Resources
A student analyzes the following reaction: .
Because oxygen gas is released rapidly with effervescence, the student initially classifies the reaction as 'combustion'.
(a) Explain the fundamental conceptual error in classifying this reaction as combustion, and state the correct classification (decomposition vs. combustion). (b) Assign the oxidation number of oxygen in , , and , and identify the specific redox sub-classification (disproportionation or synproportionation) that describes this decomposition.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Combustion requires rapid oxidation of a fuel substance by an external oxidizing agent (typically as a reactant), whereas here a single substance breaks down into two simpler products; the correct classification is decomposition. (b) Oxidation state of is in , in , and in ; because the same element is simultaneously oxidized and reduced, it is a disproportionation reaction.
Steps
Part (a): Classifying the Reaction
-
Identifying the Error:
- Combustion is an exothermic redox reaction in which a fuel reacts with an oxidant (most commonly molecular oxygen, ) to form oxidized products. In a combustion reaction, is a reactant, not a product.
- Observing vigorous bubbling or the rapid evolution of does not signify combustion; rather, gas evolution simply indicates that a gaseous product is forming rapidly.
-
Correct Classification:
- The general form of the given chemical equation is:
- A single compound () breaks down into two simpler substances ( and ). This matches the general template .
- Therefore, the correct fundamental classification is a decomposition reaction.
Part (b): Oxidation Numbers and Redox Sub-Classification
-
Assigning Oxidation Numbers for Oxygen:
- In (hydrogen peroxide): Hydrogen bonded to a nonmetal has an oxidation state of . For the neutral molecule : (Peroxides contain an single bond, giving oxygen an oxidation state of instead of the usual .)
- In (water): Hydrogen has an oxidation state of . For the neutral molecule :
- In (elemental oxygen gas): Elements in their standard elemental form always have an oxidation state of .
-
Identifying the Redox Sub-Classification:
- Oxygen begins with an oxidation state of in .
- A portion of the oxygen atoms decreases in oxidation number from to (in ), representing reduction.
- Another portion of the oxygen atoms increases in oxidation number from to (in ), representing oxidation.
- When the same element in a single reactant undergoes both oxidation and reduction simultaneously to yield products in different oxidation states, the reaction is specifically classified as a disproportionation (or dismutation) reaction. (In contrast, synproportionation is the reverse process, where two different oxidation states of the same element combine to form an intermediate oxidation state).
Typical errors
01 The student misassigns the typical -2 oxidation state to oxygen in hydrogen peroxide instead of recognizing the peroxide -1 state, leading to an incorrect redox conclusion.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Combustion requires reacting with , but is produced here. Correct classification: decomposition
- Step 2
Oxidation numbers of : , ,
CorrectIn , ; in , ; in ,
You assigned oxygen an oxidation number of in . In peroxides, each oxygen atom is bonded to another oxygen atom, giving oxygen an oxidation number of because .
- Step 3
is oxidized from to , so this is simple oxidation rather than disproportionation.
CorrectOxygen is oxidized from to in and reduced from to in ; therefore, the reaction is a disproportionation reaction.
Because of the misassigned oxidation state in hydrogen peroxide, you did not observe the simultaneous reduction of oxygen from to , leading to an incorrect redox sub-classification.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly distinguished combustion from decomposition based on whether acts as a reactant or a product.
You correctly assigned oxidation states to oxygen in elemental () and in ().
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisDefaulting to oxygen's usual oxidation state without checking the chemical formula and structure of peroxides (), where oxygen has an oxidation state of .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Peroxide Oxidation State Rule
In standard oxides, oxygen is . In peroxides containing the single bond (such as and ), oxygen has an oxidation state of .
Set up the algebraic sum of oxidation states: for , .
- Identifying Disproportionation
A disproportionation reaction occurs when atoms of the same element in a single oxidation state are simultaneously oxidized to a higher state and reduced to a lower state.
Compare the initial oxidation state of the element in the reactant against all product species containing that element.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDetermine the oxidation state of in : with , .
Track the change in oxidation number: goes from to in (oxidation) and from to in (reduction).
Classify the redox process: because the same element undergoes simultaneous oxidation and reduction from a single reactant state, it is disproportionation.
(a) Decomposition (combustion requires as a reactant); (b) Oxidation numbers of : in , in , and in . The reaction is a disproportionation reaction.
02 The student confuses disproportionation with synproportionation, incorrectly identifying the breakdown of an intermediate oxidation state as synproportionation.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Combustion must consume as a reactant rather than produce it. Correct classification: decomposition
- Step 2
Oxidation number of in : Oxidation number of in : Oxidation number of in :
- Step 3
Since oxygen changes into two different oxidation states, it is synproportionation.
CorrectBecause oxygen starts in a single intermediate oxidation state () and simultaneously oxidizes to and reduces to , the reaction is a disproportionation reaction.
You reversed the definitions of disproportionation and synproportionation. When a single element splits from one intermediate oxidation state into two different oxidation states, it is called disproportionation (or dismutation). Synproportionation (or comproportionation) is the reverse process, where two different oxidation states combine into a single intermediate state.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou clearly explained why producing does not make a reaction combustion.
You properly identified the overall reaction as a decomposition.
You accurately found the oxidation numbers of oxygen in hydrogen peroxide, water, and diatomic oxygen.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou mixed up the prefixes 'dis-' (apart/splitting) and 'syn-' (together/combining) in redox classifications.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Disproportionation vs. Synproportionation
Disproportionation means one oxidation state splits ('dis-') into two different oxidation states: . Synproportionation (comproportionation) means two different oxidation states combine ('syn-') into one intermediate state: .
Check whether the element begins as one oxidation state that branches out (disproportionation) or begins in two different states that merge into one (synproportionation).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the initial oxidation state: oxygen in is .
Observe that part of the oxygen is oxidized to in and part is reduced to in .
Because one initial state splits into higher and lower states, name the process disproportionation.
(a) Combustion requires as a reactant rather than a product; the reaction is a decomposition. (b) The oxidation state of is in , in , and in ; the redox sub-classification is disproportionation.
Lock it in
What is the oxidation number of oxygen in peroxides such as and ?
. In peroxides containing the linkage, hydrogen or group 1 metals retain their state, forcing each oxygen to be .
Similar question
Assign the oxidation number of chlorine in each species and classify the redox reaction: .
Answer
Chlorine is in , in , and in . Because chlorine is simultaneously oxidized () and reduced (), this is a disproportionation reaction.
In the reaction , assign the oxidation numbers of bromine in reactants and products, and identify whether this is disproportionation or synproportionation.
Answer
Bromine is in , in , and in . Two different oxidation states ( and ) react to yield a single intermediate state (), so this is a synproportionation (or comproportionation) reaction.
Potassium superoxide, , reacts with carbon dioxide to regenerate oxygen in closed breathing systems: . Determine the oxidation number of oxygen in each oxygen-containing species and explain whether oxygen undergoes disproportionation.
Answer
Oxygen is in , in and , and in . The superoxide oxygen () is both oxidized to in and reduced to in ; therefore, oxygen undergoes disproportionation.