Resources
Determine the Lewis structure, electron-domain geometry, and molecular geometry for the triiodide anion () and the xenon difluoride molecule (). Many students mistakenly assign these three-atom species a bent geometry similar to water (). Identify the convention error regarding lone pair placement in a -electron domain system (equatorial vs. axial) and state the correct bond angle for both species.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Both and possess a central atom with electron domains ( single bonds and lone pairs, ); electron-domain geometry: trigonal bipyramidal; molecular geometry: linear with a bond angle of exactly . The student convention trap is placing lone pairs in axial positions rather than equatorial positions; in a trigonal bipyramid, lone pairs strictly occupy equatorial sites to minimize lone pair-lone pair and lone pair-bonding pair repulsions.
Steps
Count Valence Electrons and Draw Lewis Structures
-
Triiodide ion ():
- Each iodine atom contributes valence electrons, and the charge adds electron:
- Form single bonds from the central iodine to each terminal iodine (using electrons).
- Complete the octets on both terminal iodines (using electrons).
- Remaining electrons:
- Place all remaining lone pairs on the central iodine atom.
-
Xenon difluoride ():
- Xenon contributes valence electrons, and each fluorine contributes :
- Form single bonds from the central xenon to each fluorine (using electrons).
- Complete the octets of the terminal fluorines (using electrons).
- Place the remaining electrons ( lone pairs) on the central xenon atom.
Determine Electron-Domain and Molecular Geometry (VSEPR)
For both central atoms:
- Bonding pairs (bonding domains):
- Non-bonding pairs (lone pairs):
- Total steric number (electron domains):
- VSEPR notation:
A steric number of defines a trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry.
Equatorial vs. Axial Placement and Minimizing Repulsion
In a trigonal bipyramid, there are two distinct types of positions:
- Axial positions: Each has three neighboring domains at .
- Equatorial positions: Each has two neighboring domains at and two at .
According to VSEPR theory, lone pairs are more diffuse and exert stronger electron-electron repulsion than bonding pairs. Repulsions at are significantly destabilizing compared to those at or :
- Placing a lone pair in an axial site creates three high-energy interactions.
- Placing a lone pair in an equatorial site creates only two interactions.
Therefore, lone pairs preferentially occupy all three equatorial positions. This leaves the two bonding domains in the two axial positions, directly opposite one another.
Common Pitfall: Students frequently assume that any triatomic molecule with lone pairs is bent like water (). However, has a steric number of (tetrahedral parent geometry, ), where all positions are equivalent. In a -domain system (), the equatorial placement of all three lone pairs forces the two terminal atoms into axial positions, giving a strictly linear geometry.
Final Shapes and Bond Angles
- Electron-Domain Geometry: Trigonal bipyramidal (for both and )
- Molecular Geometry: Linear (for both and )
- Bond Angle: Exactly (since the two bonded atoms reside in collinear axial positions)
Typical errors
01 The student places lone pairs in axial positions instead of equatorial positions in the trigonal bipyramidal electron geometry, leading to a T-shaped or bent geometry.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Central valence: () Electron-domain geometry: trigonal bipyramidal; Central valence: () Electron-domain geometry: trigonal bipyramidal
- Step 2
Lone pairs placed in axial positions and one equatorial position Lone pairs occupy axial positions because axial positions are farther apart from each other.
CorrectAll lone pairs must occupy the equatorial positions because equatorial sites minimize severe repulsions (only two neighbors per equatorial site vs. three neighbors per axial site).
In a trigonal bipyramidal geometry, an axial position has three adjacent domains at , whereas an equatorial position has only two adjacent domains at . Because lone pairs are more diffuse and exert stronger repulsion, minimizing high-energy interactions requires placing all lone pairs in equatorial positions, not axial positions.
- Step 3
Molecular geometry: bent Bond angle:
CorrectMolecular geometry: linear Bond angle: exactly
Because your lone pair assignment was inverted, you deduced a bent geometry. With all three lone pairs occupying the equatorial plane, the two bonded terminal atoms remain in the axial positions directly opposite each other, yielding a linear molecular geometry with a bond angle of exactly .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou accurately counted the valence electrons around the central atoms for both chemical species.
You correctly identified that a steric number of corresponds to a trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that axial positions provide more spatial separation than equatorial positions, overlooking that axial sites experience three high-energy interactions while equatorial sites experience only two.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Evaluating $90^\circ$ Repulsions in Trigonal Bipyramidal Systems
Repulsions at are much stronger than repulsions at or . Axial sites have three neighbors, whereas equatorial sites have only two neighbors.
Always place lone pairs (the most repulsive domains) in equatorial positions first when dealing with a steric number of .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationPlace all lone pairs in the three equatorial positions around the central atom.
Position the bonding domains in the two remaining axial positions collinear with the central atom.
Describe the molecular shape formed by the nuclei alone: the two axial bonds form a straight line passing through the central atom.
Both and have a trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry, a linear molecular geometry, and a bond angle of exactly .
02 The student ignores the expanded octet and treats the central atom as having only two bonding pairs and two lone pairs with an octet, concluding both have a bent geometry like water.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Central has single bonds and lone pairs to satisfy the octet rule Electron-domain geometry: tetrahedral Molecular geometry: bent
Correcthas valence electrons Central has single bonds and lone pairs ( domains, ) Electron-domain geometry: trigonal bipyramidal Molecular geometry: linear
You restricted iodine to an octet ( electron domains), but has total valence electrons, leaving lone pairs on the central iodine ( valence electrons, an expanded octet).
- Step 2
Central forms bonds with and retains lone pairs to complete octet Electron-domain geometry: tetrahedral Molecular geometry: bent
Correcthas valence electrons Central has single bonds and lone pairs ( domains, ) Electron-domain geometry: trigonal bipyramidal Molecular geometry: linear
You enforced an octet on xenon, but xenon is in Period 5 and expands its valence shell to accommodate all valence electrons, holding bonding pairs and lone pairs.
- Step 3
Assumed lone pairs follow tetrahedral geometry rather than trigonal bipyramidal positions Bond angle:
CorrectIn a trigonal bipyramidal domain ( domains), lone pairs strictly occupy the equatorial sites to minimize repulsions, placing the two bonded atoms in opposite axial positions Bond angle:
Because both species are , the three lone pairs fill the equatorial plane at angles to one another, leaving the two axial bonds collinear with an exact bond angle of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that both species feature two single bonds connecting the central atom to terminal atoms.
You recognized that electron-domain geometry directly determines the spatial arrangement of electron pairs and the resulting molecular shape.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou stopped distributing valence electrons once the central atom reached four pairs (an octet), rather than placing all calculated valence electrons onto Period 3+ central atoms.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou relied on the basic octet rule instead of systematically summing total valence electrons. Elements in Period 3 and below possess accessible orbitals and frequently expand their octets when extra electron pairs remain after satisfying terminal atom octets.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Always Sum Total Valence Electrons First
Never guess lone pairs by forcing an octet; calculate , satisfy terminal octets, and place all remaining electrons on the central atom.
For and , calculate . Terminal atoms take (including bonding pairs), leaving ( lone pairs) for the central atom.
- Equatorial Preference for Lone Pairs in 5-Domain Systems
In a trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry (steric number ), lone pairs always occupy equatorial positions because equatorial sites have only two neighbors, whereas axial sites have three.
Place all three lone pairs in the equatorial plane ( apart); the remaining two bonding atoms occupy the top and bottom axial positions, giving a linear shape with a bond angle.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationTotal valence electrons for : ; for : .
Form two single bonds to terminal atoms () and complete terminal octets (), using .
Assign the remaining as lone pairs onto the central atom, giving a steric number of (trigonal bipyramidal, ).
Place all lone pairs in equatorial positions to minimize repulsions; the two bonds reside in axial positions directly opposite each other.
Both and have trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry, linear molecular geometry, and a bond angle of .
Lock it in
In a trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry, why do lone pairs strictly occupy equatorial positions rather than axial positions?
Equatorial positions experience only two high-energy repulsions, whereas axial positions experience three repulsions. Minimizing repulsions stabilizes the molecule.
Similar question
Determine the electron-domain geometry, molecular geometry, and approximate bond angles of chlorine trifluoride ().
Answer
Chlorine has valence electrons ( domains: bonding pairs, lone pairs, ). Electron-domain geometry is trigonal bipyramidal. Placing both lone pairs in equatorial positions leaves two axial bonds and one equatorial bond, producing a T-shaped molecular geometry with bond angles of slightly less than (typically ).
Sulfur tetrafluoride () has electron domains around the central sulfur atom. State the position of the single lone pair (axial or equatorial), identify the resulting molecular geometry, and explain why.
Answer
The lone pair occupies an equatorial position to minimize repulsions (experiencing two interactions instead of three if it were axial). This arrangement yields a seesaw (or disphenoidal) molecular geometry with axial-equatorial bond angles of and an axial-axial bond angle of .
The interhalogen cation and the neutral molecule both have two terminal atoms bonded to a central halogen or noble gas. Predict whether their bond angles are closer to , , or , and provide VSEPR notation to justify your answer.
Answer
Both species have total valence electrons, giving the central atom single bonds and lone pairs (). With all lone pairs occupying the equatorial plane of a trigonal bipyramid, the two ligands reside in collinear axial positions, resulting in a linear geometry with bond angles of exactly .