Resources
An insulated container is divided into two equal compartments separated by a partition. Compartment A holds of an ideal gas at , and Compartment B is completely evacuated (a vacuum). The partition is suddenly removed, allowing the gas to expand freely into Compartment B until the total volume doubles. (a) Identifying the gas as the system, determine the values of , , and for this free expansion process. (b) Explain why despite the apparent macroscopic displacement of gas molecules.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) , , and . (b) Work in thermodynamics requires pushing against an opposing external force or pressure (); because the gas expands into a vacuum where , no opposing force is overcome, and therefore zero boundary work is performed.
Steps
Part (a): Determining , , and
- Calculate heat transfer (): The problem states that the container is thermally insulated. An insulated boundary prevents any heat exchange between the system (the gas) and its surroundings:
- Calculate boundary work (): Expansion work depends on the external pressure opposing the system's boundary: Because Compartment B is completely evacuated (a vacuum), there is no matter to push against, meaning the opposing external pressure is zero (). Consequently:
- Calculate change in internal energy (): According to the First Law of Thermodynamics: Substituting the values obtained for and :
Part (b): Physical Explanation for
- Thermodynamic Definition of Work: In thermodynamics, mechanical work is not simply defined by the motion or displacement of particles. Instead, work requires an organized force exerted against an opposing external resistance across the system boundary:
- Absence of Opposing Force: During a free expansion (Joule expansion) into a vacuum, there are no particles or walls exerting a counter-pressure on the expanding gas front (). Although the gas particles fly across space and occupy Compartment B, they encounter no opposing force to resist their motion. Without an opposing force to overcome, no energy is transferred across the boundary as work, giving .
- Common Pitfall: Do not confuse the internal pressure of the gas () with the external opposing pressure (). Work performed on or by a system is governed solely by the resistance it overcomes (), not the pressure existing inside the gas before expansion.
Typical errors
01 A student incorrectly assumes isothermal ideal-gas expansion work applies to free expansion, calculating non-zero work using w = -nRT ln(V2/V1).
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You applied the formula for a reversible isothermal expansion against an internal-equilibrium pressure. Because the gas expands freely into an evacuated chamber (a vacuum), the opposing external pressure is zero (), so no expansion work is done ().
- Step 3Correct
You correctly set up the First Law relation , but substituting your non-zero value of led to an incorrect final change in internal energy.
- Step 4Correct
You associated macroscopic molecular motion with thermodynamic work. In thermodynamics, expansion work is strictly boundary work done against an external resistance (); spreading into empty space without resistance does not perform work.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly deduced that an insulated container implies .
You correctly applied the First Law of Thermodynamics relation .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo slip was detected; this is a conceptual misunderstanding of the thermodynamic definition of pressure-volume work.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that any volume expansion of an ideal gas does work according to , without verifying whether the expansion was reversible or resisted by an external pressure. Because thermodynamic work is defined by , expanding against a vacuum () performs zero work.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Opposing Pressure vs. Internal Pressure
Always evaluate work using the external resisting pressure (), not the internal gas pressure (), unless the process is explicitly reversible ().
- Free Expansion (Joule Expansion)
When a gas expands into an evacuated space (vacuum), set immediately, yielding .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the external opposing pressure during free expansion: .
Compute work using the boundary-work integral: .
Substitute and into the First Law: .
(a) , , and . (b) Work requires an opposing external force or pressure (). Because expansion into a vacuum has , no resistance is overcome, so .
02 A student incorrectly uses the initial gas pressure as the opposing pressure to calculate work via w = -P ΔV.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Container is insulated so
- Step 2
Since the gas expands against pressure , is negative and non-zero
CorrectThermodynamic expansion work depends exclusively on the external opposing pressure (). Because Compartment B is completely evacuated (a vacuum), , so no opposing force resists the expansion and .
- Step 3Correct
You applied the First Law of Thermodynamics correctly, but substituting your non-zero value for led to an incorrect negative change in internal energy instead of .
- Step 4
Work should not be zero because moving gas molecules push against the space in Compartment B.
CorrectMechanical work across a boundary requires an opposing external force (). An empty space or vacuum exerts no opposing pressure on the gas boundary, so zero work is performed.
Empty space contains no particles to exert a resistive or counter force. In thermodynamics, particles merely flying into open space do not perform boundary work unless they overcome an external opposing pressure.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that thermal insulation implies .
You stated and applied the First Law of Thermodynamics, .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that whenever a gas expands or molecules move into a new space, work must be performed, conflating the gas's internal pressure with the external opposing pressure () which is zero in a vacuum.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Expansion Work Formula
, where is the external pressure resisting boundary displacement, not the internal gas pressure.
Always identify what is on the other side of the moving boundary before calculating work.
- Free Expansion Definition
Expansion into a vacuum is a free expansion where , which always yields .
Whenever an evacuated chamber or vacuum is mentioned, set immediately.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the external opposing pressure across the expanding boundary: since Compartment B is evacuated, .
Calculate work using .
Substitute and into the First Law: .
Explain that thermodynamic boundary work requires pushing against an opposing resistance; moving into empty space encounters no resisting force, so .
(a) , , and . (b) Thermodynamic boundary work requires an opposing external force or pressure (); because expansion occurs into a vacuum where , no opposing force is overcome, meaning .
Lock it in
What is the governing equation for pressure-volume expansion work in thermodynamics?
. Work depends strictly on the opposing external pressure (), not the internal gas pressure.
Similar question
A sample of an ideal gas at expands irreversibly from to against a constant external pressure of . Calculate the work done by the gas in joules ().
Answer
. Key steps: ; convert to joules: .
An insulated, rigid container contains of an ideal gas at in one half, while the other half is evacuated. The partition breaks, doubling the volume. What is the final temperature of the gas, and what are , , and ?
Answer
, , , and . Key steps: Insulated implies ; expansion into a vacuum has , so ; therefore . For an ideal gas, depends solely on (), so and .
Compare the work done when of an ideal gas expands from to at under two different conditions: (A) reversibly and isothermally, and (B) freely into an evacuated bulb. State both values of .
Answer
For (A), ; for (B), . Key steps: In (A), , giving . In (B), the gas expands into a vacuum where , giving .