Resources
Consider the series of linear noble gases and linear unbranched alkanes as molecular size approaches large values. As the carbon chain length of unbranched liquid alkanes increases from pentane () to -eicosane (), identify the sole intermolecular force holding the molecules together, describe how the strength of this force behaves in the asymptotic limit of large molecular weight, and predict the resulting physical state at and .
Answer and steps
Final answer
The sole intermolecular force present is London dispersion forces. In the limit of increasing molecular chain length and molecular weight, total electron count increases linearly ( electrons in vs. in ) and accessible molecular contact surface area increases, causing cumulative dispersion attractive energies to increase monotonically until they exceed typical room-temperature thermal energy (). Consequently, -eicosane is a waxy solid at and (melting point ).
Steps
Identifying the Intermolecular Force
Alkanes are hydrocarbons containing only carbon–carbon () and carbon–hydrogen () bonds.
- The electronegativity difference between carbon () and hydrogen () is very small (), rendering the bonds virtually nonpolar.
- Because the molecules are symmetric and nonpolar, they possess no permanent dipole moments and cannot participate in dipole–dipole interactions or hydrogen bonding.
Therefore, the sole intermolecular force operating between unbranched alkane molecules is London dispersion forces (induced dipole–induced dipole attractions).
Behavior of Dispersion Forces with Increasing Molecular Size
London dispersion forces arise from momentary fluctuations in electron distribution that create temporary dipoles, which in turn induce dipoles in neighboring molecules:
- Polarizability and Electron Count: As the chain grows from pentane () to -eicosane (), the total number of electrons increases dramatically from to . A larger, more diffuse electron cloud is more easily distorted (higher polarizability), leading to stronger instantaneous and induced dipoles.
- Contact Surface Area: In unbranched (linear) alkanes, an extended zigzag chain geometry provides an extensive surface area for intermolecular contact. Adjacent chains can align parallel to one another, allowing dispersion interactions to act additively along the entire length of the carbon backbone.
As molecular weight and chain length become very large, the cumulative dispersion energy increases monotonically and eventually exceeds the thermal kinetic energy () available at room temperature.
Predicting the Physical State at and
- Smaller liquid alkanes like pentane () have sufficiently weak cumulative attractions that thermal energy keeps them in the liquid phase (boiling point , melting point ).
- For -eicosane (), the sum of dispersion forces along its 20-carbon chain is so strong that molecules become held in a rigid crystal lattice at room temperature.
With a melting point of approximately , -eicosane is a waxy solid at and .
Typical errors
01 The student assumes that hydrocarbons of moderate chain length remain liquids at room temperature similar to pentane and octane, predicting a liquid state instead of a solid for n-eicosane.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
London dispersion forces
- Step 2
Polarizability increases with 20 carbons compared to 5 carbons. Strength of London dispersion forces increases with chain length.
- Step 3
Liquid at and
CorrectSolid (waxy solid) at and
By carbon atoms (melting point ), cumulative dispersion forces along the extended linear chain exceed room-temperature thermal energy (), holding the molecules in a solid lattice rather than a liquid state.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified London dispersion forces as the primary intermolecular force governing nonpolar hydrocarbons.
You accurately connected longer carbon chains and greater electron counts to increased polarizability and stronger dispersion attractions.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou recognized that dispersion forces increase with molecular size, but you assumed -eicosane remains a liquid at room temperature like mid-range alkanes.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisOverlooking that London dispersion forces are additive over long molecular contact areas and can surpass thermal kinetic energy at , leading to a solid state for unbranched alkanes with approximately or more carbons.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Alkane Phase Transitions vs. Chain Length
At and , straight-chain alkanes transition from gases () to liquids () to waxy solids ().
Check whether the carbon count is or greater when predicting the room-temperature phase of an unbranched alkane.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationEvaluate the cumulative dispersion force: an unbranched -carbon alkane has electrons and an extended linear contact surface.
Compare the resulting intermolecular attraction to ambient thermal energy ( at ): the lattice energy exceeds thermal agitation.
Determine the physical state: because the melting point of -eicosane is , it is below its melting point at .
Solid (waxy solid) at and
02 The student mistakenly identifies hydrogen bonding as the intermolecular force due to the presence of numerous hydrogen atoms bonded along the hydrocarbon chain.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Hydrogen bonding Cumulative attraction increases across 42 hydrogen atoms.
CorrectLondon dispersion forces (induced dipole–induced dipole attractions).
Hydrogen bonding requires a hydrogen atom covalently bonded to a highly electronegative atom (specifically , , or ) with available lone pairs. Because alkanes contain only nonpolar and bonds (electronegativity difference ), they possess no permanent dipoles and cannot form hydrogen bonds. The only intermolecular force present is London dispersion forces.
- Step 2
Strength of attraction increases with chain length.
CorrectAs chain length and molecular weight increase, the total electron count increases (from electrons in to in ), increasing polarizability and molecular contact surface area, causing London dispersion attractions to increase monotonically.
Your trend direction is correct, but the underlying mechanism is driven by increased electron count (higher polarizability) and greater surface contact area between parallel zigzag hydrocarbon chains, rather than cumulative hydrogen bonding.
- Step 3
Solid at and
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that the overall intermolecular attraction strengthens as hydrocarbon chain length increases.
You accurately predicted that -eicosane is a solid at and .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that the presence of hydrogen atoms in a molecular formula () implies hydrogen bonding, overlooking the strict requirement that hydrogen must be directly bonded to a highly electronegative atom (N, O, or F).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Hydrogen Bonding Criteria
A hydrogen bond occurs only when hydrogen is covalently bonded directly to , , or , interacting with a lone pair on an adjacent , , or atom.
Check the constituent atoms: if a molecule contains only carbon and hydrogen, it cannot participate in hydrogen bonding.
- Nonpolar Hydrocarbon IMF
Molecules consisting solely of carbon and hydrogen are essentially nonpolar and interact exclusively via London dispersion forces.
Attribute all intermolecular attraction in pure alkanes to instantaneous induced dipoles (London dispersion forces).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationAlkanes contain only and bonds, which have negligible electronegativity differences and no permanent dipoles.
Therefore, the sole intermolecular force holding alkane molecules together is London dispersion forces.
As chain length increases from to , the electron count increases from to electrons, greatly enhancing polarizability and contact surface area along the unbranched chains.
The cumulative dispersion energy increases monotonically until it exceeds thermal energy at room temperature, making -eicosane a waxy solid at .
The sole intermolecular force is London dispersion forces; its strength increases monotonically due to higher electron count (polarizability) and greater contact surface area, making -eicosane a solid at and .
03 The student assumes London dispersion forces are inherently weak and negligible regardless of molecular size, concluding that the force does not increase enough to change physical behavior.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
London dispersion forces
- Step 2
Dispersion forces remain weak and negligible across all sizes. Attraction does not increase significantly.
CorrectAs chain length increases from to , the total electron count increases from to and molecular contact surface area increases substantially, causing cumulative London dispersion forces to increase dramatically.
London dispersion forces are additive along molecular contact areas. In larger molecules with more polarizable electron clouds, cumulative dispersion forces become very strong rather than remaining negligible.
- Step 3
Gas at and
CorrectWaxy solid at and
Because dispersion attractions along the -carbon chain of -eicosane cumulatively exceed thermal kinetic energy at room temperature, the substance is a solid, not a gas.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that unbranched alkanes lack permanent dipoles and rely solely on London dispersion forces.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated London dispersion forces as intrinsically weak and invariant rather than recognizing that dispersion forces scale with electron count, polarizability, and molecular surface contact area.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Scaling of Dispersion Forces
London dispersion forces scale with polarizability (total electron count) and contact surface area.
Whenever molecular size or chain length increases, sum the dispersion interactions along the entire molecule instead of assuming they remain negligible.
- Intermolecular Forces vs. Thermal Energy
When cumulative intermolecular forces exceed ambient thermal kinetic energy (), substances condense into liquids and freeze into solids.
Check the room-temperature state of large nonpolar molecules (such as paraffin waxes and polymers like polyethylene) to verify that large nonpolar species are solids at .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCount electrons and compare surface contact area: pentane () has electrons, whereas -eicosane () has electrons.
Recognize that greater polarizability and extensive parallel contact along the extended -carbon zigzag chain allow cumulative dispersion attractions to increase monotonically.
Compare the resulting attractive energy to room-temperature thermal energy (): the attractions are strong enough to lock molecules into a crystal lattice (melting point ).
The sole intermolecular force is London dispersion forces; their cumulative strength increases significantly with electron count and surface area, making -eicosane a waxy solid at and .
Lock it in
What physical states do unbranched alkanes adopt at and across increasing carbon chain lengths?
are gases, are liquids, and are solids. Cumulative dispersion forces increase monotonically with chain length.
Similar question
At and , pentane () is a liquid, while methane () is a gas and paraffin wax () is a solid. Explain this trend using intermolecular force principles.
Answer
All three molecules are nonpolar and interact exclusively via London dispersion forces. As chain length increases from to , polarizability and contact surface area increase dramatically. For , attractions are weaker than thermal energy (gas); for , they are strong enough to condense the substance into a liquid; for , cumulative attractions hold the molecules in a rigid crystal lattice (solid).
Compare the boiling points and intermolecular force strengths of -pentane () and neopentane (). Both have identical molecular formulas. Which has stronger dispersion forces, and why?
Answer
-Pentane has stronger dispersion forces and a higher boiling point ( vs. ). The elongated zigzag shape of -pentane provides greater molecular contact surface area than the spherical, compact shape of neopentane, enabling more extensive instantaneous dipole contacts.
Linear polyethylene can be viewed as an alkane with thousands of repeat units, . Despite having only nonpolar and bonds, high-density polyethylene is a tough, high-melting solid (). Rationalize this observation in terms of molecular forces.
Answer
Although each individual dispersion interaction is relatively weak, a polymer chain containing thousands of carbon atoms possesses enormous contact surface area and hundreds of thousands of electrons. The sum of these dispersion forces across aligned adjacent chains is extraordinarily large, requiring high thermal energy () to disrupt the crystalline domains.