Resources
Two identical rigid flasks, Flask A and Flask B, are held at the same constant temperature of . Flask A contains of hydrogen gas (, ) and Flask B contains of oxygen gas (, ). A student predicts that because oxygen molecules are 16 times heavier than hydrogen molecules, the oxygen gas will exert a higher pressure due to having much greater momentum per particle impact. Using the Kinetic Molecular Theory: (a) Calculate the pressure in Flask A and Flask B. (b) Explain why the student's intuition fails by contrasting the momentum change per collision with collision frequency and number of particles. (c) Compare the average kinetic energy per molecule in Flask A versus Flask B.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) , ; (b) The student ignores stoichiometry and speed: while each collision transfers times more momentum (), Flask A contains times more molecules, and each molecule moves times faster (colliding times more frequently), yielding a total pressure times greater in Flask A; (c) The average kinetic energy per molecule is identical in both flasks () because depends strictly on absolute temperature.
Steps
Part (a): Calculating the Pressures in Flask A and Flask B
According to the Ideal Gas Law, the pressure exerted by a gas is given by:
where:
1. Flask A (): First, determine the number of moles of hydrogen gas:
Now, compute the pressure :
2. Flask B (): Next, determine the number of moles of oxygen gas:
Compute the pressure :
Part (b): Why the Student's Intuition Fails (Kinetic Molecular Theory)
Pressure on a microscopic level is the average force exerted per unit area by molecular collisions with the container walls, which equals the total rate of momentum delivered to the wall:
where is the number of particles, is the collision frequency per particle, and is the momentum transferred per collision.
- Root-Mean-Square Speed (): The average molecular speed is inversely proportional to the square root of molar mass: Because , hydrogen molecules travel times faster than oxygen molecules at the same temperature:
- Momentum Transferred per Collision (): The momentum change per collision is . Since and , the momentum change scales as: Thus, an individual molecule delivers times more momentum per impact than an molecule, which matches the student's initial observation.
-
Collision Frequency and Total Particle Count:
- Collision Frequency (): Because an molecule moves times faster across the same volume, it hits the walls times more frequently than an molecule (). This factor of in frequency completely cancels the oxygen molecule's -fold advantage in momentum per collision:
- Number of Particles (): For identical masses of , Flask A contains times more molecules than Flask B.
Combining these factors:
The student's error was considering only the momentum per collision while neglecting collision frequency and, most importantly, the fact that a lighter gas has far more particles per unit mass.
Part (c): Comparing Average Kinetic Energy per Molecule
According to the Kinetic Molecular Theory, the average translational kinetic energy per molecule depends solely on the absolute temperature:
Because both flasks are kept at the exact same temperature of , the average kinetic energy per molecule is identical in both flasks:
(Note: Although individual molecules are 16 times more massive, they move at one-fourth the speed. Because kinetic energy depends on speed squared, , the two effects balance perfectly.)
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the molar mass of diatomic hydrogen and oxygen by using atomic weights rather than molecular weights, leading to halved molar masses and doubled calculated pressures.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You used the atomic mass of hydrogen () instead of the molar mass of diatomic hydrogen gas (, ), which doubled the number of moles and the calculated pressure.
- Step 2Correct
You used the atomic mass of oxygen () instead of the molecular molar mass of diatomic oxygen gas (, ), causing the calculated moles and pressure to be twice their true values.
- Step 3
Although O atoms are heavier and deliver greater momentum per collision, H atoms move faster and are present in much greater quantity, creating a much higher collision frequency that produces greater total pressure.
- Step 4
Average kinetic energy is the same in both flasks because both are at 300 K.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly applied the ideal gas equation to solve for pressure.
You clearly explained how collision frequency and particle count dominate over momentum transfer per collision in the Kinetic Molecular Theory.
You correctly identified that average kinetic energy per molecule is identical when temperatures are equal.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou used the atomic weights from the periodic table ( and ) rather than doubling them for diatomic molecules.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisOverlooking the diatomic nature of common elemental gases (such as and ) when converting mass to moles.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check Diatomic Gas Formulas
Hydrogen, nitrogen, oxygen, fluorine, chlorine, bromine, and iodine exist as diatomic molecules in the gas phase: .
Multiply the periodic table atomic mass by 2 to find the molar mass before calculating .
- Verify Given Constants
The problem prompt provided for and for .
Cross-check molar masses against the values explicitly given in the problem text.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecalculate moles for Flask A: .
Solve for : .
Recalculate moles for Flask B: .
Solve for : .
,
02 The student believes average kinetic energy per molecule depends on molecular mass rather than solely on temperature, concluding that heavier O₂ molecules possess greater average kinetic energy.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
,
- Step 2
Flask A has 16 times more particles and higher molecular speeds, so the much higher collision frequency with the wall overcomes the lower momentum change per collision.
- Step 3
Flask B has greater average kinetic energy per molecule because molecules have a much larger mass than molecules.
Correct(identical average kinetic energy per molecule)
You looked at the mass term in without accounting for the fact that heavier molecules move slower by exactly the factor needed to keep the average kinetic energy equal: , so is constant at a fixed temperature.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou accurately converted masses to moles and applied the ideal gas equation.
You correctly identified that higher particle count and collision frequency compensate for lower momentum per collision.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated molecular mass as the sole deciding factor in kinetic energy while overlooking that speed decreases as mass increases.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou relied on the classical formula at the single-particle level rather than the fundamental postulate of Kinetic Molecular Theory: the average translational kinetic energy of any ideal gas is solely a function of absolute temperature ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- KMT Definition of Temperature
The average translational kinetic energy per molecule of an ideal gas depends only on absolute temperature: .
Whenever two gases are at the same temperature, immediately set their average kinetic energy per molecule equal, regardless of molecular mass.
- Mass vs. Speed Trade-off
At a given temperature, , which means .
Remember that an increase in mass is exactly cancelled by a decrease in when evaluating .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall the Kinetic Molecular Theory postulate relating temperature and motion: .
Note that both Flask A and Flask B are at the same temperature: .
Evaluate the ratio of average kinetic energy: .
The average kinetic energy per molecule is identical in both flasks.
03 The student assumes equal masses of gases imply an equal number of moles, leading to the incorrect conclusion that both flasks have the same pressure.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Both flasks contain of gas, so they contain the same amount of substance.
Correct;
Equal mass does not mean equal moles because hydrogen and oxygen have very different molar masses ( vs. ). You must divide mass by molar mass () to determine moles.
- Step 2
The student's intuition fails because with equal numbers of particles, the lighter molecules move faster and hit the walls more frequently, compensating for the smaller momentum per collision.
CorrectWhile collision frequency () balances smaller momentum per impact (), Flask A actually has times more molecules than Flask B, resulting in .
Your reasoning that higher collision frequency cancels lower momentum per impact is physically sound, but it carries over the false premise that both flasks have equal numbers of particles. In reality, Flask A contains times as many molecules as Flask B.
- Step 3
Average kinetic energy per molecule is the same in Flask A and Flask B because the temperature is in both.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that average kinetic energy per molecule depends exclusively on temperature.
You applied the ideal gas equation with the correct gas constant and units.
You recognized that lighter molecules move faster and collide with container walls more frequently.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated macroscopic mass with amount of substance (), assuming that identical masses of different chemical species provide identical mole counts.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Convert Mass to Moles Using Molar Mass
Amount of substance in moles is , not itself.
Whenever given masses of different gases, always divide each mass by its specific molar mass before calculating pressure or particle count.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFind moles of : .
Find moles of : .
Calculate .
Calculate .
(a) , ; (b) Collision frequency () balances momentum per impact (), but Flask A has times more molecules, so ; (c) Average kinetic energy per molecule is identical in both flasks.
Lock it in
What are the seven common elements that naturally exist as diatomic molecules in the gas phase?
, , , , , , and . Remember the mnemonic 'Have No Fear Of Ice Cold Beer'.
Similar question
A rigid cylinder contains of nitrogen gas () at . Calculate the pressure exerted by the gas in atmospheres. (, )
Answer
. Steps: Molar mass of . Moles . Pressure .
Two separate containers at hold equal masses () of helium gas (, ) and methane gas (, ). (a) Find the ratio of pressures . (b) Find the ratio of average molecular speeds .
Answer
(a) ; (b) . Steps: (a) , so . (b) , so .
A mixture containing equal masses of chlorine gas (, ) and neon gas (, ) is confined in a vessel at temperature . (a) Determine which gas contributes more to the total pressure and by what factor. (b) Explain how the rate of momentum transfer per unit area compares between the two gases.
Answer
(a) Neon contributes more pressure by a factor of ; (b) Pressure equals total momentum transferred per second per unit area, so delivers times more total momentum to the container walls per second than . Steps: For equal mass , . Since partial pressure , . Microscopically, although an individual collision imparts times greater momentum, neon molecules strike the wall times more frequently per particle and there are times more neon particles.