Resources

In a materials characterization lab, a student performs powder X-ray diffraction (XRD) using Cu Kα\text{Cu } K\alpha radiation (λ=1.5418 A˚\lambda = 1.5418\text{ \AA}) on a synthetic crystalline sample of silicon carbide (SiC\text{SiC}, face-centered cubic zinc blende polymorph). The first prominent diffraction peak corresponding to the (111)(111) reflection planes is recorded at an angle of 2θ=35.65∘2\theta = 35.65^\circ. (a) Using Bragg's law (nλ=2dsin⁡θn\lambda = 2d\sin\theta, with n=1n=1), calculate the interplanar spacing d111d_{111} in angstroms. (b) For a cubic crystal, dhkl=ah2+k2+l2d_{hkl} = \frac{a}{\sqrt{h^2+k^2+l^2}}; determine the cubic unit cell edge length aa. (c) If an independent differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) test shows no endothermic melting peak up to the instrument limit of 1800∘C1800^\circ\text{C} (2073 K2073\text{ K}), explain how this thermodynamic observation corroborates the XRD determination that the substance is a covalent network solid rather than a molecular solid.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Given 2θ=35.65∘2\theta = 35.65^\circ, θ=17.825∘\theta = 17.825^\circ. Using Bragg's Law: d111=λ2sin⁡θ=1.5418 A˚2sin⁡(17.825∘)=1.54182(0.3061)=2.518 A˚d_{111} = \frac{\lambda}{2\sin\theta} = \frac{1.5418\text{ \AA}}{2\sin(17.825^\circ)} = \frac{1.5418}{2(0.3061)} = 2.518\text{ \AA}. (b) For the (111)(111) planes in a cubic lattice: a=d11112+12+12=2.518 A˚×3=4.361 A˚a = d_{111} \sqrt{1^2 + 1^2 + 1^2} = 2.518\text{ \AA} \times \sqrt{3} = 4.361\text{ \AA}. (c) Molecular solids are held together by weak intermolecular forces (dipole-dipole or London dispersion) and melt well below 500∘C500^\circ\text{C} because disrupting these forces requires minimal thermal energy. The absence of melting up to 1800∘C1800^\circ\text{C} demonstrates that thermal degradation requires breaking an infinite three-dimensional lattice of localized, covalent Si−C\text{Si}-\text{C} bonds (bond enthalpy ∼318 kJ/mol\sim 318\text{ kJ/mol}), unequivocally corroborating a covalent network structure.

Steps

Part (a): Calculating the Interplanar Spacing d111d_{111}

  1. Find the Bragg diffraction angle θ\theta: Diffractometers record data as 2θ2\theta. Halving this angle gives the incident angle θ\theta: θ=2θ2=35.65∘2=17.825∘\theta = \frac{2\theta}{2} = \frac{35.65^\circ}{2} = 17.825^\circ

    Common Pitfall: Forgetting to divide the experimental angle 2θ2\theta by 22 is the most frequent error in Bragg's law calculations.

  2. Apply Bragg's Law: Bragg's Law relates the X-ray wavelength λ\lambda, the order of reflection nn, and the interplanar spacing dd: nλ=2d111sin⁡θn\lambda = 2d_{111}\sin\theta

    For first-order diffraction (n=1n = 1): d111=λ2sin⁡θd_{111} = \frac{\lambda}{2\sin\theta}

  3. Substitute the given values: sin⁡(17.825∘)≈0.3061\sin(17.825^\circ) \approx 0.3061 d111=1.5418 A˚2⋅0.3061=1.5418 A˚0.6122≈2.518 A˚d_{111} = \frac{1.5418\text{ \AA}}{2 \cdot 0.3061} = \frac{1.5418\text{ \AA}}{0.6122} \approx 2.518\text{ \AA}

Part (b): Determining the Cubic Unit Cell Edge Length aa

  1. Relate dhkld_{hkl} to the cubic lattice parameter aa: In any cubic crystal system, the spacing between parallel planes with Miller indices (hkl)(hkl) is given by: dhkl=ah2+k2+l2d_{hkl} = \frac{a}{\sqrt{h^2 + k^2 + l^2}}
  2. Rearrange to solve for aa for the (111)(111) planes: a=d111h2+k2+l2=d11112+12+12=d1113a = d_{111}\sqrt{h^2 + k^2 + l^2} = d_{111}\sqrt{1^2 + 1^2 + 1^2} = d_{111}\sqrt{3}
  3. Calculate the numerical value: a=2.518 A˚⋅3≈2.518 A˚⋅1.7321≈4.361 A˚a = 2.518\text{ \AA} \cdot \sqrt{3} \approx 2.518\text{ \AA} \cdot 1.7321 \approx 4.361\text{ \AA}

Part (c): Thermodynamic Corroboration of a Covalent Network Solid

  1. Behavior of Molecular Solids:

    • Molecular solids (such as COX2\ce{CO2}, IX2\ce{I2}, or organic crystals) consist of discrete molecules held together exclusively by weak intermolecular forces (London dispersion forces, dipole-dipole attractions, or hydrogen bonds).
    • Melting a molecular solid requires overcoming only these weak intermolecular attractions, leaving the intramolecular covalent bonds intact. Consequently, molecular solids typically exhibit low melting temperatures (almost always well below 300∘C300^\circ\text{C} to 500∘C500^\circ\text{C}).
  2. Behavior of Covalent Network Solids:

    • In a covalent network solid like silicon carbide (SiC\ce{SiC}), every atom is bonded to its neighbors in a continuous, three-dimensional framework of strong, directional covalent bonds (e.g., localized Si−C\ce{Si-C} bonds).
    • Phase change (melting) requires breaking these robust covalent bonds throughout the entire macroscopic crystal. Because the bond dissociation enthalpy of covalent bonds is very high (∼318 kJ/mol\sim 318\text{ kJ/mol} for Si−C\ce{Si-C}), an enormous amount of thermal energy is required to disrupt the lattice.
  3. Conclusion:

    • The absence of an endothermic melting transition up to 1800∘C1800^\circ\text{C} (2073 K2073\text{ K}) confirms that the solid does not consist of discrete molecules held by intermolecular forces. Instead, it definitively confirms a rigid, extended 3D covalent network structure.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student directly substitutes the recorded diffraction angle 2θ into Bragg's law without dividing it by 2 to obtain θ, yielding an erroneously small interplanar spacing and lattice parameter.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    d111=λ2sin⁡(35.65∘)  ⟹  d111=1.54182⋅0.5828=1.323 A˚d_{111} = \frac{\lambda}{2\sin(35.65^\circ)} \implies d_{111} = \frac{1.5418}{2 \cdot 0.5828} = 1.323\text{ \AA}

    Correct

    θ=2θ2=35.65∘2=17.825∘  ⟹  d111=λ2sin⁡θ=1.5418 A˚2sin⁡(17.825∘)≈2.518 A˚\theta = \frac{2\theta}{2} = \frac{35.65^\circ}{2} = 17.825^\circ \implies d_{111} = \frac{\lambda}{2\sin\theta} = \frac{1.5418\text{ \AA}}{2\sin(17.825^\circ)} \approx 2.518\text{ \AA}

    Diffractometers record peak positions in terms of the total deflection angle 2θ2\theta. Bragg's law requires the glancing angle θ\theta between the incident X-ray beam and the crystal plane, so you must divide 35.65∘35.65^\circ by 22 to get θ=17.825∘\theta = 17.825^\circ before evaluating the sine function.

  2. Step 2

    a=d111⋅12+12+12  ⟹  a=1.323⋅3=2.292 A˚a = d_{111} \cdot \sqrt{1^2+1^2+1^2} \implies a = 1.323 \cdot \sqrt{3} = 2.292\text{ \AA}

    Correct

    a=d11112+12+12=2.518 A˚⋅3≈4.361 A˚a = d_{111}\sqrt{1^2+1^2+1^2} = 2.518\text{ \AA} \cdot \sqrt{3} \approx 4.361\text{ \AA}

    Your formula a=d111h2+k2+l2a = d_{111}\sqrt{h^2+k^2+l^2} is correct, but because d111d_{111} was calculated with 2θ2\theta instead of θ\theta, the resulting unit cell length inherited that error.

  3. Step 3

    Molecular solids have weak intermolecular forces and melt at relatively low temperatures. Not melting up to 1800∘C1800^\circ\text{C} indicates a continuous network of strong covalent bonds throughout the crystal lattice, confirming a covalent network solid.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You selected the correct formula relating the interplanar spacing dhkld_{hkl} to the cubic lattice parameter aa.

You provided a thorough thermodynamic contrast between molecular solids and covalent network solids.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Diffraction Angle Definition Slip ($2\theta$ vs. $\theta$)

You substituted the full detector angle 2θ=35.65∘2\theta = 35.65^\circ directly into sin⁡θ\sin\theta in Bragg's law.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking that powder XRD data outputs the scattering angle 2θ2\theta relative to the transmitted beam, whereas Bragg's law defines θ\theta as the angle between the incident beam and the crystal plane.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check the Angular Variable in XRD Data
  • XRD diffractogram peaks are always reported as 2θ2\theta, but Bragg's law uses θ\theta.

  • Always write down θ=2θ2\theta = \frac{2\theta}{2} explicitly before computing sin⁡θ\sin\theta.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Halve the recorded angle: θ=35.65∘2=17.825∘\theta = \frac{35.65^\circ}{2} = 17.825^\circ.

  2. Substitute into Bragg's law: d111=1.5418 A˚2sin⁡(17.825∘)=1.54182(0.3061)≈2.518 A˚d_{111} = \frac{1.5418\text{ \AA}}{2\sin(17.825^\circ)} = \frac{1.5418}{2(0.3061)} \approx 2.518\text{ \AA}.

  3. Calculate the cubic lattice parameter: a=d11112+12+12=2.518 A˚×3≈4.361 A˚a = d_{111}\sqrt{1^2+1^2+1^2} = 2.518\text{ \AA} \times \sqrt{3} \approx 4.361\text{ \AA}.

Final answer

(a) d111≈2.518 A˚d_{111} \approx 2.518\text{ \AA}; (b) a≈4.361 A˚a \approx 4.361\text{ \AA}; (c) The lack of melting up to 1800∘C1800^\circ\text{C} indicates high bond enthalpy across an infinite 3D covalent lattice, ruling out a molecular solid.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before using Bragg's law, write θ=(2θ)/2\theta = (2\theta)/2 as an explicit preliminary step.

  • Check whether your calculated unit cell parameter is physically reasonable (typical ceramic cubic lattice constants range between 3 A˚3\text{ \AA} and 6 A˚6\text{ \AA}).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student mistakenly divides the interplanar spacing by the Miller index factor rather than multiplying by it when solving for the unit cell edge length a.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    θ=35.65∘/2=17.825∘  ⟹  d111=1.54182⋅sin⁡(17.825∘)=2.518 A˚\theta = 35.65^\circ / 2 = 17.825^\circ \implies d_{111} = \frac{1.5418}{2 \cdot \sin(17.825^\circ)} = 2.518\text{ \AA}

  2. Step 2

    a=d11112+12+12  ⟹  a=2.5183=1.454 A˚a = \frac{d_{111}}{\sqrt{1^2+1^2+1^2}} \implies a = \frac{2.518}{\sqrt{3}} = 1.454\text{ \AA}

    Correct

    a=d111h2+k2+l2=2.518 A˚⋅3≈4.361 A˚a = d_{111}\sqrt{h^2+k^2+l^2} = 2.518\text{ \AA} \cdot \sqrt{3} \approx 4.361\text{ \AA}

    Rearranging dhkl=ah2+k2+l2d_{hkl} = \frac{a}{\sqrt{h^2+k^2+l^2}} for the edge length aa requires multiplying both sides by h2+k2+l2\sqrt{h^2+k^2+l^2}, not dividing.

  3. Step 3

    Molecular solids melt easily because intermolecular attractions are weak. Remaining solid beyond 1800∘C1800^\circ\text{C} requires breaking pervasive strong covalent bonds, corroborating a covalent network structure.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly converted the diffractometer angle 2θ2\theta into the incident Bragg angle θ\theta.

You accurately applied Bragg's law to solve for the interplanar spacing d111d_{111}.

You correctly contrasted the weak intermolecular forces of molecular solids with the extensive covalent network bonds required to maintain solid structure above 1800∘C1800^\circ\text{C}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic rearrangement inversion

You divided d111d_{111} by 3\sqrt{3} instead of multiplying d111d_{111} by 3\sqrt{3}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When isolating the numerator aa from the fraction dhkl=ah2+k2+l2d_{hkl} = \frac{a}{\sqrt{h^2+k^2+l^2}}, you treated the denominator as a multiplying factor on aa, inadvertently placing the radical in the denominator of the solved expression.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Isolating Numerators in Ratios
  • If y=xky = \frac{x}{k}, then multiplying both sides by kk gives x=y⋅kx = y \cdot k.

  • Always clear the denominator first by multiplying both sides by h2+k2+l2\sqrt{h^2+k^2+l^2} before substituting numerical values.

Physical Dimension Sanity Check
  • For any set of crystal planes (hkl)(hkl), the interplanar spacing dhkld_{hkl} must be smaller than or equal to the unit cell edge length aa (since h2+k2+l2≥1\sqrt{h^2+k^2+l^2} \ge 1).

  • Check that your calculated unit cell edge length aa is strictly greater than d111d_{111}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Multiply both sides of d111=a12+12+12d_{111} = \frac{a}{\sqrt{1^2+1^2+1^2}} by 3\sqrt{3} to isolate aa: a=d1113a = d_{111}\sqrt{3}.

  2. Substitute d111=2.518 A˚d_{111} = 2.518\text{ \AA}: a=2.518 A˚×1.7321≈4.361 A˚a = 2.518\text{ \AA} \times 1.7321 \approx 4.361\text{ \AA}.

Final answer

(a) d111=2.518 A˚d_{111} = 2.518\text{ \AA}; (b) a=4.361 A˚a = 4.361\text{ \AA}; (c) Molecular solids melt at low temperatures by overcoming weak intermolecular forces, while covalent network solids require breaking extensive, strong covalent bonds throughout the 3D lattice, explaining why SiC\ce{SiC} remains solid past 1800∘C1800^\circ\text{C}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice cross-multiplying formulas of the form d=aNd = \frac{a}{\sqrt{N}} to solve for aa before plugging in numbers.

  • Use the physical boundary check a≥dhkla \ge d_{hkl} whenever computing cubic lattice parameters.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 A student uses the angle in degrees directly in a radian-mode calculation of the sine function, yielding a negative and unphysical value for the interplanar spacing.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    θ=35.65∘2=17.825∘\theta = \frac{35.65^\circ}{2} = 17.825^\circ

  2. Step 2

    sin⁡(17.825)=−0.5968  ⟹  d111=1.54182⋅(−0.5968)=−1.292 A˚\sin(17.825) = -0.5968 \implies d_{111} = \frac{1.5418}{2 \cdot (-0.5968)} = -1.292\text{ \AA}

    Correct

    sin⁡(17.825∘)≈0.3061  ⟹  d111=λ2sin⁡θ=1.5418 A˚2(0.3061)≈2.518 A˚\sin(17.825^\circ) \approx 0.3061 \implies d_{111} = \frac{\lambda}{2\sin\theta} = \frac{1.5418\text{ \AA}}{2(0.3061)} \approx 2.518\text{ \AA}

    You evaluated sin⁡(17.825)\sin(17.825) with an incorrect calculator angle mode (or entry error), yielding −0.5968-0.5968 and an unphysical negative interplanar spacing d111=−1.292 A˚d_{111} = -1.292\text{ \AA}. In degree mode, sin⁡(17.825∘)≈0.3061\sin(17.825^\circ) \approx 0.3061, giving d111≈2.518 A˚d_{111} \approx 2.518\text{ \AA}.

  3. Step 3

    a=d111⋅3  ⟹  a=−1.292⋅3=−2.238 A˚a = d_{111} \cdot \sqrt{3} \implies a = -1.292 \cdot \sqrt{3} = -2.238\text{ \AA}

    Correct

    a=d11112+12+12=2.518 A˚⋅3≈4.361 A˚a = d_{111}\sqrt{1^2+1^2+1^2} = 2.518\text{ \AA} \cdot \sqrt{3} \approx 4.361\text{ \AA}

    Your formula a=d1113a = d_{111}\sqrt{3} for the (111)(111) planes of a cubic crystal is completely correct, but your numerical result carries forward the erroneous negative value of d111d_{111} from part (a).

  4. Step 4

    Molecular solids have weak van der Waals forces and melt at low temperatures. A melting point above 1800∘C1800^\circ\text{C} requires breaking strong covalent bonds throughout the entire structure, which confirms it is a covalent network solid.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly halved the recorded 2θ2\theta angle to determine the Bragg angle θ=17.825∘\theta = 17.825^\circ.

You correctly applied the cubic interplanar spacing relationship a=dhklh2+k2+l2a = d_{hkl}\sqrt{h^2+k^2+l^2} with h=k=l=1h=k=l=1.

You accurately contrasted the weak intermolecular forces in molecular solids with the extensive covalent bonding in network solids to interpret the DSC data.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Trigonometric Mode Error / Negative Lattice Dimension

You obtained a negative sine value from entering 17.82517.825 into a calculator not configured for degree mode, resulting in a negative interplanar spacing.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You did not perform a physical reality check on the calculated geometric quantities. Physical distances such as interplanar spacing dd and lattice constant aa must always be positive. Whenever a trigonometric function in Bragg's law yields a negative number or a value outside (0,1)(0, 1), verify that the calculator is set to degree mode (DEG).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Calculator Angle Mode Check
  • Diffractometer angles are measured in degrees (∘^\circ). Bragg's law requires evaluating sin⁡(θ∘)\sin(\theta^\circ) with the calculator set strictly to Degree (DEG) mode.

  • Before computing sin⁡θ\sin\theta, confirm the calculator display shows 'DEG' and verify that 0<sin⁡θ≤10 < \sin\theta \le 1 for 0∘<θ<90∘0^\circ < \theta < 90^\circ.

Physical Sanity Check on Spatial Dimensions
  • Interplanar spacings dhkld_{hkl} and unit cell edge lengths aa are physical lengths and must always be strictly positive and typically on the order of 1 to 10 A˚1\text{ to }10\text{ \AA} for inorganic crystals.

  • If a computed lattice dimension is negative or unrealistically small, immediately recheck the sign of sin⁡θ\sin\theta and your algebraic rearrangement.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate sin⁡(17.825∘)\sin(17.825^\circ) in degree mode: sin⁡(17.825∘)≈0.3061\sin(17.825^\circ) \approx 0.3061.

  2. Substitute into Bragg's law (n=1n=1): d111=λ2sin⁡θ=1.5418 A˚2(0.3061)=2.518 A˚d_{111} = \frac{\lambda}{2\sin\theta} = \frac{1.5418\text{ \AA}}{2(0.3061)} = 2.518\text{ \AA}.

  3. Calculate the cubic lattice parameter aa: a=d11112+12+12=2.518 A˚×3≈4.361 A˚a = d_{111}\sqrt{1^2+1^2+1^2} = 2.518\text{ \AA} \times \sqrt{3} \approx 4.361\text{ \AA}.

Final answer

(a) d111=2.518 A˚d_{111} = 2.518\text{ \AA}; (b) a=4.361 A˚a = 4.361\text{ \AA}; (c) The lack of melting up to 1800∘C1800^\circ\text{C} indicates that melting requires cleaving strong, directional covalent Si−C\text{Si}-\text{C} bonds throughout an extended three-dimensional framework, which is characteristic of a covalent network solid rather than discrete molecules bound by weak intermolecular attractions.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always verify your calculator's mode indicator (DEG vs. RAD) before calculating trigonometric functions in crystallography problems.

  • Implement an automatic sanity check after computing any physical length or lattice spacing to ensure it is positive and physically reasonable (1–10 A˚1\text{--}10\text{ \AA}).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Using Cu Kα\text{Cu } K\alpha radiation (λ=1.5406 A˚\lambda = 1.5406\text{ \AA}), the (200)(200) peak of an unknown crystal appears at 2θ=44.50∘2\theta = 44.50^\circ. Calculate the interplanar spacing d200d_{200} for first-order diffraction (n=1n=1).

Answer

d200≈2.034 A˚d_{200} \approx 2.034\text{ \AA}. Key steps: θ=44.50∘/2=22.25∘\theta = 44.50^\circ / 2 = 22.25^\circ; sin⁡(22.25∘)≈0.3786\sin(22.25^\circ) \approx 0.3786; d=1.5406 A˚2(0.3786)≈2.034 A˚d = \frac{1.5406\text{ \AA}}{2(0.3786)} \approx 2.034\text{ \AA}.

02

A face-centered cubic metal has its (220)(220) reflection at 2θ=65.20∘2\theta = 65.20^\circ under X-rays with λ=1.5418 A˚\lambda = 1.5418\text{ \AA}. Calculate the interplanar spacing d220d_{220} and the cubic lattice constant aa.

Answer

d220≈1.430 A˚d_{220} \approx 1.430\text{ \AA}, a≈4.045 A˚a \approx 4.045\text{ \AA}. Key steps: θ=32.60∘\theta = 32.60^\circ; d220=1.5418 A˚2sin⁡(32.60∘)=1.54182(0.5388)≈1.430 A˚d_{220} = \frac{1.5418\text{ \AA}}{2\sin(32.60^\circ)} = \frac{1.5418}{2(0.5388)} \approx 1.430\text{ \AA}; a=d22022+22+02=1.430 A˚×8≈4.045 A˚a = d_{220}\sqrt{2^2+2^2+0^2} = 1.430\text{ \AA} \times \sqrt{8} \approx 4.045\text{ \AA}.

03

Diamond is a covalent network solid crystallizing in a cubic lattice with unit cell edge a=3.567 A˚a = 3.567\text{ \AA}. Using X-rays with λ=1.5418 A˚\lambda = 1.5418\text{ \AA}, at what angle 2θ2\theta will the first-order (111)(111) diffraction peak be detected?

Answer

2θ≈43.92∘2\theta \approx 43.92^\circ. Key steps: d111=a12+12+12=3.567 A˚3≈2.059 A˚d_{111} = \frac{a}{\sqrt{1^2+1^2+1^2}} = \frac{3.567\text{ \AA}}{\sqrt{3}} \approx 2.059\text{ \AA}; sin⁡θ=λ2d111=1.54182(2.059)≈0.3744\sin\theta = \frac{\lambda}{2d_{111}} = \frac{1.5418}{2(2.059)} \approx 0.3744; θ=arcsin⁡(0.3744)≈21.96∘\theta = \arcsin(0.3744) \approx 21.96^\circ; 2θ=2×21.96∘=43.92∘2\theta = 2 \times 21.96^\circ = 43.92^\circ.

Loading workspace…