Resources

An industrial wastewater stream contains lead(II) ions at a concentration of 414.4 ppm414.4\text{ ppm} (where 1 ppm=1 mg/L1\text{ ppm} = 1\text{ mg/L}, density of solution =1.00 g/mL= 1.00\text{ g/mL}). A chemical technician treats a 2.50 L2.50\text{ L} batch of this wastewater with excess sodium sulfate solution, precipitating insoluble lead(II) sulfate: Pb(aq)2++SO4(aq)2−→PbSO4(s)\text{Pb}_{\text{(aq)}}^{2+} + \text{SO}_{4\text{(aq)}}^{2-} \rightarrow \text{PbSO}_{4\text{(s)}}. (a) Classify the precipitation of PbSO4\text{PbSO}_4 as a physical change or a chemical change, and state whether the molar solubility (KspK_{\text{sp}}) of PbSO4\text{PbSO}_4 is a physical property or a chemical property. (b) Calculate the theoretical mass of dry PbSO4(s)\text{PbSO}_{4\text{(s)}} in grams recovered from this 2.50 L2.50\text{ L} batch (molar masses: Pb=207.2 g/mol\text{Pb} = 207.2\text{ g/mol}, S=32.06 g/mol\text{S} = 32.06\text{ g/mol}, O=16.00 g/mol\text{O} = 16.00\text{ g/mol}).

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Precipitation of PbSO4\text{PbSO}_4 is a chemical change (formation of an insoluble ionic lattice from hydrated ions); the solubility/solubility product constant (KspK_{\text{sp}}) is a physical property (quantifying the intrinsic equilibrium limit of dissolution without modifying elemental identity). (b) The wastewater contains 1.036 g1.036\text{ g} of Pb2+\text{Pb}^{2+}, yielding a theoretical mass of 1.52 g1.52\text{ g} of dry PbSO4(s)\text{PbSO}_{4\text{(s)}}.

Steps

Part (a): Classification of Changes and Properties

  1. Precipitation as a Chemical Change:

    • A chemical change involves breaking and forming chemical bonds, resulting in substances with different chemical properties and identities.
    • In aqueous solution, lead(II) ions and sulfate ions exist as separated, hydrated ions (PbX2+X (aq)\ce{Pb^{2+}_{(aq)}} and SOX4X2−X (aq)\ce{SO4^{2-}_{(aq)}}). When they combine to form solid lead(II) sulfate (PbSOX4X (s)\ce{PbSO4_{(s)}}), new ionic bonds form within an organized, insoluble crystal lattice: PbX2+X (aq)+SOX4X2−X (aq)→PbSOX4X (s)\ce{Pb^{2+}_{(aq)} + SO4^{2-}_{(aq)} -> PbSO4_{(s)}}
    • Because a new chemical substance with distinct bonding and solid-phase structural properties forms, this precipitation is classified as a chemical change.
  2. Solubility / KspK_{\text{sp}} as a Physical Property:

    • A physical property is a measurable characteristic of a substance that can be observed without altering its chemical identity or composition.
    • Solubility and the solubility product constant (KspK_{\text{sp}}) quantify the maximum amount of solute that dissolves in a given quantity of solvent at equilibrium. Dissolution and crystallization of a compound represent physical phase equilibria between the solid solute and its dissolved state, without altering the identity of the chemical components. Therefore, solubility is an intrinsic physical property.

Part (b): Theoretical Yield of PbSOX4X (s)\ce{PbSO4_{(s)}}

  1. Determine the total mass of dissolved PbX2+\ce{Pb^{2+}}:

    • Given a concentration of 414.4 ppm414.4\text{ ppm} and using 1 ppm=1 mg/L1\text{ ppm} = 1\text{ mg/L}: Concentration of PbX2+=414.4 mg/L=0.4144 g/L\text{Concentration of }\ce{Pb^{2+}} = 414.4\text{ mg/L} = 0.4144\text{ g/L}
    • For a batch volume of V=2.50 LV = 2.50\text{ L}: mPbX2+=0.4144 g/L⋅2.50 L=1.036 gm_{\ce{Pb^{2+}}} = 0.4144\text{ g/L} \cdot 2.50\text{ L} = 1.036\text{ g}
  2. Calculate the moles of PbX2+\ce{Pb^{2+}}:

    • Using the atomic mass of lead, MPb=207.2 g/molM_{\ce{Pb}} = 207.2\text{ g/mol}: nPbX2+=1.036 g207.2 g/mol=0.00500 moln_{\ce{Pb^{2+}}} = \frac{1.036\text{ g}}{207.2\text{ g/mol}} = 0.00500\text{ mol}
  3. Determine the molar mass of PbSOX4\ce{PbSO4}: MPbSOX4=207.2 g/mol+32.06 g/mol+4⋅(16.00 g/mol)M_{\ce{PbSO4}} = 207.2\text{ g/mol} + 32.06\text{ g/mol} + 4 \cdot (16.00\text{ g/mol}) MPbSOX4=207.2+32.06+64.00=303.26 g/molM_{\ce{PbSO4}} = 207.2 + 32.06 + 64.00 = 303.26\text{ g/mol}
  4. Calculate the theoretical mass of PbSOX4X (s)\ce{PbSO4_{(s)}}:

    • Since SOX4X2−\ce{SO4^{2-}} is in excess, PbX2+\ce{Pb^{2+}} is the limiting reactant. The stoichiometric mole ratio between PbX2+\ce{Pb^{2+}} and PbSOX4\ce{PbSO4} is 1:11:1: nPbSOX4=nPbX2+=0.00500 moln_{\ce{PbSO4}} = n_{\ce{Pb^{2+}}} = 0.00500\text{ mol}
    • Theoretical mass: mPbSOX4=0.00500 mol⋅303.26 g/mol=1.5163 gm_{\ce{PbSO4}} = 0.00500\text{ mol} \cdot 303.26\text{ g/mol} = 1.5163\text{ g}
    • Expressing to three significant figures gives 1.52 g1.52\text{ g}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the mass of lead(II) ions with the mass of lead(II) sulfate by failing to convert moles of lead to mass of lead(II) sulfate compound, stopping at the mass of Pb.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Precipitation forms a new substance, so it is a chemical change. Solubility measures dissolving without forming new substances, so it is a physical property.

  2. Step 2

    Concentration=414.4 mg/L=0.4144 g/L  ⟹  Mass of Pb2+=0.4144 g/L×2.50 L=1.036 g\text{Concentration} = 414.4\text{ mg/L} = 0.4144\text{ g/L} \implies \text{Mass of Pb}^{2+} = 0.4144\text{ g/L} \times 2.50\text{ L} = 1.036\text{ g}

  3. Step 3

    Theoretical mass of PbSO4=1.036 g\text{Theoretical mass of PbSO}_4 = 1.036\text{ g}

    Correct

    nPb2+=1.036 g207.2 g/mol=0.00500 mol  ⟹  mPbSO4=0.00500 mol×303.26 g/mol=1.52 gn_{\text{Pb}^{2+}} = \frac{1.036\text{ g}}{207.2\text{ g/mol}} = 0.00500\text{ mol} \implies m_{\text{PbSO}_4} = 0.00500\text{ mol} \times 303.26\text{ g/mol} = 1.52\text{ g}

    You set the mass of the entire PbSO4\text{PbSO}_4 solid equal to the mass of the lead ions alone. The solid precipitate also incorporates sulfate ions (SO42−\text{SO}_4^{2-}), so you must convert moles of Pb2+\text{Pb}^{2+} to mass of PbSO4\text{PbSO}_4 using the compound's molar mass.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly classified the chemical change and physical property in part (a).

You correctly converted ppm concentration to grams per liter and found the mass of lead(II) ions.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equating Ion Mass to Compound Mass

You stopped calculating after finding the mass of lead(II) ions and assigned that value directly as the mass of lead(II) sulfate precipitate.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the mass of a single constituent ion as if it were the total mass of the precipitated ionic compound, skipping the mole-to-mole stoichiometric conversion to account for the counter-ion.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Conserve Mass with Both Ions
  • An ionic precipitate contains both cations and anions, so mcompound=mcation+manionm_{\text{compound}} = m_{\text{cation}} + m_{\text{anion}}.

  • Never equate the mass of a dissolved limiting ion directly to the mass of the recovered solid compound.

Use the Mole Bridge
  • Convert the mass of the limiting reactant to moles, apply the stoichiometric ratio, and multiply by the compound's molar mass: msolid=n×Msolidm_{\text{solid}} = n \times M_{\text{solid}}.

  • Calculate nPb2+=1.036 g207.2 g/mol=0.00500 moln_{\text{Pb}^{2+}} = \frac{1.036\text{ g}}{207.2\text{ g/mol}} = 0.00500\text{ mol}, then find mPbSO4=0.00500 mol×303.26 g/molm_{\text{PbSO}_4} = 0.00500\text{ mol} \times 303.26\text{ g/mol}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert the mass of Pb2+\text{Pb}^{2+} to moles: nPb2+=1.036 g207.2 g/mol=0.00500 moln_{\text{Pb}^{2+}} = \frac{1.036\text{ g}}{207.2\text{ g/mol}} = 0.00500\text{ mol}.

  2. Calculate the molar mass of PbSO4\text{PbSO}_4: M=207.2+32.06+4(16.00)=303.26 g/molM = 207.2 + 32.06 + 4(16.00) = 303.26\text{ g/mol}.

  3. Multiply moles of PbSO4\text{PbSO}_4 (1:1 mole ratio) by its molar mass: m=0.00500 mol×303.26 g/mol=1.5163 gm = 0.00500\text{ mol} \times 303.26\text{ g/mol} = 1.5163\text{ g}.

Final answer

(a) Chemical change; physical property. (b) 1.52 g1.52\text{ g} of PbSO4\text{PbSO}_4.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the full unit and chemical formula at each step (e.g., 'g Pb2+\text{g Pb}^{2+}' vs. 'g PbSO4\text{g PbSO}_4') to avoid substituting an element's mass for a compound's mass.

  • Always use the mole bridge when converting between an individual component and the entire compound.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student miscalculates the molar mass of lead(II) sulfate by omitting the subscript of oxygen and calculating Pb + S + O instead of Pb + S + 4O, resulting in 1.28 g of PbSO4.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Precipitation forms a solid precipitate, which is a chemical change.   ⟹  \implies Molar solubility describes how much dissolves, which is a physical property.

  2. Step 2

    Mass of PbX2+=414.4 mg/L×2.50 L=1036 mg=1.036 g  ⟹  Moles of PbX2+=1.036 g207.2 g/mol=0.00500 mol\text{Mass of }\ce{Pb^{2+}} = 414.4\text{ mg/L} \times 2.50\text{ L} = 1036\text{ mg} = 1.036\text{ g} \implies \text{Moles of }\ce{Pb^{2+}} = \frac{1.036\text{ g}}{207.2\text{ g/mol}} = 0.00500\text{ mol}

  3. Step 3

    Molar mass of PbSOX4=207.2+32.06+16.00=255.26 g/mol\text{Molar mass of }\ce{PbSO4} = 207.2 + 32.06 + 16.00 = 255.26\text{ g/mol}

    Correct

    MPbSOX4=207.2+32.06+4(16.00)=303.26 g/molM_{\ce{PbSO4}} = 207.2 + 32.06 + 4(16.00) = 303.26\text{ g/mol}

    You added only one oxygen atom instead of accounting for all four oxygen atoms indicated by the formula subscript in PbSOX4\ce{PbSO4}.

  4. Step 4

    Mass of PbSOX4=0.00500 mol×255.26 g/mol=1.28 g\text{Mass of }\ce{PbSO4} = 0.00500\text{ mol} \times 255.26\text{ g/mol} = 1.28\text{ g}

    Correct

    mPbSOX4=0.00500 mol×303.26 g/mol=1.52 gm_{\ce{PbSO4}} = 0.00500\text{ mol} \times 303.26\text{ g/mol} = 1.52\text{ g}

    Your calculation method was sound, but your result was affected by the incorrect molar mass from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly classified precipitation as a chemical change and solubility as a physical property.

You accurately converted concentration in parts per million into total grams of lead(II) ions.

You correctly determined the moles of lead(II) ions using the molar mass of lead.

You correctly set up the 1:11:1 stoichiometric conversion from moles to mass.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted Subscript in Molar Mass Calculation

You wrote 16.00 g/mol16.00\text{ g/mol} for oxygen instead of 4×16.00 g/mol4 \times 16.00\text{ g/mol} when summing the atomic masses for PbSOX4\ce{PbSO4}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking chemical formula subscripts during molar mass summation leads to an understated formula weight and an underestimated theoretical yield.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Subscript Inventory Check
  • Every element in a chemical formula must be multiplied by its subscript: M=∑(subscripti×atomic massi)M = \sum (\text{subscript}_i \times \text{atomic mass}_i).

  • Before adding, list each element with its subscript count explicitly: 1 Pb+1 S+4 O1\text{ Pb} + 1\text{ S} + 4\text{ O}.

Polyatomic Ion Sanity Check
  • A sulfate group (SOX4X2−\ce{SO4^{2-}}) contains four oxygen atoms and has a formula weight of 32.06+4(16.00)=96.06 g/mol32.06 + 4(16.00) = 96.06\text{ g/mol}.

  • Verify that your anion mass matches the full polyatomic group before adding the metal cation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Count all constituent atoms in PbSOX4\ce{PbSO4}: 1 Pb1\text{ Pb}, 1 S1\text{ S}, and 4 O4\text{ O}.

  2. Compute the correct molar mass: MPbSOX4=207.2 g/mol+32.06 g/mol+4(16.00 g/mol)=303.26 g/molM_{\ce{PbSO4}} = 207.2\text{ g/mol} + 32.06\text{ g/mol} + 4(16.00\text{ g/mol}) = 303.26\text{ g/mol}.

  3. Multiply the moles of PbX2+\ce{Pb^{2+}} by the correct molar mass: m=0.00500 mol×303.26 g/mol=1.5163 g≈1.52 gm = 0.00500\text{ mol} \times 303.26\text{ g/mol} = 1.5163\text{ g} \approx 1.52\text{ g}.

Final answer

(a) Precipitation of PbSOX4\ce{PbSO4} is a chemical change; molar solubility (KspK_{\text{sp}}) is a physical property. (b) The theoretical mass of dry PbSOX4X (s)\ce{PbSO4_{(s)}} is 1.52 g1.52\text{ g}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice breaking chemical formulas into an explicit table of atom counts before calculating molar mass.

  • Memorize common polyatomic ion molar masses, such as sulfate (SOX4X2−≈96.06 g/mol\ce{SO4^{2-}} \approx 96.06\text{ g/mol}), to quickly cross-check formula weights.

  • Complete the follow-up practice exercises to reinforce stoichiometric calculations involving polyatomic compounds.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student incorrectly classifies precipitation as a physical change by confusing the formation of a precipitate with a physical phase separation or freezing.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Precipitation is just a phase change from liquid to solid, so it is a physical change.

    Correct

    Precipitation of PbSOX4\ce{PbSO4} is a chemical change because dissolved ions (PbX2+X (aq)\ce{Pb^{2+}_{(aq)}} and SOX4X2−X (aq)\ce{SO4^{2-}_{(aq)}}) combine through new ionic bonds to form an insoluble solid lattice (PbSOX4X (s)\ce{PbSO4_{(s)}}).

    Precipitation from an ionic reaction is not simply a liquid freezing into a solid. Distinct chemical entities—hydrated lead ions and sulfate ions—undergo a chemical reaction to form an entirely new compound, lead(II) sulfate, bound in a crystal lattice.

  2. Step 2

    Solubility describes the tendency to dissolve, which is a physical property.

  3. Step 3

    Mass of Pb2+=0.4144 g/L×2.50 L=1.036 g  ⟹  Moles of Pb2+=1.036 g207.2 g/mol=0.00500 mol  ⟹  Molar mass of PbSO4=207.2+32.06+4(16.00)=303.26 g/mol  ⟹  Theoretical mass of PbSO4=0.00500 mol×303.26 g/mol=1.52 g\text{Mass of Pb}^{2+} = 0.4144\text{ g/L} \times 2.50\text{ L} = 1.036\text{ g} \implies \text{Moles of Pb}^{2+} = \frac{1.036\text{ g}}{207.2\text{ g/mol}} = 0.00500\text{ mol} \implies \text{Molar mass of PbSO}_4 = 207.2 + 32.06 + 4(16.00) = 303.26\text{ g/mol} \implies \text{Theoretical mass of PbSO}_4 = 0.00500\text{ mol} \times 303.26\text{ g/mol} = 1.52\text{ g}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified solubility as a physical property.

You accurately converted parts-per-million concentration into total mass and moles of lead(II) ions.

You correctly calculated the formula mass of lead(II) sulfate and determined the final theoretical yield to three significant figures.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Precipitation Classified as Physical Change

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated a macroscopic phase transition of a pure substance (such as freezing or condensation) with an aqueous precipitation reaction where hydrated ions form new chemical bonds to produce a distinct solid compound.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Physical Phase Change vs. Chemical Precipitation
  • A physical phase change alters only the physical state of a single substance without forming or breaking chemical bonds (e.g., HX2OX (l)→HX2OX (s)\ce{H2O_{(l)} -> H2O_{(s)}}). An aqueous precipitation reaction forms new chemical bonds between previously dissociated ions to create a new insoluble compound (e.g., AX+X (aq)+BX−X (aq)→ABX (s)\ce{A^{+}_{(aq)} + B^{-}_{(aq)} -> AB_{(s)}}).

  • Check whether new chemical bonds are created between different ionic or molecular species in solution. If new bonds form a separate compound, classify it as a chemical change.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify that hydrated aqueous lead(II) ions and sulfate ions react: PbX2+X (aq)+SOX4X2−X (aq)→PbSOX4X (s)\ce{Pb^{2+}_{(aq)} + SO4^{2-}_{(aq)} -> PbSO4_{(s)}}.

  2. Because ionic bonds form to yield a new crystalline compound with different properties from the reactant ions, classify the precipitation as a chemical change.

Final answer

(a) Precipitation is a chemical change; solubility is a physical property. (b) The theoretical mass of dry PbSOX4\ce{PbSO4} is 1.52 g1.52\text{ g}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between pure-substance phase changes (freezing, boiling) and precipitation reactions that form new ionic bonds.

  • Practice identifying whether bonds are formed or broken when classifying observable laboratory phenomena.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A sample containing 0.486 g0.486\text{ g} of magnesium ions (Mg2+\text{Mg}^{2+}, molar mass 24.31 g/mol24.31\text{ g/mol}) is treated with excess hydroxide ions to precipitate magnesium hydroxide, Mg(OH)2\text{Mg(OH)}_2 (molar mass 58.32 g/mol58.32\text{ g/mol}). Calculate the theoretical mass in grams of dry Mg(OH)2\text{Mg(OH)}_2 recovered.

Answer

1.17 g1.17\text{ g}. Moles of Mg2+=0.486 g24.31 g/mol=0.0200 mol\text{Mg}^{2+} = \frac{0.486\text{ g}}{24.31\text{ g/mol}} = 0.0200\text{ mol}. Because the stoichiometric ratio of Mg2+\text{Mg}^{2+} to Mg(OH)2\text{Mg(OH)}_2 is 1:11:1, theoretical mass of Mg(OH)2=0.0200 mol×58.32 g/mol=1.1664 g≈1.17 g\text{Mg(OH)}_2 = 0.0200\text{ mol} \times 58.32\text{ g/mol} = 1.1664\text{ g} \approx 1.17\text{ g}.

02

A 500.0 mL500.0\text{ mL} wastewater sample contains calcium ions at a concentration of 80.0 ppm80.0\text{ ppm} (1 ppm=1 mg/L1\text{ ppm} = 1\text{ mg/L}). Excess sodium fluoride is added to precipitate calcium fluoride: Ca2+(aq)+2F−(aq)→CaF2(s)\text{Ca}^{2+}\text{(aq)} + 2\text{F}^-\text{(aq)} \rightarrow \text{CaF}_2\text{(s)}. Determine the theoretical mass in milligrams of dry CaF2\text{CaF}_2 recovered. (Molar masses: Ca=40.08 g/mol\text{Ca} = 40.08\text{ g/mol}, F=19.00 g/mol\text{F} = 19.00\text{ g/mol}).

Answer

77.9 mg77.9\text{ mg}. Mass of Ca2+=80.0 mg/L×0.5000 L=40.0 mg\text{Ca}^{2+} = 80.0\text{ mg/L} \times 0.5000\text{ L} = 40.0\text{ mg}. Moles of Ca2+=0.0400 g40.08 g/mol=9.98×10−4 mol\text{Ca}^{2+} = \frac{0.0400\text{ g}}{40.08\text{ g/mol}} = 9.98 \times 10^{-4}\text{ mol}. Molar mass of CaF2=40.08+2(19.00)=78.08 g/mol\text{CaF}_2 = 40.08 + 2(19.00) = 78.08\text{ g/mol}. Mass of CaF2=9.98×10−4 mol×78.08 g/mol=0.0779 g=77.9 mg\text{CaF}_2 = 9.98 \times 10^{-4}\text{ mol} \times 78.08\text{ g/mol} = 0.0779\text{ g} = 77.9\text{ mg}.

03

A 1.50 L1.50\text{ L} solution of barium chloride contains 137.3 mg/L137.3\text{ mg/L} of Ba2+\text{Ba}^{2+}. A technician adds 100.0 mL100.0\text{ mL} of 0.0200 M Na2SO40.0200\text{ M } \text{Na}_2\text{SO}_4 to precipitate BaSO4(s)\text{BaSO}_4\text{(s)}. Determine which ion is the limiting reactant and calculate the theoretical mass in grams of dry BaSO4\text{BaSO}_4 formed. (Molar masses: Ba=137.33 g/mol\text{Ba} = 137.33\text{ g/mol}, BaSO4=233.39 g/mol\text{BaSO}_4 = 233.39\text{ g/mol}).

Answer

Ba2+\text{Ba}^{2+} is limiting; theoretical mass is 0.350 g0.350\text{ g}. Moles of Ba2+=0.1373 g/L×1.50 L137.33 g/mol=0.00150 mol\text{Ba}^{2+} = \frac{0.1373\text{ g/L} \times 1.50\text{ L}}{137.33\text{ g/mol}} = 0.00150\text{ mol}. Moles of SO42−=0.1000 L×0.0200 M=0.00200 mol\text{SO}_4^{2-} = 0.1000\text{ L} \times 0.0200\text{ M} = 0.00200\text{ mol}. Since Ba2+\text{Ba}^{2+} has fewer moles in a 1:11:1 reaction, it is limiting. Mass of BaSO4=0.00150 mol×233.39 g/mol=0.350 g\text{BaSO}_4 = 0.00150\text{ mol} \times 233.39\text{ g/mol} = 0.350\text{ g}.

Loading workspace…