Resources

A soil geochemical study measures the composition of lead isotopes in a contaminated mineral sample. The sample contains two primary lead isotopes: 206Pb^{206}\text{Pb} with an isotopic mass of 205.974 amu205.974\text{ amu} at a mass concentration of 523.5 mg/g523.5\text{ mg/g}, and 208Pb^{208}\text{Pb} with an isotopic mass of 207.977 amu207.977\text{ amu} at a mass concentration of 476.5 mg/g476.5\text{ mg/g}. Assuming these two isotopes account for the entire lead content, convert the concentration data into isotopic atom abundances and calculate the sample's average atomic mass of lead to five significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

206.93 amu206.93\text{ amu}

Steps

01

Understand the Distinction Between Mass Fraction and Atom Abundance

To find the average atomic mass of lead in the mineral sample, we must first convert the given mass concentrations into isotopic atom abundances (mole fractions), and then calculate the weighted average atomic mass.

The sample data provides mass concentrations:

  • Mass of 206Pb=523.5 mg^{206}\ce{Pb} = 523.5\text{ mg} per gram of total lead
  • Mass of 208Pb=476.5 mg^{208}\ce{Pb} = 476.5\text{ mg} per gram of total lead

Because 208Pb^{208}\ce{Pb} atoms are slightly heavier than 206Pb^{206}\ce{Pb} atoms, equal masses do not contain equal numbers of atoms. Average atomic mass is defined on a per-atom basis, so we must calculate the relative number of moles (or atoms) of each isotope.

02

Calculate the Relative Number of Moles

Using the isotopic masses:

  • m(206Pb)=205.974 amum(^{206}\ce{Pb}) = 205.974\text{ amu} (or g/mol\text{g/mol})
  • m(208Pb)=207.977 amum(^{208}\ce{Pb}) = 207.977\text{ amu} (or g/mol\text{g/mol})

Divide the mass of each isotope by its isotopic mass to find the relative molar amount:

n(206Pb)=523.5 mg205.974 g/mol≈2.5416 mmoln(^{206}\ce{Pb}) = \frac{523.5\text{ mg}}{205.974\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2.5416\text{ mmol}

n(208Pb)=476.5 mg207.977 g/mol≈2.2911 mmoln(^{208}\ce{Pb}) = \frac{476.5\text{ mg}}{207.977\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2.2911\text{ mmol}

The total molar amount of lead is:

ntotal=2.5416 mmol+2.2911 mmol=4.8327 mmoln_{\text{total}} = 2.5416\text{ mmol} + 2.2911\text{ mmol} = 4.8327\text{ mmol}

03

Determine the Isotopic Atom Abundances

The atom abundance (mole fraction, xx) of each isotope is the ratio of its moles to the total moles:

x(206Pb)=n(206Pb)ntotal=2.54164.8327≈0.5259(52.59%)x(^{206}\ce{Pb}) = \frac{n(^{206}\ce{Pb})}{n_{\text{total}}} = \frac{2.5416}{4.8327} \approx 0.5259\quad (52.59\%)

x(208Pb)=n(208Pb)ntotal=2.29114.8327≈0.4741(47.41%)x(^{208}\ce{Pb}) = \frac{n(^{208}\ce{Pb})}{n_{\text{total}}} = \frac{2.2911}{4.8327} \approx 0.4741\quad (47.41\%)

04

Calculate the Average Atomic Mass

The average atomic mass (AavgA_{\text{avg}}) is the abundance-weighted average of the isotopic masses:

Aavg=x(206Pb)⋅m(206Pb)+x(208Pb)⋅m(208Pb)A_{\text{avg}} = x(^{206}\ce{Pb}) \cdot m(^{206}\ce{Pb}) + x(^{208}\ce{Pb}) \cdot m(^{208}\ce{Pb})

Substituting the values:

Aavg=(0.5259)(205.974 amu)+(0.4741)(207.977 amu)A_{\text{avg}} = (0.5259)(205.974\text{ amu}) + (0.4741)(207.977\text{ amu})

Aavg=108.32 amu+98.60 amu≈206.93 amuA_{\text{avg}} = 108.32\text{ amu} + 98.60\text{ amu} \approx 206.93\text{ amu}

Rounded to five significant figures, the average atomic mass of lead in the sample is 206.93 amu206.93\text{ amu}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student treats the given mass concentrations directly as atom abundances without converting to molar quantities, leading to an incorrect average atomic mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Total mass=523.5 mg+476.5 mg=1000.0 mg  ⟹  x(206Pb)=523.51000.0=0.5235,  x(208Pb)=476.51000.0=0.4765\text{Total mass} = 523.5\text{ mg} + 476.5\text{ mg} = 1000.0\text{ mg} \implies x(^{206}\text{Pb}) = \frac{523.5}{1000.0} = 0.5235, \; x(^{208}\text{Pb}) = \frac{476.5}{1000.0} = 0.4765

    Correct

    n(206Pb)=523.5 mg205.974 g/mol≈2.5416 mmol,  n(208Pb)=476.5 mg207.977 g/mol≈2.2911 mmol  ⟹  x(206Pb)=2.54164.8327≈0.5259,  x(208Pb)=2.29114.8327≈0.4741n(^{206}\text{Pb}) = \frac{523.5\text{ mg}}{205.974\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2.5416\text{ mmol}, \; n(^{208}\text{Pb}) = \frac{476.5\text{ mg}}{207.977\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2.2911\text{ mmol} \implies x(^{206}\text{Pb}) = \frac{2.5416}{4.8327} \approx 0.5259, \; x(^{208}\text{Pb}) = \frac{2.2911}{4.8327} \approx 0.4741

    You calculated the mass fractions rather than the isotopic atom abundances. Because isotopes have different masses per atom, equal masses do not contain equal numbers of atoms. You must divide each mass by its isotopic mass to find moles before calculating the fractional abundance.

  2. Step 2

    Average atomic mass=0.5235×205.974 amu+0.4765×207.977 amu=107.827 amu+99.101 amu=206.93 amu\text{Average atomic mass} = 0.5235 \times 205.974\text{ amu} + 0.4765 \times 207.977\text{ amu} = 107.827\text{ amu} + 99.101\text{ amu} = 206.93\text{ amu}

    Correct

    Average atomic mass=0.5259×205.974 amu+0.4741×207.977 amu≈206.93 amu\text{Average atomic mass} = 0.5259 \times 205.974\text{ amu} + 0.4741 \times 207.977\text{ amu} \approx 206.93\text{ amu}

    You applied the weighted sum correctly, but this step is affected by substituting the mass fractions from Step 1 instead of the true atom abundances.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You summed the component quantities to find the total baseline.

You correctly applied the weighted average structure ∑(xi×mi)\sum (x_i \times m_i) to find average atomic mass.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Mass fraction confused with atom abundance

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated mass fraction with atom abundance (mole fraction), overlooking that average atomic mass is defined on a per-atom basis and therefore requires isotopic amounts in moles.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check the given abundance type
  • Average atomic mass weighting requires atom abundance (mole fraction), not mass percent or mass fraction.

  • Whenever concentration or mass data is provided, divide each component mass by its isotopic mass to determine relative moles before finding fractional abundance.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert each mass into relative molar amounts: n(206Pb)=523.5 mg205.974 g/mol≈2.5416 mmoln(^{206}\text{Pb}) = \frac{523.5\text{ mg}}{205.974\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2.5416\text{ mmol} and n(208Pb)=476.5 mg207.977 g/mol≈2.2911 mmoln(^{208}\text{Pb}) = \frac{476.5\text{ mg}}{207.977\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2.2911\text{ mmol}.

  2. Find total moles: ntotal=2.5416 mmol+2.2911 mmol=4.8327 mmoln_{\text{total}} = 2.5416\text{ mmol} + 2.2911\text{ mmol} = 4.8327\text{ mmol}.

  3. Compute atom abundances: x(206Pb)=2.54164.8327≈0.5259x(^{206}\text{Pb}) = \frac{2.5416}{4.8327} \approx 0.5259 and x(208Pb)=2.29114.8327≈0.4741x(^{208}\text{Pb}) = \frac{2.2911}{4.8327} \approx 0.4741.

  4. Calculate weighted average: Aavg=(0.5259)(205.974 amu)+(0.4741)(207.977 amu)≈206.93 amuA_{\text{avg}} = (0.5259)(205.974\text{ amu}) + (0.4741)(207.977\text{ amu}) \approx 206.93\text{ amu}.

Final answer

206.93 amu206.93\text{ amu}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice converting mass percent or mass concentration of isotopes into mole fractions before weighting.

  • Always verify whether problem data provides isotopic abundances as 'atom percent' or 'mass percent'.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student divides the isotopic masses by the mass concentrations instead of dividing mass concentrations by isotopic masses to find moles.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    n(206Pb)=205.974523.5=0.39346  ⟹  n(208Pb)=207.977476.5=0.43647n(^{206}\text{Pb}) = \frac{205.974}{523.5} = 0.39346 \implies n(^{208}\text{Pb}) = \frac{207.977}{476.5} = 0.43647

    Correct

    n(206Pb)=523.5 mg205.974 g/mol≈2.5416 mmol  ⟹  n(208Pb)=476.5 mg207.977 g/mol≈2.2911 mmoln(^{206}\text{Pb}) = \frac{523.5\text{ mg}}{205.974\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2.5416\text{ mmol} \implies n(^{208}\text{Pb}) = \frac{476.5\text{ mg}}{207.977\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2.2911\text{ mmol}

    To convert mass into amount of substance (moles), you must divide mass by molar mass (n=mMn = \frac{m}{M}). You placed the isotopic mass in the numerator and the mass concentration in the denominator, which calculates Mm\frac{M}{m} rather than moles.

  2. Step 2

    Total=0.39346+0.43647=0.82993  ⟹  x(206Pb)=0.393460.82993=0.47409,  x(208Pb)=0.436470.82993=0.52591\text{Total} = 0.39346 + 0.43647 = 0.82993 \implies x(^{206}\text{Pb}) = \frac{0.39346}{0.82993} = 0.47409,\; x(^{208}\text{Pb}) = \frac{0.43647}{0.82993} = 0.52591

    Correct

    ntotal=2.5416+2.2911=4.8327 mmol  ⟹  x(206Pb)=2.54164.8327≈0.52591,  x(208Pb)=2.29114.8327≈0.47409n_{\text{total}} = 2.5416 + 2.2911 = 4.8327\text{ mmol} \implies x(^{206}\text{Pb}) = \frac{2.5416}{4.8327} \approx 0.52591,\; x(^{208}\text{Pb}) = \frac{2.2911}{4.8327} \approx 0.47409

    Your method of dividing individual moles by total moles to find atom abundances (mole fractions) is correct, but the values are inverted because of the error in Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    Average atomic mass=0.47409×205.974 amu+0.52591×207.977 amu=97.650 amu+109.378 amu=207.03 amu\text{Average atomic mass} = 0.47409 \times 205.974\text{ amu} + 0.52591 \times 207.977\text{ amu} = 97.650\text{ amu} + 109.378\text{ amu} = 207.03\text{ amu}

    Correct

    Aavg=(0.52591)(205.974 amu)+(0.47409)(207.977 amu)≈206.93 amuA_{\text{avg}} = (0.52591)(205.974\text{ amu}) + (0.47409)(207.977\text{ amu}) \approx 206.93\text{ amu}

    You correctly weighted the isotopic masses by your calculated fractional abundances, but the inverted abundances shifted the weighted average toward the heavier isotope.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that mass concentrations must be converted to mole fractions before calculating average atomic mass.

You correctly defined the atom abundance as the ratio of an isotope's moles to the total moles.

You correctly applied the weighted-average formula using fractional abundances and isotopic masses.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Molar Conversion Formula

You divided molar mass by mass instead of dividing mass by molar mass when finding relative moles.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusion between the formula n=mMn = \frac{m}{M} and its reciprocal, likely caused by not tracking dimensional units like mg\text{mg} and g/mol\text{g/mol} during the division.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dimensional Analysis for Moles
  • Amount of substance in moles equals mass divided by molar mass: n=mMn = \frac{m}{M} (with units gg/mol=mol\frac{\text{g}}{\text{g/mol}} = \text{mol}).

  • Always write the units explicitly in the fraction to ensure the mass units cancel and moles remain in the numerator.

Sanity Check on Abundances
  • A lighter isotope has more atoms per gram than a heavier isotope.

  • If the lighter isotope has a higher mass concentration (523.5 mg/g>476.5 mg/g523.5\text{ mg/g} > 476.5\text{ mg/g}), its atom fraction must be even higher than its mass fraction (x>52.35%x > 52.35\%).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. n(206Pb)=523.5 mg205.974 g/mol≈2.5416 mmoln(^{206}\text{Pb}) = \frac{523.5\text{ mg}}{205.974\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2.5416\text{ mmol} and n(208Pb)=476.5 mg207.977 g/mol≈2.2911 mmoln(^{208}\text{Pb}) = \frac{476.5\text{ mg}}{207.977\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2.2911\text{ mmol}

  2. ntotal=2.5416 mmol+2.2911 mmol=4.8327 mmoln_{\text{total}} = 2.5416\text{ mmol} + 2.2911\text{ mmol} = 4.8327\text{ mmol}

  3. x(206Pb)=2.54164.8327≈0.52591x(^{206}\text{Pb}) = \frac{2.5416}{4.8327} \approx 0.52591 and x(208Pb)=2.29114.8327≈0.47409x(^{208}\text{Pb}) = \frac{2.2911}{4.8327} \approx 0.47409

  4. Aavg=(0.52591)(205.974 amu)+(0.47409)(207.977 amu)=108.324 amu+98.599 amu≈206.93 amuA_{\text{avg}} = (0.52591)(205.974\text{ amu}) + (0.47409)(207.977\text{ amu}) = 108.324\text{ amu} + 98.599\text{ amu} \approx 206.93\text{ amu}

Final answer

206.93 amu206.93\text{ amu}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice writing explicit physical units inside conversion fractions so you immediately catch inverted ratios.

  • Before calculating the final weighted average, do a quick qualitative check: verify that the isotope with the greater mass share also has the greater atom share.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates the unweighted simple arithmetic average of the isotopic masses, completely ignoring the isotopic abundance data.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    n(206Pb)=523.5/205.974=2.5416 mmol  ⟹  n(208Pb)=476.5/207.977=2.2911 mmol  ⟹  Total moles=2.5416+2.2911=4.8327 mmoln(^{206}\text{Pb}) = 523.5 / 205.974 = 2.5416\text{ mmol} \implies n(^{208}\text{Pb}) = 476.5 / 207.977 = 2.2911\text{ mmol} \implies \text{Total moles} = 2.5416 + 2.2911 = 4.8327\text{ mmol}

  2. Step 2

    x(206Pb)=2.5416/4.8327=0.5259  ⟹  x(208Pb)=2.2911/4.8327=0.4741x(^{206}\text{Pb}) = 2.5416 / 4.8327 = 0.5259 \implies x(^{208}\text{Pb}) = 2.2911 / 4.8327 = 0.4741

  3. Step 3

    Average atomic mass=(205.974 amu+207.977 amu)/2  ⟹  413.951/2=206.98 amu\text{Average atomic mass} = (205.974\text{ amu} + 207.977\text{ amu}) / 2 \implies 413.951 / 2 = 206.98\text{ amu}

    Correct

    Aavg=(0.5259)(205.974 amu)+(0.4741)(207.977 amu)=108.32 amu+98.60 amu=206.93 amuA_{\text{avg}} = (0.5259)(205.974\text{ amu}) + (0.4741)(207.977\text{ amu}) = 108.32\text{ amu} + 98.60\text{ amu} = 206.93\text{ amu}

    You calculated a simple arithmetic mean of the two isotopic masses by dividing their sum by 22, which assumes a 50%:50%50\%:50\% split. You need to multiply each isotopic mass by its corresponding atom abundance (xx) that you found in Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that mass concentrations must be converted to molar amounts before finding atom abundances.

You accurately calculated the mole fractions of 206Pb^{206}\text{Pb} and 208Pb^{208}\text{Pb}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unweighted arithmetic average used instead of weighted average

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You forgot to apply the calculated atom abundances as weights in the average atomic mass formula, defaulting instead to a simple arithmetic mean (m1+m2)/2(m_1 + m_2)/2.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Weighted Average Formula
  • Average atomic mass is the abundance-weighted sum: Aavg=∑(xi⋅mi)A_{\text{avg}} = \sum (x_i \cdot m_i), where xix_i is the fractional atom abundance of isotope ii.

  • Always multiply each isotope's mass by its fractional abundance (xix_i) and sum the products, rather than adding the masses and dividing by the number of isotopes.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Multiply each isotopic mass by its corresponding atom fraction: Aavg=(0.5259)(205.974 amu)+(0.4741)(207.977 amu)A_{\text{avg}} = (0.5259)(205.974\text{ amu}) + (0.4741)(207.977\text{ amu})

  2. Sum the weighted contributions: Aavg=108.322 amu+98.602 amu=206.924 amuA_{\text{avg}} = 108.322\text{ amu} + 98.602\text{ amu} = 206.924\text{ amu}

  3. Round to five significant figures: 206.93 amu206.93\text{ amu}

Final answer

206.93 amu206.93\text{ amu}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definition of average atomic mass as a weighted sum ∑ximi\sum x_i m_i.

  • Check that your final average lies closer to the more abundant isotope (206Pb^{206}\text{Pb} at 52.59%52.59\% pulls the average below 206.98 amu206.98\text{ amu}).

  • Solve the follow-up practice problems to reinforce using mole fractions as weights.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A sample of neon contains 20Ne^{20}\text{Ne} (19.992 amu19.992\text{ amu}) and 22Ne^{22}\text{Ne} (21.991 amu21.991\text{ amu}) with mass concentrations of 900.0 mg/g900.0\text{ mg/g} and 100.0 mg/g100.0\text{ mg/g}, respectively. Determine the isotopic atom abundance of 20Ne^{20}\text{Ne} to four significant figures.

Answer

0.90820.9082 (or 90.82%90.82\%). Key steps: n(20Ne)=900.019.992=45.018 mmoln(^{20}\text{Ne}) = \frac{900.0}{19.992} = 45.018\text{ mmol}, n(22Ne)=100.021.991=4.547 mmoln(^{22}\text{Ne}) = \frac{100.0}{21.991} = 4.547\text{ mmol}, ntotal=49.565 mmoln_{\text{total}} = 49.565\text{ mmol}, x(20Ne)=45.01849.565≈0.9082x(^{20}\text{Ne}) = \frac{45.018}{49.565} \approx 0.9082.

02

A synthetic mixture of chlorine consists of 35Cl^{35}\ce{Cl} (34.969 amu34.969\text{ amu}) and 37Cl^{37}\ce{Cl} (36.966 amu36.966\text{ amu}) with a mass ratio of 3.000:1.0003.000 : 1.000. Calculate the average atomic mass of chlorine in this sample to four significant figures.

Answer

35.45 amu35.45\text{ amu}. Key steps: For 3.000 g3.000\text{ g} of 35Cl^{35}\ce{Cl} and 1.000 g1.000\text{ g} of 37Cl^{37}\ce{Cl}, n(35Cl)=3.00034.969=0.08579 moln(^{35}\ce{Cl}) = \frac{3.000}{34.969} = 0.08579\text{ mol}, n(37Cl)=1.00036.966=0.02705 moln(^{37}\ce{Cl}) = \frac{1.000}{36.966} = 0.02705\text{ mol}. x(35Cl)=0.085790.11284=0.7603x(^{35}\ce{Cl}) = \frac{0.08579}{0.11284} = 0.7603, x(37Cl)=0.2397x(^{37}\ce{Cl}) = 0.2397. Average atomic mass =(0.7603)(34.969)+(0.2397)(36.966)=35.45 amu= (0.7603)(34.969) + (0.2397)(36.966) = 35.45\text{ amu}.

03

An enriched lithium target has a 6Li^{6}\ce{Li} (6.015 amu6.015\text{ amu}) mass fraction of 0.40000.4000 and a 7Li^{7}\ce{Li} (7.016 amu7.016\text{ amu}) mass fraction of 0.60000.6000. Calculate both the atom abundance of 6Li^{6}\ce{Li} and the average atomic mass of lithium in the target to four significant figures.

Answer

Atom abundance of 6Li=0.4376^{6}\ce{Li} = 0.4376 (43.76%43.76\%); average atomic mass =6.578 amu= 6.578\text{ amu}. Key steps: Moles per 100 g100\text{ g}: n(6Li)=40.006.015=6.6499 moln(^{6}\ce{Li}) = \frac{40.00}{6.015} = 6.6499\text{ mol}, n(7Li)=60.007.016=8.5519 moln(^{7}\ce{Li}) = \frac{60.00}{7.016} = 8.5519\text{ mol}, ntotal=15.2018 moln_{\text{total}} = 15.2018\text{ mol}. x(6Li)=6.649915.2018=0.4376x(^{6}\ce{Li}) = \frac{6.6499}{15.2018} = 0.4376. Average mass =(0.4376)(6.015)+(0.5624)(7.016)=2.632+3.946=6.578 amu= (0.4376)(6.015) + (0.5624)(7.016) = 2.632 + 3.946 = 6.578\text{ amu}.

Loading workspace…