Resources

A student investigating alkaline earth oxides compares strontium oxide (SrO\text{SrO}, melting point 2531∘C2531^\circ\text{C}) and barium oxide (BaO\text{BaO}, melting point 1923∘C1923^\circ\text{C}). Both crystallize in the face-centered cubic rock-salt (NaCl\text{NaCl}) crystal lattice with identical coordination numbers (6:66:6) and identical formal ion charges (+2+2 and −2-2). The internuclear distance in SrO\text{SrO} is r0=258 pmr_0 = 258\text{ pm}, and its experimental lattice energy is −3223 kJ/mol-3223\text{ kJ/mol}. Assuming the lattice energy is strictly governed by the simplified Born-Landé relationship Elattice∝1r0E_{\text{lattice}} \propto \frac{1}{r_0}, determine the predicted internuclear equilibrium distance r0r_0 of BaO\text{BaO} in picometers if the experimental lattice energy of BaO\text{BaO} is −3054 kJ/mol-3054\text{ kJ/mol}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

r0(BaO)=258 pm×(−3223 kJ/mol−3054 kJ/mol)≈272 pmr_0(\text{BaO}) = 258\text{ pm} \times \left( \frac{-3223\text{ kJ/mol}}{-3054\text{ kJ/mol}} \right) \approx 272\text{ pm}.

Steps

Understanding the Relationship

The lattice energy (ElatticeE_{\text{lattice}}) of an ionic crystal measures the strength of the electrostatic forces binding its ions together. According to the simplified Born–Landé relationship, when two ionic compounds share the same crystal structure (Madelung constant), identical coordination geometry (6:66:6), and identical ionic charges (z+=+2z^+ = +2, z−=−2z^- = -2), the lattice energy is inversely proportional to the internuclear equilibrium distance r0r_0:

Elattice∝1r0E_{\text{lattice}} \propto \frac{1}{r_0}

This implies that the product of lattice energy and internuclear distance is constant:

Elattice(SrO)⋅r0(SrO)=Elattice(BaO)⋅r0(BaO)E_{\text{lattice}}(\ce{SrO}) \cdot r_0(\ce{SrO}) = E_{\text{lattice}}(\ce{BaO}) \cdot r_0(\ce{BaO})


Step-by-Step Derivation

  1. Set up the ratio for the unknown distance: Rearranging the inverse relationship to solve for the internuclear distance of BaO\ce{BaO} gives: r0(BaO)=r0(SrO)⋅(Elattice(SrO)Elattice(BaO))r_0(\ce{BaO}) = r_0(\ce{SrO}) \cdot \left( \frac{E_{\text{lattice}}(\ce{SrO})}{E_{\text{lattice}}(\ce{BaO})} \right)
  2. Substitute the given values:

    • r0(SrO)=258 pmr_0(\ce{SrO}) = 258\text{ pm}
    • Elattice(SrO)=−3223 kJ/molE_{\text{lattice}}(\ce{SrO}) = -3223\text{ kJ/mol}
    • Elattice(BaO)=−3054 kJ/molE_{\text{lattice}}(\ce{BaO}) = -3054\text{ kJ/mol}

    r0(BaO)=258 pm×(−3223 kJ/mol−3054 kJ/mol)r_0(\ce{BaO}) = 258\text{ pm} \times \left( \frac{-3223\text{ kJ/mol}}{-3054\text{ kJ/mol}} \right)

  3. Calculate the final value: −3223−3054≈1.05534\frac{-3223}{-3054} \approx 1.05534 r0(BaO)≈258 pm×1.05534≈272 pmr_0(\ce{BaO}) \approx 258\text{ pm} \times 1.05534 \approx 272\text{ pm}

Key Pitfall to Avoid

  • Direct vs. Inverse Proportionality: A common mistake is setting up a direct ratio (r0(BaO)r0(SrO)=EBaOESrO\frac{r_0(\ce{BaO})}{r_0(\ce{SrO})} = \frac{E_{\text{BaO}}}{E_{\text{SrO}}}), which would predict a smaller bond distance for the lower lattice energy compound. Because BaX2+\ce{Ba^2+} is larger than SrX2+\ce{Sr^2+}, the ions are held further apart, resulting in a weaker attraction (less negative lattice energy) and a correspondingly larger internuclear distance (r0>258 pmr_0 > 258\text{ pm}).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student treats the relationship between lattice energy and internuclear distance as directly proportional instead of inversely proportional, calculating a smaller internuclear distance for BaO.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Elattice∝r0E_{\text{lattice}} \propto r_0

    Correct

    Elattice∝1r0E_{\text{lattice}} \propto \frac{1}{r_0}

    You wrote that lattice energy is directly proportional to internuclear distance r0r_0. By Coulomb's law and the Born–Landé relationship, electrostatic attraction weakens as distance increases, so lattice energy is inversely proportional to r0r_0 (Elattice∝1r0E_{\text{lattice}} \propto \frac{1}{r_0}).

  2. Step 2

    r0(BaO)258=30543223\frac{r_0(\ce{BaO})}{258} = \frac{3054}{3223}

    Correct

    r0(BaO)258=32233054\frac{r_0(\ce{BaO})}{258} = \frac{3223}{3054}

    You substituted values into a direct ratio based on your initial formula. Because the relationship is inverse, the lattice energy ratio must be inverted.

  3. Step 3

    r0(BaO)=258⋅(30543223)=244.5 pmr_0(\ce{BaO}) = 258 \cdot \left(\frac{3054}{3223}\right) = 244.5\text{ pm}

    Correct

    r0(BaO)=258⋅(32233054)≈272 pmr_0(\ce{BaO}) = 258 \cdot \left(\frac{3223}{3054}\right) \approx 272\text{ pm}

    You carried out the arithmetic correctly for your formula, but the inverted ratio produces a value smaller than that of SrO\ce{SrO}, which is physically inconsistent since BaX2+\ce{Ba^2+} has a larger ionic radius than SrX2+\ce{Sr^2+}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the relevant numerical values from the problem statement.

You carried out the arithmetic and unit assignment accurately according to your written setup.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverse proportionality inverted to direct proportion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated electrostatic lattice energy as directly proportional to ionic separation rather than inversely proportional, leading to an inverted ratio that predicted a smaller bond distance for a compound with larger constituent ions and weaker lattice energy.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Coulomb's Law and Distance
  • Electrostatic attraction between opposite charges varies inversely with distance: E∝q1q2r0E \propto \frac{q_1 q_2}{r_0}.

  • Always verify that greater ionic separation corresponds to a smaller magnitude of lattice energy.

Periodic Trend Sanity Check
  • Cation radius increases down Group 2: r(BaX2+)>r(SrX2+)r(\ce{Ba^2+}) > r(\ce{Sr^2+}).

  • Check whether your calculated equilibrium distance r0(BaO)r_0(\ce{BaO}) is greater than r0(SrO)=258 pmr_0(\ce{SrO}) = 258\text{ pm}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Start with the inverse relationship: Elattice∝1r0E_{\text{lattice}} \propto \frac{1}{r_0}, meaning r0∝1∣Elattice∣r_0 \propto \frac{1}{|E_{\text{lattice}}|}.

  2. Set up the inverse ratio: r0(BaO)r0(SrO)=∣Elattice(SrO)∣∣Elattice(BaO)∣\frac{r_0(\ce{BaO})}{r_0(\ce{SrO})} = \frac{|E_{\text{lattice}}(\ce{SrO})|}{|E_{\text{lattice}}(\ce{BaO})|}.

  3. Substitute the given values: r0(BaO)=258 pm×3223 kJ/mol3054 kJ/molr_0(\ce{BaO}) = 258\text{ pm} \times \frac{3223\text{ kJ/mol}}{3054\text{ kJ/mol}}.

  4. Calculate the result: 258 pm×1.05534≈272 pm258\text{ pm} \times 1.05534 \approx 272\text{ pm}.

Final answer

r0(BaO)≈272 pmr_0(\ce{BaO}) \approx 272\text{ pm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Coulomb's law and the Born–Landé equation to reinforce why potential energy is inversely proportional to internuclear distance.

  • Perform a physical reality check using periodic trends (e.g., barium is below strontium, so its bond distance must be larger) whenever calculating lattice parameters.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the inverse-distance dependence of lattice energy with Coulomb's inverse-square force law, setting lattice energy proportional to 1/r₀².

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Elattice∝1r02E_{\text{lattice}} \propto \frac{1}{r_0^2}

    Correct

    Elattice∝1r0E_{\text{lattice}} \propto \frac{1}{r_0}

    Lattice energy represents electrostatic potential energy, which scales inversely with the first power of distance (1r0\frac{1}{r_0}), unlike Coulombic force, which scales as 1r02\frac{1}{r_0^2}.

  2. Step 2

    r0(BaO)2⋅3054=(258)2⋅3223  ⟹  r0(BaO)=258⋅32233054r_0(\text{BaO})^2 \cdot 3054 = (258)^2 \cdot 3223 \implies r_0(\text{BaO}) = 258 \cdot \sqrt{\frac{3223}{3054}}

    Correct

    r0(BaO)⋅3054=258⋅3223  ⟹  r0(BaO)=258⋅(32233054)r_0(\text{BaO}) \cdot 3054 = 258 \cdot 3223 \implies r_0(\text{BaO}) = 258 \cdot \left(\frac{3223}{3054}\right)

    Your algebraic rearrangement and substitution were carried out cleanly, but because they were based on the inverse-square assumption, an unneeded square root was introduced.

  3. Step 3

    r0(BaO)=258⋅1.0273=265 pmr_0(\text{BaO}) = 258 \cdot 1.0273 = 265\text{ pm}

    Correct

    r0(BaO)≈258⋅1.0553=272 pmr_0(\text{BaO}) \approx 258 \cdot 1.0553 = 272\text{ pm}

    Your arithmetic on the square root expression was correct, but the final numerical value is too low due to the square root.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that lattice energy and internuclear distance are inversely related.

You substituted the given values into your chosen ratio with correct units and magnitudes.

You executed the multi-step algebraic manipulation and arithmetic accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverse-Square vs. Inverse-Distance Confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused electrostatic potential energy (lattice energy, ∝1r\propto \frac{1}{r}) with Coulombic electrostatic force (F∝1r2F \propto \frac{1}{r^2}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Energy vs. Force Power Law
  • Electrostatic force follows Coulomb's law (F∝q1q2r2F \propto \frac{q_1 q_2}{r^2}), while electrostatic potential energy and lattice energy follow an inverse-distance law (E∝q1q2rE \propto \frac{q_1 q_2}{r}).

  • Whenever working with lattice energy or bond dissociation energy, set the relationship directly proportional to 1r0\frac{1}{r_0}, without squaring the radius.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the inverse first-power relationship: Elattice(BaO)⋅r0(BaO)=Elattice(SrO)⋅r0(SrO)E_{\text{lattice}}(\text{BaO}) \cdot r_0(\text{BaO}) = E_{\text{lattice}}(\text{SrO}) \cdot r_0(\text{SrO}).

  2. Rearrange for r0(BaO)r_0(\text{BaO}): r0(BaO)=r0(SrO)×(Elattice(SrO)Elattice(BaO))r_0(\text{BaO}) = r_0(\text{SrO}) \times \left(\frac{E_{\text{lattice}}(\text{SrO})}{E_{\text{lattice}}(\text{BaO})}\right).

  3. Substitute the values: r0(BaO)=258 pm×(−3223 kJ/mol−3054 kJ/mol)≈258 pm×1.05534r_0(\text{BaO}) = 258\text{ pm} \times \left(\frac{-3223\text{ kJ/mol}}{-3054\text{ kJ/mol}}\right) \approx 258\text{ pm} \times 1.05534.

Final answer

272 pm272\text{ pm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the dimensional distinction between electrostatic force (Newtons, 1/r21/r^2) and electrostatic potential energy (Joules, 1/r1/r).

  • Re-solve this problem without the square root to verify how a linear ratio produces 272 pm272\text{ pm}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Magnesium oxide (MgO\ce{MgO}) and calcium oxide (CaO\ce{CaO}) both share the rock-salt lattice with 6:66:6 coordination and ±2\pm 2 charges. The lattice energy of MgO\ce{MgO} is −3791 kJ/mol-3791\text{ kJ/mol} with an internuclear distance of 212 pm212\text{ pm}. If the lattice energy of CaO\ce{CaO} is −3401 kJ/mol-3401\text{ kJ/mol}, calculate the predicted internuclear distance r0r_0 of CaO\ce{CaO} using the simplified Born–Landé relation.

Answer

r0(CaO)=212 pm×(37913401)≈236 pmr_0(\ce{CaO}) = 212\text{ pm} \times \left(\frac{3791}{3401}\right) \approx 236\text{ pm}. Key steps: set up the inverse proportion r0(CaO)=r0(MgO)×∣Elattice(MgO)∣∣Elattice(CaO)∣r_0(\ce{CaO}) = r_0(\ce{MgO}) \times \frac{|E_{\text{lattice}}(\ce{MgO})|}{|E_{\text{lattice}}(\ce{CaO})|}, evaluate the ratio 1.11471.1147, and multiply to find 236 pm236\text{ pm}.

02

Two alkali fluorides, LiF\ce{LiF} and KF\ce{KF}, have identical rock-salt structures. LiF\ce{LiF} has r0=201 pmr_0 = 201\text{ pm} and a lattice energy of −1036 kJ/mol-1036\text{ kJ/mol}. If potassium fluoride has an equilibrium internuclear separation of r0=267 pmr_0 = 267\text{ pm}, estimate the lattice energy of KF\ce{KF} in kJ/mol\text{kJ/mol}.

Answer

Elattice(KF)≈−780 kJ/molE_{\text{lattice}}(\ce{KF}) \approx -780\text{ kJ/mol}. Key steps: apply inverse proportionality ∣E(KF)∣=∣E(LiF)∣×r0(LiF)r0(KF)=1036 kJ/mol×201 pm267 pm≈780 kJ/mol|E(\ce{KF})| = |E(\ce{LiF})| \times \frac{r_0(\ce{LiF})}{r_0(\ce{KF})} = 1036\text{ kJ/mol} \times \frac{201\text{ pm}}{267\text{ pm}} \approx 780\text{ kJ/mol}, then restore the negative sign for lattice energy.

03

A researcher measures two isostructural compounds: Compound X (r0=240 pmr_0 = 240\text{ pm}) and Compound Y (r0=300 pmr_0 = 300\text{ pm}). Both have identical formal charges and Madelung constants. By what percentage does the magnitude of the lattice energy decrease from Compound X to Compound Y?

Answer

20%20\%. Key steps: the ratio of lattice energy magnitudes is ∣EY∣∣EX∣=r0(X)r0(Y)=240300=0.80\frac{|E_{\text{Y}}|}{|E_{\text{X}}|} = \frac{r_0(\text{X})}{r_0(\text{Y})} = \frac{240}{300} = 0.80. The fractional decrease is 1−0.80=0.201 - 0.80 = 0.20, which corresponds to a 20%20\% decrease.

Loading workspace…