Resources
In the ground state () of the hydrogen atom: (a) The Bohr model dictates that the electron is found exclusively at a fixed radius known as the Bohr radius, . In the quantum mechanical model, the radial probability distribution function for the orbital is . Find the radius at which the probability of finding the electron per unit radial interval is maximized. (b) Calculate the probability density at the exact threshold boundary of the nucleus (), given , and state the conceptual contradiction between the Bohr model and quantum mechanics regarding the presence of the electron at .
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) (obtained by setting ); (b) . In the Bohr model, the electron can never exist at because it is confined to an orbit of radius where centrifugal and electrostatic forces balance; in quantum mechanics, the -orbital has a non-zero probability density directly at the nucleus ().
Steps
Part (a): Finding the Most Probable Radius
- Set up the derivative of the radial distribution function: The radial probability distribution function gives the probability of finding the electron in a spherical shell of thickness at radius : To find the radius of maximum probability, differentiate with respect to and set the derivative equal to zero:
- Apply the product rule: Factor out the common terms:
- Solve for : Since and for finite values of , the term in parentheses must equal zero: Given :
Part (b): Probability Density at and Conceptual Comparison
- Calculate the probability density at the nucleus: The wave function for the ground state hydrogen atom is: Evaluating this wave function at : The probability density (probability per unit volume) is the square of the wave function: Substitute the numerical value of :
-
Conceptual Contradiction:
- Bohr Model: Treats the electron as a localized particle traveling in a discrete, fixed circular orbit of radius , held by the balance of Coulomb attraction and centrifugal force. Consequently, the electron has zero possibility of ever being found at the nucleus ().
- Quantum Mechanical Model: The electron is described by a continuous three-dimensional wave function . For spherically symmetric -orbitals (), the wave function and probability density are non-zero and reach their maximum value directly at the nucleus ().
Common Pitfall: Do not confuse the probability density with the radial probability distribution . While because the surface area of a sphere of radius zero is zero (), the local volumetric probability density is strictly positive and maximal at the origin.
Typical errors
01 The student maximizes the wavefunction ψ(r) instead of the radial probability distribution P(r), incorrectly concluding that the most probable radius is at r = 0.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You differentiated the wave function instead of the given radial distribution function . Finding the radius where the probability per unit radial interval is maximized requires differentiating .
- Step 2
r = 0 r_{} = 0_
Correct1 - = 0 r_{} = a_0 = 5.292 10^{-11}_
Because you differentiated , you concluded that the maximum occurs at the boundary . Setting the true derivative yields .
- Step 3
|{1}(0)|^2 = ^2 =
- Step 4
r = a_0 r = 0 r = 0.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly evaluated the probability density at .
You clearly articulated the conceptual contrast between Bohr's rigid circular orbit and quantum mechanics' non-zero electron density at the nucleus.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou substituted the wave function into the derivative when asked to maximize the radial probability distribution function .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou overlooked the distinction between probability density at a single point, , and the radial probability distribution function, , which accounts for the expanding surface area of a spherical shell of radius .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distinguish $\psi(r)$, $|\psi(r)|^2$, and $P(r)$
The function gives probability per unit volume, whereas gives probability per unit radial thickness .
Always verify whether a problem asks for the most probable point or the most probable radius/shell before setting up the derivative.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite out the radial distribution function: .
Differentiate with respect to using the product rule: .
Set . For , the factor must vanish, giving .
(a) ; (b)
02 The student misapplies the product rule by differentiating r² to r instead of 2r, arriving at r_max = a₀/2.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You differentiated to instead of using the power rule . As a result, the first term inside the brackets is missing a factor of .
- Step 2Correct
You factored and solved your expression correctly, but this step inherited the missing coefficient from the previous line.
- Step 3
- Step 4
The Bohr model confines the electron strictly to so it cannot be at , whereas quantum mechanics gives a non-zero probability density at the nucleus.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that the maximum probability occurs where the first derivative equals zero.
You correctly applied the chain rule to the exponential component .
You accurately calculated the probability density .
You gave a precise conceptual explanation contrasting the Bohr model and quantum mechanics.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou accidentally dropped the power multiplier when taking the derivative of , writing instead of .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisA quick algebraic slip occurred while managing multiple factors during the product rule, conflating the derivative with .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Power Rule Check
, so .
Write out the product rule explicitly in two distinct parts () before combining or factoring terms.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDifferentiate using the product rule: .
Factor out the common terms: .
Set the factor equal to zero: .
;
03 The student confuses the probability density |ψ(0)|² with the radial probability P(0), erroneously concluding that the probability density at the nucleus is zero.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You substituted into the radial probability distribution function rather than squaring the wave function .
- Step 3
Both the Bohr model and quantum mechanics agree that the electron cannot be found at .
CorrectIn the Bohr model, the electron is confined to a fixed orbit of radius and can never be at . In quantum mechanics, s-orbitals have a non-zero, maximal probability density directly at the nucleus.
Because your calculation in Step 2 yielded zero, you concluded that both models forbid the electron from being at the nucleus, whereas quantum mechanics actually predicts a peak probability density at .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly applied the product rule to differentiate the radial probability distribution function.
You factored the derivative properly to find the critical point at .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the radial probability distribution function as identical to the local probability density . While due to the geometric factor of a sphere's surface area ( at ), the local volumetric probability density is non-zero and reaches its maximum at the nucleus.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Probability Density vs. Radial Probability Distribution
Probability density is (probability per unit volume), while the radial probability distribution is (probability of finding the electron in a spherical shell of thickness ).
Check whether a problem asks for probability density at a point () or probability in a radial shell () before plugging in values.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationEvaluate the wave function directly at : .
Square the wave function to find the probability density: .
Substitute : .
State the conceptual contradiction: Bohr's model confines the electron strictly to a circular trajectory of radius , forbidding , while quantum mechanics predicts a finite, maximal probability density directly at the nucleus for -electrons.
(a) ; (b) . The Bohr model forbids the electron from existing at the nucleus (), whereas quantum mechanics predicts that the probability density is non-zero and maximal at .
Lock it in
What is the physical difference between probability density and the radial distribution function ?
is probability per unit volume at a point; is probability within a spherical shell of radius and thickness .
Similar question
For the orbital of hydrogen, the radial wave function is proportional to , so where is a normalization constant. Find the most probable radius in terms of .
Answer
. Setting gives .
Explain why at the nucleus () for a electron, yet the electron has a non-zero chance of undergoing electron capture by the nucleus.
Answer
Electron capture depends on the probability density at the nucleus, , representing finite contact density with the nuclear volume. In contrast, simply reflects that a sphere of radius zero has zero surface area.
Consider an orbital with radial wave function ( orbital). (a) Find the radial node where for . (b) State whether is zero or non-zero at .
Answer
(a) , since when . (b) Non-zero; for an -orbital, , so .