Resources
An industrial wastewater stream contains lead(II) ions at a concentration of (where , density of solution ). A chemical technician treats a batch of this wastewater with excess sodium sulfate solution, precipitating insoluble lead(II) sulfate: . (a) Classify the precipitation of as a physical change or a chemical change, and state whether the molar solubility () of is a physical property or a chemical property. (b) Calculate the theoretical mass of dry in grams recovered from this batch (molar masses: , , ).
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Precipitation of is a chemical change (formation of an insoluble ionic lattice from hydrated ions); the solubility/solubility product constant () is a physical property (quantifying the intrinsic equilibrium limit of dissolution without modifying elemental identity). (b) The wastewater contains of , yielding a theoretical mass of of dry .
Steps
Part (a): Classification of Changes and Properties
-
Precipitation as a Chemical Change:
- A chemical change involves breaking and forming chemical bonds, resulting in substances with different chemical properties and identities.
- In aqueous solution, lead(II) ions and sulfate ions exist as separated, hydrated ions ( and ). When they combine to form solid lead(II) sulfate (), new ionic bonds form within an organized, insoluble crystal lattice:
- Because a new chemical substance with distinct bonding and solid-phase structural properties forms, this precipitation is classified as a chemical change.
-
Solubility / as a Physical Property:
- A physical property is a measurable characteristic of a substance that can be observed without altering its chemical identity or composition.
- Solubility and the solubility product constant () quantify the maximum amount of solute that dissolves in a given quantity of solvent at equilibrium. Dissolution and crystallization of a compound represent physical phase equilibria between the solid solute and its dissolved state, without altering the identity of the chemical components. Therefore, solubility is an intrinsic physical property.
Part (b): Theoretical Yield of
-
Determine the total mass of dissolved :
- Given a concentration of and using :
- For a batch volume of :
-
Calculate the moles of :
- Using the atomic mass of lead, :
- Determine the molar mass of :
-
Calculate the theoretical mass of :
- Since is in excess, is the limiting reactant. The stoichiometric mole ratio between and is :
- Theoretical mass:
- Expressing to three significant figures gives .
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the mass of lead(II) ions with the mass of lead(II) sulfate by failing to convert moles of lead to mass of lead(II) sulfate compound, stopping at the mass of Pb.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Precipitation forms a new substance, so it is a chemical change. Solubility measures dissolving without forming new substances, so it is a physical property.
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
You set the mass of the entire solid equal to the mass of the lead ions alone. The solid precipitate also incorporates sulfate ions (), so you must convert moles of to mass of using the compound's molar mass.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly classified the chemical change and physical property in part (a).
You correctly converted ppm concentration to grams per liter and found the mass of lead(II) ions.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou stopped calculating after finding the mass of lead(II) ions and assigned that value directly as the mass of lead(II) sulfate precipitate.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the mass of a single constituent ion as if it were the total mass of the precipitated ionic compound, skipping the mole-to-mole stoichiometric conversion to account for the counter-ion.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Conserve Mass with Both Ions
An ionic precipitate contains both cations and anions, so .
Never equate the mass of a dissolved limiting ion directly to the mass of the recovered solid compound.
- Use the Mole Bridge
Convert the mass of the limiting reactant to moles, apply the stoichiometric ratio, and multiply by the compound's molar mass: .
Calculate , then find .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationConvert the mass of to moles: .
Calculate the molar mass of : .
Multiply moles of (1:1 mole ratio) by its molar mass: .
(a) Chemical change; physical property. (b) of .
02 The student miscalculates the molar mass of lead(II) sulfate by omitting the subscript of oxygen and calculating Pb + S + O instead of Pb + S + 4O, resulting in 1.28 g of PbSO4.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Precipitation forms a solid precipitate, which is a chemical change. Molar solubility describes how much dissolves, which is a physical property.
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
You added only one oxygen atom instead of accounting for all four oxygen atoms indicated by the formula subscript in .
- Step 4Correct
Your calculation method was sound, but your result was affected by the incorrect molar mass from the previous step.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly classified precipitation as a chemical change and solubility as a physical property.
You accurately converted concentration in parts per million into total grams of lead(II) ions.
You correctly determined the moles of lead(II) ions using the molar mass of lead.
You correctly set up the stoichiometric conversion from moles to mass.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou wrote for oxygen instead of when summing the atomic masses for .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisOverlooking chemical formula subscripts during molar mass summation leads to an understated formula weight and an underestimated theoretical yield.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Subscript Inventory Check
Every element in a chemical formula must be multiplied by its subscript: .
Before adding, list each element with its subscript count explicitly: .
- Polyatomic Ion Sanity Check
A sulfate group () contains four oxygen atoms and has a formula weight of .
Verify that your anion mass matches the full polyatomic group before adding the metal cation.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCount all constituent atoms in : , , and .
Compute the correct molar mass: .
Multiply the moles of by the correct molar mass: .
(a) Precipitation of is a chemical change; molar solubility () is a physical property. (b) The theoretical mass of dry is .
03 The student incorrectly classifies precipitation as a physical change by confusing the formation of a precipitate with a physical phase separation or freezing.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Precipitation is just a phase change from liquid to solid, so it is a physical change.
CorrectPrecipitation of is a chemical change because dissolved ions ( and ) combine through new ionic bonds to form an insoluble solid lattice ().
Precipitation from an ionic reaction is not simply a liquid freezing into a solid. Distinct chemical entities—hydrated lead ions and sulfate ions—undergo a chemical reaction to form an entirely new compound, lead(II) sulfate, bound in a crystal lattice.
- Step 2
Solubility describes the tendency to dissolve, which is a physical property.
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified solubility as a physical property.
You accurately converted parts-per-million concentration into total mass and moles of lead(II) ions.
You correctly calculated the formula mass of lead(II) sulfate and determined the final theoretical yield to three significant figures.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated a macroscopic phase transition of a pure substance (such as freezing or condensation) with an aqueous precipitation reaction where hydrated ions form new chemical bonds to produce a distinct solid compound.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Physical Phase Change vs. Chemical Precipitation
A physical phase change alters only the physical state of a single substance without forming or breaking chemical bonds (e.g., ). An aqueous precipitation reaction forms new chemical bonds between previously dissociated ions to create a new insoluble compound (e.g., ).
Check whether new chemical bonds are created between different ionic or molecular species in solution. If new bonds form a separate compound, classify it as a chemical change.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify that hydrated aqueous lead(II) ions and sulfate ions react: .
Because ionic bonds form to yield a new crystalline compound with different properties from the reactant ions, classify the precipitation as a chemical change.
(a) Precipitation is a chemical change; solubility is a physical property. (b) The theoretical mass of dry is .
Lock it in
When a metal ion forms an insoluble precipitate , can the mass of the precipitate equal the initial mass of the metal ion?
No. The precipitate incorporates both cations and anions, so .
Similar question
A sample containing of magnesium ions (, molar mass ) is treated with excess hydroxide ions to precipitate magnesium hydroxide, (molar mass ). Calculate the theoretical mass in grams of dry recovered.
Answer
. Moles of . Because the stoichiometric ratio of to is , theoretical mass of .
A wastewater sample contains calcium ions at a concentration of (). Excess sodium fluoride is added to precipitate calcium fluoride: . Determine the theoretical mass in milligrams of dry recovered. (Molar masses: , ).
Answer
. Mass of . Moles of . Molar mass of . Mass of .
A solution of barium chloride contains of . A technician adds of to precipitate . Determine which ion is the limiting reactant and calculate the theoretical mass in grams of dry formed. (Molar masses: , ).
Answer
is limiting; theoretical mass is . Moles of . Moles of . Since has fewer moles in a reaction, it is limiting. Mass of .