Resources

Nuclear stability for light elements (Z≤20Z \le 20) is typically achieved when the neutron-to-proton ratio satisfies N/Z≈1.0N/Z \approx 1.0, whereas beta-minus (β−\beta^-) emission is favored when N/ZN/Z exceeds the stability boundary. Consider carbon-14 (614C^{14}_{6}\text{C}) and carbon-11 (611C^{11}_{6}\text{C}). Determine the exact N/ZN/Z ratio for both nuclides, identify which nuclide undergoes beta-minus (β−\beta^-) decay to alleviate neutron excess, and specify the daughter nuclide formed in that decay.

Answer and steps

Final answer

For 614C^{14}_{6}\text{C}, N/Z=86≈1.33N/Z = \frac{8}{6} \approx 1.33; for 611C^{11}_{6}\text{C}, N/Z=56≈0.833N/Z = \frac{5}{6} \approx 0.833. The nuclide with neutron excess that undergoes β−\beta^- decay is 614C^{14}_{6}\text{C}, yielding the stable daughter nuclide nitrogen-14 (714N^{14}_{7}\text{N}).

Steps

01

Calculate the Neutron-to-Proton Ratio (N/ZN/Z) for Each Nuclide

For any nuclide denoted as ZAX^{A}_{Z}\ce{X}:

  • The atomic number ZZ represents the number of protons.
  • The mass number AA represents the total number of nucleons (protons + neutrons).
  • The number of neutrons is given by N=A−ZN = A - Z.

Applying this to both carbon isotopes (Z=6Z = 6):

  • For Carbon-14 (X614X26214C\ce{^{14}_{6}C}): N=14−6=8N = 14 - 6 = 8 NZ=86=43≈1.33\frac{N}{Z} = \frac{8}{6} = \frac{4}{3} \approx 1.33
  • For Carbon-11 (X611X26211C\ce{^{11}_{6}C}): N=11−6=5N = 11 - 6 = 5 NZ=56≈0.833\frac{N}{Z} = \frac{5}{6} \approx 0.833

02

Identify the Nuclide with Neutron Excess

For light elements (Z≤20Z \le 20), the belt of nuclear stability corresponds to a neutron-to-proton ratio close to 1.01.0 (N/Z≈1.0N/Z \approx 1.0):

  • X614X26214C\ce{^{14}_{6}C} has an N/ZN/Z ratio of approximately 1.331.33, which is significantly greater than 1.01.0. This nuclide lies above the band of stability and possesses an excess of neutrons.
  • X611X26211C\ce{^{11}_{6}C} has an N/ZN/Z ratio of approximately 0.830.83, lying below the band of stability (it is proton-rich or neutron-deficient).

Nuclides with a high N/ZN/Z ratio lower their neutron count and raise their proton count through beta-minus (β−\beta^-) decay. Therefore, X614X26214C\ce{^{14}_{6}C} undergoes β−\beta^- emission.


03

Determine the Daughter Nuclide

During β−\beta^- decay, a neutron inside the nucleus converts into a proton and emits an electron (beta particle, X−10X2−120e\ce{^0_{-1}e} or β−\beta^-) along with an antineutrino:

X01X2021n→X11X2121p+X−10X2−120e\ce{^1_0n -> ^1_1p + ^0_{-1}e}

Setting up the balanced nuclear decay equation for X614X26214C\ce{^{14}_{6}C}:

X614X26214C→XZdAdX2Zd2AdY+X−10X2−120e\ce{^{14}_{6}C -> ^{A_d}_{Z_d}Y + ^0_{-1}e}

Apply the fundamental conservation laws:

  1. Conservation of mass number (AA): 14=Ad+0  ⟹  Ad=1414 = A_d + 0 \implies A_d = 14
  2. Conservation of atomic number (ZZ): 6=Zd+(−1)  ⟹  Zd=76 = Z_d + (-1) \implies Z_d = 7

The element with atomic number Z=7Z = 7 is nitrogen (N\ce{N}). Thus, the daughter nuclide formed is nitrogen-14 (X714X27214N\ce{^{14}_{7}N}):

X614X26214C→X714X27214N+X−10X2−120e\ce{^{14}_{6}C -> ^{14}_{7}N + ^0_{-1}e}

(Note: In the daughter nucleus X714X27214N\ce{^{14}_{7}N}, N=14−7=7N = 14 - 7 = 7, yielding N/Z=7/7=1.0N/Z = 7/7 = 1.0, which is completely stable.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the mass number A with neutron number N, calculating the ratio as A/Z instead of N/Z.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    614C:NZ=146=73≈2.33^{14}_{6}\text{C}: \frac{N}{Z} = \frac{14}{6} = \frac{7}{3} \approx 2.33 ⟹ 611C:NZ=116≈1.83^{11}_{6}\text{C}: \frac{N}{Z} = \frac{11}{6} \approx 1.83

    Correct

    614C:N=14−6=8  ⟹  NZ=86=43≈1.33^{14}_{6}\text{C}: N = 14 - 6 = 8 \implies \frac{N}{Z} = \frac{8}{6} = \frac{4}{3} \approx 1.33 ⟹ 611C:N=11−6=5  ⟹  NZ=56≈0.833^{11}_{6}\text{C}: N = 11 - 6 = 5 \implies \frac{N}{Z} = \frac{5}{6} \approx 0.833

    You substituted the mass number AA directly into the numerator instead of subtracting atomic number ZZ to find the number of neutrons N=A−ZN = A - Z.

  2. Step 2

    614C^{14}_{6}\text{C}: undergoes beta-minus decay because 2.332.33 exceeds the stability ratio more than 1.831.83.

    Correct

    614C^{14}_{6}\text{C} undergoes β−\beta^- decay because its N/Z≈1.33N/Z \approx 1.33 exceeds the stability threshold of 1.01.0, whereas 611C^{11}_{6}\text{C} has N/Z≈0.833<1.0N/Z \approx 0.833 < 1.0.

    You correctly selected 614C^{14}_{6}\text{C}, but your reasoning was affected by the earlier calculation: 611C^{11}_{6}\text{C} is actually neutron-deficient (N/Z<1.0N/Z < 1.0), not above the stability boundary.

  3. Step 3

    714N^{14}_{7}\text{N}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified 614C^{14}_{6}\text{C} as the nuclide undergoing beta-minus decay.

You correctly applied nuclear conservation rules to deduce the daughter nuclide 714N^{14}_{7}\text{N}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing Mass Number with Neutron Number

You substituted the superscript mass number AA directly as NN without subtracting ZZ.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In nuclear notation ZAX^{A}_{Z}\text{X}, the top number AA represents total nucleons (p+np + n), not isolated neutrons. Finding NN always requires calculating N=A−ZN = A - Z before taking any ratio.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Calculate Neutron Count First
  • N=A−ZN = A - Z, where AA is the mass number and ZZ is the atomic number.

  • Always subtract the lower index from the upper index before calculating the N/ZN/Z ratio.

Evaluate Nuclear Stability
  • For light elements (Z≤20Z \le 20), N/Z>1.0N/Z > 1.0 indicates neutron excess (triggering β−\beta^- emission), while N/Z<1.0N/Z < 1.0 indicates proton excess (triggering positron emission or electron capture).

  • Compare the computed N/ZN/Z directly to 1.01.0 to determine whether the nuclide is neutron-rich or neutron-poor.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Determine the number of neutrons for each isotope: for 614C^{14}_{6}\text{C}, N=14−6=8N = 14 - 6 = 8; for 611C^{11}_{6}\text{C}, N=11−6=5N = 11 - 6 = 5.

  2. Compute the exact neutron-to-proton ratios: NZ(614C)=86=43≈1.33\frac{N}{Z}(^{14}_{6}\text{C}) = \frac{8}{6} = \frac{4}{3} \approx 1.33 and NZ(611C)=56≈0.833\frac{N}{Z}(^{11}_{6}\text{C}) = \frac{5}{6} \approx 0.833.

  3. Compare each ratio against the stability criterion N/Z≈1.0N/Z \approx 1.0: 614C^{14}_{6}\text{C} has N/Z>1.0N/Z > 1.0, indicating a neutron excess that triggers β−\beta^- decay.

  4. Write the nuclear decay equation: 614C→714N+−10e^{14}_{6}\text{C} \rightarrow ^{14}_{7}\text{N} + ^{0}_{-1}\text{e}.

Final answer

For 614C^{14}_{6}\text{C}, N/Z=43≈1.33N/Z = \frac{4}{3} \approx 1.33; for 611C^{11}_{6}\text{C}, N/Z=56≈0.833N/Z = \frac{5}{6} \approx 0.833. Carbon-14 undergoes β−\beta^- decay to yield 714N^{14}_{7}\text{N}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice extracting neutron count N=A−ZN = A - Z immediately when reading nuclide symbols.

  • Verify whether an isotope lies above (N/Z>1.0N/Z > 1.0) or below (N/Z<1.0N/Z < 1.0) the belt of stability for light elements to predict decay modes reliably.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misinterprets beta-minus decay as decreasing the atomic number by 1 instead of increasing it by 1, yielding boron instead of nitrogen.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    614C:Z=6,N=14−6=8,NZ=86=43  ⟹  611C:Z=6,N=11−6=5,NZ=56^{14}_{6}\text{C}: Z=6, N=14-6=8, \frac{N}{Z} = \frac{8}{6} = \frac{4}{3} \implies ^{11}_{6}\text{C}: Z=6, N=11-6=5, \frac{N}{Z} = \frac{5}{6}

  2. Step 2

    614C undergoes beta-minus decay because NZ=43>1.0.^{14}_{6}\text{C}\text{ undergoes beta-minus decay because }\frac{N}{Z} = \frac{4}{3} > 1.0.

  3. Step 3

    614C→514B+β−  ⟹  Daughter nuclide is boron-14 (514B).^{14}_{6}\text{C} \rightarrow ^{14}_{5}\text{B} + \beta^- \implies \text{Daughter nuclide is boron-14 }(^{14}_{5}\text{B}).

    Correct

    614C→714N+−10e  ⟹  Daughter nuclide is nitrogen-14 (714N).^{14}_{6}\text{C} \rightarrow ^{14}_{7}\text{N} + ^{0}_{-1}\text{e} \implies \text{Daughter nuclide is nitrogen-14 }(^{14}_{7}\text{N}).

    In beta-minus (β−\beta^-) decay, a neutron converts into a proton and an electron (−10e^{0}_{-1}\text{e}), so the atomic number increases by 11 (Z=6−(−1)=7Z = 6 - (-1) = 7), not decreases by 11.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the neutron-to-proton ratios for both isotopes.

You accurately identified that carbon-14 undergoes beta-minus decay because its N/ZN/Z ratio is greater than 1.01.0.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Nuclear Chemistry: Misidentified Atomic Number Change in Beta-Minus Decay

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the beta-minus particle as having a charge of +1+1 (or subtracted 11 from the parent's atomic number), which corresponds to positron emission (β+\beta^+ decay) or electron capture rather than beta-minus (β−\beta^-) decay. By charge conservation, Zparent=Zdaughter+(−1)Z_{\text{parent}} = Z_{\text{daughter}} + (-1), which requires Zdaughter=Zparent+1Z_{\text{daughter}} = Z_{\text{parent}} + 1.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Conservation of Atomic Number
  • Zparent=Zdaughter+ZemittedZ_{\text{parent}} = Z_{\text{daughter}} + Z_{\text{emitted}}

  • Substitute Zemitted=−1Z_{\text{emitted}} = -1 for a β−\beta^- particle: 6=Zd+(−1)  ⟹  Zd=76 = Z_d + (-1) \implies Z_d = 7.

Subatomic Mechanism of $\beta^-$ Decay
  • 01n→11p+−10e^{1}_{0}\text{n} \rightarrow ^{1}_{1}\text{p} + ^{0}_{-1}\text{e}

  • Remember that a neutron turns into a proton, so the proton count (atomic number) must increase by 11.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the general balance equation for β−\beta^- decay: 614C→ZdAdY+−10e^{14}_{6}\text{C} \rightarrow ^{A_d}_{Z_d}\text{Y} + ^{0}_{-1}\text{e}.

  2. Apply mass number conservation: 14=Ad+0  ⟹  Ad=1414 = A_d + 0 \implies A_d = 14.

  3. Apply atomic number conservation: 6=Zd+(−1)  ⟹  Zd=76 = Z_d + (-1) \implies Z_d = 7.

  4. Identify element Z=7Z = 7 on the periodic table, which is nitrogen (N\text{N}).

Final answer

The daughter nuclide is nitrogen-14 (714N^{14}_{7}\text{N}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out the beta particle with its full isotopic notation (−10e^{0}_{-1}\text{e} or −10β^{0}_{-1}\beta) rather than just β−\beta^- to make balancing the bottom numbers straightforward.

  • Practice balancing nuclear equations for both β−\beta^- (Z→Z+1Z \to Z+1) and β+\beta^+ (Z→Z−1Z \to Z-1) decays to reinforce their opposite effects on atomic number.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student computes the reciprocal proton-to-neutron ratio Z/N instead of the neutron-to-proton ratio N/Z and concludes carbon-11 has the excess.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    614C:N=8,Z=6,ratio=68=34=0.75  ⟹  611C:N=5,Z=6,ratio=65=1.20^{14}_{6}\text{C}: N=8, Z=6, \text{ratio} = \frac{6}{8} = \frac{3}{4} = 0.75 \implies {}^{11}_{6}\text{C}: N=5, Z=6, \text{ratio} = \frac{6}{5} = 1.20

    Correct

    For 614C^{14}_{6}\text{C}, NZ=86=43≈1.33\frac{N}{Z} = \frac{8}{6} = \frac{4}{3} \approx 1.33; for 611C^{11}_{6}\text{C}, NZ=56≈0.833\frac{N}{Z} = \frac{5}{6} \approx 0.833

    You found the correct neutron counts (N=8N = 8 and N=5N = 5) and proton counts (Z=6Z = 6), but you computed the proton-to-neutron ratio (Z/NZ/N) rather than the neutron-to-proton ratio (N/ZN/Z).

  2. Step 2

    611C^{11}_{6}\text{C} undergoes beta-minus decay because its ratio 1.201.20 exceeds 1.01.0.

    Correct

    614C^{14}_{6}\text{C} undergoes β−\beta^- decay because its N/ZN/Z ratio (1.331.33) exceeds 1.01.0.

    Because your ratio was inverted, carbon-11 appeared to exceed 1.01.0. Using the true N/ZN/Z ratios, carbon-14 has N/Z≈1.33>1.0N/Z \approx 1.33 > 1.0, meaning it possesses the neutron excess that drives β−\beta^- emission.

  3. Step 3

    611C⟶711N+β−  ⟹  Daughter nuclide is nitrogen-11 (711N)^{11}_{6}\text{C} \longrightarrow {}^{11}_{7}\text{N} + \beta^- \implies \text{Daughter nuclide is nitrogen-11 } ({}^{11}_{7}\text{N})

    Correct

    614C⟶714N+β−  ⟹  Daughter nuclide is nitrogen-14 (714N)^{14}_{6}\text{C} \longrightarrow {}^{14}_{7}\text{N} + \beta^- \implies \text{Daughter nuclide is nitrogen-14 } ({}^{14}_{7}\text{N})

    You applied the nuclear conservation laws for beta-minus decay accurately (AA remains unchanged, ZZ increases by 11), but the decay applies to 614C^{14}_{6}\text{C}, forming nitrogen-14 (714N^{14}_{7}\text{N}) rather than nitrogen-11.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the neutron count N=A−ZN = A - Z for both isotopes.

You correctly remembered that a ratio exceeding 1.01.0 signals beta-minus decay for light nuclei.

You accurately conserved mass number and increased the atomic number by 11 during beta-minus emission.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Ratio Inversion ($Z/N$ instead of $N/Z$)

You set up the fraction with the atomic number ZZ in the numerator and neutron count NN in the denominator.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Inverting the fraction definition (Z/NZ/N instead of N/ZN/Z) reverses the stability trend, making neutron-deficient nuclei appear neutron-rich and vice versa.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Fraction Placement
  • The neutron-to-proton ratio is defined as neutronsprotons=NZ\frac{\text{neutrons}}{\text{protons}} = \frac{N}{Z}, with neutrons strictly on top.

  • Always write the literal fraction NZ=A−ZZ\frac{N}{Z} = \frac{A - Z}{Z} before substituting numbers.

Sanity Check for Heavy Isotopes
  • An isotope with a larger mass number of the same element must have a higher N/ZN/Z ratio.

  • Check that 14C^{14}\text{C} has a larger ratio than 11C^{11}\text{C} before deciding which isotope is neutron-rich.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the definition: NZ=A−ZZ\frac{N}{Z} = \frac{A - Z}{Z}.

  2. Calculate for carbon-14: N=14−6=8  ⟹  NZ=86≈1.33N = 14 - 6 = 8 \implies \frac{N}{Z} = \frac{8}{6} \approx 1.33.

  3. Calculate for carbon-11: N=11−6=5  ⟹  NZ=56≈0.833N = 11 - 6 = 5 \implies \frac{N}{Z} = \frac{5}{6} \approx 0.833.

  4. Compare with 1.01.0: 614C^{14}_{6}\text{C} has NZ=1.33>1.0\frac{N}{Z} = 1.33 > 1.0, which indicates neutron excess.

  5. Write the balanced β−\beta^- decay: 614C⟶714N+−10e^{14}_{6}\text{C} \longrightarrow {}^{14}_{7}\text{N} + {}^{0}_{-1}\text{e}.

Final answer

For 614C^{14}_{6}\text{C}, N/Z=86≈1.33N/Z = \frac{8}{6} \approx 1.33; for 611C^{11}_{6}\text{C}, N/Z=56≈0.833N/Z = \frac{5}{6} \approx 0.833. The nuclide that undergoes β−\beta^- decay is 614C^{14}_{6}\text{C}, forming nitrogen-14 (714N^{14}_{7}\text{N}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the fraction order for N/ZN/Z to ensure neutrons remain in the numerator.

  • Practice identifying whether a nuclide lies above or below the band of stability.

  • Complete the follow-up drills to solidify decay mode predictions.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Calculate the neutron-to-proton ratio (N/ZN/Z) for nitrogen-16 (716N^{16}_{7}\text{N}) and determine whether it is neutron-rich compared to the light-element stability benchmark (N/Z≈1.0N/Z \approx 1.0).

Answer

N=16−7=9N = 16 - 7 = 9. The ratio is N/Z=97≈1.29N/Z = \frac{9}{7} \approx 1.29. Since 1.29>1.01.29 > 1.0, nitrogen-16 is neutron-rich and undergoes β−\beta^- decay.

02

A sodium isotope undergoes radioactive decay to achieve stability: consider sodium-24 (1124Na^{24}_{11}\text{Na}) and sodium-22 (1122Na^{22}_{11}\text{Na}). Identify which nuclide undergoes beta-minus (β−\beta^-) emission, and write the balanced nuclear equation for this decay.

Answer

For 1124Na^{24}_{11}\text{Na}, N=24−11=13  ⟹  N/Z=1311≈1.18>1.0N = 24 - 11 = 13 \implies N/Z = \frac{13}{11} \approx 1.18 > 1.0. For 1122Na^{22}_{11}\text{Na}, N=22−11=11  ⟹  N/Z=1111=1.0N = 22 - 11 = 11 \implies N/Z = \frac{11}{11} = 1.0. Therefore, 1124Na^{24}_{11}\text{Na} undergoes β−\beta^- decay: 1124Na→1224Mg+−10e^{24}_{11}\text{Na} \rightarrow ^{24}_{12}\text{Mg} + ^{0}_{-1}\text{e}.

03

Phosphorus-32 (1532P^{32}_{15}\text{P}) is a pure beta emitter used in biochemistry. Calculate its N/ZN/Z ratio, state the balanced beta-minus decay equation, and compute the N/ZN/Z ratio of the resulting daughter nuclide to show how stability improves.

Answer

For 1532P^{32}_{15}\text{P}: N=32−15=17N = 32 - 15 = 17, so N/Z=1715≈1.13N/Z = \frac{17}{15} \approx 1.13. Decay equation: 1532P→1632S+−10e^{32}_{15}\text{P} \rightarrow ^{32}_{16}\text{S} + ^{0}_{-1}\text{e}. For the daughter 1632S^{32}_{16}\text{S}: N=32−16=16N = 32 - 16 = 16, so N/Z=1616=1.00N/Z = \frac{16}{16} = 1.00, reaching ideal stability for light elements.

Loading workspace…