Resources

A student dissolves 8.50 g8.50\text{ g} of potassium nitrate (KNO3\text{KNO}_3, molar mass 101.10 g/mol101.10\text{ g/mol}) in 200.0 g200.0\text{ g} of water. The student calculates the freezing point depression using ΔTf=iKfm\Delta T_f = i K_f m, but forgets that the depression represents a decrease from the pure solvent's freezing point (0.00∘C0.00^\circ\text{C}) and mistakenly reports the solution freezing point as +0.78∘C+0.78^\circ\text{C}. Taking Kf=1.86∘C⋅kg/molK_f = 1.86^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol} and assuming ideal dissociation (i=2i = 2), state both the correct magnitude of the freezing point depression (ΔTf\Delta T_f) and the actual freezing point (TfT_f) of the solution.

Answer and steps

Final answer

ΔTf=0.78∘C\Delta T_f = 0.78^\circ\text{C}; actual freezing point Tf=−0.78∘CT_f = -0.78^\circ\text{C}

Steps

01

Identify the Definition of Freezing Point Depression

Freezing point depression, ΔTf\Delta T_f, measures how much the freezing point of a pure solvent decreases when a nonvolatile solute is added:

ΔTf=Tf,pure−Tf\Delta T_f = T_{f,\text{pure}} - T_f

where:

  • Tf,pureT_{f,\text{pure}} is the normal freezing point of pure water (0.00∘C0.00^\circ\text{C}).
  • TfT_f is the actual freezing point of the solution.
  • ΔTf\Delta T_f is defined as a non-negative magnitude (a positive temperature difference).

02

Determine the Magnitude of Freezing Point Depression (ΔTf\Delta T_f)

The student computed the magnitude of the freezing point depression and reported the value as +0.78∘C+0.78^\circ\text{C}, confusing the depression magnitude itself with the solution's final temperature:

ΔTf=0.78∘C\Delta T_f = 0.78^\circ\text{C}


03

Calculate the Actual Freezing Point (TfT_f)

Because solute particles disrupt the formation of the crystal lattice of ice, the presence of solute always lowers the freezing point below that of the pure solvent.

Rearranging the definition gives:

Tf=Tf,pure−ΔTfT_f = T_{f,\text{pure}} - \Delta T_f

Substitute the pure solvent freezing point and the depression magnitude:

Tf=0.00∘C−0.78∘C=−0.78∘CT_f = 0.00^\circ\text{C} - 0.78^\circ\text{C} = -0.78^\circ\text{C}

Common Pitfall: A calculated colligative change ΔTf\Delta T_f is a positive quantity representing an interval of temperature drop. For aqueous solutions, failing to subtract ΔTf\Delta T_f from 0.00∘C0.00^\circ\text{C} leads to an unphysical positive freezing point above pure ice.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to account for the van 't Hoff factor when calculating freezing point depression, using i = 1 instead of i = 2.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    moles KNOX3=8.50101.10=0.0841 mol\text{moles } \ce{KNO3} = \frac{8.50}{101.10} = 0.0841\text{ mol}

  2. Step 2

    m=0.0841 mol0.2000 kg=0.4205 mm = \frac{0.0841\text{ mol}}{0.2000\text{ kg}} = 0.4205\text{ m}

  3. Step 3

    ΔTf=Kf⋅m=1.86⋅0.4205=0.39∘C\Delta T_f = K_f \cdot m = 1.86 \cdot 0.4205 = 0.39^\circ\text{C}

    Correct

    Δ\Delta T_f = i K_f m = 2 ×\times 1.86^\circ$$\text{C}$$\cdot$$\text{kg/mol} ×\times 0.4205 m\text{ m} ≈\approx 0.78^\circ$$\text{C}

    Because potassium nitrate is a strong electrolyte that dissociates into two ions (KX+\ce{K+} and NOX3X−\ce{NO3-}), you need to include the van 't Hoff factor i=2i = 2 in the formula ΔTf=iKfm\Delta T_f = i K_f m.

  4. Step 4

    Tf=0.00∘C−0.39∘C=−0.39∘CT_f = 0.00^\circ\text{C} - 0.39^\circ\text{C} = -0.39^\circ\text{C}

    Correct

    T_f = T_{f,pure\text{pure}} - Δ\Delta T_f = 0.00^\circ$$\text{C} - 0.78^\circ$$\text{C} = -0.78^\circ$$\text{C}_$$

    Your subtraction method from the freezing point of pure water is correct, but the numerical answer is affected by the missing factor of 22 in Step 3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You calculated the molar amount of potassium nitrate accurately.

You determined the molality by correctly dividing the moles by the mass of water in kilograms.

You correctly recognized that the freezing point of an aqueous solution is lower than 0.00∘C0.00^\circ\text{C} and subtracted the depression magnitude from pure water's freezing point.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted van 't Hoff factor ($i$)

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated an ionic salt (KNOX3\ce{KNO3}) as a non-electrolyte with i=1i = 1, overlooking the complete dissociation of soluble ionic compounds into multiple ions in aqueous solution.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Electrolyte vs. Non-electrolyte
  • Colligative properties depend on the total number of dissolved solute particles. Soluble ionic salts dissociate into ions, so ii equals the total number of ions per formula unit.

  • Always check whether the solute is ionic or molecular before setting up ΔTf=iKfm\Delta T_f = i K_f m.

Count Dissociation Products
  • KNOX3(s)→KX+(aq)+NOX3X−(aq)\ce{KNO3(s) -> K+(aq) + NO3-(aq)} produces 22 moles of ions per mole of salt, giving i=2i = 2.

  • Write the dissociation reaction to identify the correct value of ii.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the solute KNOX3\ce{KNO3} as an electrolyte that dissociates into KX+\ce{K+} and NOX3X−\ce{NO3-}, giving i=2i = 2.

  2. Multiply the molality and cryoscopic constant by ii: ΔTf=2×1.86∘C⋅kg/mol×0.4205 m=0.78∘C\Delta T_f = 2 \times 1.86^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol} \times 0.4205\text{ m} = 0.78^\circ\text{C}.

  3. Subtract ΔTf\Delta T_f from the pure solvent freezing point: Tf=0.00∘C−0.78∘C=−0.78∘CT_f = 0.00^\circ\text{C} - 0.78^\circ\text{C} = -0.78^\circ\text{C}.

Final answer

ΔTf=0.78∘C\Delta T_f = 0.78^\circ\text{C} and Tf=−0.78∘CT_f = -0.78^\circ\text{C}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice identifying the van 't Hoff factor ii for common ionic salts versus non-electrolytes (like glucose or urea).

  • Re-evaluate colligative property formulas by writing out ΔT=iKm\Delta T = i K m every time to remind yourself of the ii term.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student fails to convert the mass of water from grams to kilograms in the denominator when calculating molality.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    moles \text{moles } KNO\text{KNO}3 = 8.50101.10\frac{8.50}{101.10} = 0.0841 mol\text{ mol}

  2. Step 2

    m = 0.0841200.0\frac{0.0841}{200.0} = 0.0004205 mol/g\text{ mol/g}

    Correct

    m = 0.08408 mol0.2000 kg\frac{0.08408\text{ mol}}{0.2000\text{ kg}} = 0.4204 mol/kg\text{ mol/kg}

    You substituted the mass of water in grams (200.0 g200.0\text{ g}) instead of converting it to kilograms (0.2000 kg0.2000\text{ kg}). Molality (mm) is defined as moles of solute per kilogram of solvent.

  3. Step 3

    Δ\Delta T_f = 2 ×\times 1.86 ×\times 0.0004205 = 0.00156^$\circC\text{C}

    Correct

    Δ\Delta T_f = i K_f m = 2 ×\times 1.86^\circ$$\text{C}$$\cdot$$\text{kg/mol} ×\times 0.4204 mol/kg\text{ mol/kg} ≈\approx 1.56^\circ$$\text{C}

    You correctly applied ΔTf=iKfm\Delta T_f = i K_f m with i=2i = 2, but your numerical output was off by a factor of 10001000 due to the molality unit error in the preceding step.

  4. Step 4

    T_f = 0.00^\circ$$\text{C} - 0.00156^\circ$$\text{C} = -0.00156^$\circC\text{C}

    Correct

    T_f = 0.00^\circ$$\text{C} - 1.56^\circ$$\text{C} = -1.56^$\circC\text{C}

    You correctly subtracted the calculated depression from 0.00∘C0.00^\circ\text{C}, but the resulting temperature carried over the earlier scale error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the amount of solute in moles from its mass and molar mass.

You correctly applied the van 't Hoff factor i=2i = 2 in the colligative property formula.

You recognized that the solution freezing point is obtained by subtracting ΔTf\Delta T_f from the pure solvent freezing point (0.00∘C0.00^\circ\text{C}).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unit Conversion in Molality

You divided moles of solute by 200.0 g200.0\text{ g} rather than converting the mass of water to 0.2000 kg0.2000\text{ kg}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You omitted the conversion of solvent mass from grams to kilograms when setting up molality, resulting in molality expressed in mol/g\text{mol/g} rather than standard mol/kg\text{mol/kg}. Because the cryoscopic constant KfK_f is given in units of ∘C⋅kg/mol^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol}, the kilograms in the denominator must match for proper dimensional cancellation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Molality Unit Requirement
  • Molality (m)=moles of solutemass of solvent in kilograms\text{Molality } (m) = \frac{\text{moles of solute}}{\text{mass of solvent in kilograms}}

  • Always convert solvent mass from grams to kilograms (g÷1000=kgg \div 1000 = \text{kg}) before calculating molality.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert solvent mass from grams to kilograms: 200.0 g=0.2000 kg200.0\text{ g} = 0.2000\text{ kg}.

  2. Compute molality with proper units: m=0.08408 mol0.2000 kg=0.4204 mol/kgm = \frac{0.08408\text{ mol}}{0.2000\text{ kg}} = 0.4204\text{ mol/kg}.

  3. Calculate freezing point depression: ΔTf=iKfm=2×1.86∘C⋅kg/mol×0.4204 mol/kg=1.56∘C\Delta T_f = i K_f m = 2 \times 1.86^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol} \times 0.4204\text{ mol/kg} = 1.56^\circ\text{C}.

  4. Calculate the actual freezing point: Tf=0.00∘C−1.56∘C=−1.56∘CT_f = 0.00^\circ\text{C} - 1.56^\circ\text{C} = -1.56^\circ\text{C}.

Final answer

ΔTf=1.56∘C\Delta T_f = 1.56^\circ\text{C} and Tf=−1.56∘CT_f = -1.56^\circ\text{C}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Check that units cancel dimensionally: KfK_f has kg\text{kg} in its numerator, which requires molality to have kg\text{kg} in its denominator.

  • Perform an order-of-magnitude check: a moderate amount of salt dissolved in a cup of water typically depresses freezing point by 1∘C1^\circ\text{C} to 3∘C3^\circ\text{C}, never by thousandths of a degree.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student adds the depression to the freezing point of water instead of subtracting it, repeating the misconception mentioned in the problem.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    moles KNO3=8.50101.10=0.0841 mol  ⟹  m=0.08410.2000=0.4205 m  ⟹  ΔTf=2×1.86×0.4205=0.78∘C\text{moles } \text{KNO}_3 = \frac{8.50}{101.10} = 0.0841\text{ mol} \implies m = \frac{0.0841}{0.2000} = 0.4205\text{ m} \implies \Delta T_f = 2 \times 1.86 \times 0.4205 = 0.78^\circ\text{C}

  2. Step 2

    Tf=0.00∘C+0.78∘C=+0.78∘CT_f = 0.00^\circ\text{C} + 0.78^\circ\text{C} = +0.78^\circ\text{C}

    Correct

    Tf=Tf,pure−ΔTf=0.00∘C−0.78∘C=−0.78∘CT_f = T_{f,\text{pure}} - \Delta T_f = 0.00^\circ\text{C} - 0.78^\circ\text{C} = -0.78^\circ\text{C}

    Freezing point depression describes a decrease in freezing point relative to the pure solvent. You added ΔTf\Delta T_f instead of subtracting it from 0.00∘C0.00^\circ\text{C}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the moles of KNO3\text{KNO}_3 and the molality of the aqueous solution.

You correctly applied the freezing point depression formula ΔTf=iKfm\Delta T_f = i K_f m using the ideal van 't Hoff factor i=2i = 2.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error in colligative property temperature change

You treated freezing point depression like boiling point elevation by adding the temperature difference to the reference point rather than subtracting it.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the non-negative magnitude ΔTf\Delta T_f with an upward temperature shift, rather than recognizing that solute particles disrupt crystal lattice formation and always lower the freezing point below that of pure water.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Direction of Freezing Point Shift
  • Adding a nonvolatile solute always lowers the freezing point: Tf=Tf,pure−ΔTfT_f = T_{f,\text{pure}} - \Delta T_f.

  • Always subtract ΔTf\Delta T_f from the pure solvent's freezing point, which yields a negative Celsius value for dilute aqueous solutions.

Physical Reality Check
  • An aqueous salt solution cannot freeze at a temperature warmer than pure ice (0.00∘C0.00^\circ\text{C}).

  • Before finalizing, check that Tf<0.00∘CT_f < 0.00^\circ\text{C} for aqueous solutions.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall that freezing point depression means the solution freezes at a lower temperature than pure water: Tf=Tf,pure−ΔTfT_f = T_{f,\text{pure}} - \Delta T_f.

  2. Substitute Tf,pure=0.00∘CT_{f,\text{pure}} = 0.00^\circ\text{C} and ΔTf=0.78∘C\Delta T_f = 0.78^\circ\text{C}: Tf=0.00∘C−0.78∘C=−0.78∘CT_f = 0.00^\circ\text{C} - 0.78^\circ\text{C} = -0.78^\circ\text{C}.

Final answer

ΔTf=0.78∘C\Delta T_f = 0.78^\circ\text{C}; actual freezing point Tf=−0.78∘CT_f = -0.78^\circ\text{C}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Contrast the signs of colligative changes: boiling point increases (Tb=Tb,pure+ΔTbT_b = T_{b,\text{pure}} + \Delta T_b), while freezing point decreases (Tf=Tf,pure−ΔTfT_f = T_{f,\text{pure}} - \Delta T_f).

  • Practice with non-aqueous solvents (like cyclohexane or benzene) where Tf,pure≠0∘CT_{f,\text{pure}} \neq 0^\circ\text{C} to reinforce the subtraction rule.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Calculate the freezing point depression (ΔTf\Delta T_f) and freezing point (TfT_f) of an aqueous solution containing 0.250 mol0.250\text{ mol} of calcium chloride (CaClX2\ce{CaCl2}) dissolved in 1.00 kg1.00\text{ kg} of water. Assume ideal dissociation (Kf=1.86∘C⋅kg/molK_f = 1.86^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol}).

Answer

ΔTf=1.40∘C\Delta T_f = 1.40^\circ\text{C} and Tf=−1.40∘CT_f = -1.40^\circ\text{C}. For CaClX2\ce{CaCl2}, i=3i = 3 (one CaX2+\ce{Ca^2+} and two ClX−\ce{Cl-}). ΔTf=(3)(1.86∘C⋅kg/mol)(0.250 mol/kg)=1.395∘C≈1.40∘C\Delta T_f = (3)(1.86^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol})(0.250\text{ mol/kg}) = 1.395^\circ\text{C} \approx 1.40^\circ\text{C}. The freezing point is 0.00∘C−1.40∘C=−1.40∘C0.00^\circ\text{C} - 1.40^\circ\text{C} = -1.40^\circ\text{C}.

02

A solution is prepared by dissolving 11.7 g11.7\text{ g} of NaCl\ce{NaCl} (molar mass 58.44 g/mol58.44\text{ g/mol}) in 500.0 g500.0\text{ g} of water. What is the expected freezing point of this solution? Assume ideal behavior (Kf=1.86∘C⋅kg/molK_f = 1.86^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol}).

Answer

Tf=−1.49∘CT_f = -1.49^\circ\text{C}. First, find moles: n=11.7 g58.44 g/mol=0.2002 moln = \frac{11.7\text{ g}}{58.44\text{ g/mol}} = 0.2002\text{ mol}. Molality m=0.2002 mol0.5000 kg=0.4004 mol/kgm = \frac{0.2002\text{ mol}}{0.5000\text{ kg}} = 0.4004\text{ mol/kg}. For NaCl\ce{NaCl}, i=2i = 2, so ΔTf=2×1.86×0.4004=1.49∘C\Delta T_f = 2 \times 1.86 \times 0.4004 = 1.49^\circ\text{C}. Thus, Tf=0.00∘C−1.49∘C=−1.49∘CT_f = 0.00^\circ\text{C} - 1.49^\circ\text{C} = -1.49^\circ\text{C}.

03

An unknown ionic compound with formula AXX2\ce{AX2} has a molar mass of 120.0 g/mol120.0\text{ g/mol}. When 6.00 g6.00\text{ g} of this compound is dissolved in 250.0 g250.0\text{ g} of water, the solution freezes at −1.12∘C-1.12^\circ\text{C}. Assuming ideal dissociation into AX2+\ce{A^2+} and 2XX−2\ce{X-} (i=3i = 3), determine whether the experimental data is consistent with this formula (Kf=1.86∘C⋅kg/molK_f = 1.86^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol}).

Answer

Yes, it is consistent. Moles of solute = 6.00 g120.0 g/mol=0.0500 mol\frac{6.00\text{ g}}{120.0\text{ g/mol}} = 0.0500\text{ mol}. Molality m=0.0500 mol0.2500 kg=0.200 mm = \frac{0.0500\text{ mol}}{0.2500\text{ kg}} = 0.200\text{ m}. With i=3i = 3, predicted ΔTf=3×1.86∘C⋅kg/mol×0.200 m=1.116∘C≈1.12∘C\Delta T_f = 3 \times 1.86^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol} \times 0.200\text{ m} = 1.116^\circ\text{C} \approx 1.12^\circ\text{C}, yielding Tf=−1.12∘CT_f = -1.12^\circ\text{C}, which matches the observation.

Loading workspace…