Resources

Consider the dissolution of solid silver chloride, AgCl\text{AgCl} (Ksp=1.8×10−10K_{\text{sp}} = 1.8 \times 10^{-10}), in an ammonia solution in the extreme asymptotic limit of infinite dilution where the total analytical concentration of added ammonia approaches zero (CNH3→0C_{\text{NH}_3} \to 0). Taking the autoionization of water (Kw=1.0×10−14K_w = 1.0 \times 10^{-14}) into consideration where necessary, evaluate the limiting ratio of complexed silver to free silver ion, lim⁡CNH3→0[[Ag(NH3)2]+][Ag+]\lim_{C_{\text{NH}_3} \to 0} \frac{[[\text{Ag}(\text{NH}_3)_2]^+]}{[\text{Ag}^+]}, given Kf=1.7×107K_f = 1.7 \times 10^7 for [Ag(NH3)2]+[\text{Ag}(\text{NH}_3)_2]^+.

Answer and steps

Final answer

00

Steps

01

Relate the species ratio to the formation constant

The formation of the diammine silver(I) complex ion from free silver ion and aqueous ammonia is described by the equilibrium:

AgX+(aq)+2 NHX3(aq)⇌[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+(aq)\ce{Ag+(aq) + 2 NH3(aq) <=> [Ag(NH3)2]+(aq)}

The formation constant (KfK_f) for this reaction is defined as:

Kf=[[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][AgX+][NHX3]2K_f = \frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]}{[\ce{Ag+}][\ce{NH3}]^2}

Rearranging this expression gives the ratio of the complexed silver ion to the free silver ion in terms of the uncomplexed ammonia concentration [NHX3][\ce{NH3}]:

[[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][AgX+]=Kf[NHX3]2\frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]}{[\ce{Ag+}]} = K_f [\ce{NH3}]^2


02

Establish the mass balance on ammonia

The total analytical concentration of added ammonia, CNHX3C_{\ce{NH3}}, accounts for all ammonia-containing species in the aqueous system (free ammonia, protonated ammonium from reaction with water, and ammonia coordinated to silver):

CNHX3=[NHX3]+[NHX4X+]+[[Ag(NHX3)]X+]+2[[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+]C_{\ce{NH3}} = [\ce{NH3}] + [\ce{NH4+}] + [\ce{[Ag(NH3)]+}] + 2[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]

Since the concentration of each physical chemical species in solution must be non-negative:

0≤[NHX3]≤CNHX30 \le [\ce{NH3}] \le C_{\ce{NH3}}


03

Evaluate the asymptotic limit

Taking the limit as the total added ammonia concentration approaches zero (CNHX3→0C_{\ce{NH3}} \to 0):

lim⁡CNHX3→0[NHX3]=0\lim_{C_{\ce{NH3}} \to 0} [\ce{NH3}] = 0

Substituting this result into the ratio expression:

lim⁡CNHX3→0[[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][AgX+]=lim⁡CNHX3→0(Kf[NHX3]2)=Kf⋅(0)2=0\lim_{C_{\ce{NH3}} \to 0} \frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]}{[\ce{Ag+}]} = \lim_{C_{\ce{NH3}} \to 0} \left( K_f [\ce{NH3}]^2 \right) = K_f \cdot (0)^2 = 0

Pitfall to Avoid: Do not confuse the asymptotic limit of zero added solute with non-zero buffer conditions or equilibrium solubility in pure water. Ammonia is not generated intrinsically by the autoionization of water or the dissolution of AgCl\ce{AgCl}. Consequently, as the total external ammonia introduced into the system vanishes, the concentration of all ammonia-containing complexes must strictly vanish.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misinterprets the formation constant Kf directly as the ratio of complex to free metal ion without accounting for the dependence on ammonia concentration.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Kf=[[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][AgX+][NHX3]2K_f = \frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]}{[\ce{Ag+}][\ce{NH3}]^2}

  2. Step 2

    [[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][AgX+]=Kf\frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]}{[\ce{Ag+}]} = K_f

    Correct

    [[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][AgX+]=Kf[NHX3]2\frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]}{[\ce{Ag+}]} = K_f [\ce{NH3}]^2

    When isolating the ratio of complexed silver to free silver ion, you must multiply KfK_f by [NHX3]2[\ce{NH3}]^2. The ratio is not a constant; it varies with the concentration of uncomplexed ligand.

  3. Step 3

    lim⁡CNHX3→0[[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][AgX+]=1.7×107\lim_{C_{\ce{NH3}} \to 0} \frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]}{[\ce{Ag+}]} = 1.7 \times 10^7

    Correct

    lim⁡CNHX3→0[[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][AgX+]=lim⁡CNHX3→0(Kf[NHX3]2)=0\lim_{C_{\ce{NH3}} \to 0} \frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]}{[\ce{Ag+}]} = \lim_{C_{\ce{NH3}} \to 0} \left(K_f [\ce{NH3}]^2\right) = 0

    Because of the missing [NHX3]2[\ce{NH3}]^2 factor in the previous step, your limit evaluated to a constant instead of approaching zero as the total ammonia concentration goes to zero.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the chemical species involved and wrote the correct equilibrium expression for KfK_f.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Dropped ligand concentration from complex ratio

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the formation constant KfK_f as if it were a direct dimensionless ratio between the complex and the free metal ion, overlooking that the equilibrium ratio [MLXn][M]\frac{[\ce{ML_n}]}{[\ce{M}]} is fundamentally a function of the free ligand concentration [L]n[\ce{L}]^n.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Isolate the Ratio with Ligand Dependence
  • For a general complexation reaction M+nL⇌MLXn\ce{M + } n\ce{L <=> ML_n}, Kf=[MLXn][M][L]n  ⟹  [MLXn][M]=Kf[L]nK_f = \frac{[\ce{ML_n}]}{[\ce{M}][\ce{L}]^n} \implies \frac{[\ce{ML_n}]}{[\ce{M}]} = K_f [\ce{L}]^n.

  • Always rearrange the equilibrium expression algebraically to retain all species concentrations before evaluating a limit.

Apply Mass Balance to Limiting Conditions
  • Since [L]≤CL[\ce{L}] \le C_{\ce{L}}, as the total analytical ligand concentration CL→0C_{\ce{L}} \to 0, the free ligand concentration [L][\ce{L}] must also approach 00.

  • Check whether any external source supplies the ligand; if not, setting CL→0C_{\ce{L}} \to 0 forces all coordinated complexes and free ligand concentrations to vanish.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. From Kf=[[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][AgX+][NHX3]2K_f = \frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]}{[\ce{Ag+}][\ce{NH3}]^2}, multiply both sides by [NHX3]2[\ce{NH3}]^2 to obtain [[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][AgX+]=Kf[NHX3]2\frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]}{[\ce{Ag+}]} = K_f [\ce{NH3}]^2.

  2. Apply the mass balance for ammonia: 0≤[NHX3]≤CNHX30 \le [\ce{NH3}] \le C_{\ce{NH3}}, which implies lim⁡CNHX3→0[NHX3]=0\lim_{C_{\ce{NH3}} \to 0} [\ce{NH3}] = 0.

  3. Evaluate the limit: lim⁡CNHX3→0[[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][AgX+]=Kf⋅(0)2=0\lim_{C_{\ce{NH3}} \to 0} \frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]}{[\ce{Ag+}]} = K_f \cdot (0)^2 = 0.

Final answer

00

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice isolating species ratios from multi-reactant equilibrium expressions without dropping remaining denominator terms.

  • Review mass-balance boundary conditions to determine how individual equilibrium species behave in extreme dilution limits.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the ratio [[Ag(NH₃)₂]⁺]/[Ag⁺] with the overall dissolution equilibrium constant K = Ksp · Kf, ignoring the vanishing ammonia concentration.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    AgCl(s)+2 NHX3⇌[Ag(NHX3)X2]X++ClX−  ⟹  K=Ksp⋅Kf=(1.8×10−10)(1.7×107)=3.06×10−3\ce{AgCl(s) + 2NH3 <=> [Ag(NH3)2]+ + Cl-} \implies K = K_{\text{sp}} \cdot K_f = (1.8 \times 10^{-10})(1.7 \times 10^7) = 3.06 \times 10^{-3}

  2. Step 2

    lim⁡CNHX3→0[[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][AgX+]=3.06×10−3\lim_{C_{\ce{NH3}} \to 0} \frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]}{[\ce{Ag+}]} = 3.06 \times 10^{-3}

    Correct

    lim⁡CNHX3→0[[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][AgX+]=lim⁡CNHX3→0Kf[NHX3]2=0\lim_{C_{\ce{NH3}} \to 0} \frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]}{[\ce{Ag+}]} = \lim_{C_{\ce{NH3}} \to 0} K_f [\ce{NH3}]^2 = 0

    You equated the ratio of complexed to free silver ions directly to the equilibrium constant KK. From the complex formation equilibrium AgX++2 NHX3⇌[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+\ce{Ag+ + 2NH3 <=> [Ag(NH3)2]+}, the ratio is [[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][AgX+]=Kf[NHX3]2\frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]}{[\ce{Ag+}]} = K_f [\ce{NH3}]^2. Because no external ammonia is introduced in the limit CNHX3→0C_{\ce{NH3}} \to 0, [NHX3]→0[\ce{NH3}] \to 0, which makes the ratio 00.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly wrote the overall balanced chemical equation for the dissolution of AgCl\ce{AgCl} in ammonia.

You correctly computed the overall equilibrium constant K=Ksp⋅KfK = K_{\text{sp}} \cdot K_f.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating species concentration ratio with an overall equilibrium constant

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the species ratio [[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][AgX+]\frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]}{[\ce{Ag+}]} with the reaction quotient or equilibrium constant K=[[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][ClX−][NHX3]2K = \frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}][\ce{Cl-}]}{[\ce{NH3}]^2}. Because the ratio between the complex and free metal ion depends on the ligand concentration via [[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][AgX+]=Kf[NHX3]2\frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]}{[\ce{Ag+}]} = K_f [\ce{NH3}]^2, it must approach zero when all ammonia sources vanish.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Relate ratio directly to ligand concentration
  • For the complex formation equilibrium M+n L⇌MLXn\ce{M + nL <=> ML_n}, the species ratio is given by [MLXn][M]=Kf[L]n\frac{[\ce{ML_n}]}{[\ce{M}]} = K_f [\ce{L}]^n.

  • Write down the definition of KfK_f and isolate the desired ratio before applying any limit.

Apply mass balance on the ligand
  • Because all species concentrations are non-negative, 0≤[L]≤CL0 \le [\ce{L}] \le C_{\ce{L}}, so CL→0C_{\ce{L}} \to 0 forces [L]→0[\ce{L}] \to 0.

  • Check whether the ligand is supplied by another equilibrium before assuming its concentration is constant or non-zero.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express the formation constant: Kf=[[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][AgX+][NHX3]2K_f = \frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]}{[\ce{Ag+}][\ce{NH3}]^2}, so [[Ag(NHX3)X2]X+][AgX+]=Kf[NHX3]2\frac{[\ce{[Ag(NH3)2]+}]}{[\ce{Ag+}]} = K_f [\ce{NH3}]^2.

  2. Set up the mass balance for ammonia: 0≤[NHX3]≤CNHX30 \le [\ce{NH3}] \le C_{\ce{NH3}}.

  3. Evaluate the limit as CNHX3→0C_{\ce{NH3}} \to 0: [NHX3]→0[\ce{NH3}] \to 0, giving lim⁡CNHX3→0Kf[NHX3]2=Kf⋅02=0\lim_{C_{\ce{NH3}} \to 0} K_f [\ce{NH3}]^2 = K_f \cdot 0^2 = 0.

Final answer

00

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write the explicit mass-action expression for the required ratio instead of borrowing an overall reaction constant.

  • Track the mass balance of the coordinating ligand to verify how its free concentration behaves at extreme dilutions.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

For the formation of the complex ion [Cu(NHX3)X4]X2+\ce{[Cu(NH3)4]^2+} with Kf=2.1×1013K_f = 2.1 \times 10^{13}, determine the ratio [[Cu(NHX3)X4]X2+][CuX2+]\frac{[\ce{[Cu(NH3)4]^2+}]}{[\ce{Cu^2+}]} in a solution where the equilibrium free ammonia concentration is [NHX3]=1.0×10−3 M[\ce{NH3}] = 1.0 \times 10^{-3}\text{ M}.

Answer

2.1×1012.1 \times 10^1 (or 2121). Key step: Use [[Cu(NHX3)X4]X2+][CuX2+]=Kf[NHX3]4=(2.1×1013)(1.0×10−3)4=(2.1×1013)(1.0×10−12)=21\frac{[\ce{[Cu(NH3)4]^2+}]}{[\ce{Cu^2+}]} = K_f [\ce{NH3}]^4 = (2.1 \times 10^{13})(1.0 \times 10^{-3})^4 = (2.1 \times 10^{13})(1.0 \times 10^{-12}) = 21.

02

Solid copper(I) chloride dissolves in aqueous cyanide according to CuX+(aq)+2 CNX−(aq)⇌[Cu(CN)X2]X−(aq)\ce{Cu+(aq) + 2 CN-(aq) <=> [Cu(CN)2]-(aq)} with Kf=1.0×1024K_f = 1.0 \times 10^{24}. If total cyanide concentration approaches zero (CCNX−→0C_{\ce{CN-}} \to 0), what is the limiting ratio of free metal ion to complex ion, lim⁡CCNX−→0[CuX+][[Cu(CN)X2]X−]\lim_{C_{\ce{CN-}} \to 0} \frac{[\ce{Cu+}]}{[\ce{[Cu(CN)2]-}]}?

Answer

∞\infty (approaches positive infinity). Key step: [CuX+][[Cu(CN)X2]X−]=1Kf[CNX−]2\frac{[\ce{Cu+}]}{[\ce{[Cu(CN)2]-}]} = \frac{1}{K_f [\ce{CN-}]^2}. As [CNX−]→0[\ce{CN-}] \to 0, the denominator approaches 0+0^+, causing the ratio to diverge to infinity.

03

Cadmium forms two successive chloro-complexes: CdX2++ClX−⇌[CdCl]X+\ce{Cd^2+ + Cl- <=> [CdCl]+} (K1=100K_1 = 100) and [CdCl]X++ClX−⇌[CdClX2]\ce{[CdCl]+ + Cl- <=> [CdCl2]} (K2=5K_2 = 5). Evaluate lim⁡CClX−→0[[CdClX2]][[CdCl]X+]\lim_{C_{\ce{Cl-}} \to 0} \frac{[\ce{[CdCl2]}]}{[\ce{[CdCl]+}]} and compare it to lim⁡CClX−→0[[CdClX2]][CdX2+]\lim_{C_{\ce{Cl-}} \to 0} \frac{[\ce{[CdCl2]}]}{[\ce{Cd^2+}]}.

Answer

Both limits are 00. Key step: [[CdClX2]][[CdCl]X+]=K2[ClX−]\frac{[\ce{[CdCl2]}]}{[\ce{[CdCl]+}]} = K_2 [\ce{Cl-}] and [[CdClX2]][CdX2+]=β2[ClX−]2=(K1K2)[ClX−]2\frac{[\ce{[CdCl2]}]}{[\ce{Cd^2+}]} = \beta_2 [\ce{Cl-}]^2 = (K_1 K_2)[\ce{Cl-}]^2. As [ClX−]→0[\ce{Cl-}] \to 0, both expressions approach zero, though the second approaches zero quadratically faster.

Loading workspace…