Resources
Consider the sulfur trioxide molecule () and the sulfite anion (). (a) Determine the VSEPR molecular geometry and ideal bond angle for each species. (b) Couple these geometries with bond polarity vectors to determine whether each species has a net permanent dipole moment (polar vs. nonpolar). (c) When gaseous is dissolved in water to produce sulfurous acid, which dissociates into , explain how the change in formal oxidation state or lone pair count on sulfur dictates the transformation in macroscopic solution polarity.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) : trigonal planar (, ideal angle ); : trigonal pyramidal (, ideal angle , approximately ). (b) is nonpolar (dipole moment ) because its three equal polar bond vectors symmetrically cancel in symmetry; is polar (asymmetric charge distribution with an active non-bonding lone pair). (c) Reduction in steric bonding symmetry via the addition of a localized non-bonding lone pair on sulfur changes the geometry from planar (symmetric cancellation) to pyramidal (asymmetric dipole vector sum).
Steps
VSEPR Molecular Geometry and Bond Angles
To determine the geometries, calculate the total valence electrons and steric number () for each species:
-
Sulfur trioxide ():
- Total valence electrons: .
- Sulfur shares all its valence electrons across three bonding domains, leaving zero non-bonding lone pairs on the central sulfur atom.
- VSEPR notation: (Steric Number ).
- Electron-domain & molecular geometry: Trigonal planar.
- Ideal bond angle: Exactly .
-
Sulfite anion ():
- Total valence electrons: .
- Sulfur forms three bonding domains with oxygen atoms and retains one non-bonding lone pair.
- VSEPR notation: (Steric Number ).
- Electron-domain geometry: Tetrahedral.
- Molecular geometry: Trigonal pyramidal.
- Ideal bond angle: Because lone pair–bonding pair repulsions are stronger than bonding pair–bonding pair repulsions, the tetrahedral angle is compressed from to (approximately ).
Bond Dipoles and Net Molecular Polarity
Oxygen is significantly more electronegative than sulfur ( vs. ), giving each bond a substantial bond dipole directed outward toward the oxygen atom ():
- For : The three equal bond dipoles lie entirely in a single plane, pointing symmetrically outward at angles ( symmetry). By vector addition: The individual bond dipoles completely cancel one another, making nonpolar (net dipole moment ).
- For : The three bond dipoles are directed downward away from the apex sulfur in a pyramid ( symmetry). Their horizontal components cancel, but their vertical components reinforce one another along the three-fold axis. Additionally, the localized non-bonding lone pair introduces an asymmetric charge density. Because these vectors do not cancel: The anion is polar.
Influence of Lone Pairs on Symmetry and Polarity
- In , sulfur is in the formal oxidation state and possesses zero lone pairs (). The high planar symmetry enforces full vector cancellation.
- In , sulfur is in the oxidation state, retaining a localized valence lone pair ().
- The addition of this lone pair exerts electrostatic repulsion that pushes the three oxygen atoms out of the plane, reducing the spatial symmetry from planar () to pyramidal (). This structural distortion prevents vector cancellation, directly converting a nonpolar bonding arrangement into an inherently polar one with an asymmetric dipole vector sum.
Typical errors
01 A student overlooks the two extra electrons from the negative charge on the sulfite anion and predicts both species to have trigonal planar geometry and zero dipole moment.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
: bonds, lone pairs on trigonal planar, bond angle : bonds, lone pairs on trigonal planar, bond angle
Correct: , trigonal planar, ; : ( valence electrons, lone pair on ), trigonal pyramidal, bond angle (approx. )
You evaluated correctly ( valence electrons). However, for , the charge adds valence electrons for a total of electrons (). This leaves one non-bonding lone pair on the sulfur atom, yielding an steric number of , which corresponds to a trigonal pyramidal molecular geometry with bond angles compressed to approximately .
- Step 2
has symmetrical trigonal planar geometry with identical bonds that cancel, net dipole (nonpolar) has symmetrical trigonal planar geometry where bond dipoles cancel out completely, net dipole (nonpolar)
Correctis nonpolar because the three planar dipoles cancel symmetrically (); is polar because the three dipoles point along a trigonal pyramid () and do not cancel, reinforced by the localized lone pair.
Your polarity conclusion for is completely correct. For , because your geometry in part (a) missed the lone pair, you concluded that the dipoles cancel. In the actual trigonal pyramidal geometry, the bond dipole components along the threefold axis add together rather than canceling, giving a permanent net dipole moment.
- Step 3
The problem contains a chemical conflict because dissolving yields sulfuric acid () with sulfur in the oxidation state, not sulfurous acid or sulfite () with sulfur in the state, so a unique valid explanation cannot be given.
CorrectThe reduction of sulfur from in (zero lone pairs, steric number , ) to in gives sulfur one localized valence lone pair (steric number , ). This lone pair repels the bonding pairs downward, breaking planar symmetry and preventing dipole cancellation.
While your observation regarding the aqueous hydration reaction of to form sulfuric acid is chemically insightful, the question asks for the theoretical structural explanation connecting sulfur's oxidation state and lone pair count to molecular symmetry. The state in retains a localized lone pair, reducing the point group symmetry from to and resulting in net polarity.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly counted the valence electrons and determined the trigonal planar geometry for .
You correctly applied vector cancellation to conclude that symmetrical trigonal planar molecules with identical peripheral atoms are nonpolar.
You demonstrated advanced chemical knowledge by identifying the formal oxidation states of sulfur in and .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated the neutral molecule and the polyatomic anion as having the same number of valence electrons on sulfur.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou did not add the magnitude of the negative charge to the total valence electron tally when applying VSEPR theory to , causing you to miss the non-bonding lone pair on the central sulfur atom.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Include Anion/Cation Charge in Total Valence Count
Total valence electrons = .
Always write out the explicit electron summation before placing bonding pairs and lone pairs.
- Steric Number and Lone Pair Recognition
Steric Number .
Check whether the central atom satisfies the octet or expanded octet; for , electrons, which forms central lone pair ().
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate total valence electrons: .
Distribute electrons: bonding domains to oxygen atoms use electrons, terminal octets use electrons, leaving electrons ( lone pair) on sulfur.
Determine VSEPR type: (steric number ), giving a trigonal pyramidal molecular geometry with ideal bond angles (approx. ).
Evaluate dipole vectors: In a trigonal pyramid, the three polar bond vectors point downward and do not cancel, giving a net dipole moment (polar).
Explain polarity shift: Going from (, lone pairs) to (, lone pair) introduces a localized non-bonding pair that distorts the geometry out of the plane, breaking vector cancellation.
(a) : trigonal planar, ; : trigonal pyramidal, (approx. ). (b) is nonpolar; is polar. (c) The presence of a localized lone pair on sulfur in lowers symmetry from to , preventing bond dipole cancellation.
02 A student determines the geometries correctly but mistakenly treats SO3 as polar by assuming individual polar bonds always create a polar molecule.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
: bonding domains, lone pairs trigonal planar, bond angle : bonding domains, lone pair trigonal pyramidal, bond angle
- Step 2
bonds are polar due to electronegativity difference, so is polar
Correctis nonpolar (net dipole ) because the three identical polar bond dipoles point outward at in a trigonal planar () arrangement and sum to zero ().
Individual bond polarity does not guarantee molecular polarity. In a symmetric trigonal planar molecule with identical outer atoms, the three bond dipole vectors cancel completely.
- Step 3
has polar bonds and asymmetric trigonal pyramidal geometry, so it is polar
- Step 4
: forms sulfuric acid () upon hydration rather than sulfurous acid () or , so the premise contradicts the chemistry and prevents a unique answer.
CorrectIn , sulfur is in the oxidation state with lone pairs, giving a symmetric planar geometry where bond dipoles cancel. In , sulfur is in the oxidation state with localized non-bonding lone pair; this lone pair distorts the geometry into a pyramid, breaking symmetry and producing a net dipole moment.
While you correctly recognized that hydrates to rather than under standard conditions, the question asks for the geometric and symmetry consequence of adding a localized lone pair / altering sulfur's formal oxidation state.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly determined the VSEPR electron domains and molecular shapes for both sulfur trioxide and the sulfite ion.
You recognized that sulfur-oxygen bonds are inherently polar due to the electronegativity difference between sulfur and oxygen.
You correctly identified that the trigonal pyramidal shape of the sulfite ion leads to an asymmetric dipole distribution and a net polar molecule.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou assumed that because the individual bonds are polar, the entire molecule must be polar, neglecting geometric vector cancellation.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisEquating local bond dipoles with net molecular dipole moments without performing three-dimensional vector addition over the molecule's point group symmetry.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Molecular Dipole Vector Sum
A molecule is nonpolar if its bond dipoles are identical and point in directions that sum to zero (e.g., linear , trigonal planar , tetrahedral ).
Always draw the spatial vector arrows from central atom to peripheral atoms. If the molecule has a symmetric electron domain geometry with no lone pairs and identical ligands, set .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDraw the three equal bond dipoles directed radially outward at in the molecular plane.
Add the vectors: the resultant of two equal vectors exactly balances the third opposing vector, giving .
Conclude that is nonpolar, whereas the pyramidal shape of pushes all three dipoles downward, yielding a net downward dipole reinforced by the top lone pair.
(a) : trigonal planar, ; : trigonal pyramidal, (). (b) is nonpolar (vectors cancel); is polar. (c) Adding a lone pair (going from to oxidation state) introduces steric repulsion that bends bonds out of the plane, reducing planar symmetry to pyramidal symmetry and creating a net dipole.
Lock it in
How does an overall ionic charge affect the total valence electron count when constructing a Lewis/VSEPR structure?
Add electrons equal to the negative charge (for anions) or subtract electrons equal to the positive charge (for cations) before finding the steric number.
Similar question
Determine the total valence electron count, VSEPR molecular geometry, and polarity for the carbonate ion, .
Answer
valence electrons (). Central carbon forms three bonding domains with zero lone pairs (). Geometry is trigonal planar with bond angles; bond dipoles cancel symmetrically, making it nonpolar.
Compare the molecular geometry, ideal bond angle, and net dipole moment of the neutral molecule with the hydronium cation .
Answer
Both have valence electrons and an configuration ( bonds, central lone pair). Both exhibit trigonal pyramidal geometry with bond angles (approx. ) and both possess a net permanent dipole moment (polar).
Consider xenon trioxide () and the nitrate anion (). For each species: (1) state the number of lone pairs on the central atom, (2) predict the molecular geometry, and (3) determine whether the species has a net permanent dipole moment.
Answer
: valence electrons lone pair on (), trigonal pyramidal, polar. : valence electrons lone pairs on (), trigonal planar, nonpolar.