Resources

A student analyzes an element consisting of two isotopes, 107Ag^{107}\text{Ag} (106.905 amu106.905\text{ amu}) and 109Ag^{109}\text{Ag} (108.905 amu108.905\text{ amu}), with natural abundances of 51.84%51.84\% and 48.16%48.16\%, respectively. If the student commits a frequent sign and deviation error by expressing the average mass as mˉ=m1−f2(m2−m1)\bar{m} = m_1 - f_2(m_2 - m_1) instead of using the proper weighted sum convention mˉ=m1+f2(m2−m1)\bar{m} = m_1 + f_2(m_2 - m_1), calculate both the incorrect atomic mass obtained and the correct standard average atomic mass to five significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Incorrect value =105.94 amu= 105.94\text{ amu}; Correct standard average atomic mass =107.87 amu= 107.87\text{ amu}

Steps

01

Identify the Given Isotopic Data

For an element with two naturally occurring isotopes:

  • Isotope 1 (107Ag^{107}\ce{Ag}):
    • Mass, m1=106.905 amum_1 = 106.905\text{ amu}
    • Abundance, p1=51.84%  ⟹  p_1 = 51.84\% \implies fractional abundance f1=0.5184f_1 = 0.5184
  • Isotope 2 (109Ag^{109}\ce{Ag}):
    • Mass, m2=108.905 amum_2 = 108.905\text{ amu}
    • Abundance, p2=48.16%  ⟹  p_2 = 48.16\% \implies fractional abundance f2=0.4816f_2 = 0.4816

02

Understand the Weighted Average Formula

The standard average atomic mass mˉ\bar{m} is the weighted sum of all isotopic masses: mˉ=f1m1+f2m2\bar{m} = f_1 m_1 + f_2 m_2

Because f1+f2=1f_1 + f_2 = 1, we can substitute f1=1−f2f_1 = 1 - f_2: mˉ=(1−f2)m1+f2m2=m1+f2(m2−m1)\bar{m} = (1 - f_2)m_1 + f_2 m_2 = m_1 + f_2(m_2 - m_1)

This formulation views the average atomic mass as the baseline mass m1m_1 shifted upward toward m2m_2 by a fractional distance equal to f2f_2.

Calculate the mass difference between the two isotopes: m2−m1=108.905 amu−106.905 amu=2.000 amum_2 - m_1 = 108.905\text{ amu} - 106.905\text{ amu} = 2.000\text{ amu}

Calculate the shift term: f2(m2−m1)=0.4816⋅2.000 amu=0.9632 amuf_2(m_2 - m_1) = 0.4816 \cdot 2.000\text{ amu} = 0.9632\text{ amu}


03

Calculate the Incorrect Value

Using the student's erroneous equation with a negative sign: mˉincorrect=m1−f2(m2−m1)\bar{m}_{\text{incorrect}} = m_1 - f_2(m_2 - m_1) mˉincorrect=106.905 amu−0.9632 amu=105.9418 amu\bar{m}_{\text{incorrect}} = 106.905\text{ amu} - 0.9632\text{ amu} = 105.9418\text{ amu}

Rounding to five significant figures gives: mˉincorrect=105.94 amu\bar{m}_{\text{incorrect}} = 105.94\text{ amu}


04

Calculate the Correct Standard Average Atomic Mass

Using the proper weighted sum convention: mˉcorrect=m1+f2(m2−m1)\bar{m}_{\text{correct}} = m_1 + f_2(m_2 - m_1) mˉcorrect=106.905 amu+0.9632 amu=107.8682 amu\bar{m}_{\text{correct}} = 106.905\text{ amu} + 0.9632\text{ amu} = 107.8682\text{ amu}

Rounding to five significant figures gives: mˉcorrect=107.87 amu\bar{m}_{\text{correct}} = 107.87\text{ amu}


05

Conceptual Pitfall & Sanity Check

  • Range Rule: The weighted average of two values must always lie strictly between the smallest and largest values: m1<mˉ<m2m_1 < \bar{m} < m_2 Here, 106.905 amu<107.87 amu<108.905 amu106.905\text{ amu} < 107.87\text{ amu} < 108.905\text{ amu}, confirming the correct result.
  • The incorrect result, 105.94 amu105.94\text{ amu}, is less than the mass of the lightest isotope (106.905 amu106.905\text{ amu}). A weighted average can never lie outside the range of its components; getting a value smaller than the lightest isotope immediately signals a sign error in the shift formula.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student uses the abundance of the first isotope rather than the second in the deviation term, altering the mass shifts.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    mˉincorrect=106.905−0.5184×(108.905−106.905)  ⟹  mˉincorrect=105.87 amu\bar{m}_{\text{incorrect}} = 106.905 - 0.5184 \times (108.905 - 106.905) \implies \bar{m}_{\text{incorrect}} = 105.87\text{ amu}

    Correct

    mˉincorrect=106.905−0.4816×(108.905−106.905)  ⟹  mˉincorrect=105.94 amu\bar{m}_{\text{incorrect}} = 106.905 - 0.4816 \times (108.905 - 106.905) \implies \bar{m}_{\text{incorrect}} = 105.94\text{ amu}

    You used 0.51840.5184 for the fractional abundance in the deviation term instead of f2=0.4816f_2 = 0.4816, which belongs to 109Ag^{109}\text{Ag}.

  2. Step 2

    mˉcorrect=106.905+0.5184×(108.905−106.905)  ⟹  mˉcorrect=107.94 amu\bar{m}_{\text{correct}} = 106.905 + 0.5184 \times (108.905 - 106.905) \implies \bar{m}_{\text{correct}} = 107.94\text{ amu}

    Correct

    mˉcorrect=106.905+0.4816×(108.905−106.905)  ⟹  mˉcorrect=107.87 amu\bar{m}_{\text{correct}} = 106.905 + 0.4816 \times (108.905 - 106.905) \implies \bar{m}_{\text{correct}} = 107.87\text{ amu}

    You repeated the substitution mistake by using f1=0.5184f_1 = 0.5184 rather than f2=0.4816f_2 = 0.4816, shifting the baseline mass by the wrong weighting factor.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the baseline mass m1=106.905 amum_1 = 106.905\text{ amu} and computed the mass difference m2−m1=2.000 amum_2 - m_1 = 2.000\text{ amu}.

You correctly followed the requested signs for both the erroneous equation and the standard deviation equation.

You maintained proper arithmetic and rounded both final values to five significant figures.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Isotope Abundance Misassignment

You grabbed the first listed percentage (51.84%51.84\%) for the deviation coefficient instead of matching f2f_2 to the second isotope (48.16%48.16\%).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In the baseline deviation identity mˉ=m1+f2(m2−m1)\bar{m} = m_1 + f_2(m_2 - m_1), the shift from m1m_1 toward m2m_2 is weighted by the fraction of the second isotope (f2f_2), not the baseline isotope (f1f_1). Confusing the indices leads to shifting by the wrong proportion.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Deriving the Baseline Shift
  • mˉ=f1m1+f2m2=(1−f2)m1+f2m2=m1+f2(m2−m1)\bar{m} = f_1 m_1 + f_2 m_2 = (1 - f_2)m_1 + f_2 m_2 = m_1 + f_2(m_2 - m_1)

  • Always verify that the fraction multiplying (m2−m1)(m_2 - m_1) corresponds to isotope 2.

Symmetry Sanity Check
  • Because 107Ag^{107}\text{Ag} (51.84%51.84\%) is slightly more abundant than 109Ag^{109}\text{Ag} (48.16%48.16\%), the average atomic mass must lie slightly closer to m1m_1 than to m2m_2 (i.e., less than the midpoint 107.905 amu107.905\text{ amu}).

  • Check whether your calculated average lies on the side of the more abundant isotope.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute m1=106.905 amum_1 = 106.905\text{ amu}, m2−m1=2.000 amum_2 - m_1 = 2.000\text{ amu}, and f2=0.4816f_2 = 0.4816 into the incorrect equation: mˉincorrect=106.905−0.4816×2.000=106.905−0.9632=105.9418 amu\bar{m}_{\text{incorrect}} = 106.905 - 0.4816 \times 2.000 = 106.905 - 0.9632 = 105.9418\text{ amu}.

  2. Round mˉincorrect\bar{m}_{\text{incorrect}} to five significant figures: 105.94 amu105.94\text{ amu}.

  3. Substitute the same values into the correct equation: mˉcorrect=106.905+0.4816×2.000=106.905+0.9632=107.8682 amu\bar{m}_{\text{correct}} = 106.905 + 0.4816 \times 2.000 = 106.905 + 0.9632 = 107.8682\text{ amu}.

  4. Round mˉcorrect\bar{m}_{\text{correct}} to five significant figures: 107.87 amu107.87\text{ amu}.

Final answer

Incorrect value =105.94 amu= 105.94\text{ amu}; Correct standard average atomic mass =107.87 amu= 107.87\text{ amu}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Explicitly list m1,f1m_1, f_1 and m2,f2m_2, f_2 before plugging them into algebraic formulas.

  • Compare the result to the midpoint of the two isotope masses to verify which isotope pulls the average more strongly.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates an unweighted arithmetic mean of the isotopic masses instead of weighting them by natural abundances.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    mˉincorrect=106.905−0.4816×(108.905−106.905)  ⟹  mˉincorrect=106.905−0.9632=105.94 amu\bar{m}_{\text{incorrect}} = 106.905 - 0.4816 \times (108.905 - 106.905) \implies \bar{m}_{\text{incorrect}} = 106.905 - 0.9632 = 105.94\text{ amu}

  2. Step 2

    mˉcorrect=106.905+108.9052  ⟹  mˉcorrect=215.8102=107.91 amu\bar{m}_{\text{correct}} = \frac{106.905 + 108.905}{2} \implies \bar{m}_{\text{correct}} = \frac{215.810}{2} = 107.91\text{ amu}

    Correct

    mˉcorrect=m1+f2(m2−m1)=106.905+0.4816(2.000)=107.87 amu\bar{m}_{\text{correct}} = m_1 + f_2(m_2 - m_1) = 106.905 + 0.4816(2.000) = 107.87\text{ amu}

    You calculated a simple arithmetic mean by dividing the sum of the isotopic masses by 22. Because the two isotopes do not have equal 50%/50%50\% / 50\% abundances, you must weight each mass by its fractional abundance or apply mˉ=m1+f2(m2−m1)\bar{m} = m_1 + f_2(m_2 - m_1).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted the isotopic values into the negative-shift formula to find the incorrect mass.

You followed significant figure rules appropriately in your arithmetic.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unweighted arithmetic average instead of weighted isotopic sum

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated both isotopes as equally abundant by dividing their sum by 2, overlooking that average atomic mass must be weighted by the respective natural abundances (51.84%51.84\% and 48.16%48.16\%).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Weighted Average vs. Simple Mean
  • An element's average atomic mass is mˉ=f1m1+f2m2\bar{m} = f_1 m_1 + f_2 m_2, which simplifies to m1+m22\frac{m_1 + m_2}{2} only when f1=f2=0.50f_1 = f_2 = 0.50.

  • Multiply each isotopic mass by its decimal abundance (or add the abundance-weighted deviation f2(m2−m1)f_2(m_2 - m_1) to m1m_1) instead of dividing the sum by 2.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the natural abundances as fractions: f1=0.5184f_1 = 0.5184 and f2=0.4816f_2 = 0.4816.

  2. Apply the proper weighted sum convention: mˉcorrect=m1+f2(m2−m1)\bar{m}_{\text{correct}} = m_1 + f_2(m_2 - m_1).

  3. Substitute the given masses: mˉcorrect=106.905+0.4816(108.905−106.905)\bar{m}_{\text{correct}} = 106.905 + 0.4816(108.905 - 106.905).

  4. Evaluate the product and sum: mˉcorrect=106.905+0.9632=107.8682 amu\bar{m}_{\text{correct}} = 106.905 + 0.9632 = 107.8682\text{ amu}.

  5. Round to five significant figures: 107.87 amu107.87\text{ amu}.

Final answer

Incorrect value =105.94 amu= 105.94\text{ amu}; Correct standard average atomic mass =107.87 amu= 107.87\text{ amu}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remember that a simple average m1+m22\frac{m_1 + m_2}{2} is only valid if both isotopes are equally abundant at exactly 50%50\%.

  • Check that your final average lies closer to the mass of the more abundant isotope (since 107Ag^{107}\text{Ag} is 51.84%51.84\%, mˉ\bar{m} must be closer to 106.905 amu106.905\text{ amu} than to 108.905 amu108.905\text{ amu}).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student substitutes the natural abundance as a whole-number percentage instead of converting it to a decimal fraction.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    mˉincorrect=106.905−48.16×2.000  ⟹  mˉincorrect=106.905−96.32=10.585 amu\bar{m}_{\text{incorrect}} = 106.905 - 48.16 \times 2.000 \implies \bar{m}_{\text{incorrect}} = 106.905 - 96.32 = 10.585\text{ amu}

    Correct

    mˉincorrect=106.905−0.4816×2.000=106.905−0.9632=105.94 amu\bar{m}_{\text{incorrect}} = 106.905 - 0.4816 \times 2.000 = 106.905 - 0.9632 = 105.94\text{ amu}

    You substituted the percent abundance 48.1648.16 directly instead of dividing by 100100 to obtain the decimal fraction f2=0.4816f_2 = 0.4816. Subtracting 96.32 amu96.32\text{ amu} instead of 0.9632 amu0.9632\text{ amu} led to an incorrect mass of 10.585 amu10.585\text{ amu} instead of 105.94 amu105.94\text{ amu}.

  2. Step 2

    mˉcorrect=106.905+48.16×2.000  ⟹  mˉcorrect=106.905+96.32=203.23 amu\bar{m}_{\text{correct}} = 106.905 + 48.16 \times 2.000 \implies \bar{m}_{\text{correct}} = 106.905 + 96.32 = 203.23\text{ amu}

    Correct

    mˉcorrect=106.905+0.4816×2.000=106.905+0.9632=107.87 amu\bar{m}_{\text{correct}} = 106.905 + 0.4816 \times 2.000 = 106.905 + 0.9632 = 107.87\text{ amu}

    You repeated the same conversion error by adding 96.32 amu96.32\text{ amu} rather than 0.9632 amu0.9632\text{ amu}. A weighted average of two isotopes must lie between their respective masses (106.905 amu<mˉ<108.905 amu106.905\text{ amu} < \bar{m} < 108.905\text{ amu}), so obtaining 203.23 amu203.23\text{ amu} is a clear sign that the abundance was not converted to a decimal.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified m1=106.905 amum_1 = 106.905\text{ amu} as the baseline mass.

You accurately calculated the difference between the isotopic masses as m2−m1=2.000 amum_2 - m_1 = 2.000\text{ amu}.

You correctly applied both the required subtraction and addition operations specified in the problem statement.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Percent Abundance vs. Decimal Fraction

You entered 48.1648.16 rather than 0.48160.4816 for the fractional abundance f2f_2.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Treating percentage abundance p%p\% as an unscaled weight in a weighted sum formula without converting it to a fractional abundance f=p100f = \frac{p}{100}. Because the weights must sum to 11, using whole percentages inflates the contribution of the second isotope by a factor of 100100.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Fractional Abundance Conversion
  • Fractional abundances must satisfy ∑fi=1\sum f_i = 1, which requires fi=% abundance100f_i = \frac{\%\text{ abundance}}{100}.

  • Always convert every percentage to a decimal fraction (e.g., 48.16%  ⟹  0.481648.16\% \implies 0.4816) before multiplying by mass or mass differences.

Weighted Average Range Check
  • The average atomic mass mˉ\bar{m} must strictly satisfy mmin<mˉ<mmaxm_{\text{min}} < \bar{m} < m_{\text{max}}.

  • After calculating, verify that your result falls strictly between the lightest isotope's mass and the heaviest isotope's mass.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert the abundance: f2=48.16%100%=0.4816f_2 = \frac{48.16\%}{100\%} = 0.4816.

  2. Calculate the shift term: f2(m2−m1)=0.4816×2.000 amu=0.9632 amuf_2(m_2 - m_1) = 0.4816 \times 2.000\text{ amu} = 0.9632\text{ amu}.

  3. Compute the incorrect value: mˉincorrect=106.905 amu−0.9632 amu=105.9418 amu≈105.94 amu\bar{m}_{\text{incorrect}} = 106.905\text{ amu} - 0.9632\text{ amu} = 105.9418\text{ amu} \approx 105.94\text{ amu}.

  4. Compute the correct standard mass: mˉcorrect=106.905 amu+0.9632 amu=107.8682 amu≈107.87 amu\bar{m}_{\text{correct}} = 106.905\text{ amu} + 0.9632\text{ amu} = 107.8682\text{ amu} \approx 107.87\text{ amu}.

Final answer

Incorrect value =105.94 amu= 105.94\text{ amu}; Correct standard average atomic mass =107.87 amu= 107.87\text{ amu}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Convert all given percentages to decimal fractions immediately upon listing your known variables.

  • Perform a quick bounds check: if your average mass is greater than the heaviest isotope or smaller than the lightest isotope, inspect your abundance values for an omitted division by 100100.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A sample of europium consists of 151Eu^{151}\text{Eu} (150.920 amu150.920\text{ amu}, 47.81%47.81\%) and 153Eu^{153}\text{Eu} (152.921 amu152.921\text{ amu}, 52.19%52.19\%). Use the deviation formula mˉ=m1+f2(m2−m1)\bar{m} = m_1 + f_2(m_2 - m_1) to calculate the average atomic mass to five significant figures.

Answer

151.96 amu151.96\text{ amu}. Key steps: m2−m1=152.921−150.920=2.001 amum_2 - m_1 = 152.921 - 150.920 = 2.001\text{ amu}; shift term =0.5219×2.001=1.0443 amu= 0.5219 \times 2.001 = 1.0443\text{ amu}; mˉ=150.920+1.0443=151.9643 amu≈151.96 amu\bar{m} = 150.920 + 1.0443 = 151.9643\text{ amu} \approx 151.96\text{ amu}.

02

Chlorine has two stable isotopes: 35Cl^{35}\text{Cl} (34.969 amu34.969\text{ amu}, 75.78%75.78\%) and 37Cl^{37}\text{Cl} (36.966 amu36.966\text{ amu}, 24.22%24.22\%). If a student accidentally computes mˉ=m1+f1(m2−m1)\bar{m} = m_1 + f_1(m_2 - m_1), determine the percentage error of this mistaken result compared to the true average atomic mass.

Answer

2.84%2.84\% error. Key steps: True shift =0.2422×(1.997)=0.4837 amu  ⟹  mˉtrue=35.453 amu= 0.2422 \times (1.997) = 0.4837\text{ amu} \implies \bar{m}_{\text{true}} = 35.453\text{ amu}. Erroneous shift =0.7578×(1.997)=1.5133 amu  ⟹  mˉerr=36.482 amu= 0.7578 \times (1.997) = 1.5133\text{ amu} \implies \bar{m}_{\text{err}} = 36.482\text{ amu}. Error =∣36.482−35.453∣35.453×100%≈2.84%= \frac{|36.482 - 35.453|}{35.453} \times 100\% \approx 2.84\%.

03

An element has three isotopes: m1=20.00 amum_1 = 20.00\text{ amu} (90.00%90.00\%) as the baseline, m2=21.00 amum_2 = 21.00\text{ amu} (0.30%0.30\%), and m3=22.00 amum_3 = 22.00\text{ amu} (9.70%9.70\%). Generalize the baseline shift formula to mˉ=m1+f2(m2−m1)+f3(m3−m1)\bar{m} = m_1 + f_2(m_2 - m_1) + f_3(m_3 - m_1) and find the average atomic mass to four significant figures.

Answer

20.20 amu20.20\text{ amu}. Key steps: Shift from m2=0.0030×(1.00)=0.0030 amum_2 = 0.0030 \times (1.00) = 0.0030\text{ amu}; shift from m3=0.0970×(2.00)=0.1940 amum_3 = 0.0970 \times (2.00) = 0.1940\text{ amu}; total shift =0.1970 amu= 0.1970\text{ amu}; mˉ=20.00+0.1970=20.197 amu≈20.20 amu\bar{m} = 20.00 + 0.1970 = 20.197\text{ amu} \approx 20.20\text{ amu}.

Loading workspace…