Resources

A rigid sealed container holds an equimolar mixture of nitrogen gas (N2\text{N}_2) and argon gas (Ar\text{Ar}) at an initial total pressure of 2.00 atm2.00\text{ atm}. Additional argon gas is injected into the container at constant temperature until the total pressure reaches 5.00 atm5.00\text{ atm}. (a) Determine the final partial pressure of nitrogen, PN2P_{\text{N}_2}, and state whether it increased, decreased, or remained unchanged. (b) Determine the final mole fraction of nitrogen, XN2X_{\text{N}_2}, and explain why student intuition often confuses partial pressure with mole fraction in this scenario.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) PN2=1.00 atmP_{\text{N}_2} = 1.00\text{ atm} (remained unchanged); (b) XN2=0.200X_{\text{N}_2} = 0.200 (decreased from 0.5000.500 to 0.2000.200 because adding a non-reacting second gas changes the relative fraction without altering the independent collision frequency of the first gas on the container walls)

Steps

Part (a): Determining the Final Partial Pressure of Nitrogen

  1. Calculate the initial partial pressure of NX2\ce{N2}: The container initially holds an equimolar mixture of NX2\ce{N2} and Ar\ce{Ar}, meaning the initial mole fractions are equal: XNX2,i=XAr,i=0.500X_{\ce{N2}, i} = X_{\ce{Ar}, i} = 0.500

    According to Dalton's law of partial pressures: PNX2,i=XNX2,i⋅Ptotal,i=0.500⋅2.00 atm=1.00 atmP_{\ce{N2}, i} = X_{\ce{N2}, i} \cdot P_{\text{total}, i} = 0.500 \cdot 2.00\text{ atm} = 1.00\text{ atm}

  2. Evaluate the effect of adding Ar\ce{Ar} at constant volume and temperature: The ideal gas law for a single component in a gas mixture is: PNX2=nNX2RTVP_{\ce{N2}} = \frac{n_{\ce{N2}}RT}{V}

    • The container is rigid, so the volume VV is constant.
    • The temperature TT is kept constant.
    • No nitrogen is added or removed, so the amount of nitrogen nNX2n_{\ce{N2}} is constant.

    Because none of the variables determining PNX2P_{\ce{N2}} have changed, the partial pressure of nitrogen is independent of any added non-reacting gas: PNX2=1.00 atm(remained unchanged)P_{\ce{N2}} = 1.00\text{ atm}\quad (\text{remained unchanged})


Part (b): Determining the Final Mole Fraction of Nitrogen and Common Pitfall

  1. Calculate the final mole fraction of NX2\ce{N2}: Using Dalton's law relating partial pressure to the final total pressure (Ptotal,f=5.00 atmP_{\text{total}, f} = 5.00\text{ atm}): PNX2=XNX2,f⋅Ptotal,fP_{\ce{N2}} = X_{\ce{N2}, f} \cdot P_{\text{total}, f}

    Rearranging to solve for XNX2,fX_{\ce{N2}, f}: XNX2,f=PNX2Ptotal,f=1.00 atm5.00 atm=0.200X_{\ce{N2}, f} = \frac{P_{\ce{N2}}}{P_{\text{total}, f}} = \frac{1.00\text{ atm}}{5.00\text{ atm}} = 0.200

  2. Conceptual Pitfall: Confusing Mole Fraction with Partial Pressure:

    • Mole fraction (XNX2X_{\ce{N2}}) is an intensive relative measure of composition: XNX2=nNX2ntotalX_{\ce{N2}} = \frac{n_{\ce{N2}}}{n_{\text{total}}} Adding argon increases ntotaln_{\text{total}}, so the fraction of molecules that are nitrogen decreases from 0.5000.500 to 0.2000.200.
    • Partial pressure (PNX2P_{\ce{N2}}) is an absolute measure of molecular collisions against the container walls per unit area by nitrogen molecules alone.
    • Why confusion occurs: Learners often intuitively assume that "diluting" a gas mixture with another gas must lower the presence and therefore the pressure of the original gas. However, in a rigid container, gas particles behave independently under ideal conditions; adding argon increases total wall collisions without hindering or reducing the collisions exerted by nitrogen.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student assumes that the mole fraction of nitrogen remains constant at 0.500 after adding argon, leading to an incorrect final partial pressure of 2.50 atm.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    XN2=0.500  ⟹  PN2=0.500×5.00 atm=2.50 atm  ⟹  X_{\text{N}_2} = 0.500 \implies P_{\text{N}_2} = 0.500 \times 5.00\text{ atm} = 2.50\text{ atm} \implies The partial pressure of nitrogen increased.

    Correct

    PN2=nN2RTV=1.00 atmP_{\text{N}_2} = \frac{n_{\text{N}_2}RT}{V} = 1.00\text{ atm} (remained unchanged)

    You treated the mole fraction as fixed when total pressure increased. However, adding argon increases the total moles of gas while the moles of nitrogen, the volume, and the temperature remain constant. Therefore, the partial pressure of nitrogen stays at its initial value of 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}.

  2. Step 2

    XN2=0.500X_{\text{N}_2} = 0.500 with an explanation that students assume equal shares.

    Correct

    XN2=PN2Ptotal,f=1.00 atm5.00 atm=0.200X_{\text{N}_2} = \frac{P_{\text{N}_2}}{P_{\text{total}, f}} = \frac{1.00\text{ atm}}{5.00\text{ atm}} = 0.200

    You reported that the mole fraction remained 0.5000.500. Because additional argon was injected without adding any nitrogen, nitrogen now accounts for a smaller fraction of the total gas molecules: XN2=1.00 atm5.00 atm=0.200X_{\text{N}_2} = \frac{1.00\text{ atm}}{5.00\text{ atm}} = 0.200.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the initial equimolar ratio corresponding to an initial mole fraction of 0.5000.500.

You correctly used Dalton's law product relationship Pi=XiPtotalP_i = X_i P_{\text{total}} algebraically.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Constant-fraction fallacy in open/variable-composition gas systems

You held the mole fraction constant instead of holding the invariant partial pressure constant.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated mole fraction as an intrinsic, unchanging property of the mixture rather than a dynamic ratio of moles. In a rigid container of fixed volume and temperature, adding a non-reacting second gas does not alter the collision frequency of the original gas molecules against the walls, so its partial pressure remains constant while its mole fraction drops.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Invariant Quantities First
  • For a component gas ii, Pi=niRTVP_i = \frac{n_i RT}{V}. If nin_i, TT, and VV do not change, PiP_i cannot change.

  • Always evaluate whether the moles of the specific gas, the container volume, and the temperature have changed before applying Pi=XiPtotalP_i = X_i P_{\text{total}}.

Update Mole Fractions Upon Adding a Second Gas
  • Xi=nintotalX_i = \frac{n_i}{n_{\text{total}}}. Adding any other gas increases ntotaln_{\text{total}} and therefore decreases XiX_i.

  • Calculate the new mole fraction using the ratio of invariant partial pressure to the new total pressure: Xi=PiPtotalX_i = \frac{P_i}{P_{\text{total}}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find initial partial pressure: PN2,i=XN2,i⋅Ptotal,i=0.500×2.00 atm=1.00 atmP_{\text{N}_2, i} = X_{\text{N}_2, i} \cdot P_{\text{total}, i} = 0.500 \times 2.00\text{ atm} = 1.00\text{ atm}.

  2. Evaluate constraints: since nN2n_{\text{N}_2}, VV, and TT are constant, PN2,f=PN2,i=1.00 atmP_{\text{N}_2, f} = P_{\text{N}_2, i} = 1.00\text{ atm} (unchanged).

  3. Calculate final mole fraction using the new total pressure: XN2,f=PN2Ptotal,f=1.00 atm5.00 atm=0.200X_{\text{N}_2, f} = \frac{P_{\text{N}_2}}{P_{\text{total}, f}} = \frac{1.00\text{ atm}}{5.00\text{ atm}} = 0.200.

Final answer

(a) PN2=1.00 atmP_{\text{N}_2} = 1.00\text{ atm} (remained unchanged); (b) XN2=0.200X_{\text{N}_2} = 0.200

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice distinguishing between independent physical collisions (partial pressure) and relative proportions (mole fraction).

  • Review how Dalton's law behaves in rigid containers (constant volume) versus movable piston containers (constant total pressure).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student believes that adding argon decreases the partial pressure of nitrogen because its mole fraction decreases, erroneously concluding P_N2 decreased.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    PN2,initial=1.00 atmP_{\text{N}_2, \text{initial}} = 1.00\text{ atm}

  2. Step 2

    Adding Ar increases total moles, so \text{Adding Ar increases total moles, so } N\text{N}2  is diluted.\text{ is diluted.}   ⟹  \implies P{N\text{N}2} = 1.00 atm\text{ atm} ⋅\cdot (2.005.00)\left(\frac{2.00}{5.00}\right) = 0.400 atm\text{ atm}   ⟹  \implies The partial pressure of nitrogen decreased.\text{The partial pressure of nitrogen decreased.}

    Correct

    P_{N\text{N}_2, f} = nN2RTV\frac{n_{\text{N}_2}RT}{V} = 1.00 atm\text{ atm} \quad (remained unchanged\text{remained unchanged})

    In a rigid container of constant volume VV held at constant temperature TT, adding an unreactive gas like Ar\text{Ar} does not change nN2n_{\text{N}_2}, VV, or TT. By the ideal gas law, PN2P_{\text{N}_2} depends strictly on its own moles and remains constant at 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}.

  3. Step 3

    X_{N\text{N}_2} = 0.400 atm5.00 atm\frac{0.400\text{ atm}}{5.00\text{ atm}} = 0.080

    Correct

    X_{N\text{N}_2, f} = PN2Ptotal,f\frac{P_{\text{N}_2}}{P_{\text{total}, f}} = 1.00 atm5.00 atm\frac{1.00\text{ atm}}{5.00\text{ atm}} = 0.200

    You applied the correct relationship Xi=PiPtotalX_i = \frac{P_i}{P_{\text{total}}}, but your result was thrown off because you substituted the incorrect partial pressure of 0.400 atm0.400\text{ atm} instead of 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}.

  4. Step 4

    Students confuse partial pressure with mole fraction because dilution reduces the relative concentration, which is assumed to lower the pressure exerted by \text{Students confuse partial pressure with mole fraction because dilution reduces the relative concentration, which is assumed to lower the pressure exerted by } N\text{N}2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the initial partial pressure of nitrogen in the equimolar mixture.

You correctly applied Dalton's law relating mole fraction to partial pressure and total pressure.

You provided an accurate explanation of why dilution creates an intuitive confusion between relative abundance and absolute pressure.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
rigid container partial pressure independence

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that adding argon lowers the partial pressure of nitrogen proportionally to the pressure ratio, overlooking that in a rigid container at constant temperature, the partial pressure of an ideal gas component depends solely on its own moles (Pi=niRTVP_i = \frac{n_i RT}{V}) and is independent of other non-reacting gases.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Component Pressure Independence
  • Pi=niRTVP_i = \frac{n_i RT}{V}

  • Check whether nin_i, VV, and TT change. If none change, PiP_i remains constant regardless of other added gases.

Relative vs. Absolute Measures
  • Xi=nintotal=PiPtotalX_i = \frac{n_i}{n_{\text{total}}} = \frac{P_i}{P_{\text{total}}}

  • Remember that adding a second gas increases ntotaln_{\text{total}} and lowers XiX_i, but does not lower PiP_i in a fixed volume.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the ideal gas expression for nitrogen alone: PN2=nN2RTVP_{\text{N}_2} = \frac{n_{\text{N}_2}RT}{V}.

  2. Since nN2n_{\text{N}_2}, VV, and TT are all constant, PN2=1.00 atmP_{\text{N}_2} = 1.00\text{ atm} (remained unchanged).

  3. Use the true final partial pressure to find the final mole fraction: XN2=PN2Ptotal=1.00 atm5.00 atm=0.200X_{\text{N}_2} = \frac{P_{\text{N}_2}}{P_{\text{total}}} = \frac{1.00\text{ atm}}{5.00\text{ atm}} = 0.200.

Final answer

(a) PN2=1.00 atmP_{\text{N}_2} = 1.00\text{ atm} (remained unchanged); (b) XN2=0.200X_{\text{N}_2} = 0.200

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write Pi=niRTVP_i = \frac{n_i RT}{V} when examining gas mixtures in a rigid vessel to confirm which variables actually change.

  • Practice distinguishing rigid-container additions (constant volume, changing total pressure) from flexible-container additions (constant total pressure, changing volume).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 10.0 L10.0\text{ L} rigid vessel contains 0.40 mol0.40\text{ mol} of He\text{He} at 300 K300\text{ K}, exerting a pressure of 0.985 atm0.985\text{ atm}. If 0.60 mol0.60\text{ mol} of Ne\text{Ne} is injected into the vessel at the same temperature, determine: (a) the final partial pressure of He\text{He}, and (b) the final mole fraction of He\text{He}.

Answer

(a) PHe=0.985 atmP_{\text{He}} = 0.985\text{ atm} (unchanged, since VV, TT, and nHen_{\text{He}} remain constant); (b) XHe=nHenHe+nNe=0.401.00=0.40X_{\text{He}} = \frac{n_{\text{He}}}{n_{\text{He}} + n_{\text{Ne}}} = \frac{0.40}{1.00} = 0.40.

02

An equimolar mixture of CO2\text{CO}_2 and CH4\text{CH}_4 in a rigid tank has a total pressure of 4.00 atm4.00\text{ atm}. Additional CO2\text{CO}_2 is added at constant temperature until the total pressure reaches 10.00 atm10.00\text{ atm}. Calculate the final partial pressure and final mole fraction of CH4\text{CH}_4.

Answer

Initially, PCH4=0.500×4.00 atm=2.00 atmP_{\text{CH}_4} = 0.500 \times 4.00\text{ atm} = 2.00\text{ atm}. Because no CH4\text{CH}_4 is added and V,TV, T are fixed, PCH4=2.00 atmP_{\text{CH}_4} = 2.00\text{ atm}. The final mole fraction is XCH4=PCH4Ptotal,f=2.00 atm10.00 atm=0.200X_{\text{CH}_4} = \frac{P_{\text{CH}_4}}{P_{\text{total}, f}} = \frac{2.00\text{ atm}}{10.00\text{ atm}} = 0.200.

03

A cylinder fitted with a frictionless movable piston (constant total pressure of 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm}) contains 1.00 mol1.00\text{ mol} of N2\text{N}_2 at 298 K298\text{ K}. If 1.00 mol1.00\text{ mol} of Ar\text{Ar} is added at constant temperature and pressure, determine: (a) the final partial pressure of N2\text{N}_2, and (b) contrast this with what would happen if the cylinder were rigid.

Answer

(a) With a movable piston, Ptotal=1.00 atmP_{\text{total}} = 1.00\text{ atm} and XN2=1.002.00=0.500X_{\text{N}_2} = \frac{1.00}{2.00} = 0.500, so PN2=XN2Ptotal=0.500 atmP_{\text{N}_2} = X_{\text{N}_2} P_{\text{total}} = 0.500\text{ atm} (decreased because volume doubled). (b) In a rigid vessel, volume is fixed so PN2P_{\text{N}_2} would remain constant at 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm} while PtotalP_{\text{total}} would rise to 2.00 atm2.00\text{ atm}.

Loading workspace…