Resources

In a laboratory esterification between benzoic acid (molar mass 122.12 g/mol122.12\text{ g/mol}) and methanol (molar mass 32.04 g/mol32.04\text{ g/mol}) producing methyl benzoate (molar mass 136.15 g/mol136.15\text{ g/mol}) and water (molar mass 18.02 g/mol18.02\text{ g/mol}), the theoretical atom economy is 88.3%88.3\%. An organic synthesis protocol defines an 'acceptable green threshold' for reaction mass efficiency (RME) at RME≥65.0%\text{RME} \ge 65.0\%, assuming strictly stoichiometric feed ratios (moles of benzoic acid equals moles of methanol). Determine the critical threshold minimum reaction percent yield (% Yield\text{\% Yield}) required to meet or exceed this green chemistry benchmark to three significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

73.6%73.6\%

Steps

01

Understand the Definitions of Green Chemistry Metrics

  • Atom Economy (AE\text{AE}) measures the percentage of reactant atoms that end up in the desired product under ideal conditions: AE=Molar mass of desired productSum of molar masses of all reactants×100%\text{AE} = \frac{\text{Molar mass of desired product}}{\text{Sum of molar masses of all reactants}} \times 100\% For this reaction: AE=136.15 g/mol122.12 g/mol+32.04 g/mol×100%=136.15154.16×100%≈88.3%\text{AE} = \frac{136.15\text{ g/mol}}{122.12\text{ g/mol} + 32.04\text{ g/mol}} \times 100\% = \frac{136.15}{154.16} \times 100\% \approx 88.3\%
  • Reaction Mass Efficiency (RME\text{RME}) measures the actual mass of the desired product obtained relative to the total mass of reactants fed into the reaction: RME=Actual mass of desired productTotal mass of reactants fed×100%\text{RME} = \frac{\text{Actual mass of desired product}}{\text{Total mass of reactants fed}} \times 100\%

02

Relate Reaction Mass Efficiency to Atom Economy and Yield

When reactants are fed in strictly stoichiometric proportions (a 1:11:1 molar ratio with no excess reagent):

  • Let nn be the moles of each reactant used (CX6HX5COOH\ce{C6H5COOH} and CHX3OH\ce{CH3OH}).
  • Total mass of reactants fed is: mreactants=n⋅Mbenzoic acid+n⋅Mmethanol=n(Mbenzoic acid+Mmethanol)m_{\text{reactants}} = n \cdot M_{\text{benzoic acid}} + n \cdot M_{\text{methanol}} = n(M_{\text{benzoic acid}} + M_{\text{methanol}})
  • The actual moles of product formed is given by the fractional reaction yield (Yieldfractional=% Yield100\text{Yield}_{\text{fractional}} = \frac{\%\text{ Yield}}{100}): nproduct=n⋅Yieldfractionaln_{\text{product}} = n \cdot \text{Yield}_{\text{fractional}}
  • The actual mass of desired product obtained is: mproduct=nproduct⋅Mproduct=n⋅Yieldfractional⋅Mproductm_{\text{product}} = n_{\text{product}} \cdot M_{\text{product}} = n \cdot \text{Yield}_{\text{fractional}} \cdot M_{\text{product}}

Substituting these into the formula for RME\text{RME}: RME=n⋅Yieldfractional⋅Mproductn(Mbenzoic acid+Mmethanol)×100%=Yieldfractional×(MproductMreactants)×100%\text{RME} = \frac{n \cdot \text{Yield}_{\text{fractional}} \cdot M_{\text{product}}}{n(M_{\text{benzoic acid}} + M_{\text{methanol}})} \times 100\% = \text{Yield}_{\text{fractional}} \times \left(\frac{M_{\text{product}}}{M_{\text{reactants}}}\right) \times 100\%

Recognizing the term in parentheses as the fractional Atom Economy (AEfractional\text{AE}_{\text{fractional}}): RME=Yieldfractional⋅AE\text{RME} = \text{Yield}_{\text{fractional}} \cdot \text{AE}

Or, expressing all values as percentages: RME=% Yield×AE100%\text{RME} = \frac{\%\text{ Yield} \times \text{AE}}{100\%}

Common Pitfall: The direct relationship RME=Yield×AE\text{RME} = \text{Yield} \times \text{AE} holds only when reactants are fed in exact stoichiometric proportions. If one reactant is added in excess, the excess mass increases the total reactant mass in the denominator, reducing RME\text{RME} further.


03

Calculate the Minimum Percent Yield

Rearranging the formula to solve for the required percent yield: % Yield=RMEAE×100%\%\text{ Yield} = \frac{\text{RME}}{\text{AE}} \times 100\%

Substitute the given target benchmark (RME≥65.0%\text{RME} \ge 65.0\%) and the theoretical atom economy (AE=88.3%\text{AE} = 88.3\%): % Yield≥65.0%88.3%×100%\%\text{ Yield} \ge \frac{65.0\%}{88.3\%} \times 100\%

% Yield≥73.6127%\%\text{ Yield} \ge 73.6127\%

Rounding to three significant figures gives the minimum threshold yield of 73.6%73.6\%.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses reaction mass efficiency with atom economy and multiplies the threshold RME by the atom economy instead of dividing.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    RME=57.4%×Atom Economy  ⟹  % Yield=RME×Atom Economy\text{RME} = 57.4\% \times \text{Atom Economy} \implies \%\text{ Yield} = \text{RME} \times \text{Atom Economy}

    Correct

    RME=Yieldfractional×AE  ⟹  % Yield=RMEAE×100%\text{RME} = \text{Yield}_{\text{fractional}} \times \text{AE} \implies \%\text{ Yield} = \frac{\text{RME}}{\text{AE}} \times 100\%

    You multiplied RME by Atom Economy rather than dividing. Under stoichiometric conditions, actual mass efficiency is the product of theoretical atom economy and reaction yield (RME=Yield×AE\text{RME} = \text{Yield} \times \text{AE}), so isolating yield gives Yield=RMEAE\text{Yield} = \frac{\text{RME}}{\text{AE}}.

  2. Step 2

    % Yield=65.0%×0.883=57.4%\%\text{ Yield} = 65.0\% \times 0.883 = 57.4\%

    Correct

    % Yield=65.0%88.3%×100%≈73.61%\%\text{ Yield} = \frac{65.0\%}{88.3\%} \times 100\% \approx 73.61\%

    Because the starting formula was inverted, the substitution resulted in multiplying 65.0%65.0\% by 0.8830.883 instead of evaluating 65.0%88.3%×100%\frac{65.0\%}{88.3\%} \times 100\%.

  3. Step 3

    Minimum % Yield=57.4%\text{Minimum } \%\text{ Yield} = 57.4\%

    Correct

    73.6%73.6\%

    This final value is carried over from the incorrect multiplication in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly converted the theoretical atom economy into a decimal fraction (0.8830.883) for calculation.

You recognized that Reaction Mass Efficiency and Atom Economy are directly proportional under stoichiometric feed conditions.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Metric Formula

No, this was an algebraic misconception in relating green chemistry efficiency definitions.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated Reaction Mass Efficiency as an input factor to determine yield (% Yield=RME×AE\%\text{ Yield} = \text{RME} \times \text{AE}) rather than recognizing that RME is the combined output metric (extRME=Yield×AE ext{RME} = \text{Yield} \times \text{AE}), which requires dividing RME by AE to isolate the yield.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Stoichiometric Metric Relationship
  • Under strict stoichiometric feed ratios, RME=Yieldfractional×AE\text{RME} = \text{Yield}_{\text{fractional}} \times \text{AE}.

  • Divide the target RME by the theoretical AE whenever you need to find the required reaction yield.

Efficiency Sanity Check
  • Since Atom Economy is typically less than 100%100\% (here 88.3%88.3\%), the required reaction yield must always be numerically greater than the target RME.

  • Check that your calculated yield (73.6%73.6\%) is higher than your target RME (65.0%65.0\%), not lower (57.4%57.4\%).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the standard relation for stoichiometric reactants: RME=Yieldfractional×AE\text{RME} = \text{Yield}_{\text{fractional}} \times \text{AE}.

  2. Rearrange algebraically to isolate the percent yield: % Yield=RMEAE×100%\%\text{ Yield} = \frac{\text{RME}}{\text{AE}} \times 100\%.

  3. Substitute the given values: % Yield≥65.0%88.3%×100%≈73.61%\%\text{ Yield} \ge \frac{65.0\%}{88.3\%} \times 100\% \approx 73.61\%.

  4. Round to three significant figures to obtain the final threshold.

Final answer

73.6%73.6\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out the fundamental definition RME=Yield×AE\text{RME} = \text{Yield} \times \text{AE} before isolating any individual variable.

  • Perform a quick magnitude check: achieving an efficiency of 65%65\% when the upper theoretical limit is only 88.3%88.3\% must require completing more than 65%65\% of the reaction.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student assumes benzoic acid is the sole mass basis for calculating efficiency because it is the main organic substrate, ignoring the mass of methanol in the denominator.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Mass ratio=136.15122.12=1.115  ⟹  RME=% Yield×(136.15122.12)\text{Mass ratio} = \frac{136.15}{122.12} = 1.115 \implies \text{RME} = \%\text{ Yield} \times \left(\frac{136.15}{122.12}\right)

    Correct

    RME=Yieldfractional×AE=% Yield×(136.15122.12+32.04)=% Yield×0.883\text{RME} = \text{Yield}_{\text{fractional}} \times \text{AE} = \%\text{ Yield} \times \left(\frac{136.15}{122.12 + 32.04}\right) = \%\text{ Yield} \times 0.883

    You treated benzoic acid as the only reactant mass in the system. Reaction mass efficiency (RME\text{RME}) considers the total mass of all input reactants fed into the reaction, so the denominator must include both benzoic acid (122.12 g/mol122.12\text{ g/mol}) and methanol (32.04 g/mol32.04\text{ g/mol}).

  2. Step 2

    % Yield=65.0%1.115=58.3%\%\text{ Yield} = \frac{65.0\%}{1.115} = 58.3\%

    Correct

    % Yield≥65.0%88.3%×100%≈73.6%\%\text{ Yield} \ge \frac{65.0\%}{88.3\%} \times 100\% \approx 73.6\%

    You rearranged the formula correctly, but this step inherited the erroneous mass ratio from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    Minimum % Yield=58.3%\text{Minimum }\%\text{ Yield} = 58.3\%

    Correct

    73.6%73.6\%

    This final answer is lower than the true critical threshold because methanol was omitted from the reactant mass total.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that reaction mass efficiency is proportional to reaction yield under stoichiometric conditions.

You accurately rearranged your equation to solve for percent yield and rounded your calculation to three significant figures.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of co-reactant in reaction mass efficiency denominator

No, this stems from a conceptual misunderstanding of reaction mass efficiency, treating the primary organic substrate as the sole reactant input rather than summing all fed reactants.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Reaction mass efficiency (RME\text{RME}) is defined as the actual mass of desired product divided by the total mass of all reactants fed. For a strictly stoichiometric 1:11:1 reaction, RME=fractional yield×atom economy\text{RME} = \text{fractional yield} \times \text{atom economy}. By substituting only benzoic acid's molar mass into the denominator, you obtained a ratio greater than 11 (1.1151.115), falsely reducing the required threshold yield.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Total Reactant Mass in RME
  • RME=mproduct, actual∑mreactants, fed\text{RME} = \frac{m_{\text{product, actual}}}{\sum m_{\text{reactants, fed}}}. For stoichiometric feeds, ∑mreactants=n(MA+MB+… )\sum m_{\text{reactants}} = n(M_{\text{A}} + M_{\text{B}} + \dots).

  • Always include the mass of every reactant fed into the reaction vessel, not just the primary organic precursor.

Equivalence of RME and Yield $\times$ AE
  • When reactants are supplied in an exact stoichiometric ratio, RME=Yieldfractional×AE\text{RME} = \text{Yield}_{\text{fractional}} \times \text{AE}.

  • Use the provided theoretical atom economy directly to write % Yield=RMEAE×100%\%\text{ Yield} = \frac{\text{RME}}{\text{AE}} \times 100\%.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express reaction mass efficiency under stoichiometric feed conditions: RME=% Yield100%×AE\text{RME} = \frac{\%\text{ Yield}}{100\%} \times \text{AE}.

  2. Rearrange to isolate the required percent yield: % Yield=RMEAE×100%\%\text{ Yield} = \frac{\text{RME}}{\text{AE}} \times 100\%.

  3. Substitute the threshold RME≥65.0%\text{RME} \ge 65.0\% and theoretical AE=88.3%\text{AE} = 88.3\%: % Yield≥65.0%88.3%×100%≈73.61%\%\text{ Yield} \ge \frac{65.0\%}{88.3\%} \times 100\% \approx 73.61\%.

  4. Round to three significant figures.

Final answer

73.6%73.6\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Re-read definitions of green chemistry metrics (Atom Economy, Reaction Mass Efficiency, Process Mass Intensity) to confirm which inputs are summed in their denominators.

  • Practice distinguishing between reactions run at stoichiometric ratios versus reactions run with excess reagents when calculating RME\text{RME}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student subtracts the green threshold RME deficit directly from 100% rather than relating yield proportionally via atom economy.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Theoretical maximum atom economy=88.3%  ⟹  Green threshold=65.0%\text{Theoretical maximum atom economy} = 88.3\% \implies \text{Green threshold} = 65.0\%

  2. Step 2

    % Yield=100%−(88.3%−65.0%)=76.7%\%\text{ Yield} = 100\% - (88.3\% - 65.0\%) = 76.7\%

    Correct

    % Yield=RMEAE×100%=65.0%88.3%×100%≈73.6%\%\text{ Yield} = \frac{\text{RME}}{\text{AE}} \times 100\% = \frac{65.0\%}{88.3\%}\times 100\% \approx 73.6\%

    You subtracted the difference between atom economy and the target RME from 100%100\%. Under stoichiometric conditions, reaction mass efficiency is multiplicative: RME=AE×Yield\text{RME} = \text{AE} \times \text{Yield}, which means % Yield=RMEAE×100%\%\text{ Yield} = \frac{\text{RME}}{\text{AE}} \times 100\%.

  3. Step 3

    Minimum % Yield=76.7%\text{Minimum }\%\text{ Yield} = 76.7\%

    Correct

    Minimum % Yield=73.6%\text{Minimum }\%\text{ Yield} = 73.6\%

    Because of the additive formula used in the previous step, your final calculated threshold yield was incorrect.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the theoretical atom economy is 88.3%88.3\% and the benchmark RME threshold is 65.0%65.0\%.

You performed your arithmetic operations accurately according to your chosen formula.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Additive rather than multiplicative relationship

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated Atom Economy and Reaction Mass Efficiency as additive percentage terms rather than accounting for their fundamental relationship: under 1:1 stoichiometric conditions, mass efficiency is the product of theoretical atom economy and fractional chemical yield.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Stoichiometric RME Formula
  • When reagents are fed in exact stoichiometric proportions, RME=Yieldfractional×AE=% Yield×AE100%\text{RME} = \text{Yield}_{\text{fractional}} \times \text{AE} = \frac{\%\text{ Yield} \times \text{AE}}{100\%}.

  • Always isolate yield via division (Yield=RMEAE\text{Yield} = \frac{\text{RME}}{\text{AE}}) rather than subtracting percentage deficits.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the stoichiometric green metric identity: RME=% Yield×AE100%\text{RME} = \frac{\%\text{ Yield} \times \text{AE}}{100\%}.

  2. Rearrange to solve for the minimum required percent yield: % Yield=RMEAE×100%\%\text{ Yield} = \frac{\text{RME}}{\text{AE}} \times 100\%.

  3. Substitute the target values: % Yield=65.0%88.3%×100%≈73.613%\%\text{ Yield} = \frac{65.0\%}{88.3\%} \times 100\% \approx 73.613\%.

  4. Round to three significant figures to find the minimum threshold yield.

Final answer

73.6%73.6\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the formal derivations of Reaction Mass Efficiency (RME), Atom Economy (AE), and Mass Intensity.

  • Practice rearranging multiplicative green chemistry metric relationships before inserting numerical values.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A chemical synthesis has a theoretical atom economy of 80.0%80.0\%. Determine the minimum reaction percent yield needed to meet a reaction mass efficiency threshold of at least 60.0%60.0\% under stoichiometric feed conditions.

Answer

75.0%75.0\%. Using % Yield=RMEAE×100%\%\text{ Yield} = \frac{\text{RME}}{\text{AE}} \times 100\%, compute 60.0%80.0%×100%=75.0%\frac{60.0\%}{80.0\%} \times 100\% = 75.0\%.

02

In a direct addition reaction where no coproducts or waste atoms are formed, the theoretical atom economy is 100%100\%. If stoichiometric feeds yield an RME of 84.2%84.2\%, what is the reaction's percent yield?

Answer

84.2%84.2\%. When AE=100%\text{AE} = 100\% (1.001.00), RME=Yield×1.00\text{RME} = \text{Yield} \times 1.00, meaning percent yield is identical to RME: 84.2%84.2\%.

03

An esterification with an atom economy of 72.0%72.0\% operates under stoichiometric conditions. An engineer specifies a target RME of at least 70.0%70.0\%. Calculate the required percent yield to three significant figures, and state whether this target is attainable if equilibrium constraints cap the yield at 95.0%95.0\%.

Answer

97.2%97.2\%; unattainable. Calculation: % Yield=70.0%72.0%×100%≈97.2%\%\text{ Yield} = \frac{70.0\%}{72.0\%} \times 100\% \approx 97.2\%. Because the required yield (97.2%97.2\%) exceeds the maximum attainable equilibrium yield (95.0%95.0\%), the target RME cannot be achieved.

Loading workspace…