Resources

A chemical engineer is redesigning the epoxidation of propylene to propylene oxide (C3H6O\text{C}_3\text{H}_6\text{O}, molar mass 58.08 g/mol58.08\text{ g/mol}) to reduce hazardous emissions. The traditional chlorohydrin route yields calcium chloride waste, whereas a greener catalytic process uses aqueous hydrogen peroxide according to the reaction C3H6+H2O2→C3H6O+H2O\text{C}_3\text{H}_6 + \text{H}_2\text{O}_2 \rightarrow \text{C}_3\text{H}_6\text{O} + \text{H}_2\text{O}. Rather than evaluating yield, the plant manager mandates that the Process Mass Intensity (PMI) of the reaction mixture cannot exceed 3.2503.250 to satisfy annual resource reduction targets. The reaction is run with 100.0 g100.0\text{ g} of propylene (C3H6\text{C}_3\text{H}_6, molar mass 42.08 g/mol42.08\text{ g/mol}), 88.93 g88.93\text{ g} of 100%100\% stoichiometric H2O2\text{H}_2\text{O}_2 (molar mass 34.01 g/mol34.01\text{ g/mol}), and a certain mass of recycled methanol solvent msolvm_{\text{solv}}. If the isolated percent yield of propylene oxide is 91.50%91.50\%, solve for the maximum allowable mass of methanol solvent msolvm_{\text{solv}} (in grams) that can be introduced into the batch reactor without exceeding the maximum PMI threshold of 3.2503.250.

Answer and steps

Final answer

msolv=221.7 gm_{\text{solv}} = 221.7\text{ g}

Steps

01

Identify the Limiting Reactant and Theoretical Yield

The balanced chemical equation for the epoxidation of propylene is: CX3HX6+HX2OX2→CX3HX6O+HX2O\ce{C3H6 + H2O2 -> C3H6O + H2O}

From the stoichiometry of the reaction, 1 mol1\text{ mol} of propylene (CX3HX6\ce{C3H6}) reacts with 1 mol1\text{ mol} of hydrogen peroxide (HX2OX2\ce{H2O2}) to yield 1 mol1\text{ mol} of propylene oxide (CX3HX6O\ce{C3H6O}).

Calculate the amount of each reactant:

  • Moles of CX3HX6\ce{C3H6}: nCX3HX6=100.0 g42.08 g/mol≈2.3764 moln_{\ce{C3H6}} = \frac{100.0\text{ g}}{42.08\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2.3764\text{ mol}
  • Moles of HX2OX2\ce{H2O2}: nHX2OX2=88.93 g34.01 g/mol≈2.6148 moln_{\ce{H2O2}} = \frac{88.93\text{ g}}{34.01\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2.6148\text{ mol}

Since nCX3HX6<nHX2OX2n_{\ce{C3H6}} < n_{\ce{H2O2}}, propylene (CX3HX6\ce{C3H6}) is the limiting reactant.

The theoretical yield of propylene oxide (CX3HX6O\ce{C3H6O}, molar mass 58.08 g/mol58.08\text{ g/mol}) is: mPO, theoretical=2.3764 mol×58.08 g/mol≈138.1 gm_{\text{PO, theoretical}} = 2.3764\text{ mol} \times 58.08\text{ g/mol} \approx 138.1\text{ g}


02

Determine the Actual (Isolated) Yield of Product

Given an isolated yield of 91.50%91.50\%: mPO, isolated=mPO, theoretical×0.9150=138.1 g×0.9150≈126.36 gm_{\text{PO, isolated}} = m_{\text{PO, theoretical}} \times 0.9150 = 138.1\text{ g} \times 0.9150 \approx 126.36\text{ g}


03

Apply the Process Mass Intensity (PMI) Definition

Process Mass Intensity (PMI\text{PMI}) is defined as the ratio of the total mass of all input materials (reactants, reagents, solvents, and catalysts) to the mass of the isolated target product: PMI=mtotal, inputmproduct\text{PMI} = \frac{m_{\text{total, input}}}{m_{\text{product}}}

The total input mass consists of propylene, hydrogen peroxide, and the methanol solvent: mtotal, input=mCX3HX6+mHX2OX2+msolv=100.0 g+88.93 g+msolv=188.93 g+msolvm_{\text{total, input}} = m_{\ce{C3H6}} + m_{\ce{H2O2}} + m_{\text{solv}} = 100.0\text{ g} + 88.93\text{ g} + m_{\text{solv}} = 188.93\text{ g} + m_{\text{solv}}

To meet the target, the condition is: PMI≤3.250\text{PMI} \le 3.250

188.93 g+msolv126.36 g≤3.250\frac{188.93\text{ g} + m_{\text{solv}}}{126.36\text{ g}} \le 3.250


04

Solve for the Maximum Mass of Solvent

Multiply by the mass of isolated product and solve for msolvm_{\text{solv}}: 188.93 g+msolv≤3.250×126.36 g188.93\text{ g} + m_{\text{solv}} \le 3.250 \times 126.36\text{ g} 188.93 g+msolv≤410.67 g188.93\text{ g} + m_{\text{solv}} \le 410.67\text{ g} msolv≤410.67 g−188.93 g=221.74 gm_{\text{solv}} \le 410.67\text{ g} - 188.93\text{ g} = 221.74\text{ g}

Rounding to one decimal place consistent with the target specifications: msolv=221.7 gm_{\text{solv}} = 221.7\text{ g}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student uses the theoretical yield rather than the actual isolated product mass in the denominator of the Process Mass Intensity formula, underestimating product needed and calculating an incorrectly high solvent mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    n(C3H6)=100.042.08=2.3764 mol  ⟹  Theoretical yield of C3H6O=2.3764×58.08=138.02 gn(\text{C}_3\text{H}_6) = \frac{100.0}{42.08} = 2.3764\text{ mol} \implies \text{Theoretical yield of } \text{C}_3\text{H}_6\text{O} = 2.3764 \times 58.08 = 138.02\text{ g}

  2. Step 2

    PMI=Total input massTheoretical product mass=3.250\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total input mass}}{\text{Theoretical product mass}} = 3.250

    Correct

    mPO, isolated=138.02 g×0.9150=126.29 g  ⟹  PMI=mtotal, inputmproduct, isolated≤3.250m_{\text{PO, isolated}} = 138.02\text{ g} \times 0.9150 = 126.29\text{ g} \implies \text{PMI} = \frac{m_{\text{total, input}}}{m_{\text{product, isolated}}} \le 3.250

    Process Mass Intensity (PMI) is defined using the actual isolated mass of the target product in the denominator, not the theoretical yield.

  3. Step 3

    100.0+88.93+msolv138.02=3.250  ⟹  188.93+msolv=448.57  ⟹  msolv=259.64 g\frac{100.0 + 88.93 + m_{\text{solv}}}{138.02} = 3.250 \implies 188.93 + m_{\text{solv}} = 448.57 \implies m_{\text{solv}} = 259.64\text{ g}

    Correct

    188.93 g+msolv126.36 g≤3.250  ⟹  188.93 g+msolv≤410.67 g  ⟹  msolv≤221.7 g\frac{188.93\text{ g} + m_{\text{solv}}}{126.36\text{ g}} \le 3.250 \implies 188.93\text{ g} + m_{\text{solv}} \le 410.67\text{ g} \implies m_{\text{solv}} \le 221.7\text{ g}

    Your algebraic rearrangement was executed properly, but substituting the theoretical yield rather than the actual isolated mass carried the error forward into the final solvent mass.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the molar amount of propylene and determined the theoretical mass of propylene oxide.

You accurately summed the input masses of reactants and solvent in the numerator.

You solved the linear algebraic equation with sound arithmetic.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
PMI Denominator Misconception

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated Process Mass Intensity as a theoretical green chemistry metric rather than an operational metric based on actual isolated product mass. Because actual reactions do not achieve 100% yield, using theoretical yield artificially inflates the denominator and underestimates the true mass intensity, leading to an allowable solvent mass that is too high.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
PMI Definition
  • PMI=∑minputsmisolated product\text{PMI} = \frac{\sum m_{\text{inputs}}}{m_{\text{isolated product}}}

  • Always multiply theoretical yield by the isolated percent yield before placing the mass of product in the denominator.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the isolated product mass: misolated=138.02 g×0.9150=126.29 gm_{\text{isolated}} = 138.02\text{ g} \times 0.9150 = 126.29\text{ g} (or 126.36 g126.36\text{ g} using unrounded moles).

  2. Set up the PMI inequality: 188.93 g+msolv126.36 g≤3.250\frac{188.93\text{ g} + m_{\text{solv}}}{126.36\text{ g}} \le 3.250.

  3. Multiply both sides by 126.36 g126.36\text{ g}: 188.93 g+msolv≤410.67 g188.93\text{ g} + m_{\text{solv}} \le 410.67\text{ g}.

  4. Subtract 188.93 g188.93\text{ g}: msolv≤221.74 gm_{\text{solv}} \le 221.74\text{ g}.

Final answer

msolv=221.7 gm_{\text{solv}} = 221.7\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the formal ACS Green Chemistry Institute definitions for green metrics (PMI, E-factor, and Atom Economy).

  • Distinguish metrics that use stoichiometry/theory (such as Atom Economy) from metrics that measure real plant material flows (such as PMI and E-factor).

  • Practice calculating PMI when isolated yields vary between 70%70\% and 95%95\%.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses Process Mass Intensity with E-factor and subtracts the product mass from the numerator, yielding an incorrect solvent mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    n(C3H6)=100.042.08=2.3764 mol  ⟹  Theoretical mass=2.3764×58.08=138.02 g  ⟹  m(product)=138.02×0.9150=126.29 gn(\text{C}_3\text{H}_6) = \frac{100.0}{42.08} = 2.3764\text{ mol} \implies \text{Theoretical mass} = 2.3764 \times 58.08 = 138.02\text{ g} \implies m(\text{product}) = 138.02 \times 0.9150 = 126.29\text{ g}

  2. Step 2

    PMI=(Total mass in−mass of product)mass of product  ⟹  (100.0+88.93+msolv−126.29)126.29=3.250\text{PMI} = \frac{(\text{Total mass in} - \text{mass of product})}{\text{mass of product}} \implies \frac{(100.0 + 88.93 + m_{\text{solv}} - 126.29)}{126.29} = 3.250

    Correct

    PMI=mtotal inputmproduct=100.0+88.93+msolv126.29≤3.250\text{PMI} = \frac{m_{\text{total input}}}{m_{\text{product}}} = \frac{100.0 + 88.93 + m_{\text{solv}}}{126.29} \le 3.250

    Process Mass Intensity (PMI) is the ratio of total input mass to target product mass, with nothing subtracted from the numerator. The expression mtotal input−mproductmproduct\frac{m_{\text{total input}} - m_{\text{product}}}{m_{\text{product}}} defines the E-factor (waste per unit product), not PMI.

  3. Step 3

    62.64+msolv=410.44  ⟹  msolv=347.80 g62.64 + m_{\text{solv}} = 410.44 \implies m_{\text{solv}} = 347.80\text{ g}

    Correct

    188.93+msolv=410.44  ⟹  msolv≤221.7 g188.93 + m_{\text{solv}} = 410.44 \implies m_{\text{solv}} \le 221.7\text{ g}

    Your algebraic rearrangement was carried out correctly, but the numerical answer is shifted by exactly the product mass (126.29 g126.29\text{ g}) due to the definition error in Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified propylene as the limiting reagent.

You accurately calculated the theoretical and isolated yields of propylene oxide.

You correctly identified all three components of the total input mass.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating PMI with E-Factor

You subtracted the product mass from the total input mass in the numerator, calculating the E-factor instead of Process Mass Intensity.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflation of two closely related green chemistry metrics: E-factor measures total waste generated per unit product (mtotal−mproductmproduct\frac{m_{\text{total}} - m_{\text{product}}}{m_{\text{product}}}), whereas PMI measures total raw materials consumed per unit product (mtotalmproduct\frac{m_{\text{total}}}{m_{\text{product}}}). Notice the direct identity PMI=E-factor+1\text{PMI} = \text{E-factor} + 1.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
PMI vs. E-Factor Definition
  • PMI=∑minputsmproduct\text{PMI} = \frac{\sum m_{\text{inputs}}}{m_{\text{product}}} and E-factor=mwastemproduct=PMI−1\text{E-factor} = \frac{m_{\text{waste}}}{m_{\text{product}}} = \text{PMI} - 1.

  • When a problem specifies PMI, place the raw sum of all reactant and solvent inputs directly in the numerator without subtracting the product mass.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the PMI inequality without subtracting product mass: 100.0 g+88.93 g+msolv126.29 g≤3.250\frac{100.0\text{ g} + 88.93\text{ g} + m_{\text{solv}}}{126.29\text{ g}} \le 3.250

  2. Combine the known input masses in the numerator: 188.93 g+msolv≤3.250×126.29 g=410.44 g188.93\text{ g} + m_{\text{solv}} \le 3.250 \times 126.29\text{ g} = 410.44\text{ g}

  3. Subtract 188.93 g188.93\text{ g} from both sides to find the maximum solvent mass: msolv≤410.44 g−188.93 g=221.51 gm_{\text{solv}} \le 410.44\text{ g} - 188.93\text{ g} = 221.51\text{ g} (or 221.7 g221.7\text{ g} using unrounded product mass)

Final answer

msolv=221.7 gm_{\text{solv}} = 221.7\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definitions of PMI, E-factor, and Atom Economy side by side.

  • Memorize the relationship PMI=E-factor+1\text{PMI} = \text{E-factor} + 1 to quickly catch numerator confusion.

  • Practice solving for solvent limits using both PMI and E-factor targets to solidify the distinction.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student inverts the PMI ratio by placing product mass in the numerator and total input mass in the denominator.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    n(C3H6)=100.042.08=2.3764 mol  ⟹  m(product)=2.3764×58.08×0.9150=126.29 gn(\text{C}_3\text{H}_6) = \frac{100.0}{42.08} = 2.3764\text{ mol} \implies m(\text{product}) = 2.3764 \times 58.08 \times 0.9150 = 126.29\text{ g}

  2. Step 2

    PMI=m(product)Total input mass=3.250  ⟹  126.29(188.93+msolv)=3.250\text{PMI} = \frac{m(\text{product})}{\text{Total input mass}} = 3.250 \implies \frac{126.29}{(188.93 + m_{\text{solv}})} = 3.250

    Correct

    PMI=Total input massm(product)≤3.250  ⟹  188.93 g+msolv126.3 g≤3.250\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total input mass}}{m(\text{product})} \le 3.250 \implies \frac{188.93\text{ g} + m_{\text{solv}}}{126.3\text{ g}} \le 3.250

    Process Mass Intensity is defined as the total mass of all raw material inputs divided by the mass of isolated product, not product over inputs.

  3. Step 3

    188.93+msolv=38.86  ⟹  msolv=−150.07 g188.93 + m_{\text{solv}} = 38.86 \implies m_{\text{solv}} = -150.07\text{ g}

    Correct

    188.93 g+msolv≤3.250×126.3 g=410.5 g  ⟹  msolv≤221.7 g188.93\text{ g} + m_{\text{solv}} \le 3.250 \times 126.3\text{ g} = 410.5\text{ g} \implies m_{\text{solv}} \le 221.7\text{ g}

    Solving your inverted equation yielded an impossible negative mass (msolv=−150.07 gm_{\text{solv}} = -150.07\text{ g}).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified propylene as the limiting reagent and found its molar quantity.

You accurately calculated the isolated mass of propylene oxide using the given molar mass and percent yield.

You correctly summed the masses of the active chemical inputs (100.0 g+88.93 g=188.93 g100.0\text{ g} + 88.93\text{ g} = 188.93\text{ g}).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Definition of PMI

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused Process Mass Intensity (PMI) with a mass efficiency or mass productivity metric (such as mproductminputs\frac{m_{\text{product}}}{m_{\text{inputs}}}). Because PMI measures the intensity of resource consumption per unit of product, it is defined as ∑minputsmproduct\frac{\sum m_{\text{inputs}}}{m_{\text{product}}} and is always greater than or equal to 11.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Definition of Process Mass Intensity
  • PMI=Total mass of all input materials (reactants, solvents, reagents)Mass of isolated target product\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total mass of all input materials (reactants, solvents, reagents)}}{\text{Mass of isolated target product}}

  • Place the sum of all inputs into the reactor in the numerator and the isolated product mass in the denominator.

Physical Sanity Check
  • Since input mass is always greater than or equal to the isolated product mass by conservation of mass, PMI≥1\text{PMI} \ge 1.

  • If your calculated solvent or input mass turns out negative, check whether you accidentally inverted the ratio.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the correct ratio: PMI=mtotal, inputmproduct=188.93 g+msolv126.36 g≤3.250\text{PMI} = \frac{m_{\text{total, input}}}{m_{\text{product}}} = \frac{188.93\text{ g} + m_{\text{solv}}}{126.36\text{ g}} \le 3.250.

  2. Multiply both sides by 126.36 g126.36\text{ g}: 188.93 g+msolv≤410.67 g188.93\text{ g} + m_{\text{solv}} \le 410.67\text{ g}.

  3. Subtract 188.93 g188.93\text{ g} from both sides: msolv≤221.74 gm_{\text{solv}} \le 221.74\text{ g}.

Final answer

msolv=221.7 gm_{\text{solv}} = 221.7\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the key green chemistry metric: PMI=∑minputsmproduct\text{PMI} = \frac{\sum m_{\text{inputs}}}{m_{\text{product}}} (ideal is 11).

  • Notice that mass productivity is the reciprocal of PMI: Mass Productivity=1PMI×100%\text{Mass Productivity} = \frac{1}{\text{PMI}} \times 100\%.

  • Always verify that intermediate and final mass values are strictly positive.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A synthesis uses 50.0 g50.0\text{ g} of starting material and 150.0 g150.0\text{ g} of solvent. The theoretical yield of the purified active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) is 40.0 g40.0\text{ g}, but the reaction runs at an isolated yield of 85.0%85.0\%. Calculate the Process Mass Intensity (PMI) of the process.

Answer

PMI=5.88\text{PMI} = 5.88. Key steps: Isolated yield m=40.0 g×0.850=34.0 gm = 40.0\text{ g} \times 0.850 = 34.0\text{ g}. Total input mass =50.0 g+150.0 g=200.0 g= 50.0\text{ g} + 150.0\text{ g} = 200.0\text{ g}. PMI=200.0 g34.0 g≈5.88\text{PMI} = \frac{200.0\text{ g}}{34.0\text{ g}} \approx 5.88.

02

An esterification process requires 60.0 g60.0\text{ g} acetic acid, 74.0 g74.0\text{ g} butanol, and 5.0 g5.0\text{ g} sulfuric acid catalyst. The isolated yield of butyl acetate is 75.0%75.0\%. The theoretical yield is 116.2 g116.2\text{ g}. To keep the PMI under 2.502.50, what is the maximum mass of wash water that can be added during workup?

Answer

mwater=78.9 gm_{\text{water}} = 78.9\text{ g}. Key steps: Isolated product mass =116.2 g×0.750=87.15 g= 116.2\text{ g} \times 0.750 = 87.15\text{ g}. Maximum allowable total input mass =2.50×87.15 g=217.88 g= 2.50 \times 87.15\text{ g} = 217.88\text{ g}. Current inputs =60.0+74.0+5.0=139.0 g= 60.0 + 74.0 + 5.0 = 139.0\text{ g}. Maximum wash water =217.88 g−139.0 g=78.88 g≈78.9 g= 217.88\text{ g} - 139.0\text{ g} = 78.88\text{ g} \approx 78.9\text{ g}.

03

A continuous flow reactor converts 120.0 kg/h120.0\text{ kg/h} of reactant into a polymer. The reaction requires 30.0 kg/h30.0\text{ kg/h} of initiator and a solvent feed rate RsolvR_{\text{solv}}. The isolated yield of polymer is 90.0%90.0\%, giving 108.0 kg/h108.0\text{ kg/h} of isolated polymer. If solvent recovery recycles 80%80\% of the solvent, the plant manager defines Effective PMI using only virgin (fresh) inputs. If the virgin PMI threshold is 2.0002.000, calculate the maximum allowable total solvent circulation rate RsolvR_{\text{solv}} assuming all fresh inputs include reactants, initiator, and make-up (unrecycled) solvent.

Answer

Rsolv=330 kg/hR_{\text{solv}} = 330\text{ kg/h}. Key steps: Total virgin inputs allowed =2.000×108.0 kg/h=216.0 kg/h= 2.000 \times 108.0\text{ kg/h} = 216.0\text{ kg/h}. Virgin reactant + initiator =120.0+30.0=150.0 kg/h= 120.0 + 30.0 = 150.0\text{ kg/h}. Allowable make-up solvent =216.0−150.0=66.0 kg/h= 216.0 - 150.0 = 66.0\text{ kg/h}. Since make-up solvent is 20%20\% of total solvent circulation (1−0.801 - 0.80), 0.20×Rsolv=66.0 kg/h  ⟹  Rsolv=330 kg/h0.20 \times R_{\text{solv}} = 66.0\text{ kg/h} \implies R_{\text{solv}} = 330\text{ kg/h}.

Loading workspace…