Resources
A student proposes the hypothesis: 'Diluting a weak acid solution with pure water always shifts the system to decrease ionization because the concentrations of all aqueous species decrease.' To evaluate this model, an experimenter prepares a solution of nitrous acid (, at ) and dilutes a portion tenfold with pure deionized water to a final analytical concentration of . Calculate the percent ionization of in both the and solutions (using the quadratic formula where appropriate). Evaluate whether the experimental data support or contradict the student's hypothesis, and explain the shift using the reaction quotient relative to .
Answer and steps
Final answer
For : , so . For : , so . The data contradict the student's hypothesis: percent ionization increases from to . By Le Chatelier's principle, diluting by factor causes , driving a net forward shift to produce more ions.
Steps
Equilibrium Expression for Nitrous Acid
Nitrous acid () ionizes in water according to the equilibrium:
The acid-dissociation constant expression is:
Let be the equilibrium concentration of (which equals ). Setting up an ICE (Initial, Change, Equilibrium) table:
Percent Ionization in the Solution
Substitute and into the quadratic equation:
Applying the quadratic formula :
Calculate the percent ionization:
Percent Ionization in the Diluted () Solution
Substitute into the quadratic equation:
Solving for :
Calculate the percent ionization:
Evaluation of the Hypothesis and Explanation Using
- Evaluation: The experimental data contradict the student's hypothesis. When the solution is diluted tenfold, the percent ionization increases significantly from to .
-
Thermodynamic Basis ( vs. ): Immediately upon tenfold dilution (before the system re-equilibrates), the concentration of each aqueous species drops by a factor of :
Because , the reaction quotient is less than the equilibrium constant. In accordance with Le Chatelier's principle, the system must shift to the right (forward direction), ionizing a greater fraction of the weak acid molecules until equilibrium is restored ().
Typical errors
01 The student uses the 5% approximation invalidly on the dilute 0.0100 M solution where percent ionization exceeds 5%, underestimating the equilibrium concentration and percent ionization.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You assumed , but dilution increases percent ionization well above the validity threshold. Neglecting in the denominator leads to an overestimation of as () rather than the true quadratic solution of ().
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly set up the acid-dissociation equilibrium expressions for both concentrations.
You recognized the need for the quadratic formula on the initial solution and solved it accurately.
You clearly expressed the reaction quotient upon tenfold dilution as and deduced the correct equilibrium shift.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou relied on the simplified expression without verifying whether the small- approximation () held, overlooking that weak acids ionize to a much greater percentage at lower analytical concentrations.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- 5% Rule Validation
The approximation is valid if and only if (or roughly ).
Before finalizing , divide by . If the value exceeds , solve the full quadratic equation .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet up the exact equilibrium expression: .
Rearrange into standard quadratic form: .
Apply the quadratic formula: .
Calculate percent ionization: .
ionization for
02 The student misinterprets Q by failing to square the dilution factor in the numerator, concluding Q = Ka and erroneously stating the hypothesis is contradicted with no shift.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
The experimental data contradict the student's hypothesis because percent ionization increased from to .
- Step 4
Because , dilution does not shift the equilibrium position.
CorrectBecause , the system shifts forward (to the right), increasing ionization.
You treated the products as a single concentration term scaled by , but dissociation produces two aqueous ions: and . Each ion's concentration drops tenfold, scaling the numerator by , while the denominator drops by . This gives , driving a forward shift.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly set up and solved the quadratic equations for both solution concentrations.
You accurately calculated both percent ionizations ( and ).
You correctly deduced that the experimental results contradict the hypothesis.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou factored out a single for the numerator instead of applying the dilution factor to each separate product ion.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing overall stoichiometry with individual species concentrations in the reaction quotient expression. Because the dissociation produces two dissolved particles from one, diluting by a factor of reduces the numerator by and the denominator by , making .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Count the Aqueous Particles on Each Side
For a reaction , diluting by a factor of changes each concentration by , so .
Always write out each individual ion in the numerator of before substituting dilution factors.
- Reconcile Thermodynamic Quotient with Empirical Finding
If your calculated percent ionization increases from to , the equilibrium must shift to the product side, which requires .
Check that your theoretical vs. prediction agrees with your empirical percent ionization comparison.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the explicit quotient expression immediately after a tenfold dilution: .
Simplify the dilution factors: .
Compare to : since , the forward reaction is favored to re-establish equilibrium, producing more ions and increasing the percent ionization.
The data contradict the hypothesis because percent ionization increases from to . Immediately upon tenfold dilution, , which drives a net forward shift toward the side with more aqueous particles.
03 The student confuses the decrease in absolute [H+] with a decrease in percent ionization, claiming the data support the hypothesis.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
The experimental data contradict the student's hypothesis because percent ionization increased from to .
You tracked the decrease in the molar concentration , but 'extent of ionization' refers to the fraction or percentage of acid molecules that dissociate. Because percent ionization increased from to , the experimental data contradict the hypothesis.
- Step 4
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou set up and solved both quadratic equilibrium equations with complete mathematical accuracy.
You calculated the percent ionization for both concentrations correctly.
You correctly derived upon tenfold dilution and identified that the forward shift restores equilibrium.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated the absolute equilibrium concentration of hydronium ions, , with the degree or percent ionization of the weak acid. Although dilution lowers all absolute concentrations due to the increased volume, it shifts the equilibrium toward the side with more moles of aqueous particles, thereby ionizing a larger fraction of the remaining acid molecules.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distinguish $[\ce{H+}]$ from Percent Ionization
Diluting a weak acid always decreases absolute (raising ), but it always increases the percent ionization ().
When evaluating whether ionization increased or decreased upon dilution, compare the calculated percent ionizations rather than the molar concentrations.
- Reconcile Thermodynamic Shift with Model Claims
If , the system shifts forward (right), converting additional undissociated acid into ions.
Check that your qualitative verdict matches your analysis: a forward shift directly contradicts any claim that ionization decreased.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the two calculated percent ionization values: and .
Observe that a greater percentage of molecules ionize in the more dilute solution ().
Conclude that the experimental data contradict the student's hypothesis because dilution increases, rather than decreases, the percent ionization.
The experimental data contradict the hypothesis because percent ionization increases from to upon dilution; because , the system shifts forward to ionize a greater fraction of acid.
Lock it in
When is the small- approximation () mathematically valid for a weak acid equilibrium?
Only when percent ionization is (or approximately when ). If ionization exceeds , you must solve the quadratic equation.
Similar question
A solution of chloroacetic acid (, ) is prepared. Determine whether the approximation is valid, and calculate its equilibrium and percent ionization.
Answer
, so the approximation is invalid. Quadratic equation: . Using the quadratic formula, . Percent ionization .
An experimenter has a solution of formic acid (, ) with percent ionization . If the solution is diluted to , calculate the new percent ionization using the appropriate method.
Answer
For , , requiring the quadratic formula: . Solving yields . Percent ionization .
Explain using reaction quotient why diluting a weak base with water by a factor of 2 increases its percent protonation at equilibrium.
Answer
Immediately upon doubling the volume, every solute concentration is halved: . Because , Le Chatelier's principle dictates a net forward shift to regenerate products, thereby ionizing/protonating a larger percentage of the original base.