Resources
Students frequently assume that the central atom in an expanded octet species must use all of its extra valence capacity for bonding pairs. Consider the interhalogen triiodide anion, . (a) Determine the total count of valence electrons in . (b) Construct the complete Lewis structure for and report the number of bonding pairs and non-bonding lone pairs surrounding the central iodine atom. (c) Explain the counter-intuitive consequence for molecular geometry: despite possessing electron domains around the central atom, why is the physical ion linear rather than bent, and what are the equatorial versus axial domain assignments?
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Total valence electrons ; (b) Surrounding the central iodine atom: single bonding pairs and non-bonding lone pairs (total of electron pairs/domains); (c) In a trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry, lone pairs experience less electron-electron repulsion by occupying the equatorial positions ( repulsions) rather than axial positions ( repulsions). With all equatorial sites occupied by lone pairs, the bonding iodine atoms occupy the axial positions directly opposite each other, resulting in a strictly linear molecular geometry with an bond angle of .
Steps
Part (a): Determining the Total Valence Electron Count
-
Identify the group and valence electrons of each atom:
- Iodine () belongs to Group 17 (the halogens) and contributes valence electrons per atom.
- There are iodine atoms:
-
Account for the overall ionic charge:
- The anion carries a charge, indicating the addition of extra electron:
Part (b): Constructing the Lewis Structure and Counting Electron Pairs
-
Connect the atoms with single bonds:
- Place one iodine atom as the central atom and connect each terminal iodine atom with a single covalent bond:
- Two single bonds account for electrons, leaving:
-
Complete the octets of the terminal atoms:
- Each terminal iodine atom requires lone pairs ( electrons) to complete its octet:
- Remaining electrons:
-
Place remaining electrons on the central atom:
- Iodine is in Period 5 of the periodic table and possesses accessible -orbitals, allowing it to accommodate an expanded octet (more than valence electrons).
- Assign all remaining electrons ( lone pairs) directly to the central iodine atom.
- Place brackets around the entire structure and denote the overall charge:
-
Electron domain summary around the central iodine:
- Bonding pairs: single bonds (attached to terminal iodines).
- Non-bonding lone pairs: lone pairs.
- Total electron domains: electron pairs.
Common Pitfall: Do not try to convert terminal lone pairs into double or triple bonds to eliminate the central lone pairs. Halogens generally form single bonds as terminal atoms, and adding multiple bonds would create unfavorable formal charges and unphysical structures.
Part (c): Molecular Geometry and Domain Assignments
-
Electron-Domain Geometry:
- Five electron domains adopt a trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry to minimize electron-electron repulsion. This geometry features two distinct geometric environments:
- Axial positions: two positions oriented along the vertical axis at relative to each other and relative to the equatorial plane.
- Equatorial positions: three positions arranged in a flat plane at angles relative to each other.
- Five electron domains adopt a trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry to minimize electron-electron repulsion. This geometry features two distinct geometric environments:
-
Equatorial vs. Axial Preference for Lone Pairs:
- According to Valence Shell Electron Pair Repulsion (VSEPR) theory, non-bonding lone pairs are held closer to the central nucleus and exert stronger repulsive forces than bonding pairs ().
- Repulsions at angles close to are significantly more destabilizing than those at .
- If a lone pair were placed in an axial position, it would suffer three unfavorable repulsions with equatorial domains.
- Placed in an equatorial position, a lone pair experiences only two interactions with axial domains and wider interactions with other equatorial domains.
- Therefore, all non-bonding lone pairs preferentially occupy the equatorial positions.
-
Resulting Molecular Geometry:
- With the equatorial belt completely filled by the lone pairs, the bonding terminal iodine atoms are forced into the two opposing axial positions.
- Molecular geometry describes only the spatial arrangement of the atomic nuclei. Because the two axial bonds lie directly opposite one another along a straight line, the observed molecular geometry of is strictly linear, with an bond angle of .
Typical errors
01 The student forgets to add the extra electron from the negative charge, leading to an incorrect count of 21 valence electrons and an incomplete Lewis structure.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You calculated the neutral iodine atom contributions () but did not add electron for the overall charge of the anion .
- Step 2
Single bond to each terminal I uses electrons Complete octets on terminal atoms: electrons Remaining electrons on central I: electrons Central atom has bonding pairs and lone pairs
CorrectRemaining electrons on central I: electrons ( complete lone pairs), giving bonding pairs and non-bonding lone pairs
Your electron distribution logic was sound, but carrying forward the incorrect total of electrons led to an odd count of remaining electrons ( lone pairs) rather than electrons ( lone pairs).
- Step 3
Five electron domains adopt a trigonal bipyramidal arrangement. Lone pairs occupy equatorial positions, leaving terminal atoms in axial positions, so the geometry is linear.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly counted valence electrons for each neutral iodine atom.
You correctly allocated bonding pairs and completed terminal octets before assigning remaining electrons to the central atom.
You demonstrated a solid understanding of VSEPR theory by placing lone pairs into equatorial positions of a trigonal bipyramid to establish a linear molecular geometry.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou knew that neutral iodine contributes valence electrons, but you omitted the extra electron supplied by the ionic charge.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisForgetting to adjust the total valence electron tally for polyatomic ions (adding electrons for negative charges and subtracting for positive charges) frequently causes odd electron counts and fractional lone pairs in main-group species.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Account for Net Charge First
For any polyatomic ion with net charge , total valence electrons .
Before drawing any bonds, write out the explicit charge adjustment: add electrons for negative charges and subtract for positive charges.
- Even-Electron Sanity Check
Unless a species is explicitly identified as a free radical, main-group Lewis structures must have an even total valence electron count.
If your electron count is odd or leaves a fractional lone pair ( pairs), immediately recheck the charge of the species.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationAccount for the charge on : .
Form two single bonds , using electrons (leaving ).
Complete octets on both terminal iodine atoms with lone pairs each ( electrons), leaving electrons.
Place the remaining electrons on the central iodine atom as complete lone pairs, giving the central atom bonding pairs and lone pairs ( domains total).
(a) valence electrons; (b) bonding pairs and lone pairs; (c) Lone pairs occupy equatorial sites to minimize repulsions, leaving terminal atoms in axial positions and resulting in a linear molecular geometry.
02 The student places the lone pairs in axial positions rather than equatorial positions, erroneously concluding that the molecular geometry is bent or T-shaped.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
framework with octets on terminal atoms uses electrons. Remaining electrons placed on central as lone pairs. Central iodine has bonding pairs and lone pairs.
- Step 3
Five electron domains adopt a trigonal bipyramidal geometry. Lone pairs occupy the axial positions and equatorial position to be far apart. The bonding pairs occupy equatorial positions at a angle, making the molecular geometry bent.
CorrectAll lone pairs occupy the equatorial positions to minimize unfavorable repulsions. The bonding pairs occupy the axial positions directly opposite each other, resulting in a linear molecular geometry with an bond angle of .
In a trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry, repulsions are far more destabilizing than repulsions. Placing a lone pair in an equatorial position results in only two interactions, whereas placing it in an axial position results in three interactions. Therefore, all lone pairs must occupy equatorial positions, placing the bonding atoms in opposing axial positions to give a linear ion.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the total valence electron count of for the triiodide anion.
You correctly distributed the electrons to find that the central iodine atom holds bonding pairs and non-bonding lone pairs.
You correctly recognized that electron domains around the central atom correspond to a trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou assumed lone pairs should occupy axial positions to stay far apart, overlooking that axial sites experience three severe repulsions compared to only two for equatorial sites.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisIn trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry, electron-electron repulsions at dominate over repulsions at . Because equatorial sites have only two neighbors (the two axial domains) while axial sites have three neighbors (all three equatorial domains), bulky lone pairs always preferentially occupy equatorial positions.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Count $90^\circ$ Repulsions for Trigonal Bipyramidal Sites
An axial site has three neighbors; an equatorial site has only two neighbors.
Always place non-bonding lone pairs into equatorial positions first when working with electron domains.
- Determine Molecular Geometry from Nuclear Positions Only
Molecular geometry describes only the spatial arrangement of bonded atoms, ignoring lone pair positions.
Once equatorial sites are filled with lone pairs, check the alignment of the remaining axial bonds; two opposing axial bonds form a straight line.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationEvaluate the repulsive environments: an equatorial lone pair experiences only two repulsions (with the two axial domains), whereas an axial lone pair experiences three repulsions (with all three equatorial domains).
Because repulsions are the most destabilizing, assign all lone pairs to the equatorial positions around the central iodine atom.
Assign the bonding iodine atoms to the remaining positions, which are the axial positions lying apart along the vertical axis.
Read the resulting molecular geometry from the positions of the three iodine nuclei: the two axial bonds lie in a straight line.
The lone pairs occupy all equatorial positions, and the bonding pairs occupy the axial positions, yielding a strictly linear molecular geometry with an bond angle of .
03 The student forces the central atom to obey an octet rule by making multiple bonds, resulting in incorrect bonding pairs and lone pairs.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
Forms double bonds between central and both terminal atoms to satisfy octets: . Central atom has electrons: bonding pairs and lone pairs.
CorrectConnect with single bonds , complete terminal octets ( electrons), and place the remaining electrons ( lone pairs) on the central iodine atom. Central atom: bonding pairs and lone pairs.
Terminal halogens form single bonds. After assigning electrons to complete the octets of the two terminal iodine atoms and electrons to the two single bonds, the remaining electrons must be placed as lone pairs on the central iodine atom because iodine is in Period 5 and can expand its octet.
- Step 3
There are electron domains around the central iodine atom. Equatorial and axial assignments do not apply because there are only domains. The domains arrange at to minimize repulsion, giving a linear geometry.
CorrectThe central iodine has electron domains adopting a trigonal bipyramidal arrangement. To minimize repulsions, the lone pairs occupy all equatorial positions ( apart), forcing the bonding pairs into opposing axial positions at , producing a linear molecular geometry.
Because your Lewis structure omitted the central lone pairs, you treated the system as having electron domains rather than . Although your final geometry concluded 'linear', you missed the required explanation involving equatorial lone pair placement in a trigonal bipyramid.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly counted the total number of valence electrons, accounting for group contributions and the ionic charge.
You recognized that electron domains arrange themselves to minimize electrostatic repulsion.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that the central iodine atom must strictly adhere to an octet of 8 electrons, leading you to invent double bonds instead of placing the extra valence electrons as lone pairs on the central atom (which can expand its octet due to accessible d-orbitals in Period 5).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Expanded Octet Rule
Atoms in Period 3 or higher on the periodic table can accommodate more than 8 valence electrons.
After completing terminal atom octets with single bonds, always place any leftover valence electrons as lone pairs on the central atom.
- Trigonal Bipyramidal Lone Pair Preference
In a 5-domain trigonal bipyramidal geometry, non-bonding lone pairs always occupy equatorial positions because equatorial sites minimize severe repulsions.
Assign lone pairs to the equatorial belt first; bonding domains will then occupy the remaining axial sites.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationForm single bonds: , using electrons.
Complete octets on terminal iodines: each needs electrons ( lone pairs), using electrons. Total used so far: electrons.
Subtract used electrons from total: electrons remaining ( lone pairs).
Place all remaining electrons onto the central iodine atom, giving it single bonding pairs and lone pairs ( total electron domains).
Apply VSEPR: domains adopt a trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry. Place all lone pairs in equatorial positions to minimize repulsions, leaving the iodine atoms in the axial positions at to give a linear molecular geometry.
(a) valence electrons; (b) single bonding pairs and non-bonding lone pairs on the central iodine atom; (c) The electron domains form a trigonal bipyramidal geometry where the lone pairs occupy equatorial sites to minimize repulsions, leaving the bonded iodine atoms in opposing axial positions, yielding a linear shape ().
Lock it in
How do you adjust the total valence electron count for a polyatomic ion with charge ?
Add electrons for negative charges (anions) and subtract electrons for positive charges (cations): .
Similar question
Determine the total valence electron count and the number of lone pairs on the central iodine atom in the dichloroiodate(I) anion, .
Answer
Total valence electrons: . Bonding uses electrons; terminal chlorines take electrons. Central iodine has non-bonding electrons, which equals lone pairs.
For the tetrachloroiodate(III) anion, : (a) find the total valence electron count, and (b) report the number of bonding pairs and lone pairs around the central iodine atom.
Answer
(a) valence electrons. (b) Four single bonds use electrons; four terminal chlorines use electrons ( used total). Remaining electrons on central iodine: electrons, giving bonding pairs and lone pairs (square planar geometry).
Explain why the triiodide cation, , has a bent molecular geometry whereas the triiodide anion, , has a linear molecular geometry.
Answer
For , total valence electrons . Terminal iodines take electrons (bonds + octets), leaving electrons ( lone pairs) on the central iodine. With bonding pairs and lone pairs ( domains, tetrahedral parent), is bent. In contrast, has electrons ( lone pairs, domains), forcing all lone pairs into equatorial positions and leaving the two bonds along the straight axial axis (, linear).