Resources
A student constructs a silver concentration cell at with two identical electrodes. Compartment 1 initially contains . Compartment 2 is progressively diluted. (a) In terms of Compartment 1 and Compartment 2, identify which compartment acts as the anode and state the direction of electron flow. (b) As the silver ion concentration in Compartment 2 approaches the extreme dilution limit where , calculate the instantaneous cell potential at using .
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Compartment 2 (dilute solution) is the anode, Compartment 1 (concentrated solution) is the cathode, and electrons flow from Compartment 2 to Compartment 1; (b) .
Steps
Part (a): Identifying the Electrodes and Direction of Electron Flow
-
Principle of Concentration Cells: A concentration cell consists of two half-cells with identical electrodes and solutions of the same ion, differing only in solute concentration. The spontaneous process operates to equalize the concentrations in both compartments (driving the system toward equilibrium):
- The more dilute compartment must increase its concentration by oxidation.
- The more concentrated compartment must decrease its concentration by reduction.
-
Electrode Identification:
- Oxidation (Anode): Loss of electrons occurs in the dilute solution to produce more ions: Therefore, Compartment 2 (the dilute solution) acts as the anode.
- Reduction (Cathode): Gain of electrons occurs in the concentrated solution to consume excess ions: Therefore, Compartment 1 (the concentrated solution) acts as the cathode.
- Direction of Electron Flow: Electrons are released at the anode during oxidation and travel through the external wire to the cathode, where they are consumed in reduction. Thus, electrons flow through the external circuit from Compartment 2 to Compartment 1.
Part (b): Calculating the Instantaneous Cell Potential
- Standard Cell Potential (): Because both half-cells utilize the same chemical species (), the standard reduction potentials are identical:
- Net Cell Reaction and Reaction Quotient (): Adding the two half-reactions gives the overall cell process: The reaction quotient expresses the ratio of products to reactants:
- Applying the Nernst Equation: With electron transferred per silver atom, substitute the given values into the Nernst equation at :
- Evaluating the Logarithm: Since :
Common Pitfall: Remember that in concentration cells, the dilute compartment is always the product (). Inverting this ratio leads to a negative cell potential, which contradicts the spontaneous nature () of the discharging cell.
Typical errors
01 The student inverts the roles of the electrodes in a concentration cell by mistakenly assuming the compartment with higher ion concentration forces oxidation.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Compartment 1 has higher , so oxidation occurs there to produce more electrons. Compartment 1 acts as the anode.
CorrectCompartment 2 has the lower , so oxidation () occurs there to increase ion concentration toward equilibrium. Compartment 2 acts as the anode, and Compartment 1 acts as the cathode.
Spontaneous operation drives both half-cells toward concentration equality (Le Chatelier's principle). The dilute compartment must generate more cations by oxidation (anode), while the concentrated compartment must consume cations by reduction (cathode).
- Step 2
Electrons flow from Compartment 1 to Compartment 2.
CorrectElectrons flow through the external circuit from the anode (Compartment 2) to the cathode (Compartment 1).
Because your anode and cathode assignments were reversed in Step 1, your electron flow direction was also reversed. Electrons always flow from the anode to the cathode.
- Step 3Correct
The overall cell reaction is , so the reaction quotient is always . Reversing the half-cell roles inverted the ratio.
- Step 4Correct
Your arithmetic was executed correctly based on your value, but the inverted ratio yielded a negative cell potential. A galvanic cell discharging spontaneously must always produce .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that a concentration cell has a standard cell potential of .
You correctly determined that electron is transferred in the silver redox couple.
You accurately evaluated the logarithm and carried out the arithmetic of the Nernst equation.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo slip occurred; this was a conceptual confusion regarding which compartment drives oxidation in a concentration cell.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that a higher cation concentration forces oxidation, whereas spontaneous electrochemical processes act to equalize concentrations. Therefore, the dilute half-cell must undergo oxidation to produce more cations, making it the anode.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Equalization Principle
Galvanic concentration cells spontaneously run toward equal concentrations: dilute becomes more concentrated (oxidation), and concentrated becomes more dilute (reduction).
Always assign the anode to the dilute compartment () and the cathode to the concentrated compartment ().
- Reaction Quotient in Concentration Cells
, which ensures and .
Check your calculated cell potential: if , you have inverted .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the dilute solution as Compartment 2 () and the concentrated solution as Compartment 1 ().
Set oxidation at the dilute side: , so Compartment 2 is the anode.
Set reduction at the concentrated side: , so Compartment 1 is the cathode.
Direct electron flow through the external wire from anode to cathode: Compartment 2 to Compartment 1.
Write the net cell reaction: , yielding .
Substitute into the Nernst equation: .
(a) Compartment 2 is the anode, Compartment 1 is the cathode, and electrons flow from Compartment 2 to Compartment 1; (b) .
02 The student inverts the reaction quotient ratio in the Nernst equation as concentrated over dilute, yielding a negative cell potential for a spontaneous concentration cell.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Oxidation occurs in the more dilute solution to produce . Compartment 2 is the anode. Electrons flow from Compartment 2 to Compartment 1.
- Step 2Correct
You inverted the expression for the reaction quotient. The overall cell reaction consumes ions from the concentrated compartment and produces ions in the dilute compartment: . Therefore, products are dilute and reactants are concentrated, giving .
- Step 3Correct
Your arithmetic and application of the Nernst equation were correct, but because was inverted, your final cell potential ended up with an incorrect negative sign. Spontaneous concentration cells must yield a positive potential ().
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that oxidation occurs in the dilute compartment to generate ions.
You correctly assigned Compartment 2 as the anode and traced the external electron flow from Compartment 2 to Compartment 1.
You correctly recognized that and for a silver concentration cell.
You correctly executed the logarithmic calculation and arithmetic of the Nernst equation.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou accidentally placed the concentrated solution over the dilute solution when writing the expression for .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the reaction quotient as an arbitrary ratio of concentrations without writing out the net chemical equation: . Because oxidation occurs in the dilute compartment, dilute is the product and must be in the numerator of .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Net Reaction for Concentration Cells
Concentration cells spontaneously dilute the concentrated side and concentrate the dilute side: .
Always write down the net cell reaction before formulating to ensure you place the product (dilute) over the reactant (concentrated).
- Spontaneity Sanity Check
A discharging galvanic/concentration cell operates spontaneously, which requires .
Whenever you compute a negative for a galvanic cell, immediately check whether you inverted the numerator and denominator in .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the overall cell equation: .
Set up the reaction quotient: .
Substitute into the Nernst equation: .
Evaluate the logarithm: , so .
03 The student uses an incorrect sign in the Nernst equation, writing a plus sign instead of a minus sign before the logarithmic term.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Oxidation occurs at the lower concentration, so Compartment 2 is the anode. ⟹ Electrons flow from anode to cathode, so from Compartment 2 to Compartment 1.
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
You wrote a plus sign before the logarithmic term in the Nernst equation instead of a minus sign.
- Step 4Correct
Your evaluation followed your written formula correctly, but the initial sign error produced a negative instantaneous cell potential rather than the spontaneous positive value .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the oxidation site and direction of electron flow based on concentration differences.
You correctly determined and for a silver concentration cell.
You correctly formulated the reaction quotient .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou accidentally placed a plus sign in front of the logarithmic term in the Nernst equation.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the standard Nernst equation form with an alternative form that inverts , leading to an unphysical negative cell voltage for a spontaneous concentration cell.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Nernst Equation Standard Sign
The standard Nernst equation at is .
Always write the minus sign before , deriving it directly from divided by .
- Spontaneous Cell Potential Check
A concentration cell discharges spontaneously toward equal concentrations, meaning .
Whenever you calculate for a discharging concentration cell, verify that the resulting potential is positive.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the correct standard Nernst equation: .
Substitute the known values: .
Evaluate the logarithm: .
Multiply: .
+0.355 V
Lock it in
In any spontaneous galvanic concentration cell, which compartment serves as the anode: the dilute or the concentrated solution?
The dilute compartment. Oxidation occurs there to produce more cations, moving the system toward concentration equality.
Similar question
A zinc concentration cell is built with two electrodes at . Compartment A contains and Compartment B contains . Identify the anode, the cathode, and the direction of electron flow.
Answer
Anode: Compartment A (dilute solution oxidizes to produce ); Cathode: Compartment B (concentrated solution reduces to ); Electron flow: from Compartment A to Compartment B through the external circuit.
A nickel concentration cell at consists of two electrodes with in the cathode compartment. If the measured cell potential is , calculate the concentration of in the anode compartment. (Use and .)
Answer
. Using . Since , we find .
An electrochemical cell has two hydrogen electrodes immersed in different acid solutions at with . Compartment 1 has and Compartment 2 has . Identify the anode and determine the cell potential using .
Answer
Anode: Compartment 2; . Compartment 2 has (more dilute), so it oxidizes and acts as the anode. Compartment 1 has and acts as the cathode. For the net process , (or via ).