Resources

A sample of gas undergoes a two-step thermodynamic cycle. In the first step, the gas expands against a constant external pressure of Pext=1.20 atmP_{\text{ext}} = 1.20\text{ atm} from an unknown initial volume ViV_i to a final volume of 5.00 L5.00\text{ L}, absorbing 650 J650\text{ J} of heat. Because internal energy UU is a state function, a chemist notes that after returning the system to its initial state via a second step where q2=−420 Jq_2 = -420\text{ J} and w2=+185 Jw_2 = +185\text{ J}, the net cyclic change ΔUcycle\Delta U_{\text{cycle}} must equal zero. Reverse-engineer the initial state to determine the initial volume ViV_i (in L\text{L}) before the expansion. (1 L⋅atm=101.325 J1\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = 101.325\text{ J})

Answer and steps

Final answer

Vi=1.58 LV_i = 1.58\text{ L}

Steps

01

Use the First Law of Thermodynamics for Step 2

Internal energy UU is a state function, meaning the total change in internal energy over any complete cycle must be zero:

ΔUcycle=ΔU1+ΔU2=0\Delta U_{\text{cycle}} = \Delta U_1 + \Delta U_2 = 0

For the second step, using the First Law of Thermodynamics (ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w):

ΔU2=q2+w2=−420 J+185 J=−235 J\Delta U_2 = q_2 + w_2 = -420\text{ J} + 185\text{ J} = -235\text{ J}


02

Determine the Internal Energy and Work for Step 1

Because the cycle returns to the initial state, the change in internal energy during the first step must balance the second step:

ΔU1=−ΔU2=−(−235 J)=+235 J\Delta U_1 = -\Delta U_2 = -(-235\text{ J}) = +235\text{ J}

Now apply the First Law to Step 1 to solve for the expansion work w1w_1:

ΔU1=q1+w1\Delta U_1 = q_1 + w_1

235 J=650 J+w1235\text{ J} = 650\text{ J} + w_1

w1=235 J−650 J=−415 Jw_1 = 235\text{ J} - 650\text{ J} = -415\text{ J}

(Pitfall note: Be careful with the sign convention. Expansion work performed by the gas on the surroundings is negative: w=−PextΔVw = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V.)


03

Solve for the Initial Volume ViV_i

The work done during an expansion against a constant external pressure is given by:

w1=−Pext(Vf−Vi)w_1 = -P_{\text{ext}}(V_f - V_i)

Substitute the known values into the equation, applying the conversion factor 1 L⋅atm=101.325 J1\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = 101.325\text{ J}:

−415 J=−(1.20 atm)(5.00 L−Vi)(101.325 J⋅L−1⋅atm−1)-415\text{ J} = -(1.20\text{ atm})(5.00\text{ L} - V_i)\left(101.325\text{ J}\cdot\text{L}^{-1}\cdot\text{atm}^{-1}\right)

415 J=121.59 J⋅L−1⋅(5.00 L−Vi)415\text{ J} = 121.59\text{ J}\cdot\text{L}^{-1} \cdot (5.00\text{ L} - V_i)

ΔV=5.00 L−Vi=415121.59 L≈3.42 L\Delta V = 5.00\text{ L} - V_i = \frac{415}{121.59}\text{ L} \approx 3.42\text{ L}

Vi=5.00 L−3.42 L=1.58 LV_i = 5.00\text{ L} - 3.42\text{ L} = 1.58\text{ L}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets the negative sign in the expansion work formula, writing w = P_ext * ΔV instead of w = -P_ext * ΔV.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔU2=q2+w2=−420 J+185 J=−235 J  ⟹  ΔU1=−ΔU2=235 J\Delta U_2 = q_2 + w_2 = -420\text{ J} + 185\text{ J} = -235\text{ J} \implies \Delta U_1 = -\Delta U_2 = 235\text{ J}

  2. Step 2

    w1=ΔU1−q1=235 J−650 J=−415 J  ⟹  w1=−415 J101.325=−4.096 L⋅atmw_1 = \Delta U_1 - q_1 = 235\text{ J} - 650\text{ J} = -415\text{ J} \implies w_1 = \frac{-415\text{ J}}{101.325} = -4.096\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}

  3. Step 3

    w1=Pext∗(Vf−Vi)  ⟹  −4.096=1.20∗(5.00−Vi)  ⟹  5.00−Vi=−3.41 Lw_1 = P_{\text{ext}} * (V_f - V_i) \implies -4.096 = 1.20 * (5.00 - V_i) \implies 5.00 - V_i = -3.41\text{ L}

    Correct

    w1=−Pext(Vf−Vi)  ⟹  −4.096=−1.20(5.00−Vi)  ⟹  5.00−Vi=3.41 Lw_1 = -P_{\text{ext}}(V_f - V_i) \implies -4.096 = -1.20(5.00 - V_i) \implies 5.00 - V_i = 3.41\text{ L}

    You used w=PextΔVw = P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V instead of the correct thermodynamic formula w=−PextΔVw = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V. Because expansion work is done by the system on the surroundings, the work must be negative relative to an increase in volume.

  4. Step 4

    Vi=5.00+3.41=8.41 LV_i = 5.00 + 3.41 = 8.41\text{ L}

    Correct

    Vi=5.00−3.41=1.58 LV_i = 5.00 - 3.41 = 1.58\text{ L}

    Your final calculation followed from the sign error in the previous step. An initial volume of 8.41 L8.41\text{ L} expanding to 5.00 L5.00\text{ L} would represent a compression, which contradicts the problem statement.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the cyclic condition ΔUcycle=0\Delta U_{\text{cycle}} = 0 to relate ΔU1\Delta U_1 and ΔU2\Delta U_2.

You correctly applied the First Law of Thermodynamics ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w to find the expansion work in Joules.

You performed the unit conversion between J\text{J} and L⋅atm\text{L}\cdot\text{atm} accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign Error in Pressure-Volume Work Formula

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You forgot the standard IUPAC negative sign in the pressure-volume work expression (w=−PextΔVw = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V) and did not perform a physical reality check on whether Vi<VfV_i < V_f for an expansion.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Thermodynamic Work Convention
  • In chemistry, w=−PextΔVw = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V. When a gas expands (ΔV>0\Delta V > 0), work is done by the system on the surroundings, so w<0w < 0.

  • Always write w=−PextΔVw = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V with the explicit leading negative sign before substituting values.

Physical Sanity Check for Volume Changes
  • For an expansion process, the volume must increase, requiring Vf>ViV_f > V_i (or Vi<VfV_i < V_f).

  • Compare your calculated initial volume to the final volume: if the problem states 'expansion' and your Vi>VfV_i > V_f, immediately check for a lost negative sign.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the standard formula for work against constant external pressure: w1=−Pext(Vf−Vi)w_1 = -P_{\text{ext}}(V_f - V_i)

  2. Substitute the known values: −4.096 L⋅atm=−(1.20 atm)(5.00 L−Vi)-4.096\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = -(1.20\text{ atm})(5.00\text{ L} - V_i)

  3. Divide both sides by −1.20 atm-1.20\text{ atm}: 5.00 L−Vi=−4.096−1.20=+3.413 L5.00\text{ L} - V_i = \frac{-4.096}{-1.20} = +3.413\text{ L}

  4. Solve for ViV_i: Vi=5.00 L−3.413 L=1.587 L≈1.58 LV_i = 5.00\text{ L} - 3.413\text{ L} = 1.587\text{ L} \approx 1.58\text{ L}

Final answer

Vi=1.58 LV_i = 1.58\text{ L}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the IUPAC sign conventions for heat (qq) and work (ww) relative to the system.

  • Practice setting up w=−PextΔVw = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V in single-step and cyclic thermodynamic problems.

  • Always check that an expansion results in ΔV>0\Delta V > 0 and Vi<VfV_i < V_f.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to convert work from joules to liter-atmospheres before substituting into the pressure-volume equation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔU2=−420 J+185 J=−235 J  ⟹  ΔU1=235 J  ⟹  w1=ΔU1−q1=235 J−650 J=−415 J\Delta U_2 = -420\text{ J} + 185\text{ J} = -235\text{ J} \implies \Delta U_1 = 235\text{ J} \implies w_1 = \Delta U_1 - q_1 = 235\text{ J} - 650\text{ J} = -415\text{ J}

  2. Step 2

    w1=−Pext⋅(Vf−Vi)  ⟹  −415=−1.20⋅(5.00−Vi)w_1 = -P_{\text{ext}} \cdot (V_f - V_i) \implies -415 = -1.20 \cdot (5.00 - V_i)

    Correct

    w1=−Pext(Vf−Vi)⋅101.325 J/(L⋅atm)  ⟹  −415 J=−(1.20 atm)(5.00 L−Vi)(101.325 J⋅L−1⋅atm−1)w_1 = -P_{\text{ext}}(V_f - V_i) \cdot 101.325\text{ J}/(\text{L}\cdot\text{atm}) \implies -415\text{ J} = -(1.20\text{ atm})(5.00\text{ L} - V_i)(101.325\text{ J}\cdot\text{L}^{-1}\cdot\text{atm}^{-1})

    You equated work in joules (−415 J-415\text{ J}) directly to −PextΔV-P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V where PextP_{\text{ext}} is in atmospheres and volume is in liters. Because 1 L⋅atm=101.325 J1\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = 101.325\text{ J}, you must convert the units so that both sides match.

  3. Step 3

    5.00−Vi=345.83 L  ⟹  Vi=5.00−345.83=−340.83 L5.00 - V_i = 345.83\text{ L} \implies V_i = 5.00 - 345.83 = -340.83\text{ L}

    Correct

    5.00 L−Vi=415121.59 L≈3.42 L  ⟹  Vi=5.00 L−3.42 L=1.58 L5.00\text{ L} - V_i = \frac{415}{121.59}\text{ L} \approx 3.42\text{ L} \implies V_i = 5.00\text{ L} - 3.42\text{ L} = 1.58\text{ L}

    This step followed correctly from your previous equation, but the missing conversion factor resulted in an unphysical negative volume.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the internal energy change of the second step using ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w.

You recognized that ΔU1=−ΔU2\Delta U_1 = -\Delta U_2 because internal energy is a state function over a complete cycle.

You accurately isolated and calculated the work done in the first step as −415 J-415\text{ J}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Missing Unit Conversion

You omitted the conversion factor between L⋅atm\text{L}\cdot\text{atm} and J\text{J} when substituting into w=−PextΔVw = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating mechanical pressure-volume work units (L⋅atm\text{L}\cdot\text{atm}) with standard metric energy units (J\text{J}) without explicitly tracking units during algebraic substitution.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Unit Consistency Check
  • Whenever calculating w=−PextΔVw = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V with pressure in atmospheres and volume in liters, the resulting product has units of L⋅atm\text{L}\cdot\text{atm}, which must be multiplied by 101.325 J/(L⋅atm)101.325\text{ J}/(\text{L}\cdot\text{atm}) to equal energy in joules.

  • Write out physical units with every numerical quantity during substitution to catch unit mismatches before solving.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert work to liter-atmospheres or the pressure-volume product to joules: −415 J=−(1.20 atm)(5.00 L−Vi)(101.325 J⋅L−1⋅atm−1)-415\text{ J} = -(1.20\text{ atm})(5.00\text{ L} - V_i)(101.325\text{ J}\cdot\text{L}^{-1}\cdot\text{atm}^{-1}).

  2. Evaluate the right-side coefficient: −415 J=−(121.59 J/L)(5.00 L−Vi)-415\text{ J} = -(121.59\text{ J/L})(5.00\text{ L} - V_i).

  3. Divide to isolate the volume change: ΔV=5.00 L−Vi=−415−121.59 L≈3.413 L\Delta V = 5.00\text{ L} - V_i = \frac{-415}{-121.59}\text{ L} \approx 3.413\text{ L}.

  4. Solve for the initial volume: Vi=5.00 L−3.413 L=1.58 LV_i = 5.00\text{ L} - 3.413\text{ L} = 1.58\text{ L}.

Final answer

Vi=1.58 LV_i = 1.58\text{ L}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the dimensional analysis of expansion work (1 L⋅atm=101.325 J1\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = 101.325\text{ J}).

  • Perform a physical plausibility check on answers; negative volumes or negative absolute temperatures indicate an algebraic or unit conversion error.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misapplies the first law of thermodynamics as ΔU = q - w instead of ΔU = q + w when calculating w_1.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔU2=−420 J+185 J=−235 J  ⟹  ΔU1=235 J\Delta U_2 = -420\text{ J} + 185\text{ J} = -235\text{ J} \implies \Delta U_1 = 235\text{ J}

  2. Step 2

    ΔU1=q1−w1  ⟹  w1=q1−ΔU1=650 J−235 J=415 J\Delta U_1 = q_1 - w_1 \implies w_1 = q_1 - \Delta U_1 = 650\text{ J} - 235\text{ J} = 415\text{ J}

    Correct

    ΔU1=q1+w1  ⟹  w1=ΔU1−q1=235 J−650 J=−415 J\Delta U_1 = q_1 + w_1 \implies w_1 = \Delta U_1 - q_1 = 235\text{ J} - 650\text{ J} = -415\text{ J}

    In chemistry, work done on the system adds energy, so the First Law is ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w. Because the gas expands, it does work on the surroundings, which means w1w_1 must be negative (−415 J-415\text{ J}). Writing ΔU=q−w\Delta U = q - w is the physics convention where ww is work done by the system; combining that with w=−PextΔVw = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V double-counts the negative sign.

  3. Step 3

    w1=−Pext(Vf−Vi)  ⟹  415 J101.325=4.096 L⋅atm  ⟹  4.096=−1.20(5.00−Vi)  ⟹  5.00−Vi=−3.41 L  ⟹  Vi=8.41 Lw_1 = -P_{\text{ext}}(V_f - V_i) \implies \frac{415\text{ J}}{101.325} = 4.096\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} \implies 4.096 = -1.20(5.00 - V_i) \implies 5.00 - V_i = -3.41\text{ L} \implies V_i = 8.41\text{ L}

    Correct

    −415 J=−(1.20 atm)(5.00 L−Vi)(101.325 J⋅L−1⋅atm−1)  ⟹  5.00 L−Vi=3.41 L  ⟹  Vi=1.58 L-415\text{ J} = -(1.20\text{ atm})(5.00\text{ L} - V_i)(101.325\text{ J}\cdot\text{L}^{-1}\cdot\text{atm}^{-1}) \implies 5.00\text{ L} - V_i = 3.41\text{ L} \implies V_i = 1.58\text{ L}

    Your unit conversion and algebra followed your equation correctly, but because w1w_1 had the wrong sign, you arrived at an expansion starting from 8.41 L8.41\text{ L} down to 5.00 L5.00\text{ L}, which would be a compression.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that internal energy is a state function with ΔUcycle=0\Delta U_{\text{cycle}} = 0.

You calculated ΔU2=−235 J\Delta U_2 = -235\text{ J} and correctly deduced ΔU1=+235 J\Delta U_1 = +235\text{ J}.

You accurately applied the conversion factor 1 L⋅atm=101.325 J1\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = 101.325\text{ J} and handled the multi-step algebraic rearrangement.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign convention conflict in First Law of Thermodynamics

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You blended the physics form of the First Law (ΔU=q−w\Delta U = q - w, where ww is work done by the system) with the standard chemical work formula (w=−PextΔVw = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V, where ww is defined from the system's perspective). Under the IUPAC/chemistry convention, all energy inputs are positive, giving ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
First Law Sign Convention (IUPAC)
  • In chemistry, internal energy change is ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w, where w=−PextΔVw = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V.

  • Always write ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w first, and remember that expansion (Vf>ViV_f > V_i) must yield w<0w < 0 because the system loses energy doing work on the surroundings.

Physical Sanity Check on Volume
  • An expanding gas must have Vi<VfV_i < V_f.

  • If a problem states the gas expands to 5.00 L5.00\text{ L}, verify that your calculated ViV_i is strictly less than 5.00 L5.00\text{ L}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. ΔU1=q1+w1  ⟹  235 J=650 J+w1  ⟹  w1=−415 J\Delta U_1 = q_1 + w_1 \implies 235\text{ J} = 650\text{ J} + w_1 \implies w_1 = -415\text{ J}

  2. w1=−Pext(Vf−Vi)  ⟹  −415 J=−(1.20 atm)(101.325 J⋅L−1⋅atm−1)(5.00 L−Vi)w_1 = -P_{\text{ext}}(V_f - V_i) \implies -415\text{ J} = -(1.20\text{ atm})(101.325\text{ J}\cdot\text{L}^{-1}\cdot\text{atm}^{-1})(5.00\text{ L} - V_i)

  3. ΔV=5.00 L−Vi=−415 J−121.59 J⋅L−1=3.413 L\Delta V = 5.00\text{ L} - V_i = \frac{-415\text{ J}}{-121.59\text{ J}\cdot\text{L}^{-1}} = 3.413\text{ L}

  4. Vi=5.00 L−3.413 L=1.58 LV_i = 5.00\text{ L} - 3.413\text{ L} = 1.58\text{ L}

Final answer

Vi=1.58 LV_i = 1.58\text{ L}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the IUPAC convention for heat and work: energy entering the system is positive (q>0q > 0, w>0w > 0) and energy leaving is negative (q<0q < 0, w<0w < 0).

  • Whenever you solve an expansion or compression problem, pause after finding ww to verify that its sign matches the physical process (w<0w < 0 for expansion, w>0w > 0 for compression).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A gas absorbs 350 J350\text{ J} of heat while expanding against a constant external pressure of 1.50 atm1.50\text{ atm} from 2.00 L2.00\text{ L} to 4.50 L4.50\text{ L}. Calculate the change in internal energy ΔU\Delta U of the gas. (1 L⋅atm=101.325 J1\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = 101.325\text{ J})

Answer

ΔU=−30 J\Delta U = -30\text{ J}

  1. Work: w=−PextΔV=−(1.50 atm)(4.50−2.00 L)=−3.75 L⋅atmw = -P_{\text{ext}}\Delta V = -(1.50\text{ atm})(4.50 - 2.00\text{ L}) = -3.75\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}.
  2. Convert to Joules: w=−3.75×101.325 J=−380.0 Jw = -3.75 \times 101.325\text{ J} = -380.0\text{ J}.
  3. First Law: ΔU=q+w=350 J+(−380.0 J)=−30 J\Delta U = q + w = 350\text{ J} + (-380.0\text{ J}) = -30\text{ J}.
02

In a thermodynamic process, a gas is compressed from an unknown initial volume ViV_i to a final volume of 2.20 L2.20\text{ L} under a constant external pressure of 2.00 atm2.00\text{ atm}. During this compression, w=+405.3 Jw = +405.3\text{ J} of work is done on the gas. Determine ViV_i. (1 L⋅atm=101.325 J1\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = 101.325\text{ J})

Answer

Vi=4.20 LV_i = 4.20\text{ L}

  1. Convert work to L⋅atm\text{L}\cdot\text{atm}: w=+405.3 J101.325 J/(L⋅atm)=+4.00 L⋅atmw = \frac{+405.3\text{ J}}{101.325\text{ J}/(\text{L}\cdot\text{atm})} = +4.00\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm}.
  2. Use w=−Pext(Vf−Vi)w = -P_{\text{ext}}(V_f - V_i): +4.00=−2.00(2.20−Vi)+4.00 = -2.00(2.20 - V_i).
  3. Solve for ViV_i: 2.20−Vi=−2.00  ⟹  Vi=4.20 L2.20 - V_i = -2.00 \implies V_i = 4.20\text{ L} (consistent with compression).
03

A gas undergoes a cyclic process consisting of two steps. In step 1, it expands against Pext=2.50 atmP_{\text{ext}} = 2.50\text{ atm} from 1.00 L1.00\text{ L} to 3.50 L3.50\text{ L} while absorbing 800 J800\text{ J} of heat. In step 2, it returns to its initial state with w2=+350 Jw_2 = +350\text{ J}. Calculate the heat exchanged in step 2, q2q_2. (1 L⋅atm=101.325 J1\text{ L}\cdot\text{atm} = 101.325\text{ J})

Answer

q2=−517 Jq_2 = -517\text{ J}

  1. Step 1 work: w1=−(2.50 atm)(2.50 L)(101.325 J/(L⋅atm))=−633.3 Jw_1 = -(2.50\text{ atm})(2.50\text{ L})(101.325\text{ J}/(\text{L}\cdot\text{atm})) = -633.3\text{ J}.
  2. Step 1 internal energy: ΔU1=q1+w1=800−633.3=+166.7 J\Delta U_1 = q_1 + w_1 = 800 - 633.3 = +166.7\text{ J}.
  3. Cyclic state function condition: ΔU2=−ΔU1=−166.7 J\Delta U_2 = -\Delta U_1 = -166.7\text{ J}.
  4. Solve for q2q_2: q2=ΔU2−w2=−166.7 J−350 J=−516.7 J≈−517 Jq_2 = \Delta U_2 - w_2 = -166.7\text{ J} - 350\text{ J} = -516.7\text{ J} \approx -517\text{ J}.
Loading workspace…