text{ mol} \times 146.19\text{ g/mol} = 73.095\text{ g}

With an isolated yield of 82.00%82.00\%, calculate the actual isolated mass:

misolated=73.095 g×0.8200=59.9379 g≈59.94 gm_{\text{isolated}} = 73.095\text{ g} \times 0.8200 = 59.9379\text{ g} \approx 59.94\text{ g}


03

Determine the Total Mass of All Inputs

Process Mass Intensity (PMI\text{PMI}) accounts for every chemical introduced into the system, including reactants, excess reagents, catalysts, and solvents:

mtotal, input=mbenzaldehyde+macetone+mwater+mNaOHm_{\text{total, input}} = m_{\text{benzaldehyde}} + m_{\text{acetone}} + m_{\text{water}} + m_{\ce{NaOH}}

mtotal, input=53.06 g+58.08 g+150.00 g+2.00 g=263.14 gm_{\text{total, input}} = 53.06\text{ g} + 58.08\text{ g} + 150.00\text{ g} + 2.00\text{ g} = 263.14\text{ g}


04

Calculate the Process Mass Intensity (PMI\text{PMI})

The green chemistry metric Process Mass Intensity (PMI\text{PMI}) is defined as:

PMI=Total mass of input materialsMass of isolated product\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total mass of input materials}}{\text{Mass of isolated product}}

Substitute the values:

PMI=263.14 g59.9379 g≈4.39\text{PMI} = \frac{263.14\text{ g}}{59.9379\text{ g}} \approx 4.39

Common Pitfall: Unlike Atom Economy or E-factor, PMI\text{PMI} includes all inputs in the numerator (reactants, excess reagents, solvent, and catalyst) and divides directly by the mass of the final isolated pure product, not the theoretical product mass or total reaction mixture mass.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates PMI using the theoretical yield instead of the isolated product mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    n(benzaldehyde)=53.06/106.12=0.5000 mol  ⟹  n(acetone)=58.08/58.08=1.000 mol  ⟹  Benzaldehyde is limitingn(\text{benzaldehyde}) = 53.06 / 106.12 = 0.5000\text{ mol} \implies n(\text{acetone}) = 58.08 / 58.08 = 1.000\text{ mol} \implies \text{Benzaldehyde is limiting}

  2. Step 2

    Theoretical yield=0.5000×146.19=73.10 g  ⟹  Isolated mass=73.10×0.8200=59.94 g\text{Theoretical yield} = 0.5000 \times 146.19 = 73.10\text{ g} \implies \text{Isolated mass} = 73.10 \times 0.8200 = 59.94\text{ g}

  3. Step 3

    Total input mass=53.06+58.08+150.00+2.00=263.14 g\text{Total input mass} = 53.06 + 58.08 + 150.00 + 2.00 = 263.14\text{ g}

  4. Step 4

    PMI=Total input massTheoretical product mass=263.1473.10=3.60\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total input mass}}{\text{Theoretical product mass}} = \frac{263.14}{73.10} = 3.60

    Correct

    PMI=Total mass of all inputsMass of isolated product=263.14 g59.94 g≈4.39\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total mass of all inputs}}{\text{Mass of isolated product}} = \frac{263.14\text{ g}}{59.94\text{ g}} \approx 4.39

    Process Mass Intensity measures the total mass of materials required to produce a unit mass of real, isolated product. The denominator must be the actual isolated mass (59.94 g59.94\text{ g}), not the theoretical maximum yield (73.10 g73.10\text{ g}).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the moles of each reactant and deduced that benzaldehyde is limiting.

You found the correct theoretical and isolated product masses.

You accounted for all input materials (reactants, excess reagents, catalyst, and solvent) when finding the total input mass.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Green Chemistry Metric Formula Misapplication

Using theoretical yield instead of actual isolated product mass in the denominator of Process Mass Intensity (PMI).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating theoretical yield metrics (such as Atom Economy, which is purely based on stoichiometric theory) with real-world operational waste metrics (such as PMI and E-factor, which evaluate actual mass consumed per mass of pure product collected).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
PMI Definition
  • PMI=∑minputsmisolated product\text{PMI} = \frac{\sum m_{\text{inputs}}}{m_{\text{isolated product}}}

  • Always place the actual, weighed mass of isolated product in the denominator, never the theoretical yield.

Theoretical vs. Real Metrics
  • Atom economy evaluates idealized stoichiometry; PMI and E-factor evaluate real process performance including incomplete conversion, losses, solvents, and catalysts.

  • Before calculating, confirm whether the metric describes theoretical efficiency or operational material consumption.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall the definition of Process Mass Intensity: PMI=Total mass of all input materialsMass of isolated product\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total mass of all input materials}}{\text{Mass of isolated product}}.

  2. Substitute the total input mass (263.14 g263.14\text{ g}) and the isolated mass calculated in part (a) (59.94 g59.94\text{ g}): PMI=263.14 g59.94 g\text{PMI} = \frac{263.14\text{ g}}{59.94\text{ g}}.

  3. Evaluate the quotient: PMI≈4.39\text{PMI} \approx 4.39.

Final answer

(a) Isolated mass=59.94 g\text{Isolated mass} = 59.94\text{ g}; (b) PMI=4.39\text{PMI} = 4.39

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definitions of PMI, E-factor, and Atom Economy to ensure you know which metrics use theoretical quantities versus isolated product quantities.

  • Practice calculating PMI from raw lab mass balances where yields are below 100%100\%.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student omits the solvent water and catalyst from the total input mass calculation for PMI.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    n(benzaldehyde)=53.06106.12=0.5000 mol  ⟹  n(acetone)=58.0858.08=1.000 moln(\text{benzaldehyde}) = \frac{53.06}{106.12} = 0.5000\text{ mol} \implies n(\text{acetone}) = \frac{58.08}{58.08} = 1.000\text{ mol}

  2. Step 2

    Theoretical yield=0.5000×146.19=73.10 g  ⟹  Isolated mass=73.10×0.8200=59.94 g\text{Theoretical yield} = 0.5000 \times 146.19 = 73.10\text{ g} \implies \text{Isolated mass} = 73.10 \times 0.8200 = 59.94\text{ g}

  3. Step 3

    Total mass=53.06+58.08=111.14 g\text{Total mass} = 53.06 + 58.08 = 111.14\text{ g}

    Correct

    mtotal, input=53.06+58.08+150.00+2.00=263.14 gm_{\text{total, input}} = 53.06 + 58.08 + 150.00 + 2.00 = 263.14\text{ g}

    You only summed the masses of benzaldehyde and acetone. Process Mass Intensity (PMI) requires the total mass of every substance entering the process, which includes the 150.00 g150.00\text{ g} of water and the 2.00 g2.00\text{ g} of NaOH\text{NaOH} catalyst.

  4. Step 4

    PMI=111.1459.94=1.85\text{PMI} = \frac{111.14}{59.94} = 1.85

    Correct

    PMI=263.14 g59.94 g≈4.39\text{PMI} = \frac{263.14\text{ g}}{59.94\text{ g}} \approx 4.39

    Your formula structure for PMI was set up properly as input mass divided by isolated product mass, but the final numerical value was affected by omitting water and catalyst from the numerator.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the molar amounts of both reactants to deduce the limiting reagent.

You accurately calculated both the theoretical yield and the isolated product mass using the given percent yield.

You correctly set up the mathematical ratio of input mass to isolated product mass for the PMI definition.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Solvent and Catalyst in Process Mass Intensity

You summed only the stoichiometric organic reactants and left out the reaction solvent and dissolved catalyst.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating Process Mass Intensity (PMI) with reaction-mass metrics (such as complete E-factor or simple stoichiometric input). In green chemistry metrics, PMI measures the total mass footprint of the entire chemical process, mandating the inclusion of all solvents, reagents, catalysts, and workup materials.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Full Input Accounting
  • PMI=∑mall inputsMass of isolated product\text{PMI} = \frac{\sum m_{\text{all inputs}}}{\text{Mass of isolated product}}

  • Whenever calculating PMI, audit every single item listed in the procedure—reactants, excess reagents, solvents, acids/bases, and catalysts—and sum them all into the numerator.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. mtotal, input=mbenzaldehyde+macetone+mwater+mNaOH=53.06 g+58.08 g+150.00 g+2.00 g=263.14 gm_{\text{total, input}} = m_{\text{benzaldehyde}} + m_{\text{acetone}} + m_{\text{water}} + m_{\text{NaOH}} = 53.06\text{ g} + 58.08\text{ g} + 150.00\text{ g} + 2.00\text{ g} = 263.14\text{ g}

  2. PMI=263.14 g59.94 g≈4.39\text{PMI} = \frac{263.14\text{ g}}{59.94\text{ g}} \approx 4.39

Final answer

(a) Isolated mass=59.94 g\text{Isolated mass} = 59.94\text{ g}; (b) PMI=4.39\text{PMI} = 4.39

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the green chemistry definition of Process Mass Intensity (PMI) to ensure you always include solvents and catalysts in the numerator.

  • Practice auditing reaction recipe tables by checking off every mass component before computing mass-intensity ratios.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misidentifies acetone as the limiting reactant because its molar mass is smaller, leading to an incorrect product mass and PMI.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    n(benzaldehyde)=53.06/106.12=0.5000 mol  ⟹  n(acetone)=58.08/58.08=1.000 moln(\text{benzaldehyde}) = 53.06 / 106.12 = 0.5000\text{ mol} \implies n(\text{acetone}) = 58.08 / 58.08 = 1.000\text{ mol}

  2. Step 2

    Acetone is limiting: theoretical yield \text{Acetone is limiting: theoretical yield } = 1.000 ×\times 146.19 = 146.19 g\text{ g}   ⟹  \implies Isolated mass\text{Isolated mass} = 146.19 ×\times 0.8200 = 119.88 g\text{ g}

    Correct

    Benzaldehyde is limiting \text{Benzaldehyde is limiting } (0.5000 mol\text{ mol} < 1.000 mol\text{ mol}): theoretical yield\text{theoretical yield} = 0.5000 mol\text{ mol} ×\times 146.19 g/mol\text{ g/mol} = 73.095 g\text{ g}   ⟹  \implies m_{isolated\text{isolated}} = 73.095 g\text{ g} ×\times 0.8200 = 59.94 g\text{ g}_

    Because the balanced equation shows a 1:11:1 stoichiometric ratio, the reactant with fewer moles (0.5000 mol0.5000\text{ mol} of benzaldehyde versus 1.000 mol1.000\text{ mol} of acetone) is limiting. You selected acetone as limiting, which doubled the theoretical yield.

  3. Step 3

    Total input mass\text{Total input mass} = 53.06 + 58.08 + 150.00 + 2.00 = 263.14 g\text{ g}

  4. Step 4

    PMI\text{PMI} = 263.14 / 119.88 = 2.20

    Correct

    PMI=263.14 g59.9379 g≈4.39\text{PMI} = \frac{263.14\text{ g}}{59.9379\text{ g}} \approx 4.39

    Your formula setup for PMI as total input massisolated product mass\frac{\text{total input mass}}{\text{isolated product mass}} was completely correct, but the numerical result was affected by the incorrect isolated product mass from Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the initial moles of both benzaldehyde and acetone.

You correctly identified all process inputs, including solvent and catalyst, for the total input mass.

You correctly applied the formula for Process Mass Intensity (PMI).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Limiting Reactant Misidentification

You selected the reactant with the larger mole quantity (1.000 mol1.000\text{ mol} of acetone vs. 0.5000 mol0.5000\text{ mol} of benzaldehyde) as the limiting reactant.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating reactant molar quantities or selecting the reactant present in excess as limiting, possibly influenced by acetone having the smaller molar mass or by rushing through the comparison 0.5000 mol<1.000 mol0.5000\text{ mol} < 1.000\text{ mol}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Compare Moles to Stoichiometric Coefficients
  • For a 1:11:1 reaction, the limiting reagent is always the reactant with the strictly smaller molar amount: nAa<nBb\frac{n_A}{a} < \frac{n_B}{b}.

  • Always write an explicit comparison inequality (e.g., 0.5000 mol<1.000 mol0.5000\text{ mol} < 1.000\text{ mol}) before designating the limiting reactant.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare moles: 0.5000 mol benzaldehyde<1.000 mol acetone0.5000\text{ mol benzaldehyde} < 1.000\text{ mol acetone}, so benzaldehyde is limiting.

  2. Calculate theoretical yield: mtheoretical=0.5000 mol×146.19 g/mol=73.095 gm_{\text{theoretical}} = 0.5000\text{ mol} \times 146.19\text{ g/mol} = 73.095\text{ g}.

  3. Calculate isolated product mass: misolated=73.095 g×0.8200=59.94 gm_{\text{isolated}} = 73.095\text{ g} \times 0.8200 = 59.94\text{ g}.

  4. Calculate PMI using the corrected product mass: PMI=263.14 g59.9379 g=4.39\text{PMI} = \frac{263.14\text{ g}}{59.9379\text{ g}} = 4.39.

Final answer

(a) Isolated mass=59.94 g\text{Isolated mass} = 59.94\text{ g}; (b) PMI=4.39\text{PMI} = 4.39

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before calculating theoretical yield, explicitly circle the smaller molar value and write 'limiting' next to it.

  • Verify that the problem statement mentions 'excess of acetone' as a contextual cross-check.

  • Re-evaluate downstream metrics like PMI whenever theoretical or isolated product mass changes.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A chemist carries out an esterification using 60.0 g60.0\text{ g} of acetic acid, 46.0 g46.0\text{ g} of ethanol, 2.0 g2.0\text{ g} of sulfuric acid catalyst, and 100.0 g100.0\text{ g} of toluene solvent. The reaction produces 70.4 g70.4\text{ g} of isolated ethyl acetate (theoretical yield is 88.0 g88.0\text{ g}). Calculate the Process Mass Intensity (PMI) of the process.

Answer

Total input mass =60.0+46.0+2.0+100.0=208.0 g= 60.0 + 46.0 + 2.0 + 100.0 = 208.0\text{ g}. PMI=Total input massIsolated product mass=208.0 g70.4 g≈2.95\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total input mass}}{\text{Isolated product mass}} = \frac{208.0\text{ g}}{70.4\text{ g}} \approx 2.95.

02

In a pharmaceutical peptide coupling, 12.50 g12.50\text{ g} of amine and 18.00 g18.00\text{ g} of activated acid react in 250.0 g250.0\text{ g} of dichloromethane using 8.50 g8.50\text{ g} of coupling agent. The theoretical yield of peptide is 24.00 g24.00\text{ g}, but due to purification losses, the isolated yield is 75.0%75.0\%. Calculate: (a) the isolated mass of product, and (b) the PMI.

Answer

(a) Isolated mass=24.00 g×0.750=18.00 g\text{Isolated mass} = 24.00\text{ g} \times 0.750 = 18.00\text{ g}. (b) Total input mass =12.50+18.00+250.0+8.50=289.0 g= 12.50 + 18.00 + 250.0 + 8.50 = 289.0\text{ g}. PMI=289.0 g18.00 g≈16.06\text{PMI} = \frac{289.0\text{ g}}{18.00\text{ g}} \approx 16.06.

03

A synthesis has a total input mass of 850 g850\text{ g} and an environmental factor (E-factorE\text{-factor}) of 7.57.5. Using the relationship PMI=E-factor+1\text{PMI} = E\text{-factor} + 1, determine: (a) the PMI, and (b) the actual mass of isolated product obtained.

Answer

(a) PMI=E-factor+1=7.5+1=8.5\text{PMI} = E\text{-factor} + 1 = 7.5 + 1 = 8.5. (b) Since PMI=minputsmproduct\text{PMI} = \frac{m_{\text{inputs}}}{m_{\text{product}}}, we have mproduct=850 g8.5=100 gm_{\text{product}} = \frac{850\text{ g}}{8.5} = 100\text{ g}.

Loading workspace…