Resources
The Clapeyron equation governing phase equilibrium boundaries is given by . In the phase diagram of water, ice Ih melts into liquid water with an increase in density ( and at ). For dry ice (solid ), the solid density is and the liquid density at is . (a) Determine the algebraic sign (positive or negative) of the slope of the solid-liquid coexistence line for and for . (b) Based on these sign conventions, state whether increasing the pressure on a solid sample at a temperature just below its normal melting point causes melting or prevents melting for each substance.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) is negative () for and positive () for ; (b) For , increasing pressure causes melting; for , increasing pressure prevents melting (favors the solid phase).
Steps
Part (a): Determining the Sign of
The Clapeyron equation for a solid-to-liquid phase transition (melting or fusion) is:
- Sign of and : Melting is an endothermic process for any pure substance, which means heat is absorbed: Absolute temperature in Kelvin is always positive (). Therefore, the sign of the slope is completely determined by the sign of the volume change upon melting:
-
Volume change from density: Specific volume is inversely proportional to density ():
- For : Since the liquid is denser than the solid, it occupies a smaller volume: Substituting this into the Clapeyron equation gives:
- For : Since the solid is denser than the liquid, the volume expands upon melting: Substituting this into the Clapeyron equation gives:
Part (b): Effect of Increasing Pressure Just Below the Melting Point
By Le Chatelier's principle, applying pressure to a system in equilibrium shifts it toward the phase with the higher density (smaller molar volume). Graphically, increasing pressure corresponds to moving vertically upward on a pressure-temperature () phase diagram:
- For : Because , the solid-liquid coexistence line tilts backward (to the left). A solid point just below the normal melting point lies directly underneath the liquid region. Increasing pressure at this temperature moves the state point vertically upward across the boundary into the liquid region. Thus, increasing pressure causes melting.
- For : Because , the solid-liquid coexistence line tilts forward (to the right), which is standard for most substances. Solid is denser than liquid . Applying pressure stabilizes the denser solid phase, moving the state point further into the solid domain and shifting the melting temperature to a higher value. Thus, increasing pressure prevents melting (favors the solid phase).
Typical errors
01 The student calculates ΔV as V_initial - V_final (solid - liquid) instead of V_final - V_initial, inverting the sign of ΔV and therefore inverting the slope dP/dT for both substances.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
For any physical transition, change is defined as final state minus initial state. Because melting goes from solid to liquid, the change in volume is .
- Step 3
For , and and
CorrectFor :
Your reasoning about the relative specific volumes from densities was solid, but substituting your inverted formula for flipped the sign of for both substances.
- Step 4
For , so increasing pressure raises melting point and prevents melting. For , so increasing pressure lowers melting point and causes melting.
CorrectFor : , so increasing pressure lowers the melting point and causes melting. For : , so increasing pressure raises the melting point and prevents melting.
You correctly related the sign of to the shift in melting point, but because the signs were inverted in the previous step, your conclusions for both substances were reversed.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly established that melting is an endothermic process with .
You correctly used the inverse relationship between density and specific volume to compare solid and liquid phases.
You followed a clear, logical chain of thermodynamic reasoning from the Clapeyron equation to phase behavior.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou reversed the order of subtraction when defining , writing initial minus final instead of final minus initial.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- State Function Difference Convention
For any process going from state A to state B, .
Always write out before substituting values or signs.
- Le Chatelier Check for Pressure
Increasing pressure always favors the phase with higher density (smaller volume).
Check your final result physically: liquid water is denser than ice, so higher pressure must favor the liquid (causing melting).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDefine the volume change of fusion correctly: .
For , liquid water is denser than ice, so , giving . With and , .
For , solid dry ice is denser than liquid , so , giving . Therefore, .
Evaluate increasing pressure just below the melting point: for , the negative slope shifts the equilibrium so that pressure favors the denser liquid phase (causes melting); for , the positive slope means pressure favors the denser solid phase (prevents melting).
(a) is negative () for and positive () for ; (b) For , increasing pressure causes melting; for , increasing pressure prevents melting.
02 The student misinterprets a negative solid-liquid slope, assuming a negative slope means higher pressure corresponds to higher melting temperature.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
For , , For ,
- Step 2
For , is negative, so increasing pressure shifts equilibrium to the solid and prevents melting. ⟹ For , is positive, so increasing pressure shifts equilibrium to the liquid and causes melting.
CorrectFor , increasing pressure causes melting. For , increasing pressure prevents melting (favors the solid).
Increasing pressure always shifts a phase equilibrium toward the denser phase (the one with smaller volume). For , liquid water is denser than ice (), so higher pressure favors the liquid and causes melting. On a diagram where the melting line has a negative slope (tilting left), moving vertically upward (increasing ) at a temperature just below the normal melting point crosses from the solid region into the liquid region. For , the solid is denser, so higher pressure stabilizes the solid and prevents melting.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly established that for melting.
You accurately linked density to specific volume to find the sign of for both substances.
You correctly deduced that is negative for and positive for .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou inverted the relationship between pressure, phase boundary slope, and phase stability. According to Le Chatelier's principle, an increase in pressure favors the phase with smaller volume (higher density). Alternatively, on a plot with on the vertical axis, moving upward at constant moves across a negatively sloped boundary into the liquid phase (for water), and stays in/enters the solid phase across a positively sloped boundary (for ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Pressure and Density Rule
By Le Chatelier's principle, increasing pressure shifts the system toward whichever phase has the higher density (smaller volume).
Compare and . Whichever is larger is the phase stabilized by higher pressure.
- Phase Diagram Geometry
On a phase diagram ( vertical, horizontal), the solid phase is at lower (left) and the liquid phase is at higher (right).
Draw a vertical line moving upward at . If the solid-liquid line has (tilts left), going up crosses from solid into liquid.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall that an increase in pressure shifts equilibrium toward the phase with higher density (smaller volume).
For : , so increasing pressure favors the liquid phase. Moving vertically upward on a diagram across the negatively sloped boundary takes the solid into the liquid region, causing melting.
For : , so increasing pressure favors the solid phase. The positively sloped line shifts the melting point higher, preventing melting.
(a) is negative for and positive for ; (b) For , increasing pressure causes melting; for , increasing pressure prevents melting.
03 The student confuses density and volume, erroneously concluding that higher liquid density means liquid volume is greater than solid volume.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
Specific volume is inversely proportional to density (). Because liquid water is denser than ice, a given mass of liquid occupies less volume than the solid (). Therefore, melting involves a contraction (), making negative.
- Step 2Correct
Because solid is denser than liquid , melting results in an expansion (, so ). Since and , the slope is positive.
- Step 3Correct
Your reasoning that a positive slope means pressure increases the melting point is logically sound, but it follows from the incorrect sign determined in part (a). Because , applying pressure lowers the melting point and drives the solid into the denser liquid phase, causing melting.
- Step 4Correct
This conclusion is carried over from the inverted sign in part (a). Because the true slope is positive (), increasing pressure raises the melting temperature and stabilizes the denser solid phase, preventing melting.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the Clapeyron equation as the governing relationship.
You recognized that and , so the algebraic sign of depends entirely on the sign of .
You demonstrated consistent graphical interpretation by linking the sign of to how melting temperature shifts under applied pressure.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated density and volume as directly proportional instead of inversely proportional when evaluating .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing density () with volume led to the mistaken assumption that higher density corresponds to larger volume, which inverted the sign of for both substances.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Density-to-Volume Inversion
For a fixed mass , molar or specific volume is inversely proportional to density: .
Always write so that immediately yields .
- Le Chatelier and Phase Density
Increasing pressure always shifts equilibrium toward the phase with higher density (smaller volume).
Check your final answer against density: since liquid water is denser than ice, compression must favor liquid water (causes melting).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationApply the inverse relationship : for , .
For , .
Substitute into the Clapeyron equation with and : (negative) for , and (positive) for .
Analyze the effect of increasing pressure just below the melting point: for , the negative slope means moving vertically upward on a diagram crosses into the liquid region (causes melting); for , the positive slope means moving vertically upward stays in the solid region (prevents melting).
(a) is negative () for and positive () for ; (b) For , increasing pressure causes melting; for , increasing pressure prevents melting.
Lock it in
In the Clapeyron equation for melting (solid liquid), how is defined?
(always final state minus initial state).
Similar question
Elemental bismuth expands upon freezing (its solid density is and its liquid density is ). Determine the sign of the slope of its solid-liquid equilibrium boundary.
Answer
Negative (). For melting, . Since and , .
Benzene has a standard enthalpy of fusion at its normal melting point of (). Upon melting, its molar volume increases by . Calculate the slope in (given ).
Answer
. Convert . Using the Clapeyron equation: .
A substance exhibits a negative fusion slope . If an external pressure of is applied to a sample existing at solid-liquid equilibrium, will its melting temperature increase, decrease, or remain unchanged? Explain using the differential relationship.
Answer
It will decrease. Because , taking the reciprocal gives . Therefore, an increase in pressure () causes a negative change in melting temperature ().