Resources

Consider the neutral third-period elements magnesium (Z=12Z = 12) and aluminum (Z=13Z = 13). Rather than comparing atomic radius, determine the exact ratio of the effective nuclear charge felt by a valence 3p3p electron in aluminum to that felt by a valence 3s3s electron in magnesium, using Slater's rules to calculate Zeff=Z−SZ_{\text{eff}} = Z - S. Express the ratio Zeff(Al,3p)Zeff(Mg,3s)\frac{Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Al}, 3p)}{Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Mg}, 3s)} as a simplified fraction and as a decimal rounded to three significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Zeff(Al,3p)Zeff(Mg,3s)=3.502.85=7057≈1.23\frac{Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Al}, 3p)}{Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Mg}, 3s)} = \frac{3.50}{2.85} = \frac{70}{57} \approx 1.23

Steps

01

State Slater's Rules for ss and pp Electrons

Effective nuclear charge is defined by: Zeff=Z−SZ_{\text{eff}} = Z - S where ZZ is the atomic number (nuclear charge) and SS is the shielding constant.

According to Slater's rules, the electron configuration is grouped in order of increasing principal quantum number: (1s)(2s,2p)(3s,3p)(3d)(4s,4p)…(1s)(2s, 2p)(3s, 3p)(3d)(4s, 4p)\dots

For an electron in an [ns,np][ns, np] group:

  • Each other electron in the same [ns,np][ns, np] group contributes 0.350.35 to SS.
  • Each electron in the (n−1)(n-1) shell contributes 0.850.85 to SS.
  • Each electron in deeper shells ((n−2)(n-2) and lower) contributes 1.001.00 to SS.

02

Calculate ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} for Magnesium (Mg\ce{Mg}, Z=12Z = 12)

Write the grouped electron configuration: Mg:(1s)2(2s,2p)8(3s)2\ce{Mg}: (1s)^2 (2s, 2p)^8 (3s)^2

To evaluate the shielding felt by one of the valence 3s3s electrons:

  • Same group (n=3n = 3): There is 11 remaining electron in the (3s,3p)(3s, 3p) group: 1×0.35=0.351 \times 0.35 = 0.35
  • (n−1)(n - 1) shell (n=2n = 2): There are 88 electrons in (2s,2p)(2s, 2p): 8×0.85=6.808 \times 0.85 = 6.80
  • (n−2)(n - 2) shell (n=1n = 1): There are 22 electrons in (1s)(1s): 2×1.00=2.002 \times 1.00 = 2.00

Summing these contributions gives the total shielding constant: S(Mg)=0.35+6.80+2.00=9.15S(\text{Mg}) = 0.35 + 6.80 + 2.00 = 9.15

Calculate ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}: Zeff(Mg,3s)=12−9.15=2.85Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Mg}, 3s) = 12 - 9.15 = 2.85


03

Calculate ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} for Aluminum (Al\ce{Al}, Z=13Z = 13)

Write the grouped electron configuration: Al:(1s)2(2s,2p)8(3s,3p)3\ce{Al}: (1s)^2 (2s, 2p)^8 (3s, 3p)^3

To evaluate the shielding felt by one valence 3p3p electron:

  • Same group (n=3n = 3): There are 22 remaining electrons in the (3s,3p)(3s, 3p) group: 2×0.35=0.702 \times 0.35 = 0.70
  • (n−1)(n - 1) shell (n=2n = 2): There are 88 electrons in (2s,2p)(2s, 2p): 8×0.85=6.808 \times 0.85 = 6.80
  • (n−2)(n - 2) shell (n=1n = 1): There are 22 electrons in (1s)(1s): 2×1.00=2.002 \times 1.00 = 2.00

Summing these contributions gives the total shielding constant: S(Al)=0.70+6.80+2.00=9.50S(\text{Al}) = 0.70 + 6.80 + 2.00 = 9.50

Calculate ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}: Zeff(Al,3p)=13−9.50=3.50Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Al}, 3p) = 13 - 9.50 = 3.50


04

Determine the Ratio

Set up the ratio of the effective nuclear charge of the valence electron in aluminum to that in magnesium: Zeff(Al,3p)Zeff(Mg,3s)=3.502.85\frac{Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Al}, 3p)}{Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Mg}, 3s)} = \frac{3.50}{2.85}

Multiply the numerator and denominator by 100100 to eliminate decimals, then simplify: 350285=350÷5285÷5=7057\frac{350}{285} = \frac{350 \div 5}{285 \div 5} = \frac{70}{57}

Converting to a decimal rounded to three significant figures: 7057≈1.23\frac{70}{57} \approx 1.23

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student includes all electrons in the valence shell rather than subtracting one to exclude the electron under consideration.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Mg\ce{Mg}: (1s)^2 (2s, 2p)^8 (3s)^2   ⟹  \implies S(Mg\text{Mg}) = 2(0.35) + 8(0.85) + 2(1.00) = 9.50   ⟹  \implies Z_{eff\text{eff}}(Mg\text{Mg}) = 12 - 9.50 = 2.50_

    Correct

    Mg\ce{Mg}: (1s)^2 (2s, 2p)^8 (3s)^2   ⟹  \implies S(Mg\text{Mg}) = 1(0.35) + 8(0.85) + 2(1.00) = 9.15   ⟹  \implies Z_{eff\text{eff}}(Mg\text{Mg}) = 12 - 9.15 = 2.85_

    An electron cannot shield itself. When evaluating the shielding felt by one 3s3s electron in magnesium, only the remaining 2−1=12 - 1 = 1 electron in the (3s,3p)(3s, 3p) group contributes 0.350.35, giving S=9.15S = 9.15 and Zeff=2.85Z_{\text{eff}} = 2.85.

  2. Step 2

    Al\ce{Al}: (1s)^2 (2s, 2p)^8 (3s, 3p)^3   ⟹  \implies S(Al\text{Al}) = 3(0.35) + 8(0.85) + 2(1.00) = 9.85   ⟹  \implies Z_{eff\text{eff}}(Al\text{Al}) = 13 - 9.85 = 3.15_

    Correct

    Al\ce{Al}: (1s)^2 (2s, 2p)^8 (3s, 3p)^3   ⟹  \implies S(Al\text{Al}) = 2(0.35) + 8(0.85) + 2(1.00) = 9.50   ⟹  \implies Z_{eff\text{eff}}(Al\text{Al}) = 13 - 9.50 = 3.50_

    Similarly for aluminum, out of the 33 electrons in the (3s,3p)(3s, 3p) group, excluding the target 3p3p electron leaves 3−1=23 - 1 = 2 electrons contributing 0.350.35 each, giving S=9.50S = 9.50 and Zeff=3.50Z_{\text{eff}} = 3.50.

  3. Step 3

    Ratio\text{Ratio} = 3.152.50\frac{3.15}{2.50} = 6350\frac{63}{50} = 1.26

    Correct

    Ratio=3.502.85=7057≈1.23\text{Ratio} = \frac{3.50}{2.85} = \frac{70}{57} \approx 1.23

    Your fraction simplification and decimal evaluation followed correctly from your values, but the ratio was affected by the self-shielding error in the previous steps.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly wrote the grouped electron configurations for both magnesium and aluminum according to Slater's rules.

You correctly applied the core shielding factors of 0.850.85 for the (n−1)(n-1) shell and 1.001.00 for the (n−2)(n-2) shell.

You correctly set up the final ratio as a simplified fraction and decimal.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Slater's Rules Self-Shielding Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You forgot to exclude the reference electron from the valence group count, effectively allowing an electron to shield itself. Under Slater's rules, only the other electrons in the same group contribute 0.350.35 to the shielding constant SS.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Exclude the Reference Electron
  • An electron never shields itself: in any group with kk electrons, exactly (k−1)(k - 1) other electrons provide shielding.

  • Before multiplying by 0.350.35, write down (k−1)(k - 1) explicitly for the same-group contribution.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. For Mg\ce{Mg}, exclude the target 3s3s electron: S=(2−1)(0.35)+8(0.85)+2(1.00)=0.35+6.80+2.00=9.15S = (2 - 1)(0.35) + 8(0.85) + 2(1.00) = 0.35 + 6.80 + 2.00 = 9.15.

  2. Calculate Zeff(Mg)=12−9.15=2.85Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{Mg}) = 12 - 9.15 = 2.85.

  3. For Al\ce{Al}, exclude the target 3p3p electron: S=(3−1)(0.35)+8(0.85)+2(1.00)=0.70+6.80+2.00=9.50S = (3 - 1)(0.35) + 8(0.85) + 2(1.00) = 0.70 + 6.80 + 2.00 = 9.50.

  4. Calculate Zeff(Al)=13−9.50=3.50Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{Al}) = 13 - 9.50 = 3.50.

  5. Compute the ratio: Zeff(Al)Zeff(Mg)=3.502.85=350285=7057≈1.23\frac{Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{Al})}{Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{Mg})} = \frac{3.50}{2.85} = \frac{350}{285} = \frac{70}{57} \approx 1.23.

Final answer

7057≈1.23\frac{70}{57} \approx 1.23

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out (k−1)(k - 1) for the same shell to ensure you do not count the electron under consideration.

  • Review how effective nuclear charge increases across a period: each added valence proton is shielded by only 0.350.35 from the extra electron, so ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} increases by 0.650.65 per step across a period.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student groups 3s and 3p into separate groups, treating the 3s² electrons in aluminum as (n-1) electrons shielding the 3p electron with factor 0.85 instead of 0.35.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Mg:(1s)2(2s,2p)8(3s)2  ⟹  S(Mg)=1(0.35)+8(0.85)+2(1.00)=0.35+6.80+2.00=9.15  ⟹  Zeff(Mg)=12−9.15=2.85\ce{Mg}: (1s)^2 (2s, 2p)^8 (3s)^2 \implies S(\ce{Mg}) = 1(0.35) + 8(0.85) + 2(1.00) = 0.35 + 6.80 + 2.00 = 9.15 \implies Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{Mg}) = 12 - 9.15 = 2.85

  2. Step 2

    Al:(1s)2(2s,2p)8(3s)2(3p)1  ⟹  S(Al)=0(0.35)+(8+2)(0.85)+2(1.00)=8.50+2.00=10.50  ⟹  Zeff(Al)=13−10.50=2.50\ce{Al}: (1s)^2 (2s, 2p)^8 (3s)^2 (3p)^1 \implies S(\ce{Al}) = 0(0.35) + (8+2)(0.85) + 2(1.00) = 8.50 + 2.00 = 10.50 \implies Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{Al}) = 13 - 10.50 = 2.50

    Correct

    Al:(1s)2(2s,2p)8(3s,3p)3  ⟹  S(Al)=2(0.35)+8(0.85)+2(1.00)=0.70+6.80+2.00=9.50  ⟹  Zeff(Al,3p)=13−9.50=3.50\ce{Al}: (1s)^2 (2s, 2p)^8 (3s, 3p)^3 \implies S(\ce{Al}) = 2(0.35) + 8(0.85) + 2(1.00) = 0.70 + 6.80 + 2.00 = 9.50 \implies Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{Al}, 3p) = 13 - 9.50 = 3.50

    Slater's rules require grouping ss and pp subshells of the same shell together as (ns,np)(ns, np). In aluminum, the valence group is (3s,3p)3(3s, 3p)^3. Therefore, the two 3s3s electrons are in the same group as the target 3p3p electron and contribute 0.350.35 each to shielding, not (n−1)(n-1) shielding of 0.850.85.

  3. Step 3

    Ratio=2.502.85=5057≈0.877\text{Ratio} = \frac{2.50}{2.85} = \frac{50}{57} \approx 0.877

    Correct

    Zeff(Al,3p)Zeff(Mg,3s)=3.502.85=7057≈1.23\frac{Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{Al}, 3p)}{Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{Mg}, 3s)} = \frac{3.50}{2.85} = \frac{70}{57} \approx 1.23

    Your ratio setup and simplification were algebraically consistent with your earlier value, but the result is affected by the incorrect ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} for aluminum.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly wrote the electron configurations and applied Slater's shielding factors for magnesium.

You accurately calculated the shielding contributions from the (n−1)(n-1) and (n−2)(n-2) shells.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Slater's Rules Subshell Grouping Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You split the n=3n=3 shell into separate (3s)(3s) and (3p)(3p) groups instead of combining them into a single (3s,3p)(3s, 3p) group, incorrectly treating the 3s3s electrons as inner-shell (n−1)(n-1) electrons rather than same-shell peers.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Group $(ns, np)$ Together
  • In Slater's rules, all electrons with the same principal quantum number nn in ss and pp subshells belong to the same group: (ns,np)(ns, np). Orbitals with dd and ff form their own isolated groups like (nd)(nd) and (nf)(nf).

  • Write electron configurations using parentheses around combined groups: (1s)(2s,2p)(3s,3p)(3d)…(1s)(2s, 2p)(3s, 3p)(3d)\dots before counting electrons.

Identify Same-Group Shielding
  • Every other electron in the same (ns,np)(ns, np) group shields the test electron with a factor of 0.350.35 (or 0.300.30 if the test electron is in 1s1s).

  • Subtract 11 from the total electrons in the target (ns,np)(ns, np) group, then multiply the remaining number of electrons by 0.350.35.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Group aluminum's configuration properly: Al:(1s)2(2s,2p)8(3s,3p)3\ce{Al}: (1s)^2 (2s, 2p)^8 (3s, 3p)^3.

  2. Calculate the shielding constant for one 3p3p electron: S(Al)=2(0.35)+8(0.85)+2(1.00)=0.70+6.80+2.00=9.50S(\ce{Al}) = 2(0.35) + 8(0.85) + 2(1.00) = 0.70 + 6.80 + 2.00 = 9.50.

  3. Calculate Zeff(Al,3p)=13−9.50=3.50Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{Al}, 3p) = 13 - 9.50 = 3.50.

  4. Evaluate the ratio: Zeff(Al,3p)Zeff(Mg,3s)=3.502.85=7057≈1.23\frac{Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{Al}, 3p)}{Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{Mg}, 3s)} = \frac{3.50}{2.85} = \frac{70}{57} \approx 1.23.

Final answer

7057≈1.23\frac{70}{57} \approx 1.23

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how Slater's rules group atomic subshells, paying close attention to why (ns,np)(ns, np) are always grouped together.

  • Recalculate ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} for elements with partially filled pp subshells like silicon and phosphorus to solidify this grouping rule.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student computes the inverse ratio of effective nuclear charge of Mg to Al instead of Al to Mg.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Mg:(1s)2(2s,2p)8(3s)2  ⟹  S(Mg)=1(0.35)+8(0.85)+2(1.00)=9.15  ⟹  Zeff(Mg,3s)=12−9.15=2.85\text{Mg}: (1s)^2 (2s, 2p)^8 (3s)^2 \implies S(\text{Mg}) = 1(0.35) + 8(0.85) + 2(1.00) = 9.15 \implies Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Mg}, 3s) = 12 - 9.15 = 2.85

  2. Step 2

    Al:(1s)2(2s,2p)8(3s,3p)3  ⟹  S(Al)=2(0.35)+8(0.85)+2(1.00)=9.50  ⟹  Zeff(Al,3p)=13−9.50=3.50\text{Al}: (1s)^2 (2s, 2p)^8 (3s, 3p)^3 \implies S(\text{Al}) = 2(0.35) + 8(0.85) + 2(1.00) = 9.50 \implies Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Al}, 3p) = 13 - 9.50 = 3.50

  3. Step 3

    Ratio=Zeff(Mg,3s)Zeff(Al,3p)=2.853.50=5770≈0.814\text{Ratio} = \frac{Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Mg}, 3s)}{Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Al}, 3p)} = \frac{2.85}{3.50} = \frac{57}{70} \approx 0.814

    Correct

    Zeff(Al,3p)Zeff(Mg,3s)=3.502.85=7057≈1.23\frac{Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Al}, 3p)}{Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Mg}, 3s)} = \frac{3.50}{2.85} = \frac{70}{57} \approx 1.23

    You set up the inverse ratio. The question asked for the ratio of the effective nuclear charge of Al\ce{Al} to that of Mg\ce{Mg}, meaning Zeff(Al,3p)Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Al}, 3p) must be in the numerator.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You grouped the atomic orbitals correctly according to Slater's rules.

You applied the exact shielding weights (0.350.35 for the same group, 0.850.85 for the n−1n-1 shell, and 1.001.00 for core shells).

You accurately subtracted the total shielding constant from the atomic number for each element.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted target ratio

You set up the ratio as MgAl\frac{\text{Mg}}{\text{Al}} rather than AlMg\frac{\text{Al}}{\text{Mg}}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Misreading the requested target direction in the phrase 'ratio of A to B', which maps mathematically to AB\frac{A}{B}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Parsing 'Ratio of A to B'
  • The verbal expression 'ratio of AA to BB' universally defines the quotient AB\frac{A}{B}, where the first quantity named is the numerator.

  • Always write out the algebraic expression directly matching the prompt's explicit formula Zeff(Al,3p)Zeff(Mg,3s)\frac{Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Al}, 3p)}{Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Mg}, 3s)} before substituting values.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Place the aluminum value in the numerator and magnesium in the denominator: Zeff(Al,3p)Zeff(Mg,3s)=3.502.85\frac{Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Al}, 3p)}{Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Mg}, 3s)} = \frac{3.50}{2.85}.

  2. Multiply both numerator and denominator by 100100 and divide by 55: 350285=7057\frac{350}{285} = \frac{70}{57}.

  3. Convert to decimal to three significant figures: 7057≈1.23\frac{70}{57} \approx 1.23.

Final answer

7057≈1.23\frac{70}{57} \approx 1.23

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that the numerator matches the first term in 'ratio of A to B' before simplifying.

  • Check that periodic trends match intuition: effective nuclear charge increases across a period, so Zeff(Al)Zeff(Mg)\frac{Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Al})}{Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Mg})} should be greater than 11.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Using Slater's rules, calculate the effective nuclear charge ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} felt by a valence 2p2p electron in a neutral fluorine atom (Z=9Z = 9).

Answer

Zeff=5.20Z_{\text{eff}} = 5.20. Electron configuration: (1s)2(2s,2p)7(1s)^2(2s, 2p)^7. The reference 2p2p electron is shielded by (7−1)=6(7 - 1) = 6 electrons in the n=2n = 2 group and 22 electrons in n=1n = 1. Total S=6(0.35)+2(0.85)=2.10+1.70=3.80S = 6(0.35) + 2(0.85) = 2.10 + 1.70 = 3.80. Therefore, Zeff=9−3.80=5.20Z_{\text{eff}} = 9 - 3.80 = 5.20.

02

Using Slater's rules, calculate ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} for a 4s4s valence electron in neutral potassium (Z=19Z = 19).

Answer

Zeff=2.20Z_{\text{eff}} = 2.20. Grouping: (1s)2(2s,2p)8(3s,3p)8(4s)1(1s)^2(2s, 2p)^8(3s, 3p)^8(4s)^1. For the single 4s4s electron, there are 00 other electrons in the same group: 0(0.35)=00(0.35) = 0. The (n−1)(n-1) shell has 88 electrons: 8(0.85)=6.808(0.85) = 6.80. The deeper shells have 1010 electrons: 10(1.00)=10.0010(1.00) = 10.00. Total S=6.80+10.00=16.80S = 6.80 + 10.00 = 16.80. Thus, Zeff=19−16.80=2.20Z_{\text{eff}} = 19 - 16.80 = 2.20.

03

Compare the effective nuclear charges felt by a 3d3d electron and a 4s4s electron in neutral zinc (Z=30Z = 30). Which electron experiences a higher ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}?

Answer

The 3d3d electron experiences a higher ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} (8.858.85 vs. 4.354.35). For 4s4s: (1s)2(2s,2p)8(3s,3p)8(3d)10(4s)2  ⟹  S=1(0.35)+18(0.85)+10(1.00)=25.65  ⟹  Zeff=30−25.65=4.35(1s)^2(2s, 2p)^8(3s, 3p)^8(3d)^{10}(4s)^2 \implies S = 1(0.35) + 18(0.85) + 10(1.00) = 25.65 \implies Z_{\text{eff}} = 30 - 25.65 = 4.35. For 3d3d: grouping (3d)10(3d)^{10} has (10−1)=9(10 - 1) = 9 same-group electrons contributing 0.350.35 and all 1818 inner electrons contributing 1.001.00 each: S=9(0.35)+18(1.00)=3.15+18.00=21.15  ⟹  Zeff=30−21.15=8.85S = 9(0.35) + 18(1.00) = 3.15 + 18.00 = 21.15 \implies Z_{\text{eff}} = 30 - 21.15 = 8.85.

Loading workspace…