Resources
Consider the following four pure substances at standard pressure: methane (, molar mass ), propane (, molar mass ), fluoromethane (, molar mass ), and methanol (, molar mass ). Rank these four substances in order of increasing normal boiling point, and identify the predominant intermolecular force responsible for holding the liquid phase together for each substance.
Answer and steps
Final answer
; Predominant intermolecular forces: : London dispersion forces; : London dispersion forces; : Dipole-dipole interactions; : Hydrogen bonding.
Steps
Identify Molecular Polarity and Predominant Intermolecular Forces
The normal boiling point of a molecular liquid depends primarily on the strength and type of its intermolecular forces (IMFs). To determine these forces, we analyze the structure and polarity of each molecule:
-
Methane ():
- Structure: Tetrahedral geometry with symmetric bonds.
- Polarity: Nonpolar (dipole moments cancel completely).
- Predominant IMF: London dispersion forces.
-
Propane ():
- Structure: Hydrocarbon chain with roughly nonpolar and bonds.
- Polarity: Nonpolar.
- Predominant IMF: London dispersion forces.
-
Fluoromethane ():
- Structure: Tetrahedral geometry with a highly electronegative fluorine atom bonded to carbon.
- Polarity: Polar (permanent dipole moment directed toward the atom; however, fluorine cannot form hydrogen bonds here because it is bonded to carbon, not directly to hydrogen).
- Predominant IMF: Dipole-dipole interactions (in addition to London dispersion forces).
-
Methanol ():
- Structure: Contains a polar hydroxyl () group where hydrogen is directly bonded to an oxygen atom.
- Polarity: Highly polar.
- Predominant IMF: Hydrogen bonding (a particularly strong type of dipole-dipole attraction, along with dispersion forces).
Compare the Relative Strengths of the Intermolecular Forces
-
Comparing Nonpolar Substances ( vs. ):
- Both molecules exhibit only London dispersion forces.
- The strength of dispersion forces increases with greater polarizability, which correlates with higher molecular mass and a larger electron cloud.
- Propane has a significantly larger electron cloud and molar mass () than methane (). Consequently, the dispersion forces in are much weaker than in , giving the lowest boiling point.
-
Comparing Nonpolar Propane () and Polar Fluoromethane ():
- While propane relies entirely on dispersion forces, fluoromethane possesses a permanent molecular dipole.
- Between molecules of comparable size, permanent dipole-dipole attractions generally provide stronger intermolecular attraction than dispersion forces alone, resulting in a higher boiling point for relative to the nonpolar hydrocarbons.
-
Comparing Dipole Interactions to Hydrogen Bonding ( vs. ):
- While and have very similar molar masses ( vs. ), methanol has an atom covalently bonded to highly electronegative .
- This allows methanol molecules to form strong intermolecular hydrogen bonds with one another. Because hydrogen bonds are substantially stronger than typical dipole-dipole attractions, requires the most thermal energy to vaporize and exhibits the highest boiling point.
Combine and Rank by Increasing Boiling Point
Arranging the substances in order of increasing strength of predominant intermolecular forces yields:
Typical errors
01 The student assumes any polar molecule with dipole-dipole forces must have a higher boiling point than any nonpolar molecule with only dispersion forces, placing C3H8 below CH3F.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
: London dispersion forces : London dispersion forces : dipole-dipole attractions : hydrogen bonding
- Step 2
is smaller than , so for nonpolar substances.
- Step 3
Nonpolar molecules only have London dispersion forces, which are weaker than dipole-dipole attractions. Polar substances have stronger attractions than nonpolar substances, so both nonpolar molecules boil below .
CorrectPropane (, electrons, ) has a significantly larger and more polarizable electron cloud than fluoromethane (, electrons, ). Consequently, the London dispersion forces in are strong enough to exceed the combined dipole-dipole and dispersion forces of , giving a lower boiling point () than ().
You applied a rigid rule that dipole-dipole attractions are always stronger than London dispersion forces. While this holds for molecules of very similar size and electron count, London dispersion forces scale with polarizability and can become substantially stronger than dipole-dipole attractions when comparing a larger molecule like propane to a smaller one like fluoromethane.
- Step 4
forms hydrogen bonds, which are the strongest intermolecular forces.
- Step 5
Increasing boiling point:
CorrectIncreasing boiling point:
Because propane's dispersion forces outweigh fluoromethane's dipole-dipole forces, fluoromethane must be ranked below propane.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly classified the predominant intermolecular force for each of the four substances.
You correctly determined that propane has stronger dispersion forces than methane due to its larger size.
You correctly identified methanol as having the highest boiling point because of hydrogen bonding.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou assumed that any polar molecule with dipole-dipole forces must have a higher boiling point than any nonpolar molecule with only dispersion forces.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated intermolecular force types as a strict categorical hierarchy without considering how differences in polarizability and electron cloud size allow dispersion forces in larger nonpolar molecules to exceed dipole-dipole forces in smaller polar molecules.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Evaluate Polarizability Before Comparing Force Types
London dispersion forces scale continuously with electron count and molecular size, whereas dipole-dipole forces only provide a modest boost relative to molecules of identical or near-identical electron count.
Always compare the total number of electrons and molar mass; if a nonpolar molecule has significantly more electrons (like propane with vs. fluoromethane with ), its dispersion forces can easily outweigh weak-to-moderate dipole-dipole interactions.
- Use the 'Similar Size' Condition Carefully
The textbook rule 'dipole-dipole > London dispersion' is strictly valid only when comparing molecules with comparable electron counts and polarizabilities.
Check whether the molecules being compared have approximately the same number of electrons before assuming polarity will dictate the higher boiling point.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the electron clouds of and : propane has electrons and a molar mass of , while fluoromethane has only electrons and a molar mass of .
Because propane's electron cloud is substantially larger and more diffuse, its London dispersion forces are much stronger than those in fluoromethane, surpassing fluoromethane's permanent dipole-dipole attractions.
Therefore, the normal boiling point of () is lower than that of ().
02 The student misidentifies fluoromethane as exhibiting hydrogen bonding because it contains both hydrogen and fluorine, ranking CH3F above CH3OH or confusing the ranking of strong forces.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
: London dispersion forces, : London dispersion forces, : hydrogen bonding, : hydrogen bonding
Correct: London dispersion forces; : London dispersion forces; : Dipole-dipole interactions; : Hydrogen bonding
You correctly identified the forces for , , and . However, in fluoromethane (), the three hydrogen atoms and the fluorine atom are all covalently bonded directly to the central carbon atom. Because there is no direct covalent bond, pure cannot form intermolecular hydrogen bonds; its predominant intermolecular force is dipole-dipole interactions.
- Step 2
and only have dispersion forces, so due to lower molar mass.
- Step 3
and both have hydrogen bonding because and are bonded with in the formulas. has a higher molar mass () than (), so its attractions are stronger.
Correctexhibits dipole-dipole forces, whereas exhibits hydrogen bonding through its group. Hydrogen bonding is significantly stronger than dipole-dipole interactions between molecules of similar molar mass, so .
Your comparison was affected by assuming both molecules form hydrogen bonds. Because only exhibits hydrogen bonding, its intermolecular attractions are much stronger than the dipole-dipole forces of , giving methanol a higher boiling point.
- Step 4
Increasing boiling point:
CorrectYour final sequence placed at the highest boiling point as a direct consequence of your earlier misclassification of its intermolecular forces.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified London dispersion forces as the predominant intermolecular force in nonpolar and .
You correctly related molar mass and electron cloud size to the relative strength of dispersion forces between and .
You correctly identified hydrogen bonding in methanol ().
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that simply containing both hydrogen and an electronegative atom () in the chemical formula allows a molecule to engage in hydrogen bonding, overlooking the strict structural requirement that hydrogen must be directly, covalently bonded to , , or .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Direct Bonding Criterion for Hydrogen Bonding
A pure substance can form intermolecular hydrogen bonds only if at least one atom is directly covalently bonded to a highly electronegative atom (, , or ).
Always draw or inspect the Lewis structure to confirm whether an , , or bond exists before assigning hydrogen bonding.
- Comparing Dipole-Dipole vs. Hydrogen Bonding
For molecules of comparable molar mass, hydrogen bonding is substantially stronger than normal dipole-dipole interactions.
When molecules have similar sizes (such as at and at ), place the hydrogen-bonding substance at the higher boiling point.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationInspect the Lewis structure of fluoromethane: carbon is central with three single bonds and one bond. There is no bond, so its predominant force is dipole-dipole attraction.
Inspect the Lewis structure of methanol: oxygen is bonded to carbon and directly to hydrogen (an bond), so its predominant force is hydrogen bonding.
Compare relative strengths: dispersion forces (, ) < permanent dipole-dipole forces () < hydrogen bonding ().
Assemble the overall ranking by increasing normal boiling point.
03 The student ranks boiling points strictly by molar mass without considering the types or relative strengths of intermolecular forces.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
: London dispersion forces ⟹ : London dispersion forces ⟹ : dipole-dipole forces ⟹ : hydrogen bonding
- Step 2
Boiling point increases directly with molar mass because heavier molecules require more energy to vaporize.
CorrectFor molecules of comparable size and molar mass, boiling points depend primarily on the type and strength of intermolecular forces: .
Molar mass correlates with London dispersion force polarizability, but it does not supersede stronger interactions like dipole-dipole attractions or hydrogen bonding when comparing molecules of comparable molecular weight.
- Step 3Correct
Because methanol exhibits strong intermolecular hydrogen bonds, it has the highest boiling point, followed by polar fluoromethane, nonpolar propane, and lastly nonpolar methane.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the nonpolar nature and London dispersion forces of and .
You correctly identified the permanent dipole in and the hydrogen bonding in .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated molar mass as the sole governing factor for vaporization energy, overlooking the fact that specific intermolecular force types (especially hydrogen bonding and dipole-dipole attractions) dominate over small molar mass differences.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Hierarchical IMF Comparison
For molecules with similar molar masses, hydrogen bonding is generally stronger than dipole-dipole attractions, which are stronger than London dispersion forces.
Always compare the types of predominant intermolecular forces first before using molar mass as a tie-breaker.
- Role of Molar Mass
Molar mass primarily affects London dispersion strength through electron cloud polarizability.
Use molar mass to compare substances that share the same dominant IMF type (such as vs. ).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the two nonpolar hydrocarbons: has a larger electron cloud and higher molar mass () than (), so its dispersion forces are stronger, meaning .
Compare substances of similar molar mass: () has permanent dipole-dipole interactions, making its forces stronger than the nonpolar hydrocarbons.
Methanol (, ) forms intermolecular hydrogen bonds via its group, which are significantly stronger than the dipole-dipole forces in .
Lock it in
Can a nonpolar substance with only London dispersion forces have a higher boiling point than a polar substance with dipole-dipole forces?
Yes. If the nonpolar molecule has a significantly larger and more polarizable electron cloud, its London dispersion forces can be stronger than the polar molecule's dipole attractions.
Similar question
Which substance has the higher normal boiling point: dichloromethane (, polar, molar mass ) or carbon tetrachloride (, nonpolar, molar mass )? Explain briefly.
Answer
has the higher boiling point ( vs. ). Although is nonpolar, its electrons create a much larger, more polarizable electron cloud than ( electrons), resulting in dispersion forces that exceed the dipole-dipole plus dispersion attractions of .
Rank the following three pure substances in order of increasing normal boiling point: ethane (, ), chloromethane (, ), and hexane (, ).
Answer
. Ethane and chloromethane have comparable small sizes, so chloromethane's dipole moment gives it a higher boiling point than nonpolar ethane. However, nonpolar hexane has electrons and a long carbon chain, making its dispersion forces far stronger than chloromethane's dipole attractions.
Consider bromine (, nonpolar, liquid at room temperature) and hydrogen chloride (, polar, gas at room temperature). Explain why is a liquid while is a gas at and in terms of intermolecular forces.
Answer
has electrons and a molar mass of , while has only electrons and a molar mass of . The extensive polarizability of 's electron cloud produces very strong London dispersion forces that hold it in the liquid phase, whereas the modest dipole-dipole attractions in small molecules are insufficient to condense it at room temperature.