Resources
A divalent cation () derived from a first-row transition metal exhibits a ground-state electron configuration ending in . (a) Deduce the complete ground-state electron configuration of the neutral, parent atom . (b) Identify the element and its atomic number . (c) Explain which subshell loses electrons during the ionization of to , in accordance with energy changes upon orbital filling.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Neutral atom : (or ); (b) Element: Cobalt (), ; (c) The electrons are removed first because once the orbitals are populated, the effective nuclear charge stabilizes below , making the electrons higher in energy and outermost.
Steps
Understand Transition Metal Ionization and Reconstruct the Neutral Atom
When first-row transition metals form cations, electrons are removed from the outermost shell () before the inner shell (). Therefore, the two electrons lost to form the divalent cation come from the subshell rather than the subshell.
Given the configuration of :
To find the ground-state electron configuration of the neutral parent atom , add the two removed electrons back into the subshell:
Expanding the argon core (), the full ground-state electron configuration is:
Identify the Element and Atomic Number
- Calculate the total number of electrons in neutral atom :
- Determine atomic number (): For a neutral atom, the number of protons equals the number of electrons:
- Identify the element: The element with atomic number on the periodic table is Cobalt ().
Explain the Orbital Energetics During Ionization
- Filling vs. Ionization: According to the Aufbau principle, the subshell fills before in neutral atoms because empty orbitals have a lower energy than empty orbitals.
- Energy Inversion upon Filling: As electrons populate the subshell across the transition series, the increasing effective nuclear charge () acts strongly on the inner electrons. This lowers the energy of the orbitals significantly below that of the orbitals.
- Electron Loss: Because the electrons are at a higher principal quantum number (), they possess a greater average distance from the nucleus (larger radial extent) and are higher in energy in the populated atom. Consequently, they are the least tightly bound and are removed first during ionization:
Common Pitfall: A frequent mistake is applying the Aufbau filling order in reverse for ionization (e.g., assuming with came from a neutral configuration of or removing electrons first). Always remember: transition metals fill before , but lose before .
Typical errors
01 The student misapplies the Aufbau filling order in reverse for ionization, incorrectly assuming that electrons are added to 3d to form the neutral atom and removed from 3d during ionization.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
When a neutral transition metal atom ionizes, it loses its outermost valence electrons from first. Therefore, reconstructing neutral requires adding the two electrons back into the subshell rather than .
- Step 2Correct
Because neutral has the configuration , the total electron count is . The neutral atom with is cobalt ().
- Step 3Correct
Ionization does not simply reverse the Aufbau filling sequence. Once electrons occupy the subshell, the effective nuclear charge felt by electrons increases, lowering the energy of below . Because electrons have a higher principal quantum number (), they are farther from the nucleus, higher in energy in the populated atom, and removed first.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that a divalent cation has two fewer electrons than its neutral parent atom.
You fully expanded the core argon configuration down to the level.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated ionization as a simple 'last in, first out' reversal of the Aufbau filling rule, overlooking that populating orbitals shifts their energies below so that outermost electrons are removed first.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- First-In, First-Out for 4s
First-row transition metals fill before , but they also lose before during ionization.
Always remove electrons from the highest principal quantum number () first when forming transition metal cations.
- Orbital Energy Inversion
In an empty atom, is lower in energy than ; however, once contains electrons, the increased stabilizes below .
Treat as the outermost and highest-energy valence subshell in any populated neutral transition metal atom.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationStart with the cation configuration: .
Add 2 electrons to the outermost valence subshell () to reconstruct the neutral atom: .
Count the total electrons: , which identifies element as cobalt ().
Explain that electrons are removed first because orbitals have greater radial extension and become higher in energy once is occupied.
(a) (or ); (b) Cobalt (), ; (c) The subshell loses electrons first because is stabilized below upon filling, leaving as the outermost and highest-energy subshell.
02 The student confuses the atomic number with the total valence electron count of the neutral atom, identifying the element solely by the number of valence electrons (9).
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You counted only the valence/outer electrons () and set . For a neutral atom, the atomic number equals the total number of electrons, which includes the electrons in the core.
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly restored the two lost electrons to the subshell to write the neutral atom's full electron configuration.
You clearly explained that electrons in the subshell have a higher principal quantum number () and are removed first upon ionization.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou equated the atomic number to the sum of the and electrons () while forgetting to add the electrons contained within the noble gas core.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the valence electron count with the total atomic number when reading condensed noble-gas notation.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Accounting for Core Electrons
In condensed noble-gas notation , the total electron count is .
Always replace the bracketed noble gas symbol with its corresponding atomic number (e.g., ) before calculating for a neutral atom.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the total number of electrons in neutral atom : .
For a neutral atom, the atomic number equals the total electron count: .
Locate atomic number on the periodic table: the element is Cobalt ().
, Cobalt ()
Lock it in
Which subshell loses electrons first when a neutral first-row transition metal atom is ionized?
The subshell. Transition metals always lose outermost valence electrons () before inner -electrons ().
Similar question
A divalent cation has the ground-state electron configuration . Deduce the electron configuration of neutral and identify element .
Answer
Neutral configuration: . Total electrons = , so element is Manganese (, ).
An unknown transition metal forms a trivalent ion with the configuration . (a) Determine the neutral configuration of . (b) State which subshells lost electrons during the formation of .
Answer
(a) Neutral : undergoes stability rearrangement or Aufbau assignment to Vanadium: (strictly , element ). (b) Two electrons are lost from and one electron is lost from .
Explain why the first ionization energy of scandium removes a electron rather than a electron, referring to both radial distribution (distance from nucleus) and effective nuclear charge.
Answer
Although the orbital penetrates closer to the nucleus at very small radii (allowing it to fill first in empty atoms), its principal quantum number is , giving it a greater average radial distance. Once the orbital is populated, the shielding it provides combined with increasing nuclear charge lowers the energy of the orbital well below . Consequently, the electron is the least tightly bound and outermost, requiring the least energy to remove.