Resources
A student posits that because fluorine () has a smaller atomic number and fewer electrons than magnesium (), the fluoride ion () must also possess fewer electrons than the magnesium ion (). (a) Determine the complete subatomic particle counts (protons, neutrons, electrons) for both and . (b) Evaluate whether the student's intuition holds true by comparing their electron configurations.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) For : protons, neutrons, electrons; for : protons, neutrons, electrons. (b) The student's intuition fails; both ions are isoelectronic, each possessing exactly electrons ().
Steps
Part (a): Determining Subatomic Particle Counts
For any nuclide symbol :
- Atomic number (): Equals the number of protons ().
- Mass number (): Equals the total number of nucleons (protons + neutrons), so neutrons () .
- Net charge (): Determined by the balance between protons and electrons:
Applying these rules to each ion:
-
Fluoride ion ():
- Protons:
- Neutrons:
- Electrons: The ion has a charge (), meaning it has gained electron relative to the neutral atom:
-
Magnesium ion ():
- Protons:
- Neutrons:
- Electrons: The ion has a charge (), meaning it has lost electrons relative to the neutral atom:
Part (b): Evaluating the Student's Claim
-
Neutral atoms:
- Neutral fluorine has electrons: .
- Neutral magnesium has electrons: . In their neutral forms, fluorine indeed has fewer electrons than magnesium.
-
Ions:
- By gaining one electron, attains a filled valence shell:
- By losing two valence electrons, empties its third shell and achieves the same filled second shell:
Conclusion: The student's intuition fails. Although neutral fluorine has fewer electrons than neutral magnesium, ionization causes both species to attain identical noble gas electron configurations (the neon core, with electrons). Species that share the exact same electron count and configuration are described as isoelectronic.
Common Pitfall: Assuming the relative electron counts of neutral atoms always predict those of their ions. Cations lose electrons while anions gain them, which can invert or equalize their electron counts.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the sign of ion charges and subtracts electrons for an anion while adding them for a cation.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You correctly determined that has protons and neutrons. However, a charge indicates the atom has gained negatively charged electron (), not lost one.
- Step 2Correct
You correctly found protons and neutrons for . However, a charge indicates that the neutral magnesium atom lost electrons (), rather than gained .
- Step 3Correct
You wrote the electron configurations consistent with your calculated electron totals, but because both ions actually have electrons, both have the noble gas electron configuration .
- Step 4
^- ^{2+}
Correct10 (1s^2,2s^2,2p^6).
Your conclusion was logically drawn from your earlier numbers, but because both ions have identical electron counts ( electrons), the original student's intuition fails.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the proton count directly from the atomic number for both species.
You accurately calculated the neutron count using for both fluorine and magnesium.
You correctly followed the Aufbau principle to write electron configurations matching your calculated electron totals.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo; you consistently inverted the charge operation for both the anion and the cation, indicating a conceptual misconception about how charge relates to electron count.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou associated a negative charge sign with subtraction and a positive charge sign with addition. Because each electron carries a charge of , the relationship is . An anion (negative charge) has excess electrons and gains them, whereas a cation (positive charge) has a deficit of electrons and has lost them.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Connecting Charge to Electron Transfer
Electrons carry a charge, so , where is the ion's net charge.
For a negative charge , add electrons to the atomic number; for a positive charge , subtract electrons from the atomic number.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate electrons for : .
Calculate electrons for : .
Write the shared electron configuration for both -electron species: .
Compare counts: both species have electrons, meaning they are isoelectronic.
(a) For : protons, neutrons, electrons; for : protons, neutrons, electrons. (b) The student's intuition fails; both ions are isoelectronic, each possessing exactly electrons ().
02 The student ignores the ionic charges and uses neutral atom electron counts to evaluate the ions.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You found the correct numbers of protons and neutrons. However, a fluoride ion has a charge, meaning it gained electron relative to neutral fluorine, giving it electrons instead of .
- Step 2Correct
You determined the correct numbers of protons and neutrons. However, a magnesium ion has a charge, meaning it lost electrons relative to neutral magnesium, leaving it with electrons instead of .
- Step 3Correct
Because your electron counts were based on neutral atoms, you wrote the ground-state electron configurations for neutral and neutral . With electrons each, both ions have the configuration .
- Step 4
The student's claim is correct because has electrons and has electrons.
CorrectThe student's intuition fails; both ions are isoelectronic, each possessing exactly electrons ().
The student's claim is incorrect. While neutral fluorine has fewer electrons than neutral magnesium, gains an electron and loses two electrons, so both ions end up with identical electron counts ( electrons each).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the atomic number as the number of protons for both elements.
You calculated the neutron count accurately by subtracting the atomic number from the mass number ().
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou used the neutral atomic number () for the electron count instead of adjusting for the net ionic charge with .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Account for Net Charge
For any ion , the electron count is given by . Anions gain electrons (), while cations lose electrons ().
Always check the superscript charge before writing the electron count. Add electrons for negative charges and subtract electrons for positive charges.
- Recognize Isoelectronic Species
Ions of different elements can achieve the same stable noble gas configuration by gaining or losing electrons.
Recalculate electron counts independently from the charge rather than relying on the neutral atom's position in the periodic table.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate electron counts incorporating ionic charges: for , ; for , .
Write the ground-state electron configuration for each species using electrons: and .
Compare configurations and electron numbers to evaluate the claim: since both have electrons, the student's intuition is incorrect; the two ions are isoelectronic.
(a) For : protons, neutrons, electrons; for : protons, neutrons, electrons. (b) The student's intuition fails; both ions are isoelectronic, each possessing exactly electrons ().
03 The student removes electrons from the wrong subshell or misidentifies the 2+ charge as affecting protons instead of electrons.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
The atomic number of an element never changes during chemical ionization; magnesium always has protons, which gives neutrons. A positive charge indicates a loss of electrons, so has electrons.
- Step 3
has electrons: has electrons:
Correct( electrons) and ( electrons)
Because of the previous error in electron count, you wrote the electron configuration of neutral magnesium ( electrons) rather than removing the two valence electrons from the subshell to form ( electrons).
- Step 4
The student's intuition is correct because has electrons and has electrons.
CorrectThe student's intuition is incorrect because both and possess electrons and are isoelectronic ().
Propagating the incorrect electron count for led to the wrong conclusion. Both ions actually have electrons and identical electron configurations.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the protons, neutrons, and electrons for the anion .
You wrote the correct ground-state electron configuration for the -electron species .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the charge of a cation by adding protons to the nucleus instead of removing electrons from the electron cloud. Protons define the element's identity and remain constant during ionization; net charge is entirely determined by the gain or loss of electrons.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Nuclear Constancy
Chemical ionization never alters the nucleus: and regardless of charge.
Always copy the atomic number directly as the proton count without adding or subtracting charge.
- Ion Electron Formula
Net charge reflects electron transfer: , where is the ion charge with its sign.
For cations (), subtract electrons from the neutral count; for anions (), add electrons.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet the proton count equal to the atomic number: .
Calculate neutrons using the mass number: .
Calculate electrons using the net charge: .
Write the electron configuration for electrons: is .
Compare configurations: both and have the configuration ( electrons), so the student's intuition is incorrect; the ions are isoelectronic.
(a) For : protons, neutrons, electrons; for : protons, neutrons, electrons. (b) The student's intuition is incorrect because both ions are isoelectronic, each having electrons with configuration .
Lock it in
How do you determine the number of electrons in an ion with atomic number and net charge ?
Use . A positive charge means electrons were lost (subtract ), while a negative charge means electrons were gained (add ).
Similar question
Determine the number of protons, neutrons, and electrons for the sulfide ion, .
Answer
Protons: , Neutrons: , Electrons: electrons. (Key step: a charge means additional electrons are added to the neutral count).
A student states that since calcium () has more electrons than chlorine (), a ion must have more electrons than a ion. Evaluate this claim by providing the electron count and electron configuration for both ions.
Answer
The claim is false. For , electrons . For , electrons . Both ions have identical electron configurations: ( electrons, isoelectronic with ).
Consider the three ions , , and . (a) Calculate the subatomic particle counts (, , ) for each ion. (b) Explain the term that describes their relationship regarding electron count.
Answer
(a) : , , ; : , , ; : , , . (b) All three species are described as isoelectronic because they share the same number of electrons () and identical ground-state electron configurations.