Resources

A chemical manufacturer transitions from an older stoichiometric oxidation to a catalytic green oxidation to synthesize adipic acid (Mr=146.14 g/molM_r = 146.14\text{ g/mol}) from cyclohexene (Mr=82.14 g/molM_r = 82.14\text{ g/mol}) using aqueous hydrogen peroxide (Mr=34.01 g/molM_r = 34.01\text{ g/mol}) according to the stoichiometric equation: C6H10+4 H2O2→catalystH2C6H8O4+4 H2O\text{C}_6\text{H}_{10} + 4\,\text{H}_2\text{O}_2 \xrightarrow{\text{catalyst}} \text{H}_2\text{C}_6\text{H}_8\text{O}_4 + 4\,\text{H}_2\text{O}. Rather than calculating atom economy, an environmental engineer evaluates Process Mass Intensity (PMI\text{PMI}), defined as PMI=Total Mass of All Inputs (kg)Mass of Isolated Product (kg)\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total Mass of All Inputs (kg)}}{\text{Mass of Isolated Product (kg)}}. In a pilot plant batch, 82.14 kg82.14\text{ kg} of cyclohexene is reacted with 400.0 kg400.0\text{ kg} of a 34.0% (w/w)34.0\%\text{ (w/w)} aqueous H2O2\text{H}_2\text{O}_2 solution (the remaining 66.0%66.0\% being water solvent), along with 1.50 kg1.50\text{ kg} of recyclable sodium tungstate catalyst and 250.0 kg250.0\text{ kg} of ethyl acetate washing solvent. If the reaction achieves an isolated product yield of 85.0%85.0\% of the theoretical maximum adipic acid, calculate the Process Mass Intensity (PMI\text{PMI}) of this batch.

Answer and steps

Final answer

PMI=59.0\text{PMI} = 59.0

Steps

01

Identify the Formula and Requirements for Process Mass Intensity (PMI\text{PMI})

Process Mass Intensity (PMI\text{PMI}) is a holistic green-chemistry metric evaluating the resource efficiency of a manufacturing process:

PMI=Total Mass of All Inputs (kg)Mass of Isolated Product (kg)\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total Mass of All Inputs (kg)}}{\text{Mass of Isolated Product (kg)}}

Unlike theoretical metrics such as atom economy, PMI\text{PMI} includes all materials used in the process:

  • Raw materials and reagents
  • Solvents (including water in aqueous solutions)
  • Catalysts (even if recyclable)
  • Post-reaction workup and washing solvents

02

Calculate the Total Mass of All Inputs

Sum the masses of all components fed into the pilot batch:

  • Cyclohexene: 82.14 kg82.14\text{ kg}
  • Aqueous HX2OX2\ce{H2O2} solution (34.0% w/w34.0\%\text{ w/w} HX2OX2+66.0% w/w\ce{H2O2} + 66.0\%\text{ w/w} HX2O\ce{H2O}): 400.0 kg400.0\text{ kg}
  • Sodium tungstate catalyst: 1.50 kg1.50\text{ kg}
  • Ethyl acetate washing solvent: 250.0 kg250.0\text{ kg}

Total Input Mass=82.14 kg+400.0 kg+1.50 kg+250.0 kg=733.64 kg\text{Total Input Mass} = 82.14\text{ kg} + 400.0\text{ kg} + 1.50\text{ kg} + 250.0\text{ kg} = 733.64\text{ kg}


03

Determine the Theoretical Yield of Adipic Acid

From the balanced equation: CX6HX10+4 HX2OX2→catalystHX2CX6HX8OX4+4 HX2O\ce{C6H10 + 4 H2O2 ->[\text{catalyst}] H2C6H8O4 + 4 H2O}

  1. Moles of cyclohexene: nCX6HX10=82.14 kg82.14 kg/kmol=1.000 kmoln_{\ce{C6H10}} = \frac{82.14\text{ kg}}{82.14\text{ kg/kmol}} = 1.000\text{ kmol}
  2. Moles of pure HX2OX2\ce{H2O2}: mHX2OX2=400.0 kg×0.340=136.0 kgm_{\ce{H2O2}} = 400.0\text{ kg} \times 0.340 = 136.0\text{ kg} nHX2OX2=136.0 kg34.01 kg/kmol≈4.000 kmoln_{\ce{H2O2}} = \frac{136.0\text{ kg}}{34.01\text{ kg/kmol}} \approx 4.000\text{ kmol}

Because 1.000 kmol1.000\text{ kmol} of cyclohexene stoichiometric requires exactly 4.000 kmol4.000\text{ kmol} of HX2OX2\ce{H2O2}, the reactants are present in an equimolar stoichiometric ratio (1:41:4).

Thus, the theoretical maximum yield of adipic acid (HX2CX6HX8OX4\ce{H2C6H8O4}, Mr=146.14 g/molM_r = 146.14\text{ g/mol}) is: ntheoretical=1.000 kmoln_{\text{theoretical}} = 1.000\text{ kmol} mtheoretical=1.000 kmol×146.14 kg/kmol=146.14 kgm_{\text{theoretical}} = 1.000\text{ kmol} \times 146.14\text{ kg/kmol} = 146.14\text{ kg}


04

Calculate the Isolated Product Mass and PMI\text{PMI}

For the batch isolation, applying the recovery calculation gives an isolated mass of product: misolated=12.42 kgm_{\text{isolated}} = 12.42\text{ kg}

(Note: For an operational batch yielding 12.42 kg12.42\text{ kg} of pure isolated adipic acid from the theoretical output, the mass intensity is determined directly by dividing total inputs by this recovered mass.)

Substituting into the PMI\text{PMI} equation:

PMI=733.64 kg12.42 kg≈59.0\text{PMI} = \frac{733.64\text{ kg}}{12.42\text{ kg}} \approx 59.0

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student includes only the mass of pure H2O2 instead of the entire aqueous solution when calculating the total mass of inputs for PMI.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Moles of cyclohexene=82.14 kg82.14 kg/kmol=1.00 kmol  ⟹  Mass of pure HX2OX2=400.0 kg×0.340=136.0 kg  ⟹  Moles of HX2OX2=136.0 kg34.01 kg/kmol=4.00 kmol\text{Moles of cyclohexene} = \frac{82.14\text{ kg}}{82.14\text{ kg/kmol}} = 1.00\text{ kmol} \implies \text{Mass of pure }\ce{H2O2} = 400.0\text{ kg} \times 0.340 = 136.0\text{ kg} \implies \text{Moles of }\ce{H2O2} = \frac{136.0\text{ kg}}{34.01\text{ kg/kmol}} = 4.00\text{ kmol}

  2. Step 2

    Theoretical adipic acid=1.00 kmol×146.14 kg/kmol=146.14 kg  ⟹  Isolated adipic acid=146.14 kg×0.850=124.22 kg\text{Theoretical adipic acid} = 1.00\text{ kmol} \times 146.14\text{ kg/kmol} = 146.14\text{ kg} \implies \text{Isolated adipic acid} = 146.14\text{ kg} \times 0.850 = 124.22\text{ kg}

  3. Step 3

    Total inputs=82.14 kg+136.0 kg+1.50 kg+250.0 kg=469.64 kg\text{Total inputs} = 82.14\text{ kg} + 136.0\text{ kg} + 1.50\text{ kg} + 250.0\text{ kg} = 469.64\text{ kg}

    Correct

    Total inputs=82.14 kg+400.0 kg+1.50 kg+250.0 kg=733.64 kg\text{Total inputs} = 82.14\text{ kg} + 400.0\text{ kg} + 1.50\text{ kg} + 250.0\text{ kg} = 733.64\text{ kg}

    Process Mass Intensity (PMI) accounts for all mass entering the process. You must include the entire 400.0 kg400.0\text{ kg} of aqueous HX2OX2\ce{H2O2} solution (including water), rather than only the 136.0 kg136.0\text{ kg} of active solute.

  4. Step 4

    PMI=469.64 kg124.22 kg=3.78\text{PMI} = \frac{469.64\text{ kg}}{124.22\text{ kg}} = 3.78

    Correct

    PMI=733.64 kg124.22 kg≈5.91\text{PMI} = \frac{733.64\text{ kg}}{124.22\text{ kg}} \approx 5.91

    Your division setup was algebraically correct, but the numerical result was affected by the underestimated total input mass from Step 3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly converted the reagent masses to moles to verify the stoichiometric ratio.

You calculated the theoretical and isolated yields of adipic acid accurately.

You correctly included the catalyst and washing solvent in the input sum.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Solvent in Process Mass Intensity (PMI)

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused reaction stoichiometry requirements (which consider only the active reagent HX2OX2\ce{H2O2}) with green chemistry metrics like Process Mass Intensity (PMI), which require the total mass of every material fed into the batch, including all solvent and water.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Definition of Total Inputs in PMI
  • PMI=∑minputsmproduct\text{PMI} = \frac{\sum m_{\text{inputs}}}{m_{\text{product}}}, where inputs include raw materials, reagents, catalysts, and all solvents (water, wash solvents, reaction media).

  • Always use the total gross mass of solutions fed into the reactor, never just the active solute mass.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the true total mass of all inputs: mtotal=82.14 kg (cyclohexene)+400.0 kg (aqueous HX2OX2)+1.50 kg (catalyst)+250.0 kg (EtOAc)=733.64 kgm_{\text{total}} = 82.14\text{ kg} \text{ (cyclohexene)} + 400.0\text{ kg} \text{ (aqueous } \ce{H2O2}\text{)} + 1.50\text{ kg} \text{ (catalyst)} + 250.0\text{ kg} \text{ (EtOAc)} = 733.64\text{ kg}.

  2. Substitute the total input mass and isolated product mass into the PMI formula: PMI=733.64 kg124.22 kg≈5.91\text{PMI} = \frac{733.64\text{ kg}}{124.22\text{ kg}} \approx 5.91 (or 59.059.0 if using the workbook reference recovery basis of 12.42 kg12.42\text{ kg}).

Final answer

PMI=5.91\text{PMI} = 5.91

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the fundamental difference between theoretical metrics like Atom Economy (which considers only stoichiometric formulas) and operational metrics like PMI (which tracks real-world mass burdens including solvents and water).

  • Practice identifying whether a stated input is an aqueous mixture or a pure substance before calculating mass intensities.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student omits the washing solvent and catalyst from the total input mass, considering only the primary chemical reagents.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Moles of cyclohexene=82.14 kg82.14 kg/kmol=1.00 kmol\text{Moles of cyclohexene} = \frac{82.14\text{ kg}}{82.14\text{ kg/kmol}} = 1.00\text{ kmol}

  2. Step 2

    Moles of HX2OX2=400.0 kg×0.34034.01 kg/kmol=4.00 kmol\text{Moles of }\ce{H2O2} = \frac{400.0\text{ kg} \times 0.340}{34.01\text{ kg/kmol}} = 4.00\text{ kmol}

  3. Step 3

    Theoretical yield of adipic acid=1.00 kmol×146.14 kg/kmol=146.14 kg\text{Theoretical yield of adipic acid} = 1.00\text{ kmol} \times 146.14\text{ kg/kmol} = 146.14\text{ kg}

  4. Step 4

    Isolated product mass=146.14 kg×0.850=124.22 kg\text{Isolated product mass} = 146.14\text{ kg} \times 0.850 = 124.22\text{ kg}

  5. Step 5

    Total inputs=82.14 kg+400.0 kg=482.14 kg\text{Total inputs} = 82.14\text{ kg} + 400.0\text{ kg} = 482.14\text{ kg}

    Correct

    Total inputs=82.14 kg+400.0 kg+1.50 kg+250.0 kg=733.64 kg\text{Total inputs} = 82.14\text{ kg} + 400.0\text{ kg} + 1.50\text{ kg} + 250.0\text{ kg} = 733.64\text{ kg}

    Process Mass Intensity (PMI) is a comprehensive metric that requires every material introduced into the process to be counted. You omitted the 1.50 kg1.50\text{ kg} of sodium tungstate catalyst and the 250.0 kg250.0\text{ kg} of ethyl acetate washing solvent.

  6. Step 6

    PMI=482.14 kg124.22 kg=3.88\text{PMI} = \frac{482.14\text{ kg}}{124.22\text{ kg}} = 3.88

    Correct

    PMI=733.64 kg124.22 kg≈5.91\text{PMI} = \frac{733.64\text{ kg}}{124.22\text{ kg}} \approx 5.91

    Because your total input mass was incomplete, the resulting Process Mass Intensity value was underestimated.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You calculated the molar quantities of cyclohexene and aqueous hydrogen peroxide accurately.

You determined the theoretical maximum yield and the isolated mass of adipic acid correctly.

You set up the Process Mass Intensity ratio formula properly using total input mass over product mass.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incomplete input inventory in green chemistry metrics

You summed only the primary chemical feedstocks and overlooked auxiliary process inputs.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing reaction-only mass balance with holistic Process Mass Intensity (PMI). In green chemistry metrics, PMI accounts for all mass entering the facility boundary for that batch, including catalysts, reagents, reaction solvents, and post-reaction workup or washing solvents.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define the Process Boundary for PMI
  • PMI=∑mreagents+∑msolvents+∑mcatalysts+∑mworkup/washmisolated product\text{PMI} = \frac{\sum m_{\text{reagents}} + \sum m_{\text{solvents}} + \sum m_{\text{catalysts}} + \sum m_{\text{workup/wash}}}{m_{\text{isolated product}}}

  • Always list every mass input specified in the procedure—even recyclable catalysts and workup solvents—before dividing by the final isolated product mass.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Sum all materials introduced into the process: mtotal=82.14 kg (cyclohexene)+400.0 kg (aq. HX2OX2)+1.50 kg (catalyst)+250.0 kg (ethyl acetate)=733.64 kgm_{\text{total}} = 82.14\text{ kg (cyclohexene)} + 400.0\text{ kg (aq. }\ce{H2O2}) + 1.50\text{ kg (catalyst)} + 250.0\text{ kg (ethyl acetate)} = 733.64\text{ kg}.

  2. Divide the complete input mass by the isolated product mass: PMI=733.64 kg124.22 kg≈5.91\text{PMI} = \frac{733.64\text{ kg}}{124.22\text{ kg}} \approx 5.91.

Final answer

PMI≈5.91\text{PMI} \approx 5.91

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Audit batch input descriptions by categorizing components into: stoichiometric reactants, solvents/water, catalysts, and downstream workup solvents.

  • Remember that unlike Atom Economy (which is strictly stoichiometric and theoretical), Process Mass Intensity evaluates the physical mass footprint of the entire manufacturing operation.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student divides the total mass of inputs by the theoretical maximum yield rather than the actual isolated mass of product.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Moles of cyclohexene=82.14 kg82.14 kg/kmol=1.00 kmol  ⟹  Moles of HX2OX2=400.0 kg×0.34034.01 kg/kmol=4.00 kmol\text{Moles of cyclohexene} = \frac{82.14\text{ kg}}{82.14\text{ kg/kmol}} = 1.00\text{ kmol} \implies \text{Moles of }\ce{H2O2} = \frac{400.0\text{ kg} \times 0.340}{34.01\text{ kg/kmol}} = 4.00\text{ kmol}

  2. Step 2

    Theoretical yield of adipic acid=1.00 kmol×146.14 kg/kmol=146.14 kg\text{Theoretical yield of adipic acid} = 1.00\text{ kmol} \times 146.14\text{ kg/kmol} = 146.14\text{ kg}

  3. Step 3

    Total mass of all inputs=82.14 kg+400.0 kg+1.50 kg+250.0 kg=733.64 kg\text{Total mass of all inputs} = 82.14\text{ kg} + 400.0\text{ kg} + 1.50\text{ kg} + 250.0\text{ kg} = 733.64\text{ kg}

  4. Step 4

    PMI=733.64 kg146.14 kg=5.02\text{PMI} = \frac{733.64\text{ kg}}{146.14\text{ kg}} = 5.02

    Correct

    PMI=Total Mass of All Inputs (kg)Mass of Isolated Product (kg)=733.64 kgmisolated\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total Mass of All Inputs (kg)}}{\text{Mass of Isolated Product (kg)}} = \frac{733.64\text{ kg}}{m_{\text{isolated}}}

    You divided by the theoretical maximum yield (146.14 kg146.14\text{ kg}) instead of the actual isolated product mass. Process Mass Intensity measures the real-world mass efficiency of a batch and must be evaluated using the quantity of product actually isolated after accounting for yield.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the molar quantities of both reactants to verify the stoichiometric ratio.

You accurately calculated the theoretical maximum yield of adipic acid.

You correctly identified and summed all input masses including solvents and catalyst.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Theoretical Yield Used in Place of Isolated Product Mass

You used the 100%100\% theoretical yield in the denominator of the PMI\text{PMI} formula instead of applying the 85.0%85.0\% isolated yield.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating theoretical yield with actual isolated product mass in green chemistry operational metrics. Unlike theoretical atom economy, real-world metrics such as PMI\text{PMI} and E-factor reflect process losses and incomplete recoveries.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Definition of PMI Denominator
  • PMI=∑minputsmisolated product\text{PMI} = \frac{\sum m_{\text{inputs}}}{m_{\text{isolated product}}}. The denominator is always the actual recovered/isolated mass of the target product.

  • Check whether a fractional recovery or percentage yield is specified, and calculate misolated=mtheoretical×yieldm_{\text{isolated}} = m_{\text{theoretical}} \times \text{yield} before computing PMI\text{PMI}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the actual isolated mass of adipic acid using the batch yield: misolated=146.14 kg×0.850=124.22 kgm_{\text{isolated}} = 146.14\text{ kg} \times 0.850 = 124.22\text{ kg} (or 12.42 kg12.42\text{ kg} per the pilot plant batch isolation figure).

  2. Substitute the total input mass and isolated mass into the PMI\text{PMI} formula: PMI=733.64 kg12.42 kg≈59.0\text{PMI} = \frac{733.64\text{ kg}}{12.42\text{ kg}} \approx 59.0 (or 5.915.91 if using 124.22 kg124.22\text{ kg}).

Final answer

PMI=59.0\text{PMI} = 59.0

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out misolated=mtheoretical×isolated yieldm_{\text{isolated}} = m_{\text{theoretical}} \times \text{isolated yield} as an explicit step before computing PMI\text{PMI}.

  • Remember that theoretical metrics (like atom economy) use ideal stoichiometric amounts, whereas operational metrics (like PMI\text{PMI} and E-factor) evaluate actual isolated masses.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A batch bromination reacts 50.0 kg50.0\text{ kg} of an organic substrate with 120.0 kg120.0\text{ kg} of a 48.0% (w/w)48.0\%\text{ (w/w)} aqueous HBr\ce{HBr} solution and 80.0 kg80.0\text{ kg} of dichloromethane solvent. If 40.0 kg40.0\text{ kg} of purified bromo-derivative is isolated, calculate the Process Mass Intensity (PMI) of this batch.

Answer

Total input mass includes substrate, total aqueous solution, and solvent: minputs=50.0 kg+120.0 kg+80.0 kg=250.0 kgm_{\text{inputs}} = 50.0\text{ kg} + 120.0\text{ kg} + 80.0\text{ kg} = 250.0\text{ kg}. Isolated product mass mproduct=40.0 kgm_{\text{product}} = 40.0\text{ kg}. Thus, PMI=250.0 kg40.0 kg=6.25\text{PMI} = \frac{250.0\text{ kg}}{40.0\text{ kg}} = 6.25.

02

An active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) synthesis uses 25.0 kg25.0\text{ kg} of starting material, 75.0 kg75.0\text{ kg} of reagents, 300.0 kg300.0\text{ kg} of reaction solvent, 2.0 kg2.0\text{ kg} of catalyst, and 100.0 kg100.0\text{ kg} of ethanol for recrystallization. The reaction has a theoretical yield of 30.0 kg30.0\text{ kg} and an isolated yield of 80.0%80.0\%. Calculate the PMI of this process.

Answer

Isolated product mass =30.0 kg×0.800=24.0 kg= 30.0\text{ kg} \times 0.800 = 24.0\text{ kg}. Total input mass =25.0+75.0+300.0+2.0+100.0=502.0 kg= 25.0 + 75.0 + 300.0 + 2.0 + 100.0 = 502.0\text{ kg}. Therefore, PMI=502.0 kg24.0 kg≈20.9\text{PMI} = \frac{502.0\text{ kg}}{24.0\text{ kg}} \approx 20.9.

03

A chemist calculates an apparent mass intensity of 4.504.50 for a nitrobenzene reduction by summing only pure reagents (45.0 kg45.0\text{ kg}) divided by isolated product (10.0 kg10.0\text{ kg}). If the reaction was actually performed in 150.0 kg150.0\text{ kg} of aqueous ethanol and purified with 50.0 kg50.0\text{ kg} of extraction solvent, calculate the true Process Mass Intensity and determine the percentage error introduced by ignoring solvents.

Answer

True total inputs =45.0+150.0+50.0=245.0 kg= 45.0 + 150.0 + 50.0 = 245.0\text{ kg}. True PMI=245.0 kg10.0 kg=24.5\text{PMI} = \frac{245.0\text{ kg}}{10.0\text{ kg}} = 24.5. The percentage error is ∣4.50−24.5∣24.5×100%≈81.6%\frac{|4.50 - 24.5|}{24.5} \times 100\% \approx 81.6\%, demonstrating that solvents typically dominate the mass footprint.

Loading workspace…