Resources

A sample of potassium hydrogen phthalate (KHP, molar mass =204.22 g/mol= 204.22\text{ g/mol}) is titrated to the phenolphthalein endpoint. The concentration of the resulting sodium hydroxide solution is calculated via C=mM⋅VC = \frac{m}{M \cdot V}, where MM is treated as an exact constant with negligible error. The delivered volume of titrant from a class A buret is V=(24.35±0.03) mLV = (24.35 \pm 0.03)\text{ mL} (relative uncertainty 0.123%0.123\%). If the maximum allowable percent relative uncertainty in the resulting molarity CC is %εC=0.200%\%\varepsilon_C = 0.200\%, calculate the maximum absolute uncertainty δm\delta m in grams permitted for the mass measurement of KHP when using an analytical sample size of m=0.5100 gm = 0.5100\text{ g}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

δm=0.0008 g\delta m = 0.0008\text{ g} (or 8×10−4 g8 \times 10^{-4}\text{ g})

Steps

01

Identify the propagation rule for relative uncertainties

The concentration is calculated from the quotient: C=mM⋅VC = \frac{m}{M \cdot V}

Because the molar mass MM is an exact constant with negligible error, the uncertainty in CC originates solely from independent random uncertainties in the mass mm and the volume VV.

For products and quotients with independent errors, relative uncertainties add in quadrature (root sum of squares): (%εC)2=(%εm)2+(%εV)2\left(\% \varepsilon_C\right)^2 = \left(\% \varepsilon_m\right)^2 + \left(\% \varepsilon_V\right)^2

02

Solve for the maximum allowable relative uncertainty in mass

Rearranging the quadrature relation to isolate the allowable percent relative uncertainty in mass, %εm\% \varepsilon_m: (%εm)2=(%εC)2−(%εV)2\left(\% \varepsilon_m\right)^2 = \left(\% \varepsilon_C\right)^2 - \left(\% \varepsilon_V\right)^2

Substitute the given values (%εC=0.200%\% \varepsilon_C = 0.200\% and %εV=0.123%\% \varepsilon_V = 0.123\%): (%εm)2=(0.200%)2−(0.123%)2\left(\% \varepsilon_m\right)^2 = (0.200\%)^2 - (0.123\%)^2 (%εm)2=0.040000−0.015129=0.024871%2\left(\% \varepsilon_m\right)^2 = 0.040000 - 0.015129 = 0.024871\%^2 %εm=0.024871%2≈0.1577%\% \varepsilon_m = \sqrt{0.024871\%^2} \approx 0.1577\%

03

Calculate the maximum absolute uncertainty in mass (δm\delta m)

The percent relative uncertainty relates to the absolute uncertainty δm\delta m and the measured mass mm by: %εm=δmm×100%\% \varepsilon_m = \frac{\delta m}{m} \times 100\%

Rearranging for δm\delta m: δm=m⋅%εm100%\delta m = m \cdot \frac{\% \varepsilon_m}{100\%}

Substitute the sample mass m=0.5100 gm = 0.5100\text{ g}: δm=0.5100 g⋅0.1577100≈0.000804 g\delta m = 0.5100\text{ g} \cdot \frac{0.1577}{100} \approx 0.000804\text{ g}

Rounding to one significant figure (standard practice for measurement uncertainties): δm=0.0008 gor8×10−4 g\delta m = 0.0008\text{ g} \quad \text{or} \quad 8 \times 10^{-4}\text{ g}

Common Pitfall: A frequent mistake is adding relative uncertainties linearly (%εC=%εm+%εV\% \varepsilon_C = \% \varepsilon_m + \% \varepsilon_V). Linear addition represents worst-case bound for systematic errors rather than standard error propagation for independent random measurements. Using linear addition would yield an overly conservative bound of δm≈0.0004 g\delta m \approx 0.0004\text{ g}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student linearly adds relative uncertainties instead of combining them in quadrature, underestimating the allowable uncertainty in mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    %εC=%εm+%εV\%\varepsilon_C = \%\varepsilon_m + \%\varepsilon_V

    Correct

    (%εC)2=(%εm)2+(%εV)2(\%\varepsilon_C)^2 = (\%\varepsilon_m)^2 + (\%\varepsilon_V)^2

    For products and quotients with independent random uncertainties, relative uncertainties combine in quadrature (root sum of squares), not by direct linear addition.

  2. Step 2

    %εm=%εC−%εV=0.200%−0.123%=0.077%\%\varepsilon_m = \%\varepsilon_C - \%\varepsilon_V = 0.200\% - 0.123\% = 0.077\%

    Correct

    %εm=(%εC)2−(%εV)2=(0.200%)2−(0.123%)2≈0.1577%\%\varepsilon_m = \sqrt{(\%\varepsilon_C)^2 - (\%\varepsilon_V)^2} = \sqrt{(0.200\%)^2 - (0.123\%)^2} \approx 0.1577\%

    This calculation followed your linear formula correctly, but the starting propagation formula was incorrect.

  3. Step 3

    δm=0.5100 g×(0.077100)=0.00039 g\delta m = 0.5100\text{ g} \times \left(\frac{0.077}{100}\right) = 0.00039\text{ g}

    Correct

    δm=0.5100 g×(0.1577100)≈0.0008 g\delta m = 0.5100\text{ g} \times \left(\frac{0.1577}{100}\right) \approx 0.0008\text{ g}

    You correctly set up the relation δm=m⋅%εm100%\delta m = m \cdot \frac{\%\varepsilon_m}{100\%}, but the numerical result is affected by the value carried over from Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly related percent relative uncertainty to absolute uncertainty using δm=m⋅%εm100%\delta m = m \cdot \frac{\%\varepsilon_m}{100\%}.

You carried out the algebraic rearrangement and arithmetic steps accurately based on your chosen model.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Linear addition of relative uncertainties

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated independent random uncertainties in multiplication and division as worst-case bounds (linear sum) instead of using standard Gaussian error propagation (addition in quadrature: σrel2=∑σrel,i2\sigma_{rel}^2 = \sum \sigma_{rel, i}^2).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Random vs. Systematic Error Propagation
  • Independent random uncertainties in products and quotients add in quadrature: (δzz)2=(δxx)2+(δyy)2\left(\frac{\delta z}{z}\right)^2 = \left(\frac{\delta x}{x}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{\delta y}{y}\right)^2.

  • Always square the relative uncertainties before adding or subtracting them when propagating independent random errors.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the quadrature propagation formula: (%εC)2=(%εm)2+(%εV)2(\%\varepsilon_C)^2 = (\%\varepsilon_m)^2 + (\%\varepsilon_V)^2.

  2. Isolate and solve for the allowable mass relative uncertainty: %εm=(0.200%)2−(0.123%)2=0.024871%≈0.1577%\%\varepsilon_m = \sqrt{(0.200\%)^2 - (0.123\%)^2} = \sqrt{0.024871\%} \approx 0.1577\%.

  3. Convert to absolute uncertainty: δm=0.5100 g×0.1577100≈0.000804 g\delta m = 0.5100\text{ g} \times \frac{0.1577}{100} \approx 0.000804\text{ g}.

Final answer

δm=0.0008 g\delta m = 0.0008\text{ g} (or 8×10−4 g8 \times 10^{-4}\text{ g})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the difference between worst-case bounds (linear addition) and standard random error propagation (quadrature).

  • Practice isolating an individual component's allowable tolerance from a total target uncertainty using the Pythagorean-like quadrature formula.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student treats relative uncertainty as absolute uncertainty and directly subtracts the absolute volume error from the allowable percent uncertainty.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    δm=%εC−δV=0.200−0.03=0.170 g\delta m = \%\varepsilon_C - \delta V = 0.200 - 0.03 = 0.170\text{ g}

    Correct

    (%εm)2=(%εC)2−(%εV)2  ⟹  %εm=(0.200%)2−(0.123%)2≈0.158%(\%\varepsilon_m)^2 = (\%\varepsilon_C)^2 - (\%\varepsilon_V)^2 \implies \%\varepsilon_m = \sqrt{(0.200\%)^2 - (0.123\%)^2} \approx 0.158\%

    You subtracted the absolute buret uncertainty δV=0.03 mL\delta V = 0.03\text{ mL} directly from the percent relative uncertainty %εC=0.200%\%\varepsilon_C = 0.200\%. Quantities with different dimensions and definitions cannot be subtracted directly, and independent random uncertainties in multiplication or division propagate via the root-sum-of-squares rule: (%εC)2=(%εm)2+(%εV)2(\%\varepsilon_C)^2 = (\%\varepsilon_m)^2 + (\%\varepsilon_V)^2.

  2. Step 2

    δm=0.170 g\delta m = 0.170\text{ g}

    Correct

    δm=m⋅%εm100%=0.5100 g×0.1577100≈0.0008 g\delta m = m \cdot \frac{\%\varepsilon_m}{100\%} = 0.5100\text{ g} \times \frac{0.1577}{100} \approx 0.0008\text{ g}

    Because the initial propagation equation mixed incompatible quantities, the resulting mass uncertainty was heavily overestimated. The absolute uncertainty is found by multiplying the sample mass by its fractional relative uncertainty.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the allowable uncertainty in concentration places an upper limit on the acceptable mass uncertainty.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incompatible error types and incorrect propagation model

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated a percent relative uncertainty and an absolute uncertainty as interchangeable additive quantities rather than using relative uncertainty quadrature for quotients.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Distinguish absolute vs. relative uncertainty
  • Absolute uncertainty δx\delta x shares the unit of xx, whereas relative uncertainty %εx=δxx×100%\%\varepsilon_x = \frac{\delta x}{x} \times 100\% is dimensionless.

  • Never add or subtract absolute uncertainties and relative percentages together.

Propagation in products and quotients
  • For y=ab⋅cy = \frac{a}{b \cdot c} with independent random errors, relative uncertainties add in quadrature: (%εy)2=(%εa)2+(%εb)2+(%εc)2(\%\varepsilon_y)^2 = (\%\varepsilon_a)^2 + (\%\varepsilon_b)^2 + (\%\varepsilon_c)^2.

  • Isolate the unknown relative uncertainty by subtracting squares under a square root.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the quadrature relationship for relative uncertainties: (%εC)2=(%εm)2+(%εV)2(\%\varepsilon_C)^2 = (\%\varepsilon_m)^2 + (\%\varepsilon_V)^2.

  2. Rearrange to solve for mass percent uncertainty: %εm=(0.200%)2−(0.123%)2=0.040000−0.015129=0.024871%≈0.1577%\%\varepsilon_m = \sqrt{(0.200\%)^2 - (0.123\%)^2} = \sqrt{0.040000 - 0.015129} = \sqrt{0.024871\%} \approx 0.1577\%.

  3. Convert percent relative uncertainty to absolute uncertainty in grams: δm=m×%εm100%=0.5100 g×0.1577100≈0.000804 g\delta m = m \times \frac{\%\varepsilon_m}{100\%} = 0.5100\text{ g} \times \frac{0.1577}{100} \approx 0.000804\text{ g}.

Final answer

δm=0.0008 g\delta m = 0.0008\text{ g} (or 8×10−4 g8 \times 10^{-4}\text{ g})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before writing an error equation, explicitly label each given error as either absolute (with physical units) or relative (percentage).

  • Practice combining independent random uncertainties in products and quotients using the root-sum-of-squares formula.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student forgets to take the square root when solving for the relative uncertainty in mass from the quadrature equation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    (%εC)2=(%εm)2+(%εV)2(\%\varepsilon_C)^2 = (\%\varepsilon_m)^2 + (\%\varepsilon_V)^2

  2. Step 2

    %εm=(0.200%)2−(0.123%)2=0.0249%\%\varepsilon_m = (0.200\%)^2 - (0.123\%)^2 = 0.0249\%

    Correct

    %εm=(0.200%)2−(0.123%)2=0.02487%2≈0.158%\%\varepsilon_m = \sqrt{(0.200\%)^2 - (0.123\%)^2} = \sqrt{0.02487\%^2} \approx 0.158\%

    You evaluated the difference of squares (0.200%)2−(0.123%)2(0.200\%)^2 - (0.123\%)^2, but you omitted the square root needed to solve for %εm\%\varepsilon_m from (%εm)2(\%\varepsilon_m)^2.

  3. Step 3

    δm=0.5100 g×0.0249100=0.000127 g\delta m = 0.5100\text{ g} \times \frac{0.0249}{100} = 0.000127\text{ g}

    Correct

    δm=0.5100 g×0.1577100≈0.0008 g\delta m = 0.5100\text{ g} \times \frac{0.1577}{100} \approx 0.0008\text{ g}

    Your conversion from relative uncertainty to absolute mass uncertainty was set up properly, but the numerical result was thrown off by the missing square root in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that relative uncertainties combine in quadrature for products and quotients.

You set up the conversion from percent relative uncertainty to absolute uncertainty using δm=m⋅%εm100\delta m = m \cdot \frac{\%\varepsilon_m}{100} correctly.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted square root in quadrature rearrangement

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When rearranging (%εC)2=(%εm)2+(%εV)2(\%\varepsilon_C)^2 = (\%\varepsilon_m)^2 + (\%\varepsilon_V)^2 for %εm\%\varepsilon_m, the squared term (%εm)2(\%\varepsilon_m)^2 was treated as %εm\%\varepsilon_m, omitting the required square root step.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Dimensions of Squared Uncertainties
  • The difference of squared percentages has units of %2\%^2, not %\%.

  • Always take the square root (%εC)2−(%εV)2\sqrt{(\%\varepsilon_C)^2 - (\%\varepsilon_V)^2} to return to linear percent uncertainty before using it in calculations.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Take the square root of the difference of squares: %εm=0.04000%2−0.01513%2=0.02487%2≈0.1577%\%\varepsilon_m = \sqrt{0.04000\%^2 - 0.01513\%^2} = \sqrt{0.02487\%^2} \approx 0.1577\%.

  2. Calculate the maximum absolute uncertainty: δm=m⋅%εm100=0.5100 g×0.1577100=0.000804 g\delta m = m \cdot \frac{\%\varepsilon_m}{100} = 0.5100\text{ g} \times \frac{0.1577}{100} = 0.000804\text{ g}.

  3. Round the uncertainty to one significant figure: δm=0.0008 g\delta m = 0.0008\text{ g} (or 8×10−4 g8 \times 10^{-4}\text{ g}).

Final answer

δm=0.0008 g\delta m = 0.0008\text{ g} (or 8×10−4 g8 \times 10^{-4}\text{ g})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that whenever you subtract squared values in a Pythagorean or quadrature equation (a2=c2−b2a^2 = c^2 - b^2), you take the square root (a=c2−b2a = \sqrt{c^2 - b^2}) before moving on.

  • Perform a sanity check on units: subtracting squares yields percent squared (%2\%^2), which cannot directly multiply mass to give grams.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

The density of a cylinder is determined by ρ=mπr2h\rho = \frac{m}{\pi r^2 h}. If the relative uncertainty in mass is 0.6%0.6\%, radius is 0.4%0.4\%, and height is 0.5%0.5\%, calculate the percent relative uncertainty in density %ερ\%\varepsilon_\rho.

Answer

Key steps: Power coefficients multiply relative uncertainties before squaring: (%ερ)2=(%εm)2+(2⋅%εr)2+(%εh)2=(0.6%)2+(0.8%)2+(0.5%)2=0.36+0.64+0.25=1.25%2(\%\varepsilon_\rho)^2 = (\%\varepsilon_m)^2 + (2\cdot\%\varepsilon_r)^2 + (\%\varepsilon_h)^2 = (0.6\%)^2 + (0.8\%)^2 + (0.5\%)^2 = 0.36 + 0.64 + 0.25 = 1.25\%^2. Result: %ερ=1.25≈1.1%\%\varepsilon_\rho = \sqrt{1.25} \approx 1.1\%.

02

A student prepares a standard solution by dissolving solute of mass mm into volume VV, where concentration C=mVC = \frac{m}{V}. The total relative uncertainty in CC must not exceed 0.50%0.50\%. If the volumetric flask has a relative uncertainty of 0.30%0.30\%, what is the maximum allowable absolute uncertainty in mass δm\delta m if m=1.250 gm = 1.250\text{ g}?

Answer

Key steps: Solve in quadrature: %εm=(%εC)2−(%εV)2=(0.50%)2−(0.30%)2=0.40%\%\varepsilon_m = \sqrt{(\%\varepsilon_C)^2 - (\%\varepsilon_V)^2} = \sqrt{(0.50\%)^2 - (0.30\%)^2} = 0.40\%. Then δm=1.250 g×0.40100=0.0050 g\delta m = 1.250\text{ g} \times \frac{0.40}{100} = 0.0050\text{ g}. Result: δm=0.005 g\delta m = 0.005\text{ g}.

03

In a spectrophotometric assay, absorbance is given by A=ε⋅b⋅cA = \varepsilon \cdot b \cdot c. You need to determine concentration c=Aε⋅bc = \frac{A}{\varepsilon \cdot b} with a maximum relative uncertainty of 1.5%1.5\%. The pathlength bb has negligible uncertainty, and ε\varepsilon has a relative uncertainty of 0.9%0.9\%. What is the maximum allowable relative uncertainty in the absorbance reading AA, and how does this compare to the incorrect result from linear subtraction?

Answer

Key steps: Correct quadrature gives %εA=(1.5%)2−(0.9%)2=2.25−0.81=1.44=1.2%\%\varepsilon_A = \sqrt{(1.5\%)^2 - (0.9\%)^2} = \sqrt{2.25 - 0.81} = \sqrt{1.44} = 1.2\%. Linear subtraction incorrectly gives 1.5%−0.9%=0.6%1.5\% - 0.9\% = 0.6\%. Result: %εA=1.2%\%\varepsilon_A = 1.2\% (twice as lenient as the overly restrictive linear bound of 0.6%0.6\%).

Loading workspace…