Resources

An industrial wastewater analysis quantifies trace organic pollutant constituents: 545.4 mg/L545.4\text{ mg/L} carbon, 91.5 mg/L91.5\text{ mg/L} hydrogen, and 363.1 mg/L363.1\text{ mg/L} oxygen. Convert these concentrations to molar quantities ( mmol/L\,\text{mmol/L}) and determine the empirical formula of the dissolved pollutant.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Carbon: 45.41 mmol/L45.41\text{ mmol/L}; Hydrogen: 90.8 mmol/L90.8\text{ mmol/L}; Oxygen: 22.69 mmol/L22.69\text{ mmol/L}; Empirical formula: C2H4O\text{C}_2\text{H}_4\text{O}

Steps

01

Convert mass concentrations to molar concentrations

The concentration of each element is given in milligrams per liter (mg/L\text{mg/L}). Since 1 g/mol=1 mg/mmol1\text{ g/mol} = 1\text{ mg/mmol}, dividing the mass concentration in mg/L\text{mg/L} by the standard atomic weight in g/mol\text{g/mol} directly yields the molar concentration in millimoles per liter (mmol/L\text{mmol/L}):

Molar concentration (mmol/L)=Mass concentration (mg/L)Molar mass (mg/mmol)\text{Molar concentration } (\text{mmol/L}) = \frac{\text{Mass concentration } (\text{mg/L})}{\text{Molar mass } (\text{mg/mmol})}

Using standard atomic weights (C=12.011 g/mol\ce{C} = 12.011\text{ g/mol}, H=1.008 g/mol\ce{H} = 1.008\text{ g/mol}, O=16.00 g/mol\ce{O} = 16.00\text{ g/mol}):

  • Carbon (C\ce{C}): Concentration of C=545.4 mg/L12.011 mg/mmol≈45.41 mmol/L\text{Concentration of C} = \frac{545.4\text{ mg/L}}{12.011\text{ mg/mmol}} \approx 45.41\text{ mmol/L}
  • Hydrogen (H\ce{H}): Concentration of H=91.5 mg/L1.008 mg/mmol≈90.8 mmol/L\text{Concentration of H} = \frac{91.5\text{ mg/L}}{1.008\text{ mg/mmol}} \approx 90.8\text{ mmol/L}
  • Oxygen (O\ce{O}): Concentration of O=363.1 mg/L16.00 mg/mmol≈22.69 mmol/L\text{Concentration of O} = \frac{363.1\text{ mg/L}}{16.00\text{ mg/mmol}} \approx 22.69\text{ mmol/L}

Common Pitfall: When analyzing elemental compositions of organic compounds, always divide by the atomic molar mass of the individual element (H≈1.008 g/mol\ce{H} \approx 1.008\text{ g/mol}, O≈16.00 g/mol\ce{O} \approx 16.00\text{ g/mol}), not diatomic molecular masses (HX2\ce{H2} or OX2\ce{O2}).


02

Determine the simplest mole ratio

To find the empirical formula, divide each molar quantity by the smallest molar value among them (22.69 mmol/L22.69\text{ mmol/L}):

  • Ratio for C\ce{C}: 45.41 mmol/L22.69 mmol/L≈2.001≈2\frac{45.41\text{ mmol/L}}{22.69\text{ mmol/L}} \approx 2.001 \approx 2
  • Ratio for H\ce{H}: 90.8 mmol/L22.69 mmol/L≈4.002≈4\frac{90.8\text{ mmol/L}}{22.69\text{ mmol/L}} \approx 4.002 \approx 4
  • Ratio for O\ce{O}: 22.69 mmol/L22.69 mmol/L=1\frac{22.69\text{ mmol/L}}{22.69\text{ mmol/L}} = 1

03

Write the empirical formula

The resulting whole-number mole ratio is: C:H:O=2:4:1\ce{C} : \ce{H} : \ce{O} = 2 : 4 : 1

Thus, the empirical formula of the dissolved pollutant is CX2HX4O\ce{C2H4O}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student divides the mass of hydrogen by the molar mass of diatomic hydrogen (H2, 2.016 g/mol) instead of atomic hydrogen (H), resulting in an incorrect molar quantity and mole ratio.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    C: 545.4/12.01=45.41 mmol/L  ⟹  H: 91.5/2.016=45.39 mmol/L  ⟹  O: 363.1/16.00=22.69 mmol/L\text{C: } 545.4 / 12.01 = 45.41\text{ mmol/L} \implies \text{H: } 91.5 / 2.016 = 45.39\text{ mmol/L} \implies \text{O: } 363.1 / 16.00 = 22.69\text{ mmol/L}

    Correct

    Concentration of H=91.5 mg/L1.008 mg/mmol≈90.8 mmol/L\text{Concentration of H} = \frac{91.5\text{ mg/L}}{1.008\text{ mg/mmol}} \approx 90.8\text{ mmol/L}

    You used the molar mass of diatomic hydrogen gas (HX2≈2.016 g/mol\ce{H2} \approx 2.016\text{ g/mol}) rather than atomic hydrogen (H≈1.008 g/mol\ce{H} \approx 1.008\text{ g/mol}). Chemical formulas count individual atoms, so elemental conversions always require atomic molar masses.

  2. Step 2

    C: 45.41/22.69=2.00  ⟹  H: 45.39/22.69=2.00  ⟹  O: 22.69/22.69=1.00\text{C: } 45.41 / 22.69 = 2.00 \implies \text{H: } 45.39 / 22.69 = 2.00 \implies \text{O: } 22.69 / 22.69 = 1.00

    Correct

    C: 45.4122.69≈2  ⟹  H: 90.822.69≈4  ⟹  O: 22.6922.69=1\text{C: } \frac{45.41}{22.69} \approx 2 \implies \text{H: } \frac{90.8}{22.69} \approx 4 \implies \text{O: } \frac{22.69}{22.69} = 1

    Your division method by the smallest value was executed properly, but the ratio for hydrogen inherited the molar value error from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    Empirical formula: CX2HX2O\text{Empirical formula: } \ce{C2H2O}

    Correct

    Empirical formula: CX2HX4O\text{Empirical formula: } \ce{C2H4O}

    Because the mole ratio for hydrogen was halved, the resulting formula was written as CX2HX2O\ce{C2H2O} instead of CX2HX4O\ce{C2H4O}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the unit conversion relationship where 1 mg/L÷1 g/mol=1 mmol/L1\text{ mg/L} \div 1\text{ g/mol} = 1\text{ mmol/L}.

You accurately calculated the molar concentrations of carbon and oxygen.

You used the correct strategy of dividing each molar amount by the smallest molar value to establish integer ratios.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Diatomic mass used instead of atomic mass

Dividing hydrogen by 2.016 g/mol2.016\text{ g/mol} instead of 1.008 g/mol1.008\text{ g/mol}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the molar mass of free diatomic gas molecules (HX2\ce{H2}) with the atomic mass of hydrogen atoms (H\ce{H}) bound inside a chemical compound.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Use atomic molar mass for formula calculations
  • Empirical and molecular formulas represent ratios of individual atoms, never diatomic molecules.

  • Always divide elemental masses by individual atomic weights (e.g., H=1.008 g/mol\ce{H} = 1.008\text{ g/mol}, O=16.00 g/mol\ce{O} = 16.00\text{ g/mol}, N=14.01 g/mol\ce{N} = 14.01\text{ g/mol}).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recalculate hydrogen's concentration using atomic molar mass: 91.5 mg/L1.008 mg/mmol≈90.8 mmol/L\frac{91.5\text{ mg/L}}{1.008\text{ mg/mmol}} \approx 90.8\text{ mmol/L}.

  2. Recalculate the hydrogen mole ratio by dividing by the smallest quantity (22.69 mmol/L22.69\text{ mmol/L}): 90.8 mmol/L22.69 mmol/L≈4.00\frac{90.8\text{ mmol/L}}{22.69\text{ mmol/L}} \approx 4.00.

  3. Assemble the whole-number atom ratio: C:H:O=2:4:1\ce{C} : \ce{H} : \ce{O} = 2 : 4 : 1.

Final answer

Carbon: 45.41 mmol/L;Hydrogen: 90.8 mmol/L;Oxygen: 22.69 mmol/L;Empirical formula: CX2HX4O\text{Carbon: } 45.41\text{ mmol/L}; \text{Hydrogen: } 90.8\text{ mmol/L}; \text{Oxygen: } 22.69\text{ mmol/L}; \text{Empirical formula: } \ce{C2H4O}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the difference between elemental constituents in a compound (atoms) versus standard elemental states (diatomic gases).

  • Practice empirical formula problems that feature hydrogen, oxygen, and nitrogen to solidify using atomic weights.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student uses the mass concentrations directly as the ratio of atoms in the formula rather than converting them to molar quantities first.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    C: 545.4 mg/L/12.01 mg/mmol=45.41 mmol/L  ⟹  H: 91.5 mg/L/1.008 mg/mmol=90.77 mmol/L  ⟹  O: 363.1 mg/L/16.00 mg/mmol=22.69 mmol/L\text{C: } 545.4\text{ mg/L} / 12.01\text{ mg/mmol} = 45.41\text{ mmol/L} \implies \text{H: } 91.5\text{ mg/L} / 1.008\text{ mg/mmol} = 90.77\text{ mmol/L} \implies \text{O: } 363.1\text{ mg/L} / 16.00\text{ mg/mmol} = 22.69\text{ mmol/L}

  2. Step 2

    C: 545.4/91.5=5.96≈6  ⟹  H: 91.5/91.5=1.00  ⟹  O: 363.1/91.5=3.97≈4\text{C: } 545.4 / 91.5 = 5.96 \approx 6 \implies \text{H: } 91.5 / 91.5 = 1.00 \implies \text{O: } 363.1 / 91.5 = 3.97 \approx 4

    Correct

    C: 45.41 mmol/L22.69 mmol/L≈2,H: 90.77 mmol/L22.69 mmol/L≈4,O: 22.69 mmol/L22.69 mmol/L=1\text{C: } \frac{45.41\text{ mmol/L}}{22.69\text{ mmol/L}} \approx 2, \quad \text{H: } \frac{90.77\text{ mmol/L}}{22.69\text{ mmol/L}} \approx 4, \quad \text{O: } \frac{22.69\text{ mmol/L}}{22.69\text{ mmol/L}} = 1

    You reverted to the initial mass concentrations (545.4545.4, 91.591.5, and 363.1 mg/L363.1\text{ mg/L}) to find the ratios instead of using the molar amounts you calculated in Step 1. Empirical formulas represent atom-to-atom or mole-to-mole ratios, so you must divide each molar value by the smallest molar value (22.69 mmol/L22.69\text{ mmol/L}).

  3. Step 3

    Empirical formula: CX6HOX4\text{Empirical formula: } \ce{C6HO4}

    Correct

    Empirical formula: CX2HX4O\text{Empirical formula: } \ce{C2H4O}

    Because the ratios were derived from mass values rather than molar amounts, the resulting empirical formula is incorrect.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used standard atomic masses to convert milligram concentrations into millimolar concentrations.

You recognized the general procedure of dividing numbers by the smallest value to find whole-number subscripts.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Mass ratio used instead of mole ratio

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You understood that formulas require whole-number ratios, but you lost track of which quantities to compare and divided the given mass values rather than the converted mole values.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Subscripts Represent Moles
  • Chemical formula subscripts indicate relative counts of atoms (or moles of atoms), never relative masses.

  • Once you convert masses to moles, set aside the mass numbers completely so you do not accidentally reuse them.

Divide Moles by Smallest Moles
  • To find the simplest ratio, divide every element's molar value by the smallest molar quantity obtained.

  • Identify the smallest value among your calculated molar concentrations (22.69 mmol/L22.69\text{ mmol/L}) and divide all molar amounts by it.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Take the molar concentrations from Step 1: C=45.41 mmol/L\text{C} = 45.41\text{ mmol/L}, H=90.77 mmol/L\text{H} = 90.77\text{ mmol/L}, O=22.69 mmol/L\text{O} = 22.69\text{ mmol/L}.

  2. Identify the smallest molar concentration, which is 22.69 mmol/L22.69\text{ mmol/L} for O\ce{O}.

  3. Divide each molar concentration by 22.69 mmol/L22.69\text{ mmol/L} to find the relative mole ratio: C=45.4122.69≈2\text{C} = \frac{45.41}{22.69} \approx 2, H=90.7722.69≈4\text{H} = \frac{90.77}{22.69} \approx 4, O=22.6922.69=1\text{O} = \frac{22.69}{22.69} = 1.

Final answer

CX2HX4O\ce{C2H4O}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Cross out or visually isolate the original mass numbers once you have converted them to millimoles to avoid picking them up again.

  • Verify that your final ratio represents atoms or moles, not grams or milligrams.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student rounds the mole ratio of hydrogen (90.77 / 45.41) relative to carbon incorrectly or inverts the ratio division, dividing by the largest molar quantity rather than the smallest.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    C:545.4/12.01=45.41 mmol/L  ⟹  H:91.5/1.008=90.77 mmol/L  ⟹  O:363.1/16.00=22.69 mmol/L\text{C}: 545.4 / 12.01 = 45.41\text{ mmol/L} \implies \text{H}: 91.5 / 1.008 = 90.77\text{ mmol/L} \implies \text{O}: 363.1 / 16.00 = 22.69\text{ mmol/L}

  2. Step 2

    Divide by largest (90.77):C:45.41/90.77=0.50  ⟹  H:90.77/90.77=1.00  ⟹  O:22.69/90.77=0.25\text{Divide by largest } (90.77): \text{C}: 45.41 / 90.77 = 0.50 \implies \text{H}: 90.77 / 90.77 = 1.00 \implies \text{O}: 22.69 / 90.77 = 0.25

    Correct

    Divide each by the smallest molar value (22.69 mmol/L):C:45.4122.69≈2  ⟹  H:90.7722.69≈4  ⟹  O:22.6922.69=1\text{Divide each by the smallest molar value } (22.69\text{ mmol/L}): \text{C}: \frac{45.41}{22.69} \approx 2 \implies \text{H}: \frac{90.77}{22.69} \approx 4 \implies \text{O}: \frac{22.69}{22.69} = 1

    You divided by the largest molar quantity (90.77 mmol/L90.77\text{ mmol/L}) instead of the smallest (22.69 mmol/L22.69\text{ mmol/L}). The standard rule for finding mole ratios is to divide every mole value by the smallest value so that the least abundant element is assigned a baseline subscript of 11.

  3. Step 3

    Multiply by 4 to get integers: C2H4O1  ⟹  Empirical formula: C2H4O\text{Multiply by 4 to get integers: } \text{C}_2\text{H}_4\text{O}_1 \implies \text{Empirical formula: } \text{C}_2\text{H}_4\text{O}

    Correct

    Empirical formula: C2H4O\text{Empirical formula: } \text{C}_2\text{H}_4\text{O}

    Because your previous step yielded fractions (0.500.50, 1.001.00, 0.250.25), you had to multiply by 44 to find whole numbers. While your algebra successfully recovered the correct ratio, dividing by the smallest quantity in Step 2 directly yields the whole numbers 22, 44, and 11 without this extra step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the molar concentrations of carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen from their mass concentrations.

You correctly converted your decimal values into whole numbers by multiplying through by 44.

You stated the correct final empirical formula as C2H4O\text{C}_2\text{H}_4\text{O}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Dividing by Largest Rather Than Smallest Molar Quantity

You divided all molar concentrations by the maximum value (90.77 mmol/L90.77\text{ mmol/L}) instead of the minimum value (22.69 mmol/L22.69\text{ mmol/L}).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You reversed the baseline reference element in the empirical formula algorithm. Dividing by the largest value produces numbers less than or equal to 11, turning integer ratios into decimals that are difficult to interpret in more complex problems. Always divide by the smallest molar quantity so that the baseline subscript is 11 and all other subscripts are greater than or equal to 11.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Baseline Division Rule
  • To find the simplest mole ratio, always divide every element's mole amount by the smallest mole amount in the set.

  • Scan all calculated mole values, identify the smallest one, and place it in the denominator for every element.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the smallest molar concentration among the elements: O=22.69 mmol/L\text{O} = 22.69\text{ mmol/L}.

  2. Divide each molar value by 22.69 mmol/L22.69\text{ mmol/L}:

  3. C=45.4122.69≈2.00\text{C} = \frac{45.41}{22.69} \approx 2.00

  4. H=90.7722.69≈4.00\text{H} = \frac{90.77}{22.69} \approx 4.00

  5. O=22.6922.69=1.00\text{O} = \frac{22.69}{22.69} = 1.00

  6. Write the empirical formula using these whole numbers: C2H4O\text{C}_2\text{H}_4\text{O}.

Final answer

C2H4O\text{C}_2\text{H}_4\text{O}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remember the four-step rhyme: 'Percent to mass, mass to mole, divide by small, multiply 'til whole.'

  • Practice identifying the smallest molar quantity first before setting up ratio divisions.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A sample of an unknown hydrocarbon contains 85.6 g85.6\text{ g} of carbon and 14.4 g14.4\text{ g} of hydrogen. Determine its empirical formula.

Answer

Moles of C=85.6 g12.01 g/mol≈7.13 mol\text{Moles of C} = \frac{85.6\text{ g}}{12.01\text{ g/mol}} \approx 7.13\text{ mol}; Moles of H=14.4 g1.008 g/mol≈14.29 mol\text{Moles of H} = \frac{14.4\text{ g}}{1.008\text{ g/mol}} \approx 14.29\text{ mol}. Ratio H/C=14.297.13≈2\ce{H}/\ce{C} = \frac{14.29}{7.13} \approx 2. Empirical formula: CHX2\ce{CH2}.

02

A combustion analysis of an alcohol reveals 60.0% C60.0\%\text{ C}, 13.4% H13.4\%\text{ H}, and 26.6% O26.6\%\text{ O} by mass. Determine the empirical formula of the alcohol.

Answer

Per 100 g100\text{ g}: C=60.0 g12.01 g/mol=5.00 mol\text{C} = \frac{60.0\text{ g}}{12.01\text{ g/mol}} = 5.00\text{ mol}; H=13.4 g1.008 g/mol=13.29 mol\text{H} = \frac{13.4\text{ g}}{1.008\text{ g/mol}} = 13.29\text{ mol}; O=26.6 g16.00 g/mol=1.66 mol\text{O} = \frac{26.6\text{ g}}{16.00\text{ g/mol}} = 1.66\text{ mol}. Divide by 1.661.66: C3.01H8.01O1\ce{C}_{3.01}\ce{H}_{8.01}\ce{O}_1. Empirical formula: CX3HX8O\ce{C3H8O}.

03

An aqueous organic amine contains 38.7 mg/L38.7\text{ mg/L} carbon, 9.74 mg/L9.74\text{ mg/L} hydrogen, and 45.1 mg/L45.1\text{ mg/L} nitrogen. Calculate the molar quantity of each element in mmol/L\text{mmol/L} and determine the empirical formula.

Answer

C=38.712.01=3.22 mmol/L\text{C} = \frac{38.7}{12.01} = 3.22\text{ mmol/L}; H=9.741.008=9.66 mmol/L\text{H} = \frac{9.74}{1.008} = 9.66\text{ mmol/L}; N=45.114.01=3.22 mmol/L\text{N} = \frac{45.1}{14.01} = 3.22\text{ mmol/L}. Divide by 3.223.22: C:H:N=1:3:1\ce{C} : \ce{H} : \ce{N} = 1 : 3 : 1. Empirical formula: CHX3N\ce{CH3N}.

Loading workspace…