Resources
A neutral titanium atom () and a neutral carbon atom () each have exactly electrons in their highest-energy open subshell in the ground state ( and , respectively). First, use Hund's rule and the Pauli exclusion principle to determine the magnetic character (paramagnetic or diamagnetic) and the number of unpaired electrons for both neutral atoms. Second, determine the magnetic character and number of unpaired electrons when titanium is oxidized to and carbon is ionized to the gas-phase cation .
Answer and steps
Final answer
For neutral (), Hund's rule yields unpaired electrons in the subshell (paramagnetic). For neutral (), Hund's rule yields unpaired electrons in the subshell (paramagnetic). When oxidized to , ionization removes the valence electrons, leaving the configuration , which still contains unpaired electrons and remains paramagnetic. When ionized to , ionization removes the two electrons, yielding , which has unpaired electrons and is diamagnetic.
Steps
Part 1: Neutral Atoms ( and )
-
Carbon (, ):
- Electron Configuration: The ground-state configuration is .
- Orbital Filling: The inner and subshells are fully occupied by spin-paired electrons (). The subshell contains degenerate orbitals ().
- Applying Hund's Rule and Pauli Exclusion: Hund's rule states that electrons singly occupy each degenerate orbital with parallel spins before pairing occurs. Therefore, the electrons occupy two separate orbitals:
- Result: Neutral has unpaired electrons and is paramagnetic.
-
Titanium (, ):
- Electron Configuration: The ground-state configuration is (or ).
- Orbital Filling: The subshell is fully filled (). The subshell has degenerate orbitals.
- Applying Hund's Rule and Pauli Exclusion: The electrons in the subshell occupy two separate degenerate orbitals with parallel spins:
- Result: Neutral has unpaired electrons and is paramagnetic.
Part 2: Cations ( and )
-
Ionization of Titanium to :
- Order of Electron Removal: When transition metals form cations, electrons are removed first from the outermost principal energy level () before the subshell. Therefore, ionization removes the two valence electrons, not the electrons.
- Cation Configuration:
- Magnetic Character: The subshell remains untouched with unpaired electrons. Thus, has unpaired electrons and remains paramagnetic.
-
Ionization of Carbon to :
- Order of Electron Removal: For main-group elements, electrons are removed from the highest-energy subshell (). Removing two electrons empties the subshell entirely.
- Cation Configuration:
- Magnetic Character: Both and subshells are completely filled with paired electrons, leaving no unpaired electrons. Thus, has unpaired electrons and is diamagnetic.
Typical errors
01 A student removes electrons from the 3d subshell instead of the 4s subshell when ionizing titanium, concluding Ti²⁺ has 0 unpaired electrons and is diamagnetic.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
^{2+} 2 3d [],4s^2 3d^0 4s: 0
Correct^{2+} 2 4s [],3d^2 2
When first-row transition metals form cations, electrons are removed first from the valence shell with the highest principal quantum number (, ) rather than the () subshell.
- Step 4
^{2+} 2 2p: 1s^2 2s^2 0
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly wrote the ground-state electron configurations for both neutral atoms.
You correctly applied Hund's rule and the Pauli exclusion principle to find the unpaired electrons and magnetic character of neutral and .
You correctly identified that ionizing to removes the two valence electrons, leaving a diamagnetic core.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou assumed electrons leave subshells in the strict reverse order of the Aufbau filling sequence ( before ).
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating the Aufbau filling order (where fills before in neutral atoms) with the ionization order. In transition metals, the outermost valence electrons (, the subshell) are at a greater average distance from the nucleus and are removed first upon ionization.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- First-In, First-Out for $4s$ in Transition Metals
For neutral atoms, fills before , but upon ionization, electrons are always removed before electrons.
When writing the configuration of a transition metal cation, remove electrons from the outermost orbital first until it is completely empty.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecognize that titanium has the neutral configuration .
To form , remove the two electrons from the highest principal quantum number shell (), yielding .
Distribute the remaining two electrons into separate orbitals with parallel spins according to Hund's rule: .
Conclude that has unpaired electrons and is paramagnetic.
has unpaired electrons and is paramagnetic.
02 A student violates Hund's rule by pairing the two valence electrons in a single orbital for both neutral atoms, concluding both have 0 unpaired electrons and are diamagnetic.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
According to Hund's rule, electrons must occupy degenerate orbitals singly with parallel spins before any pairing occurs. In the subshell, the two electrons go into separate orbitals, giving unpaired electrons and making neutral paramagnetic.
- Step 2Correct
The three orbitals are degenerate. By Hund's rule, the two electrons occupy two different orbitals with parallel spins, resulting in unpaired electrons and making neutral paramagnetic.
- Step 3Correct
You correctly removed the electrons first to form . However, the remaining two electrons still occupy separate degenerate orbitals by Hund's rule, so has unpaired electrons and remains paramagnetic.
- Step 4
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou wrote the correct ground-state electron configurations for both neutral and neutral .
You correctly recognized that transition metals lose their valence electrons before electrons upon ionization.
You correctly determined the configuration and diamagnetic character of .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou applied the Pauli exclusion principle (which allows up to two electrons of opposite spin per orbital) as a requirement to fill an orbital before moving to the next, overlooking Hund's rule, which mandates that degenerate orbitals must each be occupied by one electron with parallel spins before any orbital is doubly occupied.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Hund's Rule for Degenerate Orbitals
Every orbital in a subshell is singly occupied with one electron before any one orbital is doubly occupied, and all electrons in singly occupied orbitals have parallel spins.
When populating degenerate sets of orbitals (, , or ), draw out individual orbital boxes or dashes and place one spin-up arrow in each before adding any spin-down pairing arrows.
- Determining Magnetic Character
A species with at least one unpaired electron is paramagnetic; a species with only paired electrons (zero unpaired electrons) is diamagnetic.
Count the total number of single electrons across all unfilled subshells; if the count is greater than zero, label the species paramagnetic.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationApply Hund's rule to the configuration of neutral : place one electron in each of two separate orbitals (). This yields unpaired electrons, so is paramagnetic.
Apply Hund's rule to the configuration of neutral : place one electron in each of two separate orbitals (). This yields unpaired electrons, so is paramagnetic.
Ionize to by removing the two electrons, leaving . The two electrons remain in separate degenerate orbitals, giving unpaired electrons (paramagnetic).
Ionize to by removing the two electrons, leaving . All electrons are paired, giving unpaired electrons (diamagnetic).
Neutral : unpaired electrons, paramagnetic; Neutral : unpaired electrons, paramagnetic; : unpaired electrons, paramagnetic; : unpaired electrons, diamagnetic.
Lock it in
When a first-row transition metal atom forms a positive ion, from which subshell are electrons removed first?
Electrons are removed first from the outermost subshell () before any electrons are removed from the subshell ().
Similar question
Determine the ground-state electron configuration, number of unpaired electrons, and magnetic character (paramagnetic or diamagnetic) for the iron(II) cation, ().
Answer
Neutral iron is . Ionization removes the two electrons first, giving . By Hund's rule, the five orbitals contain one paired set and four singly occupied orbitals (). Thus, has unpaired electrons and is paramagnetic.
An unknown divalent transition metal ion is diamagnetic and has an argon noble-gas core plus a fully occupied subshell. Identify the neutral metal , write the electron configurations for both and , and explain why has zero unpaired electrons.
Answer
The cation configuration is , which has all electrons paired ( unpaired electrons, diamagnetic). Since two electrons were removed from the subshell to form , the neutral atom has the configuration , which is zinc (, ).
Consider the neutral chromium atom (, ) with anomalous ground-state configuration . Determine the electron configuration, orbital diagram for valence electrons, and magnetic character for: (a) neutral , and (b) the chromic ion, .
Answer
(a) Neutral is . It has electron in and singly occupied orbitals, totaling unpaired electrons (paramagnetic). (b) Ionizing to removes three electrons: the single electron first, followed by two electrons. This leaves . The three electrons singly occupy separate orbitals with parallel spins, giving unpaired electrons (paramagnetic).