Resources
Consider the autoionization of liquid water at : . Evaluate whether pure liquid water satisfies the Arrhenius definition of both an acid and a base simultaneously, and state the exact quantitative threshold concentration for and at which this neutral boundary is maintained.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Pure water acts as both an Arrhenius acid and base because its self-ionization yields equal concentrations of (or ) and at .
Steps
Review the Arrhenius Definitions
According to the Arrhenius theory:
- An Arrhenius acid is a substance that produces or increases the concentration of hydrogen ions ( or hydronium ions, ) in aqueous solution.
- An Arrhenius base is a substance that produces or increases the concentration of hydroxide ions () in aqueous solution.
Evaluate Pure Water Under the Arrhenius Definition
Liquid water undergoes self-ionization (autoionization) according to the reversible reaction:
In pure liquid water, the dissociation of water molecules directly yields both hydronium ions () and hydroxide ions (). Because pure water intrinsically generates both of these characteristic ions in an aqueous medium, it simultaneously satisfies the criteria for both an Arrhenius acid and an Arrhenius base.
Calculate the Neutral Threshold Concentration at
The ion-product constant of liquid water at is defined as:
Because the autoionization of pure water produces hydronium and hydroxide ions in a strict stoichiometric ratio:
Substituting this equality into the equilibrium expression gives:
Therefore, the exact quantitative threshold concentration maintaining this neutral boundary at is:
Common Pitfall: Students often classify water as amphoteric solely using the Brønsted-Lowry proton-transfer definition (proton donor vs. proton acceptor) and assume it cannot be an Arrhenius acid or base because it is the solvent itself. However, because its self-dissociation directly supplies both and , it satisfies the Arrhenius definition simultaneously.
Typical errors
01 A student confuses the Brønsted-Lowry amphiprotic definition of water with the Arrhenius definition, incorrectly claiming water is both an Arrhenius acid and base because it produces both hydronium and hydroxide ions upon autoionization.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Arrhenius acid produces and Arrhenius base produces in water. Autoionization produces both and simultaneously. Pure liquid water acts as both an Arrhenius acid and an Arrhenius base.
- Step 2
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly stated the criteria for Arrhenius acids and bases in aqueous media.
You properly connected the chemical equation for water autoionization to the simultaneous generation of both characteristic ions.
You correctly used the ion-product constant at to find the exact neutral threshold concentrations.
02 A student misidentifies the quantitative concentration threshold by conflating the neutral concentration with the neutral pH value of 7, yielding 7 M or confusing the exponent with the product Kw.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Arrhenius acids and bases are solutes added to water that increase or . Water is the solvent, so pure water cannot be an Arrhenius acid or base simultaneously.
CorrectBecause liquid water self-ionizes () to release both and ions into the aqueous phase, pure water simultaneously satisfies both the Arrhenius acid and Arrhenius base criteria.
You restricted the Arrhenius definition to external solutes dissolved in water. However, the Arrhenius model classifies any substance that produces or in an aqueous medium as an acid or base; because autoionization directly yields both characteristic ions, water qualifies as both.
- Step 2Correct
You correctly noted that and , but you equated the individual ion concentrations directly to the product constant rather than taking its square root. Since , the concentration is (which also corresponds to ).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recalled that the ion-product constant of water is at .
You correctly recognized that a neutral aqueous solution at has and equal concentrations of hydronium and hydroxide.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou wrote despite noting , confusing the product with the single ion concentration.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conceptualized Arrhenius acids and bases strictly as external solutes rather than species that generate or in aqueous solution, and algebraically equated individual equilibrium factors to their product constant () instead of solving .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Arrhenius Criteria for Pure Substances
An Arrhenius acid yields in water, and an Arrhenius base yields in water, regardless of whether the substance is a solute or the liquid itself.
Check whether self-dissociation directly supplies both ions into solution.
- Solving Symmetric Ion Products
When a 1:1 autoionization occurs, , so .
Always take the square root of to find neutral ion concentrations; do not equate the single ion molarity to the overall equilibrium constant.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the autoionization reaction: .
Evaluate Arrhenius definitions: because water self-ionizes into both (the acid ion) and (the base ion), it acts as an Arrhenius acid and base simultaneously.
Write the equilibrium expression for neutral water: at .
Set , giving .
Solve for : .
Pure water satisfies both the Arrhenius acid and base definitions simultaneously, maintaining a neutral threshold of at .
Lock it in
How does pure liquid water qualify as both an Arrhenius acid and an Arrhenius base simultaneously?
Its self-ionization () directly generates both and ions in aqueous solution.
Similar question
At , the autoionization constant of water is . Calculate and for pure water at this temperature, and state whether the water is acidic, basic, or neutral.
Answer
Because in pure water, . The water remains strictly neutral because , even though the .
Explain whether the hydrogen carbonate ion () can act as an Arrhenius acid and base in aqueous solution by writing the relevant chemical equilibrium reactions.
Answer
Yes. As an Arrhenius acid, , producing . As an Arrhenius base, , producing .
A solution at has . Calculate using , classify the solution as acidic or basic, and determine how the Arrhenius definition classifies the added solute.
Answer
. Because , the solution is acidic, and the added solute acted as an Arrhenius acid by increasing above .