Resources

A student attempts to dilute 25.0 mL25.0\text{ mL} of a 0.800 M0.800\text{ M} calcium chloride (CaCl2\text{CaCl}_2) solution to prepare a target concentration of 1.20 M1.20\text{ M} solely by adding pure deionized water. Using the dilution equation M1V1=M2V2M_1V_1 = M_2V_2, explain why this target concentration represents a physical threshold boundary and state the maximum final concentration achievable exclusively through water addition.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Impossible to achieve via solvent addition; dilution can only decrease solute concentration (V2>V1  ⟹  M2<M1V_2 > V_1 \implies M_2 < M_1). The theoretical upper boundary achievable by adding water is M2≤0.800 MM_2 \le 0.800\text{ M} (approaching 0.800 M0.800\text{ M} as volume added approaches 0 mL0\text{ mL}).

Steps

01

Apply the Principle of Conservation of Solute

The dilution equation is based on the fact that adding pure solvent does not change the amount of solute (nn in moles):

M1V1=M2V2=nsoluteM_1V_1 = M_2V_2 = n_{\text{solute}}

Where:

  • M1=0.800 MM_1 = 0.800\text{ M} (initial molarity)
  • V1=25.0 mLV_1 = 25.0\text{ mL} (initial volume)
  • M2M_2 is the final molarity
  • V2V_2 is the final volume, where V2=V1+Vwater addedV_2 = V_1 + V_{\text{water added}}
02

Analyze the Mathematical Effect of Adding Solvent

Rearranging the dilution formula to solve for the final concentration M2M_2:

M2=M1⋅(V1V2)M_2 = M_1 \cdot \left(\frac{V_1}{V_2}\right)

When pure deionized water is added to the solution:

  • Vwater added>0 mLV_{\text{water added}} > 0\text{ mL}, so V2>V1V_2 > V_1.
  • The ratio V1V2\frac{V_1}{V_2} must be strictly less than 11 (V1V2<1\frac{V_1}{V_2} < 1).
  • Consequently, the final concentration must decrease relative to the starting concentration:

M2<M1  ⟹  M2<0.800 MM_2 < M_1 \implies M_2 < 0.800\text{ M}

03

Evaluate the Target Concentration (1.20 M1.20\text{ M})

If one were to mathematically solve for the final volume V2V_2 needed to achieve M2=1.20 MM_2 = 1.20\text{ M}:

V2=M1V1M2=0.800 M⋅25.0 mL1.20 M≈16.7 mLV_2 = \frac{M_1V_1}{M_2} = \frac{0.800\text{ M} \cdot 25.0\text{ mL}}{1.20\text{ M}} \approx 16.7\text{ mL}

This would require a final volume less than the starting volume (V2<V1V_2 < V_1), corresponding to adding a negative volume of water (Vadded=16.7 mL−25.0 mL=−8.3 mLV_{\text{added}} = 16.7\text{ mL} - 25.0\text{ mL} = -8.3\text{ mL}). To reach 1.20 M1.20\text{ M}, solvent would have to be removed (such as by evaporation) rather than added.

04

Conclusion and Physical Upper Boundary

  • Possibility: It is physically impossible to achieve 1.20 M1.20\text{ M} solely by adding pure water because dilution can only decrease solute concentration.
  • Maximum Achievable Concentration: The theoretical maximum final concentration achievable strictly through water addition is bounded by the initial concentration:

M2≤0.800 MM_2 \le 0.800\text{ M}

This maximum is approached as the volume of added water approaches zero (Vadded→0 mLV_{\text{added}} \to 0\text{ mL}).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates the final volume as 16.7 mL using the dilution formula but concludes that adding 8.3 mL of water will achieve the higher concentration, misunderstanding that dilution decreases concentration.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    M1V1=M2V2  ⟹  (0.800 M)(25.0 mL)=(1.20 M)V2  ⟹  V2=16.7 mLM_1V_1 = M_2V_2 \implies (0.800\text{ M})(25.0\text{ mL}) = (1.20\text{ M})V_2 \implies V_2 = 16.7\text{ mL}

  2. Step 2

    Water to add=25.0 mL−16.7 mL=8.3 mL\text{Water to add} = 25.0\text{ mL} - 16.7\text{ mL} = 8.3\text{ mL}

    Correct

    Vadded=V2−V1=16.7 mL−25.0 mL=−8.3 mLV_{\text{added}} = V_2 - V_1 = 16.7\text{ mL} - 25.0\text{ mL} = -8.3\text{ mL} (solvent must be removed, not added)

    When adding water, the final volume must be greater than the initial volume (V2=V1+VaddedV_2 = V_1 + V_{\text{added}}). Because V2=16.7 mLV_2 = 16.7\text{ mL} is less than V1=25.0 mLV_1 = 25.0\text{ mL}, the required change is −8.3 mL-8.3\text{ mL}, meaning water must be removed rather than added.

  3. Step 3

    Adding 8.3 mL of water achieves 1.20 M, so it is physically possible.\text{Adding } 8.3\text{ mL} \text{ of water achieves } 1.20\text{ M}, \text{ so it is physically possible.}

    Correct

    Impossible via water addition; adding pure water increases volume (V2>V1V_2 > V_1), which strictly decreases concentration (M2<M1M_2 < M_1).

    Because adding solvent increases the total solution volume while keeping solute moles constant, dilution can only decrease concentration (M2<0.800 MM_2 < 0.800\text{ M}).

  4. Step 4

    1.20 M1.20\text{ M}

    Correct

    M2,max≤0.800 MM_{2,\text{max}} \le 0.800\text{ M} (approached as Vadded→0 mLV_{\text{added}} \to 0\text{ mL})

    The maximum concentration achievable strictly by adding pure solvent is the initial concentration itself, 0.800 M0.800\text{ M}, achieved when zero water is added.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled and algebraically rearranged the dilution equation M1V1=M2V2M_1V_1 = M_2V_2.

You accurately computed the hypothetical volume V2≈16.7 mLV_2 \approx 16.7\text{ mL} corresponding to 1.20 M1.20\text{ M}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Dilution Directionality Misconception

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You subtracted the smaller volume from the larger volume to obtain a positive volume difference, overlooking the physical meaning that dilution (Vadded>0V_{\text{added}} > 0) strictly decreases solute concentration (M2<M1M_2 < M_1).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Direction of Dilution
  • Adding pure solvent always increases total volume (V2>V1V_2 > V_1), which strictly lowers molarity (M2=M1⋅V1V2<M1M_2 = M_1 \cdot \frac{V_1}{V_2} < M_1).

  • Check whether M2<M1M_2 < M_1 before solving; if M2>M1M_2 > M_1, pure solvent addition cannot achieve it.

Sign of Added Volume
  • Vadded=V2−V1V_{\text{added}} = V_2 - V_1. If V2<V1V_2 < V_1, Vadded<0V_{\text{added}} < 0, which signifies solvent removal (concentration/evaporation), not solvent addition.

  • Always compute V2−V1V_2 - V_1, not ∣V1−V2∣|V_1 - V_2|, to maintain the correct physical sign.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that reaching M2=1.20 MM_2 = 1.20\text{ M} requires V2=16.7 mLV_2 = 16.7\text{ mL}, which is less than the starting volume of 25.0 mL25.0\text{ mL}.

  2. Compute the required solvent change: Vadded=V2−V1=16.7 mL−25.0 mL=−8.3 mLV_{\text{added}} = V_2 - V_1 = 16.7\text{ mL} - 25.0\text{ mL} = -8.3\text{ mL}.

  3. Conclude that reaching 1.20 M1.20\text{ M} requires removing 8.3 mL8.3\text{ mL} of water (e.g., by boiling/evaporation), making it impossible exclusively by adding water.

  4. Identify the upper concentration limit achievable by water addition as M2≤0.800 MM_2 \le 0.800\text{ M}, approached when Vadded→0 mLV_{\text{added}} \to 0\text{ mL}.

Final answer

It is physically impossible to achieve 1.20 M1.20\text{ M} solely by adding water because dilution can only decrease concentration (V2>V1  ⟹  M2<M1V_2 > V_1 \implies M_2 < M_1). The maximum concentration achievable exclusively through water addition is 0.800 M0.800\text{ M} (when Vadded=0 mLV_{\text{added}} = 0\text{ mL}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the inverse relationship between volume and molarity in M1V1=M2V2M_1V_1 = M_2V_2 when solute moles are constant.

  • Practice evaluating whether a target concentration requires dilution (adding solvent) or concentration (removing solvent or adding solute) before performing numerical calculations.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student assumes that dilution can produce any concentration and states that the maximum achievable concentration is infinite or has no upper bound.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    M1V1=M2V2  ⟹  V2=0.800 M×25.0 mL1.20 M=16.7 mLM_1V_1 = M_2V_2 \implies V_2 = \frac{0.800\text{ M} \times 25.0\text{ mL}}{1.20\text{ M}} = 16.7\text{ mL}

  2. Step 2

    V2V_2 is less than V1V_1, meaning the solution cannot be diluted to a higher molarity by adding water   ⟹  1.20 M\implies 1.20\text{ M} is impossible because adding water only lowers concentration.

  3. Step 3

    No maximum concentration limit exists

    Correct

    Maximum achievable concentration is M2≤0.800 MM_2 \le 0.800\text{ M} (approaching 0.800 M0.800\text{ M} as Vadded→0 mLV_{\text{added}} \to 0\text{ mL}).

    Because pure water addition requires Vadded≥0 mLV_{\text{added}} \ge 0\text{ mL}, the final volume satisfies V2≥V1V_2 \ge V_1. Consequently, M2=M1(V1V2)≤M1M_2 = M_1\left(\frac{V_1}{V_2}\right) \le M_1, which places a strict theoretical upper boundary at the initial concentration of 0.800 M0.800\text{ M}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the dilution equation to calculate the hypothetical final volume.

You clearly articulated why adding pure water cannot increase the molarity of a solution.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Bounded range misconception in dilution

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the achievable concentration as unbounded rather than recognizing that the physical constraint of adding water (Vadded≥0V_{\text{added}} \ge 0) bounds the resulting concentration to the interval (0,M1](0, M_1].

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Physical Volume Constraint
  • When adding pure solvent, the added volume cannot be negative: V2=V1+Vsolvent≥V1V_2 = V_1 + V_{\text{solvent}} \ge V_1.

  • Always check the domain of V2V_2 implied by the physical process before evaluating limits on concentration.

Upper Boundary of Dilution
  • Since V2≥V1V_2 \ge V_1, the ratio V1V2≤1\frac{V_1}{V_2} \le 1, meaning M2≤M1M_2 \le M_1.

  • Recognize that the initial concentration M1M_1 is the absolute maximum concentration attainable strictly by solvent addition (achieved when Vadded=0V_{\text{added}} = 0).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the constraint on added volume: V2=V1+VwaterV_2 = V_1 + V_{\text{water}}, where Vwater≥0 mLV_{\text{water}} \ge 0\text{ mL}, which implies V2≥25.0 mLV_2 \ge 25.0\text{ mL}.

  2. Express final concentration as a function of volume: M2=M1⋅V1V2=0.800 M⋅25.0 mLV2M_2 = M_1 \cdot \frac{V_1}{V_2} = 0.800\text{ M} \cdot \frac{25.0\text{ mL}}{V_2}.

  3. Determine the maximum value: Because V2≥25.0 mLV_2 \ge 25.0\text{ mL}, the fraction 25.0 mLV2≤1\frac{25.0\text{ mL}}{V_2} \le 1, so M2≤0.800 MM_2 \le 0.800\text{ M}.

Final answer

The maximum achievable concentration exclusively via water addition is 0.800 M0.800\text{ M} (approached as Vwater→0 mLV_{\text{water}} \to 0\text{ mL}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Express the final molarity explicitly as an inequality based on V2≥V1V_2 \ge V_1 whenever a problem specifies pure solvent addition.

  • Practice identifying physical domain limits (such as non-negative volume added) in chemistry word problems.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A chemist has 50.0 mL50.0\text{ mL} of a 0.500 M CuSO40.500\text{ M}\text{ CuSO}_4 solution. Is it possible to prepare a 0.200 M0.200\text{ M} solution solely by adding deionized water? If so, calculate the volume of water that must be added.

Answer

Yes, it is possible because M2<M1M_2 < M_1 (0.200 M<0.500 M0.200\text{ M} < 0.500\text{ M}). Using M1V1=M2V2M_1V_1 = M_2V_2: V2=(0.500 M)(50.0 mL)0.200 M=125 mLV_2 = \frac{(0.500\text{ M})(50.0\text{ mL})}{0.200\text{ M}} = 125\text{ mL} Vwater added=V2−V1=125 mL−50.0 mL=75.0 mLV_{\text{water added}} = V_2 - V_1 = 125\text{ mL} - 50.0\text{ mL} = 75.0\text{ mL}

02

A laboratory technician wants to convert 100.0 mL100.0\text{ mL} of 0.600 M HCl0.600\text{ M}\text{ HCl} into a 0.900 M HCl0.900\text{ M}\text{ HCl} solution. Explain why adding water cannot accomplish this, and determine what volume of water would need to be evaporated (assuming no HCl\text{HCl} gas escapes) to reach the target concentration.

Answer

Adding water increases volume, which strictly dilutes the solution (M2<M1M_2 < M_1), making it impossible to reach a higher concentration (0.900 M>0.600 M0.900\text{ M} > 0.600\text{ M}). To achieve 0.900 M0.900\text{ M} via evaporation: V2=(0.600 M)(100.0 mL)0.900 M=66.7 mLV_2 = \frac{(0.600\text{ M})(100.0\text{ mL})}{0.900\text{ M}} = 66.7\text{ mL} Volume evaporated=V1−V2=100.0 mL−66.7 mL=33.3 mL\text{Volume evaporated} = V_1 - V_2 = 100.0\text{ mL} - 66.7\text{ mL} = 33.3\text{ mL}

03

You are given 40.0 mL40.0\text{ mL} of a 1.50 M KNO31.50\text{ M}\text{ KNO}_3 stock solution. You have two target solutions: Solution A (0.750 M0.750\text{ M}) and Solution B (2.00 M2.00\text{ M}). Specify the required action for each target (dilution with water vs. solute addition/solvent removal), and state the exact volume of water to add for whichever target is achievable exclusively by water addition.

Answer

For Solution A (0.750 M<1.50 M0.750\text{ M} < 1.50\text{ M}): Achievable by dilution with water. V2=(1.50 M)(40.0 mL)0.750 M=80.0 mL  ⟹  Vadded=80.0 mL−40.0 mL=40.0 mL of waterV_2 = \frac{(1.50\text{ M})(40.0\text{ mL})}{0.750\text{ M}} = 80.0\text{ mL} \implies V_{\text{added}} = 80.0\text{ mL} - 40.0\text{ mL} = 40.0\text{ mL}\text{ of water} For Solution B (2.00 M>1.50 M2.00\text{ M} > 1.50\text{ M}): Impossible by water addition; requires solvent removal (10.0 mL10.0\text{ mL} evaporated) or dissolving additional solid KNO3\text{KNO}_3.

Loading workspace…