Resources

An industrial bio-ethanol distillation column processes a fermented broth stream fed at a rate of 45.0 m3/h45.0\,\text{m}^3/\text{h}. The analytical assay of the feed indicates an ethanol concentration of 82.5 g/L82.5\,\text{g/L} with a broth density of 0.988 g/cm30.988\,\text{g/cm}^3. The distillation overhead stream recovers 94.0%94.0\% of the total feed ethanol at a commercial purity of 95.6 wt%95.6\,\text{wt}\% ethanol (density 0.804 kg/dm30.804\,\text{kg/dm}^3). The reboiler supplies saturated process steam at an energy intensity of 3.25 MJ3.25\,\text{MJ} per kilogram of recovered pure ethanol. Determine: (a) the volumetric flow rate of the recovered commercial ethanol product in L/h\text{L/h}, and (b) the thermal power requirement of the reboiler expressed in megawatts (MW\text{MW}).

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Product flow rate=4.54×103 L/h\text{Product flow rate} = 4.54 \times 10^3\,\text{L/h}; (b) Reboiler thermal power=3.15 MW\text{Reboiler thermal power} = 3.15\,\text{MW}.

Steps

01

Calculate the Mass Flow Rate of Ethanol in the Feed Stream

The feed stream enters at a volumetric flow rate of: Vfeed=45.0 m3/h=45.0×103 L/h=45 000 L/hV_{\text{feed}} = 45.0\,\text{m}^3/\text{h} = 45.0 \times 10^3\,\text{L/h} = 45\,000\,\text{L/h}

With an analytical concentration of 82.5 g/L82.5\,\text{g/L}, the mass flow rate of pure ethanol entering the column, m˙EtOH, feed\dot{m}_{\text{EtOH, feed}}, is: m˙EtOH, feed=45 000 L/h⋅82.5 g/L=3 712 500 g/h=3712.5 kg/h\dot{m}_{\text{EtOH, feed}} = 45\,000\,\text{L/h} \cdot 82.5\,\text{g/L} = 3\,712\,500\,\text{g/h} = 3712.5\,\text{kg/h}

(Note: The total broth density is provided as background physical property data, but it is not needed here because the ethanol content is already specified per unit volume).


02

Determine the Mass and Volume of Recovered Ethanol Product (Part a)

The distillation column achieves a recovery efficiency of 94.0%94.0\% for ethanol: m˙EtOH, recovered=0.940⋅3712.5 kg/h=3489.75 kg/h\dot{m}_{\text{EtOH, recovered}} = 0.940 \cdot 3712.5\,\text{kg/h} = 3489.75\,\text{kg/h}

The overhead product is not anhydrous; it contains 95.6 wt%95.6\,\text{wt}\% ethanol. Therefore, the total mass flow rate of the commercial overhead stream, m˙product\dot{m}_{\text{product}}, is: m˙product=m˙EtOH, recovered0.956=3489.75 kg/h0.956≈3650.37 kg/h\dot{m}_{\text{product}} = \frac{\dot{m}_{\text{EtOH, recovered}}}{0.956} = \frac{3489.75\,\text{kg/h}}{0.956} \approx 3650.37\,\text{kg/h}

Using the product density ρproduct=0.804 kg/dm3=0.804 kg/L\rho_{\text{product}} = 0.804\,\text{kg/dm}^3 = 0.804\,\text{kg/L}, the volumetric flow rate of the product stream is: Vproduct=m˙productρproduct=3650.37 kg/h0.804 kg/L≈4.54×103 L/hV_{\text{product}} = \frac{\dot{m}_{\text{product}}}{\rho_{\text{product}}} = \frac{3650.37\,\text{kg/h}}{0.804\,\text{kg/L}} \approx 4.54 \times 10^3\,\text{L/h}


03

Determine the Reboiler Thermal Power Requirement (Part b)

The reboiler requires 3.25 MJ3.25\,\text{MJ} of thermal energy per kilogram of pure ethanol recovered.

Calculate the total hourly energy demand: Q˙hourly=3489.75 kg/h⋅3.25 MJ/kg=11 341.69 MJ/h\dot{Q}_{\text{hourly}} = 3489.75\,\text{kg/h} \cdot 3.25\,\text{MJ/kg} = 11\,341.69\,\text{MJ/h}

Convert this energy rate into thermal power (megawatts, where 1 MW=1 MJ/s1\,\text{MW} = 1\,\text{MJ/s}): Thermal Power=11 341.69 MJ/h3600 s/h≈3.15 MW\text{Thermal Power} = \frac{11\,341.69\,\text{MJ/h}}{3600\,\text{s/h}} \approx 3.15\,\text{MW}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misinterprets 95.6 wt% as volume percent and directly multiplies the recovered ethanol volume by 0.956 instead of dividing the mass by the mass fraction.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Vfeed=45.0 m3/h=45000 L/h  ⟹  Mass of ethanol fed=45000 L/h×82.5 g/L=3712500 g/h=3712.5 kg/hV_{\text{feed}} = 45.0\,\text{m}^3/\text{h} = 45000\,\text{L/h} \implies \text{Mass of ethanol fed} = 45000\,\text{L/h} \times 82.5\,\text{g/L} = 3712500\,\text{g/h} = 3712.5\,\text{kg/h}

  2. Step 2

    Recovered ethanol mass=3712.5 kg/h×0.940=3489.75 kg/h\text{Recovered ethanol mass} = 3712.5\,\text{kg/h} \times 0.940 = 3489.75\,\text{kg/h}

  3. Step 3

    Total mass of product=3489.75 kg/h×0.956=3336.20 kg/h\text{Total mass of product} = 3489.75\,\text{kg/h} \times 0.956 = 3336.20\,\text{kg/h}

    Correct

    m˙product=m˙EtOH, recoveredwEtOH=3489.75 kg/h0.956≈3650.37 kg/h\dot{m}_{\text{product}} = \frac{\dot{m}_{\text{EtOH, recovered}}}{w_{\text{EtOH}}} = \frac{3489.75\,\text{kg/h}}{0.956} \approx 3650.37\,\text{kg/h}

    Because ethanol makes up 95.6 wt%95.6\,\text{wt}\% of the commercial product, the total product stream must weigh more than the pure ethanol it contains. By definition, m˙EtOH=wEtOH⋅m˙product\dot{m}_{\text{EtOH}} = w_{\text{EtOH}} \cdot \dot{m}_{\text{product}}, which means you must divide by 0.9560.956 rather than multiply.

  4. Step 4

    Vproduct=3336.20 kg/h/0.804 kg/L=4149.50 L/hV_{\text{product}} = 3336.20\,\text{kg/h} / 0.804\,\text{kg/L} = 4149.50\,\text{L/h}

    Correct

    Vproduct=m˙productρproduct=3650.37 kg/h0.804 kg/L≈4.54×103 L/hV_{\text{product}} = \frac{\dot{m}_{\text{product}}}{\rho_{\text{product}}} = \frac{3650.37\,\text{kg/h}}{0.804\,\text{kg/L}} \approx 4.54 \times 10^3\,\text{L/h}

    Your formula for converting product mass flow rate to volumetric flow rate using density was correct, but the numerical answer was affected by the mass flow rate calculated in Step 3.

  5. Step 5

    Q˙=3489.75 kg/h×3.25 MJ/kg=11341.69 MJ/h  ⟹  Thermal power=11341.69 MJ/h/3600 s/h=3.15 MW\dot{Q} = 3489.75\,\text{kg/h} \times 3.25\,\text{MJ/kg} = 11341.69\,\text{MJ/h} \implies \text{Thermal power} = 11341.69\,\text{MJ/h} / 3600\,\text{s/h} = 3.15\,\text{MW}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the feed mass flow rate of pure ethanol using the feed volume and analytical concentration.

You applied the distillation recovery factor correctly to get the recovered pure ethanol mass flow rate.

You calculated the reboiler thermal power in part (b) with perfect unit conversions.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted mass fraction relationship

You set m˙total=m˙pure×w\dot{m}_{\text{total}} = \dot{m}_{\text{pure}} \times w instead of m˙total=m˙pure/w\dot{m}_{\text{total}} = \dot{m}_{\text{pure}} / w.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the part-to-whole relationship when working with mass fractions. A mixture containing an impure component always has a total mass greater than or equal to the mass of the pure component.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Sanity Check Mixture vs. Pure Mass
  • For any component with mass fraction wi<1w_i < 1, Total mixture mass>Pure component mass\text{Total mixture mass} > \text{Pure component mass}.

  • Whenever you solve for total stream mass from a pure component mass, divide by the weight fraction: mtotal=mi/wim_{\text{total}} = m_i / w_i.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. m˙product=3489.75 kg/h0.956=3650.37 kg/h\dot{m}_{\text{product}} = \frac{3489.75\,\text{kg/h}}{0.956} = 3650.37\,\text{kg/h}

  2. Vproduct=3650.37 kg/h0.804 kg/L≈4540.26 L/h≈4.54×103 L/hV_{\text{product}} = \frac{3650.37\,\text{kg/h}}{0.804\,\text{kg/L}} \approx 4540.26\,\text{L/h} \approx 4.54 \times 10^3\,\text{L/h}

Final answer

(a) 4.54×103 L/h4.54 \times 10^3\,\text{L/h}; (b) 3.15 MW3.15\,\text{MW}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before dividing or multiplying by a mass fraction, ask yourself whether you are finding the smaller part (pure component) or the larger whole (total stream).

  • Practice converting between component mass and total solution mass across different mass percentages.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates the reboiler thermal duty using the total feed ethanol mass rate instead of the recovered pure ethanol mass rate.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Vfeed=45.0 m3/h=45000 L/h  ⟹  Mass of ethanol fed=45000 L/h×82.5 g/L=3712.5 kg/hV_{\text{feed}} = 45.0\,\text{m}^3/\text{h} = 45000\,\text{L/h} \implies \text{Mass of ethanol fed} = 45000\,\text{L/h} \times 82.5\,\text{g/L} = 3712.5\,\text{kg/h}

  2. Step 2

    Recovered pure ethanol=3712.5 kg/h×0.940=3489.75 kg/h\text{Recovered pure ethanol} = 3712.5\,\text{kg/h} \times 0.940 = 3489.75\,\text{kg/h}

  3. Step 3

    Mass of commercial product=3489.75 kg/h/0.956=3650.37 kg/h  ⟹  Vproduct=3650.37 kg/h/0.804 kg/L=4540.26 L/h\text{Mass of commercial product} = 3489.75\,\text{kg/h} / 0.956 = 3650.37\,\text{kg/h} \implies V_{\text{product}} = 3650.37\,\text{kg/h} / 0.804\,\text{kg/L} = 4540.26\,\text{L/h}

  4. Step 4

    Energy intensity applies to feed ethanol: \text{Energy intensity applies to feed ethanol: } 3712.5,kg/h\text{kg/h}   ⟹  \implies Total energy\text{Total energy} = 3712.5,kg/h\text{kg/h} ×\times 3.25,MJ/kg\text{MJ/kg} = 12065.625,MJ/h\text{MJ/h}   ⟹  \implies Thermal power\text{Thermal power} = 12065.625,MJ/h\text{MJ/h} / 3600,s/h\text{s/h} = 3.35,MW\text{MW}

    Correct

    \dot{Q} = 3489.75 kg/h×3.25 MJ/kg3600 s/h\frac{3489.75\,\text{kg/h} \times 3.25\,\text{MJ/kg}}{3600\,\text{s/h}} ≈\approx 3.15,MW\text{MW}

    You based the energy demand on the total feed ethanol (3712.5 kg/h3712.5\,\text{kg/h}) rather than the recovered pure ethanol (3489.75 kg/h3489.75\,\text{kg/h}) as specified in the problem statement.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the volumetric feed rate and the entering ethanol mass flow rate.

You accurately calculated the recovered mass of pure ethanol using the separation recovery factor.

You correctly accounted for the commercial purity and stream density to find the product volumetric flow rate.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Wrong Basis for Specific Energy Metric

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You selected the feed mass flow rate instead of the recovered product mass flow rate as the basis for the specific energy consumption metric. Industrial energy intensity figures are usually defined per unit of target product recovered or produced unless explicitly stated on a raw-feed basis.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Verify Specific Energy Basis
  • Specific energy metrics (Espec=Q/mE_{\text{spec}} = Q / m) must be multiplied by the exact reference stream specified in the problem (e.g., product stream vs. feed stream).

  • Highlight the denominator units in the energy intensity statement (here, 'per kilogram of recovered pure ethanol') before selecting the mass flow rate to multiply.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Multiply the specific energy intensity (3.25 MJ/kg3.25\,\text{MJ/kg}) by the recovered pure ethanol rate: Q˙=3489.75 kg/h×3.25 MJ/kg=11 341.69 MJ/h\dot{Q} = 3489.75\,\text{kg/h} \times 3.25\,\text{MJ/kg} = 11\,341.69\,\text{MJ/h}.

  2. Convert the hourly thermal duty into megawatts: Pthermal=11 341.69 MJ/h3600 s/h≈3.15 MWP_{\text{thermal}} = \frac{11\,341.69\,\text{MJ/h}}{3600\,\text{s/h}} \approx 3.15\,\text{MW}.

Final answer

(a) Product flow rate=4.54×103 L/h\text{Product flow rate} = 4.54 \times 10^3\,\text{L/h}; (b) Reboiler thermal power=3.15 MW\text{Reboiler thermal power} = 3.15\,\text{MW}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check whether specific energy intensity or carbon intensity is defined per unit of raw feed processed or per unit of recovered product.

  • Review the conversion between hourly energy flow rates (MJ/h\text{MJ/h}) and instantaneous thermal power (MW=MJ/s\text{MW} = \text{MJ/s}).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student omits the 94.0% recovery factor when determining the overhead ethanol stream, assuming 100% recovery.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Vfeed=45000 L/h  ⟹  Mass of ethanol fed=45000 L/h×82.5 g/L=3712.5 kg/hV_{\text{feed}} = 45000\,\text{L/h} \implies \text{Mass of ethanol fed} = 45000\,\text{L/h} \times 82.5\,\text{g/L} = 3712.5\,\text{kg/h}

  2. Step 2

    Recovered ethanol=3712.5 kg/h\text{Recovered ethanol} = 3712.5\,\text{kg/h}

    Correct

    m˙EtOH, recovered=0.940×3712.5 kg/h=3489.75 kg/h\dot{m}_{\text{EtOH, recovered}} = 0.940 \times 3712.5\,\text{kg/h} = 3489.75\,\text{kg/h}

    You assumed 100% of the fed ethanol is recovered in the overhead product. The column achieves a 94.0% recovery efficiency, so you need to multiply the feed ethanol mass flow rate by 0.9400.940.

  3. Step 3

    Total product mass=3712.5 kg/h/0.956=3883.37 kg/h  ⟹  Vproduct=3883.37 kg/h/0.804 kg/L=4830.06 L/h\text{Total product mass} = 3712.5\,\text{kg/h} / 0.956 = 3883.37\,\text{kg/h} \implies V_{\text{product}} = 3883.37\,\text{kg/h} / 0.804\,\text{kg/L} = 4830.06\,\text{L/h}

    Correct

    m˙product=3489.75 kg/h0.956≈3650.37 kg/h  ⟹  Vproduct=3650.37 kg/h0.804 kg/L≈4.54×103 L/h\dot{m}_{\text{product}} = \frac{3489.75\,\text{kg/h}}{0.956} \approx 3650.37\,\text{kg/h} \implies V_{\text{product}} = \frac{3650.37\,\text{kg/h}}{0.804\,\text{kg/L}} \approx 4.54 \times 10^3\,\text{L/h}

    Your formulas for converting pure component mass to commercial product mass and then to volumetric flow rate are completely correct, but the numerical result is affected by using 3712.5 kg/h3712.5\,\text{kg/h} instead of 3489.75 kg/h3489.75\,\text{kg/h}.

  4. Step 4

    Total energy=3712.5 kg/h×3.25 MJ/kg=12065.625 MJ/h  ⟹  Thermal power=12065.625 MJ/h/3600 s/h=3.35 MW\text{Total energy} = 3712.5\,\text{kg/h} \times 3.25\,\text{MJ/kg} = 12065.625\,\text{MJ/h} \implies \text{Thermal power} = 12065.625\,\text{MJ/h} / 3600\,\text{s/h} = 3.35\,\text{MW}

    Correct

    Q˙=3489.75 kg/h×3.25 MJ/kg=11 341.69 MJ/h  ⟹  Power=11 341.69 MJ/h3600 s/h≈3.15 MW\dot{Q} = 3489.75\,\text{kg/h} \times 3.25\,\text{MJ/kg} = 11\,341.69\,\text{MJ/h} \implies \text{Power} = \frac{11\,341.69\,\text{MJ/h}}{3600\,\text{s/h}} \approx 3.15\,\text{MW}

    Your method for calculating hourly thermal energy demand and converting it to megawatts is sound, but this step carries forward the unadjusted feed ethanol rate.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately converted m3/h\text{m}^3/\text{h} to L/h\text{L/h} and computed the feed ethanol mass rate.

You correctly used the weight fraction 0.9560.956 to relate pure component mass to total product stream mass.

You converted units of energy per hour to megawatts correctly by dividing by 3600 s/h3600\,\text{s/h}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Fractional Component Recovery

You equated the recovered ethanol mass directly to the feed ethanol mass.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In industrial separations, fractional recovery (yield to overhead) and product purity (concentration in overhead) are distinct parameters; recovery determines how much of the target component exits in that stream before purity is applied.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Distinguish Recovery from Purity
  • Recovered Component Mass=Feed Component Mass×Fractional Recovery\text{Recovered Component Mass} = \text{Feed Component Mass} \times \text{Fractional Recovery}

  • Always multiply the entering target mass by the specified split or recovery factor before dividing by the product weight fraction.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. m˙EtOH, recovered=3712.5 kg/h×0.940=3489.75 kg/h\dot{m}_{\text{EtOH, recovered}} = 3712.5\,\text{kg/h} \times 0.940 = 3489.75\,\text{kg/h}

  2. m˙product=3489.75 kg/h0.956≈3650.37 kg/h\dot{m}_{\text{product}} = \frac{3489.75\,\text{kg/h}}{0.956} \approx 3650.37\,\text{kg/h}

  3. Vproduct=3650.37 kg/h0.804 kg/L≈4.54×103 L/hV_{\text{product}} = \frac{3650.37\,\text{kg/h}}{0.804\,\text{kg/L}} \approx 4.54 \times 10^3\,\text{L/h}

  4. Q˙thermal=3489.75 kg/h×3.25 MJ/kg3600 s/h≈3.15 MW\dot{Q}_{\text{thermal}} = \frac{3489.75\,\text{kg/h} \times 3.25\,\text{MJ/kg}}{3600\,\text{s/h}} \approx 3.15\,\text{MW}

Final answer

(a) 4.54×103 L/h4.54 \times 10^3\,\text{L/h}; (b) 3.15 MW3.15\,\text{MW}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review separation process flow diagrams to trace component splits between overhead and bottoms streams.

  • Practice distinguishing between component recovery percentage (feed-to-product split) and stream purity percentage (mass fraction).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A crystallization process recovers 240 kg/h240\,\text{kg/h} of pure citric acid in a wet cake stream that contains 80.0 wt%80.0\,\text{wt}\% citric acid. What is the total mass flow rate of the wet cake stream?

Answer

m˙cake=m˙acidwacid=240 kg/h0.800=300 kg/h\dot{m}_{\text{cake}} = \frac{\dot{m}_{\text{acid}}}{w_{\text{acid}}} = \frac{240\,\text{kg/h}}{0.800} = 300\,\text{kg/h}.

02

A bio-refinery stream contains 1200 kg/h1200\,\text{kg/h} of recovered isopropanol. It is formulated as an aqueous disinfectant containing 70.0 wt%70.0\,\text{wt}\% isopropanol with a density of 0.875 kg/L0.875\,\text{kg/L}. Calculate the volumetric flow rate of the disinfectant in L/h\text{L/h}.

Answer
  1. Total mass flow rate: m˙total=1200 kg/h0.700≈1714.29 kg/h\dot{m}_{\text{total}} = \frac{1200\,\text{kg/h}}{0.700} \approx 1714.29\,\text{kg/h}.\n2. Volumetric flow rate: V=1714.29 kg/h0.875 kg/L≈1.96×103 L/hV = \frac{1714.29\,\text{kg/h}}{0.875\,\text{kg/L}} \approx 1.96 \times 10^3\,\text{L/h}.
03

A fermentation broth of 20.0 m3/h20.0\,\text{m}^3/\text{h} has a lactic acid concentration of 45.0 g/L45.0\,\text{g/L}. A membrane separation unit recovers 90.0%90.0\% of the lactic acid as an 85.0 wt%85.0\,\text{wt}\% commercial aqueous solution (density 1.20 kg/L1.20\,\text{kg/L}). Determine the volumetric flow rate of the commercial lactic acid product in L/h\text{L/h}.

Answer
  1. Lactic acid fed: 20 000 L/h×45.0 g/L=900 kg/h20\,000\,\text{L/h} \times 45.0\,\text{g/L} = 900\,\text{kg/h}.\n2. Pure lactic acid recovered: 900×0.900=810 kg/h900 \times 0.900 = 810\,\text{kg/h}.\n3. Total product mass: m˙product=810 kg/h0.850≈952.94 kg/h\dot{m}_{\text{product}} = \frac{810\,\text{kg/h}}{0.850} \approx 952.94\,\text{kg/h}.\n4. Volumetric flow rate: V=952.94 kg/h1.20 kg/L≈794 L/hV = \frac{952.94\,\text{kg/h}}{1.20\,\text{kg/L}} \approx 794\,\text{L/h}.
Loading workspace…